International Trade Essay, Research Paper
INTERNATIONAL TRADE (EC549)
EDI HOUADRIA ESSAY #1
Subject #2: Does the Leontief paradox invalidate the Heckscher-Ohlin model of trade?
Why and how countries trade has always been a difficult and capital question for economists. The Ricardian model explained trade patterns through differences in labour productivity, however international trade can only partially be explained this way. It has also been wildly believed that resource allocation also plays a vital role in how nations trade, Heckscher-Ohlin (H-O), two Swedish economists, were the first to integrate resource allocation in an economic model of trade now referred to as the Heckscher-Ohlin model of trade. This theory was generally accepted when it was published. However Leontief published empirical data about USAtrading (1953) that was largely inconsistent with the H-O theory of trade. Since then data about what countries trade has been so inconsistent and confusing that there is no real empirical data supporting the H-O model of trade. Thus there are flaws in the original H-O theory; the questions now are : why isn?t there any empirical data, and under what conditions is it possible to make the model consistent with reality?
The H-O theory is also called the factor proportion theory this is because it stresses the importance of the allocation of different factors of production, and what proportion they play in what countries trade. This model is capable of explaining the different input combinations producers may face, which is the optimal one and thus the comparative advantage the nation thus possesses.
The simplest way to explain this model is by explaining how it works in a two-factor economy (two kind of industries with two kinds of inputs), and what happens when this economy opens to trade with a twin nation.
Thus we have a nation who produces two goods i.e. cloth and food, and these goods necessitate two factors of production i.e. land and labour, of course this is set under the conditions of pure and perfect competition thus both factors are mobile. This model explains how the variations of the price or quantity of one factor can have an influence upon the other. For example if the quantity of land suddenly varies this will have little effect upon cloth who is more labour intensive, on the other hand food who is more land intensive will probably have an important price and wage variation ; therefor it is possible to assume that there is an important correlation between the rent of land and the wages of labour, and there is also correlation between the price of food and the price cloth (as illustrated beneath). Depending on these ratios a country can determine in what kind of sector it has a comparative advantage. This is due to the
Input possibilities in food production
fact that changes in the different factors affect the different sectors in a disproportionate manner advantaging one and disadvantaging the other.
If this nation comes to open to trade with another nation, this will lead to factor price convergence, the workforce involved in the countries most abundant factor gain , whereas on the other hand the owners of the countries most scarce resource will probably lose from trade, there are though, important suppositions, both countries produce both goods, technologies are the same, no barriers to trade. Thus trade equalises the relative price of all factors, this is because trade is but a mask, for countries through food and cloth are in fact trading factor endowments and labour.
The US which is the country in the world with the most capital per unit of labour, and thus has a comparative advantage in capital intensive goods. Applying the H-O model to the US should reveal that it exports capital intensive goods. However Leontief studied US exports for the 25 years following World War2, and revealed that US imports were consistently more capital intensive than it?s exports which goes against all the conclusions of the H-O model. The study also outlined the fact that US exports were more skill intensive. This study shatters all the assumptions of the H-O theory because the US is one of the most liberal nations, and one whose sheer economic size means that if it is not possible to include it in the H-O theory, how much is the H-O really worth?
Since then many have addressed the issue but even there studies are confusing however some seem to be pointing in the right direction. First of all it seems that economists have wrongly been considering the nature of what can be considered as a factor in the H-O model. The factors considered should be immobile in the sense that this combination of factors (in those specific proportions and quantities), is unique to this particular nation(i.e. natural resources and labour). However many economists have considered capital as being one of those factor inputs. But capital nowadays is something that can travel more freely than ever. This is largely due to the fact that many free trade areas have been created (EU, NAFTA?), and the appearance of big trans-national companies that can easily move large sums of capital to a subsidiary branch in another nation. Another assumption that greatly hinders the H-O model of trade is the fact that it assumes that technology is the same everywhere and even though machines can be bought it can be argued that technology is relatively immobile, thus creating greater differences in the needs of firms to operate with skill or unskilled labour.
