Paper
Edmund Burke s Reflections on the French Revolution
Edmund Burke s renowned book of 1790 is as famous as any text in the history of
politics, and as controversial. Reflections on the French Revolution has been and will
most likely continue to be the subject of many disagreements, however its distinction is
usually admitted even by those whose ideology makes them an opponent of its principles.
Burke claimed that the revolution went wrong because its leaders tried to scrap an entire
political system and replace it overnight rather than change things slowly and within the
current system. He relates this to the outlook of the philosophes, political rationalists
whose methods lacked realism in an era where abstractness can be fatal. These are also
points that few would argue with, and Burke makes strong cases for both of these points.
It is true that the wholesale abolition of an entire order in France in 1789 created immense
confusion during the period of transformation. The old Feudalism system was declared
dead, which meant the dissolution of institutions such as the army, local government, the
judicial system, and the clergy. As this relates to philosophes political ideology, it did
indeed consist of in good part a general adage without much detail creating a revolution
that was good at destruction put not helpful in the rebuilding process.
Whether Burke s analysis of the French Revolution was right or wrong, the events
in France stimulated him to formulate his political philosophy. Burke s sense for the
subtle points in politics makes this an important book. The leading idea emerging from
this piece of literature was that society is a vast and complicated historical product which
may not be tinkered with at will like a machine. It is a repository for collective human
wisdom to be regarded with reverence, and if it is reformed it must be with due respect for
the continuity of its programs and traditions. There were other related ideas: that a
political community is something made by history, an unanalyzed bond between men
which makes free government possible; that the social organism has its natural aristocracy
which common types of men must and do and respect in a healthy society; and that general
rules and abstract principles are no help to politics.
With the disdain for the abstract rights proclaimed by the French Burke tried to
make clear the real rights of man. Burke certainly believed in rights, but he stressed the
degree to which men in entering civil society must give up some of their liberties in order
to gain advantages of government. He distrusted the restless innovator who had no
patience to search out the wisdom of their ancestors but must draw amateur blueprints for
the total reconstruction of society, as if they were the first to ever think about it. The
science of government is not for those, whose visionary schemes are abstractly true but
are morally and politically false. Burke was pious and felt that political society was sound
only on Christian foundations. To Burke two human needs were evident above all others,
history and religion. Man is a religious animal who, if he did not have Christianity would
turn to some other , and probably less satisfactory faith. He is a social animal, who would
be no more than a beast if he were cut off from the fabric of ancient custom and tradition
that sustains him. Reverence toward God and toward the social order are therefore the
two great duties, and they are linked, for history is the revelation of God s purpose.
Perhaps it was not necessarily conservative in the most obvious sense of this
word. In suggesting an empirical approach to the enormous complexity of human affairs,
in place of the vague sloganizing of the philosophes, Burke may well be viewed as the
founder of a real science of social reform, rather than as a hidebound conservative. He
was certainly not opposed to change, if properly carried out, and his own career, that of a
person of humble birth, consisted of one passionate crusade after another. His more
famous crusades were on behalf of American independence, Ireland, India, and against the
French Revolution. He always seemed to need a great cause to serve, some monstrous
injustice to repair.
There was also the very conservative Burke, the Burke traits that came to be
thought of as conservative. The feeling of piety for the social order, the mistrust of
harebrained reformers with a one shot plan, the organic concept of social growth, these
were the foundation of the conservative faith. A great deal of Burke has been accepted as
essential political wisdom for anyone who wants to participate in politics. The features of
Burke that are less appealing to most moderns include his belief in the aristocracy, with
the accompanying rejection of equality.
Burke lacked faith in the capacity of individuals to think and reason things out for
themselves. He viewed society as a collective, and that collective was more responsible
and rational than was the individual. Man, in his opinion, is by nature unequal; all men are
not created equal. He also believed man to be very religious by nature, and that politics
should be closely intertwined with religion.
