There are several arguments against philosophical anarchism. Most of the arguments are in line with either the theory that consent is not required or of the theory we have already consented. For the sake of being brief, this essay will attempt to refute only the latter of the two. Along with the idea of individual consent is the longstanding, traditional theory of the authority of God. Other arguments follow a less anarchist view and are that of tacit consent and more specifically that of majority consent.
The idea that consent is essential for the legitimacy of political authority can be argued against in many ways. Traditionally, the argument that God gave government authority was valid and in accepting religion we accept this as well. If you rebel against this order, you rebel against God. It was reason enough for most people to stop questioning such authority. In the last few centuries, however, the idea of personal freedom and independence has shifted mainstream thinking to being skeptical of the religious premise of government. Just because you believe in God doesn’t mean that you believe he gives government authority over you. The rising political awareness in our societies is causing many people to wonder how much power our government should really have over us. Even if the argument of political authority by God still cannot be argued against, then what about those who do not believe in God? Are they expected to follow governmental authority just as everyone else when they do not believe a god gave authority to government? How does on reconcile that they do and still try to argue that everyone has consented in this way?
Next, is the argument of tacit consent. Those upholding this argument say that we consent to government through some action such as voting, paying taxes, or even just by living in its territory. It even goes as far to saying that we consent simply by remaining silent. Does this mean that we consent to something when we choose an option that is forced upon us? We have more options than the ones given to us by the government. It’s just that they have the power to punish us if we don’t choose from their palette of choices. The fact that we make a choice does not necessarily make it voluntary. Can one say then that if someone believes they make a choice voluntarily it constitutes consent? Is a person bound by his consent that he gave if he should not have given it? One could argue that confusion and ignorance are not states of mind that give rational consent. Obviously, we are not coerced into voting or remaining silent. When we vote we believe we might make a choice that will affect a final choice to be made. We are, however, forced into choosing between only certain choices and not necessarily ones we would have chosen by our own free will. By remaining silent do we consent? We could make the time to do something about the way our government is run in one way or another. The way set up for us is through our state representatives. Whether or not we voted for them or voted at all, we have a choice as to whether or not we become involved with them to voice our own opinions. That depends on if the representative has the time to listen to us and if they agree with our point of view. Is this a realistic way of trying to change our options? Lobbying is certainly another way of getting our opinions noticed, but also depends on the representatives’ point of view. Becoming an activist is another option for changing government. The squeaky wheel gets the grease, right? This depends on how many other people agree with you in order to start anything that will get noticed. Even if you do get noticed, then who is to say whether anything will change or not? Why should one even have to go to these measures in order to make an individual choice according to their own free will?
There is also the argument of majority consent. According to this theory, not everyone is required to consent, but a degree of the majority is sufficient to make a governmental command legitimate. Who is to say, though, whether a ruler would rule according to this common will? What about when a person of this majority does not agree with a governmental decision but is forced to obey anyway? Doesn’t this invalidate their consent as part of the majority? When that majority changes according to a specific decision then the majority rule is no longer valid. The idea that prior majority consent validates it falls short in the logic for consenting to it in the first place.
It must be admitted that the theory of consent may not be realistic and the practical applications of it would make government unstable and ineffective. Since not everyone would agree to a specific law it would be extremely difficult and time consuming to ask consent from everyone on a case-by-case basis. Robert Nozick, in his essay, The Minimal State, mentions that if one could prove that the state would be better than a non-state, and if the state arose by a process involving no morally impermissible steps, then that state would be justified. This may be a valid argument for the legitimacy of political authority.
The arguments against anarchism have many problems. The first is that they all encourage ignorance of any thought regarding whether political authority is legitimate. They ask for one to follow authority blindly on the given arguments. This is obviously how authority stays in power. Also, all these theories require that a person give up free will and responsibility from themselves to authority. Rousseau said “To renounce liberty is to renounce being a man.” More questions must be asked on the validity of the arguments and more research is to be done on the practicality of them.
To my mind political anarchy is the most cruel way of ruling the country.