Another problem is how the different sectors have evolved ; the primary sector depends much more upon natural resource allocation than any other sector. Natural resources are truly immobile and specific to a country thus the H-O model applies quite well to patterns of trade applied to primary goods. On the other hand it is more complicated to compare and set a pattern of inter-sector trade because of the difference between the nature of primary agricultural goods (traded by the south) and industrial goods (traded by the north). This is because agricultural goods prices have a tendency to fall or increase relatively slowly compared to the price of industrial goods who increase rapidly. Thus the benefits of trade implied in the H-O model can be greatly deformed or void.
However it is important to point out that the evidence that arises from the Leontief report against the H-O model must be taken into it?s context, the US has a unique status, in the fact that it is the technologically most advanced country in the world which maybe implies that it specialises in exports of relatively new sophisticated products, which are maybe to sophisticated to be produced by capital instead of skill. Thus explaining why it imports more mature products from heavy manufactures that are more capital intensive.
It is now clearer what are the weaknesses of the H-O theory, however it is possible to make it perform relatively well under certain conditions. First of all it is necessary to chose factors that are immobile the best examples of this is of course is the level of skill amongst labour relative to their wages, and the natural resources of a country. Secondly if capital should be included it should under the form of interest rates, a country with a lower interest rate (compared to world average), thus has a comparative advantage in capital endowments. However this can be generally omitted because interest rates do not change much from a country to another. Finally H-O must be applied to sectors where resource allocation is crucial because like North South trading or primary products, otherwise similarities between nations can make endogenous factors come into account like national preferences or protectionism (to a certain extent).
The H-O theory is a very complete instrument that can help if correctly used with the right factors in the right sectors. However it is far from giving us a complete general theory on how countries trade. The limitations thus imposed restrict it mainly to north-south trading, it also helps put into perspective the true role of labour skill in trade patterns as well as the role of technology. The H-O model is not the truth but simply an instrument that can give us an idea what the big picture is.
-P.Krugman, ?International Economics?, International Edition.
-A.Wood, ?Give Hecksher and Ohlin a Chance?, SLC.
-W.Staiger ?An evaluation of factor endowments and??,SLC
Другие работы по теме:
BioTechnology Essay Research Paper The shortterm future
Bio-Technology Essay, Research Paper The short-term future of biotechnology in production agriculture looks bleak. The unattractive truth is that economics, not science can play a larger role in the future of biotechnology.
Protectionism Versus FreeTrad Essay Research Paper The
Protectionism Versus Free-Trad Essay, Research Paper The main objective of the following paper is to explain the protectionism versus free trade argument, to explain the problems this debate has created in the arena of international trade and to outline the ways in which international agreements have contributed to their resolve.
Personal Injuries Essay Research Paper Security Committee
Personal Injuries Essay, Research Paper Security Committee Topic A: Disarmament of Paramilitary Groups in the Former Yugoslavia Argentina The Committee on Disarmament and International Security has taken upon the task of disarming paramilitary groups in Yugoslavia. It is important that we examine states’ policies toward disarmament and prevention of the proliferation of light weapons.
African Slave Trade Essay Research Paper With
African Slave Trade Essay, Research Paper With exploration arising in the 1400 s, so did the completion for success between Portugal and Spain. Both countries were in search for the ultimate prize of exploration, gold. Portugal sought after Africa and Spain attempted to find more in the Americas. Even though the African slave trade seemed racist in historical perspective, it was indeed more for economic benefits instead because of the necessity of workers by Spaniards and fact that slavery was accepted in Africa.
Mercantilism Essay Research Paper Mercantilism as a
Mercantilism Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism as a global economic policy tends to subscribe to the following premises: wealth is an essential means to power, power is essential as a means to the acquisition of wealth, wealth and power are each proper ultimate ends of national policy, and there is a long run balance of trade between these ends.
Land Mines Essay Research Paper Land mines
Land Mines Essay, Research Paper Land mines greatly contribute to the danger of international security because they are used as military weapons. Because land mines have caused great destruction there has been an effort from international and non-governmental organizations to ban mines and clear areas infected with them.