Burke believed society was a contract, not easily broken, between those who have
lived, are living, and are going to live. The aim of this contract is for all of society to
achieve the good life as a whole. Society develops because individuals lack the ability to
govern his own actions. It is up to the aristocracy, the more enlightened class in society,
to see that the present generation builds on the culture established by the past for the
future. Society develops for the good of the whole. Burke also believes that people
should absolutely obey the government. The people obey because they were taught to
obey, like countless generations before them. Burke s society would have a deep
reverence for the past. The past would be responsible for many of societies laws, these
laws coming from a countries customs. Custom is the groundwork or roots of society,
and to challenge or disrupt them could undermind it.
To Burke the best form of government would be an aristocracy that rules with a
monarch, the old British system. Burke believed that the aristocracy was part of God s
scheme for governing society. It is his idea that the aristocracy, and people with wealth
were the keeper of societies political wisdom. He also believes in an idea called virtual
representation because he feels only men with property should be allowed to vote. People
have common interests and Burke believed that the landed people act on the behalf of the
non-landed people. Burke strongly believes in the system that has evolved in Britain,
though he believed that there can be no system of politics that can be used in all nations.
Politics is about dealing with situations, and there is no exact way of accomplishing
political ends. For Burke tradition is the democracy of the dead, the appeal to historical
experience, and a recognition of the role of individuals in history. In my opinion, taking
into account Burke s ideas of a reverence for culture and the past, that the best form of
government is what best suits a countries culture. The government that has evolved over
time.
Burke believes that humans have different capacities for freedom. Basically,
freedom and liberty are class issues, and rights are closely related to class, rank, and
privilege. Basically he doesn t mention anything about basic fundamental rights other than
the government should not be oppressive. According to Burke humans are absolutely not
equal, and should not be equal. To Burke inequality among classes is one of the
foundations of society, and is natural. To try and level out the inequality among classes
only disrupts the natural order, and never ends in equality. The higher classes should also
have all the power, and control the lower classes. The aristocracy should be the ruling
class in Burke s society. He believes that the aristocracy is part of God s plan to rule
society. However it is wrong for the aristocracy to use their power to oppress the lower
classes.
Burke was a philosophical conservative on almost all issues. While opposed to the
emerging liberalism in Europe, he was also equally critical of revolutionary change or
unchanging reaction. Revolution was especially detrimental, for it sweeps away all sound
principles of political action and discards nature s guidance on a nation. Political
institutions were part of an order which included nature in which things were kept fast in
their place, as they should be. The task of statesmen was, therefore, a threefold
obligation: (1) to take account of all relevant circumstances:(2) to act on the basis of
prudence and caution, which were the cardinal virtues; and (3) to preserve and improve
the legacy of tradition. In differentiating between different actions in history, Burke stated
that the French Revolution was a complete break with the past, and therefore a negative
for the country. However the English, American, and Indian rebellions of the near past
tried to recover past privileges and traditions, and therefore were positive. Many of
Burke s thoughts were attacked by liberal journalists including Thomas Paine, whose
attack was such a harsh blow to Burke that he never fully recovered.
Другие работы по теме:
French Revolution 2 Essay Research Paper Have
French Revolution 2 Essay, Research Paper Have you ever thought, “Did the world just become the way it is gradually over time, or was there an actual turning point that can be referred to?” The answer is yes there was an actual turning point, the French Revolution. The French Revolution was a turning point in European political and social history, and was a period that changed the outcome of world history dramatically.
The Senegal Tribe Essay Research Paper The
The Senegal Tribe Essay, Research Paper The Senegal Tribe Many students of African history wonder why the native people of Africa did not rise up in violent rebellion against their Imperialist conquerers. What
Napolean Bonaparte Essay Research Paper Napoleon Bonaparte
Napolean Bonaparte Essay, Research Paper Napoleon Bonaparte ? French Revolution Napoleon was the cure of the French Revolution when he came to power. It would be impossible to put them together. From what was chaos throughout France during the Revolution, came a new government that Napoleon created. He was able to balance the government?s budgets and setting up national banks thus helping and supporting the economy of France.