Другие работы по теме:
Anarchism 2 Essay Research Paper I have
Anarchism 2 Essay, Research Paper I have always thought of anarchy as a bad thing. I had the image of some English punk dressed in leather with a copious amount of metal piercings adorning his body. How deluded that image is. If you have that same visual image, then you are the person I am talking to. Throughout this paper I am going to erase that negative image of anarchism and replace it with the meaning and intent that anarchism truly represents.
Laghston Hughes Essay Research Paper RPG Vault
Laghston Hughes Essay, Research Paper RPG Vault: Tor Andre Wigmostad – December 23, 1999 It’s the year 29,475 AD, and there isn’t a single elf in sight. Humanity has colonized much of the
Party Politics In Africa Essay Research Paper
Political parties are a group of people with a defined programme organised to capture political power or stay in it through elections to control personnel and policies of government. This form of government was introduced to africa in general and ghana in particular by the colonial imperialists and it?s a form of western ideology which was not known to the ghanaian society until the advent of colonialism and it?s aftermath.
Dedicated To One Task Essay Research Paper
As the Human Race enters the new millenium we have created a somewhat organized and affective society. This society consists of many states that govern their people by allowing them to go about their daily activities and providing them services without a large amount of chaos interfering in their lives “Human beings usually do not venture out of their caves (or the modern counterpart) unless there is a reasonable probability that they can return safely.” (Lowi & Ginsberg, 12) Whether a particular government is very constricting or very helpful to the citizens, humans flock into political societies in order to concentrate on their allowed freedoms instead of anarchy in which legality and a right of ownership are non-existent.
Thomas Hobbes Injustice
& Sovereign Essay, Research Paper Political Philosophy 101: Essay 2 Aaron Lavack ?It has already been shown, that nothing the sovereign representative can do to a subject?can properly be called injustice, or injury?? [Hobbes, Leviathan] What does Hobbes mean by this? Why does he believe it?
The Representatin Of The Gauch Essay Research
Paper During the 1820 s there was no national government in Argentina, at least not one which survived for long. In the year 1820, the year of anarchy , the province of Buenos Aires itself had at least twenty-four governors. In the rest of the country government was in the hands of the local gaucho leaders – caudillos.
Anarchy Essay Research Paper Anarchy coming from
Anarchy Essay, Research Paper Anarchy, coming from the greek term meaning “without government”, is the political theory that society does not need a government to run the country or any governmental fundings
Anarchy Essay Research Paper Anarchy noun 1
Anarchy Essay, Research Paper Anarchy: noun. 1. Absence of any form of political authority. 2. Political disorder and confusion. 3. Absence of any cohering principle, as a common standard or purpose. [Greek anarkhia, without a ruler] (American Heritage Dictionary). Anarchy is a political philosophy shrouded in misconception.
Anarchy Essay Research Paper Anarchy Anarchy Anarchism
Anarchy Essay, Research Paper Anarchy Anarchy Anarchism seems to be defined many ways by many different sources. Most dictionary definitions define anarchism as the absence of government. A leading modern dictionary, Webster’s Third International Dictionary, defines anarchism briefly but accurately as, “a political theory opposed to all forms of government and governmental restraint and advocating voluntary cooperation and free association of individuals and groups in order to satisfy their needs.” Other dictionaries describe anarchism with similar definitions.
Anarchy Essay Research Paper AnarchyThe word anarchy
Anarchy Essay, Research Paper Anarchy The word anarchy comes from the Greek term meaning without a government. Anarchy is a form of government in which there is no government. The people under an anarchy have no rules or anyone to tell them what they can or can t do. An anarchist is someone how believes in an anarchy form of government and does acts to bring about this form of government.
Second Coming Essay Research Paper The poem
Second Coming Essay, Research Paper The poem The Second Coming was written by William Butler Yeats in 1919. Yeats was an accomplished Irish poet and was known for the socio-religious ideas he emphasized in his poetry. In The Second Coming, his ideas unfold in three significant metaphors.
Political Propaganda Essay Research Paper The Deception
Political Propaganda Essay, Research Paper The Deception of Political Propaganda Have you ever heard a political speech? Did you find you self in favor of the speakers idea after his speech sometimes even if you weren?t before. Politicians use political language to make us have a certain felling about something.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Institutions
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Institutions The main idea in this essay, I believe, is how institutions can be so complex with their chain of laws, traditions, custom ideas that provide structure and order of political life. Civilization evolves and changes, and crafted by people who would mold institutions by their own ideology or philosophical view of politics.