Slave Trades Essay Research Paper African slave
Slave Trades Essay, Research Paper African slave trade to the America and the European was much worse than slavery in Africa. In this essay ,I will show you the differences. Where were the slave trade took place. Slavery was mostly happing in North America in the carribean and in Europe.The ships full of slaves mostly come to Cuba.
Atlantic Slave Trade Essay Research Paper Atlantic
Atlantic Slave Trade Essay, Research Paper Atlantic Slave Trade When most people talk about or think about slavery, they look at how it effected the US. The Atlantic Slave Trade had a huge effect on the US but there are no words or expressions that can describe the effects it had on Africa and its family?s. It is estimated that between 1450 and 1900, there were 11,698,000 slaves exported from Africa. (Atlantic Slave trade, pg.170) To understand the effects this had on Africa you must consider the families that lost relatives, the stores that lost business, and even the friends that lost friendships.
Foreign Bribary Essay Research Paper Since moral
Foreign Bribary Essay, Research Paper Since moral standards vary across cultures, firms that develop in global markets have to face more complex ethical issues than if they just made business in one country and one culture. Laws and customs in one country don’t necessarily agree with the laws and customs from another country and that is what makes the international business system so complex.
Advantages Of Technology In The International Market
Essay, Research Paper Technology plays a major role in international trade. Databases, overnight delivery and faxes have opened the world market to not only larger companies but small ones too. To add to this globalization, companies and even competitors are combining and forming alliances to cut cost and increase the profit margin.
Greeks Essay Research Paper The Greek International
Greeks Essay, Research Paper The Greek International System The Greeks settled around the Greek peninsula and the islands in the Aegean Sea. They also went to areas located in India. Through the International system, city-states are formed sovereign within themselves. With the Greeks, there was a conglomeration of city-states that had external pressures by the Persians.
The Silk Road Essay Research Paper The
The Silk Road Essay, Research Paper The Silk Road is the most well-known trading route of ancient Chinese civilization. Trade in silk grew under the Han Dynasty in the first and second centuries. Originally, the Chinese trade silk internally, within the empire. Caravans from the empire’s interior would carry silk to the western edges of the region.
European Union Essay Research Paper EUROPE ESSAYThe
European Union Essay, Research Paper EUROPE ESSAY The European Union is a movement that will let Europe trade easier. Europeans are removing the borders to let it be easier to enter into a different country. They figured that the U.S. had few problems with it, they are going to try.
The Golden Marmoset Essay Research Paper Golden
The Golden Marmoset Essay, Research Paper Golden marmosets, or Leontopithecus chrysomelas, have a mane derived from long hairs on the top of the head, cheeks and throat. The golden marmoset is predominantly black with golden to reddish-orange on the front of the mane, the lower half of the front paws and part of the tail.
CITES Essay Research Paper CITESCITES is
C.I.T.E.S Essay, Research Paper CITES CITES is the singles most important treaty protecting species at an international level. CITES stands for Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species. It was established in 1973 in association with the United Nations Environmental Program (UNEP). Currently, the treaty has been ratified by more than 120 countries.
Consequences Of Trade Restrictions And Tariffs Essay
, Research Paper Consequences of Trade Restrictions and Tariffs How does imposing trade restrictions affect a country’s macro economic objectives? Nowadays all countries need to trade between themselves. Countries
Modernization Vs Dependency Essay Research Paper MODERNIZATION
Modernization Vs. Dependency Essay, Research Paper MODERNIZATION VS. DEPENDENCY The modernization perspective is behavioral or microsociological the primary focus is on individuals or aggregates of individuals, their values, attitudes, and beliefs. The dependency perspective, by contrast, is structural or macrosociological its focus is on the mode of production, patterns of international trade, political and economic linkages between elites in peripheral and central countries, group and class alliances and conflicts, and so on. (Valenzuela & Valenzuela, 1978)
Australian Foreign Policy Essay Research Paper What
Australian Foreign Policy Essay, Research Paper What is Foreign Policy?Foreign Policy is a nations? attitude, actions (ie economic sanctions, peacekeeping, military activity) as well as our dealings with other countries (ie trade, immigration, aid, defence) and anything that is directed towards preserving and furthering certain national interests.