Western Front Essay Research Paper On 3rd
Western Front Essay, Research Paper On 3rd August, 1914, German troops crossed the Belgian border in the narrow gap between Holland and France. The German First and Second Armies swept aside the small Belgian Army and by 20th August had occupied Brussels.
Jewish Societies Essay Research Paper Until the
Jewish Societies Essay, Research Paper Until the late 18th century, The Jewish societies all over the world were treated unfairly. Hatred and discrimination were used against because of their
Rocket Essay Research Paper comes to hockey
Rocket Essay, Research Paper comes to hockey, both groups share a deep passion. English-Canadians proudly cheer for their Toronto Maple Leafs, while the French-French and English
30 Year War Essay Research Paper Why
30 Year War Essay, Research Paper Why Would France, a Catholic power, help Protestants in the Thirty Years War? The Thirty Years War was a time of great religious conflict. The Calvinists opposed the Lutherans and the Catholics opposed the Protestants. Each side had no tolerance for the other and felt a deep hatred for them.
French Revolution 4 Essay Research Paper The
French Revolution 4 Essay, Research Paper The causes of the French Revolution, being provoked by this collision of the powers of the rising bourgeoise and an sinking aristocracy defending its privileges, was the Financial debt of the government and the long-standing political differences in the government.
French Rev Essay Research Paper The year
French Rev Essay, Research Paper The year 1989 marks the 200th anniversary of the French Revolution. To celebrate, the French government is throwing its biggest party in at least
French And German Constitution Essay Research Paper
The executive in the French Vth Republic and the executive in the Federal republic in Germany have a few similarities and many differences. Since the French Vth constitution was tailor made by DeGaulles himself, the executive in this republic is very strong and authoritative. However, the executive in the Federal Republic of Germany, (the Bundesrepublik- Germany after 1945) was made up to prevent another Hitler from raising up, so it is very weak and is more of an executive figurehead.
The Louisiana Purchase Essay Research Paper The
The Louisiana Purchase Essay, Research Paper The Louisiana Purchase was the purchase of the French province of Louisiana by the United States in 1803. The province stretched from the Mississippi River westward to the
Euro Essay Research Paper Tax breaks promised
Euro Essay, Research Paper Tax breaks promised by France and Italy to lorry drivers who mounted fuel price protest blockades in the summer looked to set to cause controversy among EU finance ministers meeting in Brussels today (19 January). The concessions are illegal under EU competition law and upset some of the countries? EU partners who were angry that the French and Italian governments gave in to the protesters.
Impressionism And Postimpressionism Essay Research Paper Impressionism
Impressionism And Postimpressionism Essay, Research Paper Impressionism was a form of art in the late nineteenth century that used luminosity, subtlety of tone and preoccupation with sensation. The impressionist subject matter preserved the romantic fascination with nature and the realist preoccupation with late century French society.
England And Global Language Essay Research Paper
This essay will be about the prohibition of English words in France by law. It is quiet a big problem to forbid words only because the government is afraid that it s own language could die. The spread of English all over the world and it s position as global language can t be stopped or disputed and that is why I think that it is irresponsible to outlaw English words.
John Doe Essay Research Paper French Revolution
John Doe Essay, Research Paper French Revolution “Revolutions evolve in definite phases. At first they are moderate in scope, then they become radical to excess and finally they are brought to abrupt conclusions by the emerg…
Looking Beyond The Sexes Essay Research Paper
A woman gets pregnant, and her boyfriend leaves her. In Karen Horney?s ?The Distrust Between the Sexes?, she explains how a person?s psychological history causes him/her to distrust people of the opposite sex because of certain expectations they might have. Longings for happiness, childhood reflections, and childhood conflicts are all things that invent these expectations.