Importance Of Priority In Today
’s Society Essay, Research Paper Importance of Priority in Today’s Society In today’s society it is of the ultimate importance to keep self- discipline as a major priority. Right now we may not realize it, but we are not
Gandhi Economic Freedom And Politics Essay Research
Paper Economic means are often used to achieve political goals. There are some situations in which economic action has been used to achieve a political goal. One of these actions is the boycott of British goods led by Mohandas Gandhi.
Anarchy 2 Essay Research Paper Anarchy is
Anarchy 2 Essay, Research Paper Anarchy is the theory of life and conduct under which social interactions exist without government interference or assistance. It is not chaos,
Verdict Of Political Leaders Essay Research Paper
Verdict of Political Leaders Political leaders have many responsibilities. However their personal life should not be interfered with their business life. If political leaders make poor decisions pertaining to their personal lives, there?s a possibility that they will make poor decisions in their business life.
The Ancient City Essay Research Paper The
The Ancient City Essay, Research Paper The Ancient City Pompeii How democratic was Pompeian politics? In order to answer the above question, it is first necessary to consider the exact meaning of the term democracy . Whilst it is difficult to give an exact definition of the word, it is certainly possible to create a list of the implications of democratic government for a society and its citizens.
The Gradual Development Of Chaos Among The
Boys In Lord Of The Flies Essay, Research Paper Lord of the Flies was written by William Golding, and the topic of this essay is to show how Golding suggests that the boys on the island gradually move from their civilized behavior to total anarchy. In the book, Lord of the Flies, an undefined number of boys are stranded on a desert island, and a leader is chosen.
Plato Essay Research Paper Plato was a
Plato Essay, Research Paper Plato was a philosopher in the time of the distinguished Greek philosophers. He wrote a book entitled The Republic in which he explains some of his philosophy on subjects ranging from education to government. Plato constructed a model by which he proposed all governments evolve.
Government Essay Research Paper 2 We know
Government Essay, Research Paper 2. We know that the fundamental difference between ancient political science and modern political science has to do with the relationship of the individual to the state. For Aristotle, a person was an inherently political animal. For modern political philosophers (social contract theorists), individual rights existed prior to the formation of government.
Campaign Finance Reform Essay Research Paper Campaign
Campaign Finance Reform Essay, Research Paper Campaign Finance Reform: Soft Money One of the key issues facing this year?s Presidential Campaign is campaign finance reform. More specifically, whether or not to ban soft
Political Change Essay Research Paper Political ChangeIn
Political Change Essay, Research Paper Political Change In the French and Russian Revolutions, could political change have occurred without bloodshed and the use of force? In the French and Russian Revolutions, there was a lot of force and bloodshed used. Can political change occur without the use of bloodshed and force?
Federalism In Political Culture Essay Research Paper
The Significance of Federalism in Political Culture The United States government is constructed of many systems and ideas which, when bound together, create the Democratic government utilized by the country. All of
Liberalism In Political Ideologies Essay Research Paper
Political ideology, Webster?s defines it as integrated assertions, theories and aims, that constitute a sociopolitical program (Webster, 2000). In essence, an ideology is a set of beliefs about economical, political, social and cultural issues. These beliefs together form a plan for a productive and beneficial political system.
Locke And The American Political System Essay
, Research Paper John Locke and his ideas about philosophy was a major influence on the American political system, not to mention many other political systems, too. His ideas were very
Political Power Essay Research Paper Political power
Political Power Political power can simply be defined as the power to influence. The power to influence is essentially the power to control. When pertaining to political matters, the most influential people in any form of government have the most power. The underlying argument is between who has the most influence.
Law And Society Essay Research Paper Law
Law And Society Essay, Research Paper Law and Society The function of law in a society is more or less universal. It acts as a deterrent to control the evil and treacherous behavior of humans, to maintain discipline and imposes restrictions on some freedom. We live in a chaotic and uncertain world. Without an orderly environment based on and backed by law, the normal activities of life would be lacerated with chaos.