Communication Essay Research Paper CommunicationCommunication is very
Communication Essay, Research Paper Communication Communication is very important to your customers. An aspect of communication is personal trade. Personal trade is a customer that comes into your store and asks for you by name. This customer might be someone you spoke with over the phone and a relationship was developed.
Intewrnationl Day Essay Research Paper International DayInternational
Intewrnationl Day Essay, Research Paper International Day International Day was a day where the students from foreign country’s get to share there pride in there country and culture and that’s exactly what they did. This international day was the first one I’ve ever attended and I will attend them from now on.
The International Monetary Fund Essay Research Paper
The International Monetary Fund The original policies and goals created in 1944 by the International Monetary Fund(IMF) differ little from the main focus of the organization at present. The IMF was created to rebuild and stabilize the world economy after World War II. And to this day it continues in its efforts to support and stabilize the economies of its member nations.
Should Canada And The Us Trade Essay
, Research Paper Should Canada and the US trade with China? With all the civil rights abused in China, should the Canada and the US be trading with them? In the view of one side, we should not trade with China because of these abused rights. It is thought that if we stop all trade with them, we will have an impact on their economy and they will at least cut down on their civil rights abuses in order to regain our trade and economy.
World Trade Organization Essay Research Paper THE
World Trade Organization Essay, Research Paper THE U.S. ALLIANCE FOR TRADE EXPANSION The U.S. Alliance for Trade Expansion, representing $2 trillion in annual trade and over 150 million American consumers, farmers, and workers, seeks to promote economic growth, job expansion, and higher living standards in the United States by rules-based multilateral trade liberalization through the World Trade Organization (WTO).
Internationl Trade Essay Research Paper International TradeIn
Internationl Trade Essay, Research Paper International Trade In today s world there are many issues in need of reformation, one of which is international trade, otherwise known as globalization. Although there are a great deal of rules, regulations, and policies imposed on international trade, the manner in which those rules have been enforced is a major controversy that seems to be escalating day by day.
International Students Essay Research Paper International Students
International Students Essay, Research Paper International Students on Campus There are many International students that attend East Texas University. There are Hispanics, Russians, and Chinese that attend this institution. I talked to Mario and he said that East Texas really helps the International students in many ways.
WTO Essay Research Paper World Trade OrganizationThe
WTO Essay, Research Paper World Trade Organization The World Trade Organization, (WTO), is the primary international body to help promote free trade, by drawing up the rules of international trade. It has been criticized for being very opaque and not allowing enough public participation, while being very welcoming to large corporations.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Retail Trade Essay Research Paper Write a
Retail Trade Essay, Research Paper Write a structure-performance study of the retail trade industry Paper should include the ff structure 1 Introduction. In this section you give an overview of the industry, its size, growth over the past 10-20 yrs, its important to the economy and other significant factors. 1-2 pages
Child Porn Essay Research Paper The child
Child Porn Essay, Research Paper The child sex trade has been traditionally identified with underdeveloped third-world countries; particularly in Southeast Asia, where the cheap prices, ready availability of underage prostitutes and lax law enforcement have attracted Western sex tourists. However, the child sex trade is ever present in even the most civilised and advanced countries, and is an age-old problem that has long been underestimated.
Globalization Essay Research Paper Globalization is the
Globalization Essay, Research Paper Globalization is ?the integration of states through increasing contact, communication and trade to create a holistic, single global system in which the process of change increasingly binds people together in a common fate. ? Some economists recognize globalization as being in the best interest of all states, while others believe that increasingly liberated trade and global economic interaction is detrimental in many ways.
International Business Essay Research Paper The Rise
International Business Essay, Research Paper The Rise of International Business In today s global arena, international business plays a critical role in the success and longevity of almost all business activity. The growth and expansion of international business has been dramatic in recent years, overtaking that of domestic business.