French Government Essay Research Paper The modern
French Government Essay, Research Paper The modern French government is run very much like the government of the United States. France is a democratic republic that is divided into three branches,
Reflections Of Knights And Their Archetypal Damsels
(King Arthur) Essay, Research Paper 495 words Reflections of Knights and Their Archetypal Damsels In The Acts of King Arthur and His Noble Knights, there are many different relationships between knights and their damsels. The damsels, in some ways, reflect in different ways throughout the knights. Some example of knights and their damsels are Merlin and Nyneve, Ewain and Lyne, and Sir Accolon and Morgan Le Fay.
Colonial Society And Economy Essay Research Paper
There were numerous effects of the French and Indian War; the Peace of Paris of 1763 ended the French and Indian War, closing all French power in North America. With the Death of King George II, the new English king, King George the III, wanted to put an end to the French and Indian War, pursuing peace and agreement.
Arthurian Romance Essay Research Paper Arthurian RomanceArthurian
Arthurian Romance Essay, Research Paper Arthurian Romance Arthurian romance has been changed over and over again throughout the years in order to keep up with the audience of the moment. Throughout history Arthurian romance was and still is being used in many different forms. The Celtic s Arthurian romance was much different from that of the French.
The French Language Charter Essay Research Paper
Expository Essay – The French Language Charter In 1977, the French Language Charter (Bill 101) was introduced to the residents of Quebec by the Parti Quebecois . It made French the official language in the province. Bill
Louis Pasteur Essay Research Paper The French
Louis Pasteur Essay, Research Paper The French chemist Louis Pasteur devoted his life to solving practical problems of industry, agriculture, and medicine. His discoveries have saved countless lives and created new wealth for the world. Among his discoveries are the pasteurization process and ways of preventing silkworm diseases, anthrax, chicken cholera, and rabies.
Metric System Essay Research Paper Metric SystemThe
Metric System Essay, Research Paper Metric System The Metric System, also known as the System Internationale (SI) was developed in France in 1799. The Metric System was created because the French and English were not in agreement politically, therefore the French did not want anything to do with the English including their system of measurements.
Chicken Or Egg Essay Research Paper Which
Chicken Or Egg Essay, Research Paper Which came first, Chicken? Or Egg? The answer is that this is the wrong question. The trouble here is the word ‘First’s. A human life contains many firsts, so the word comes easily to our lips. For example, a creationist could ask how the metamorphosis of a butterfly occurred for the ‘First time’.
President Roosevelt Essay Research Paper In 1943
President Roosevelt Essay, Research Paper In 1943 President Roosevelt suggested that Indochina come under the control of four powers after the war, proposing that the eventual independence of the Indo-chinese might follow in twenty to thirty years time. No one knew whether the policy would require American troops, but America was firm on the fact that independence could not be taken by the Vietnamese, but would be granted to the Vietnamese by the Great Powers at their convenience.
The French And Indian War Essay Research
Paper The French and Indian War The French and Indian War was fought on July 9, 1755. This battle took place at Fort Duquesne, in western Pennsylvania, which was one of the many
French Essay Research Paper From a young
French Essay, Research Paper From a young age, the French are taught to adhere to a certain schedule which helps them learn to be more independent people as they grow older and become adults. Typical work hours for the French are from around nine in the morning until about six in the evening. Interestingly lunch is an important meal for them and they set aside around two hours in the afternoon for this meal.
The Red Balloon Essay Research Paper The
The Red Balloon Essay, Research Paper The Red Balloon Essay The Red Balloon is about a little boy and his love for a red balloon. The movie is a French short movie which won the Cannes Film Festival Award. The film has many symbolic meanings. The movie begins when a little boy finds a large, red balloon. He rescues the balloon from a lampost and takes it to school.
The French Sociologists Essay Research Paper The
The French Sociologists Essay, Research Paper The French sociologists (holistic approach), during the eighteenth and nineteenth century were much concerned with the nature of society and of the human social institutions. Their interests
Slavery And The History Of The Negro
. Essay, Research Paper Slavery and the History of the Negro. The issue of slavery has been touched upon often in the course of history. The institution of slavery was addressed by French