Heloise Essay, Research Paper
Observations on the Theologies of Abelard and Heloise
Analysis of the first two letters between Heloise and Abelard demonstrates the variety of theological and practical viewpoints of thirteenth century France. Interesting points of contrast emerge on examination of their views of theological authority, Abelard?s ?calamities?, their entry into monasticism, and the own-ership of the Convent of the Paraclete.
Theological Authority
Comparison of these letters shows a marked difference in the theological use of authorities. Heloise?s letter appeals to di-verse authorities; Abelard?s letter uses only one.
Abelard places primary theological authority in the Bible (he quotes Biblical material thirty-six times in his letter). Arguably, the letter also uses the authority of the general tradi-tion of the Church (regarding the efficacy of prayer and the Divine Office) and Abelard?s personal authority.
Heloise only rarely cites the Bible (six times in her letter, generally as parallel phrasings rather than quotations) and quotes secular and pagan authors, Seneca (110) and Aeschines Socratius. (114)
The idea of the authority of the individual is apparent in Heloise?s letter. Heloise overtly gives her own desires and moti-vations authority, ?Wholly guilty though I am, I am also, as you know, wholly innocent.? (115)
She also recognizes Abelard?s will as authoritative for her, ?I have finally denied myself every pleasure in obedience to your will, kept nothing for myself except to prove that now, even more, I am yours.? (117) Their marriage was not her will, but his. She is just as happy to be his ?mistress? or ?whore?. Her motivation for her relationship with him has been from pure motives, and should be so judged, ?God knows I never sought anything in you ex-cept yourself; I wanted simply you, nothing of yours.? (113) Her subjection to his will is her own free decision; the final arbiter then is her own will.
Heloise also raises a theology of obligation and debt. ?How great the debt by which you have bound yourself to us needs nei-ther proof nor witness.? (111) ?Remember, I implore you, what I have done, and think how much you owe me.? (117) His misfortune obligates him to comfort her, (113) not her to comfort him!
In the comparison of the two letters, then, we see a contrast between Abelard?s grounding of authority in the Bible with Heloise?s grounding of authority in the words of secular authors, the feudal concepts of debt and obligation, and the desire, mo-tives, and will of the individual.
Abelard?s Calamities
For Heloise, Abelard?s misfortunes have been caused by human be-ings; he has been ?persecuted?, ?attacked?, ?mutilated?, plotted against, slandered. (109) To Abelard, however, he has been under attack by Satan, ?May divine mercy protect me through the support of your prayers and quickly crush Satan beneath our feet.? (119) Heloise?s letter contains no reference to Satan.
In this difference, again, the individualism of Heloise is ap-parent. Given her understanding of the authority of the individ-ual, Abelard?s enemies are personally acting against him, they are not mere tools of a supernatural being. Interestingly, neither Abelard nor Heloise seem able to entertain the idea that Abelard may have treated his enemies badly, or that such concepts as tact and judgment have a place in their lives.
Their Entry into Monasticism
To Abelard, their entry into monasticism was, ?Our conversion from the world to God,? (119) that is, it was done for the love of God. In his eyes, Heloise has sanctity, ?You whose sanctity must surely have the greatest influence in the eyes of God.? (123) Her sacrifice of prayer will protect him. ?Here you have an example, sister, and an assurance how much your prayers for me may prevail on God.? (121)
Heloise, however, entered the convent for love of Abelard, not God, ?I can expect no reward for this from God, for it is certain that I have done nothing as yet for love of him.? (117)
Again, their ultimate concern is quite different. Abelard is considering their lives in relation to God while Heloise is con-sidering their lives in relation to each other.
Whose Convent is it, anyway?
Abelard, troubled by his sins, asks to be buried at the Paraclete where, ?There is no place, I think, so safe and salutary for a soul grieving for its sins and desolated by its transgres-sions than that which is specially consecrated to the true Paraclete.? (125) To Abelard, then, the convent is truly God?s.
To Heloise, however, the convent may belong ultimately to God but it is truly Abelard?s, ?And so it is yours, truly your own, this new plantation for God?s purpose.? (111) ?You devote your care to another?s vineyard; think what you owe to your own.? (112)
In this issue, also, Abelard is focused on God, while Heloise concentrates on individual this-world actions and responsibili-ties.
Synthesis
The comparison of the two letters reveals two strongly contrast-ing personalities and theologies. Abelard appears to stand in the tradition of Irenaus, Augustine, and Benedict, while Heloise emerges as a forerunner of Voltaire and Rousseau.
Abelard?s themes are centered on Biblical authority, Satan?s persecution, and a surrender to God; he focuses beyond the world on God. Heloise holds up her personal will and her love, and sees the world in terms of the actions of people, not of God and Satan. She concentrates on personal relationships within the present world.
In this short sample, we hear a conversation between a mediaeval man and a modern woman.
The ultimate goal of the humility:
When a monk has climbed all twelve steps, he will find that perfect love of God which casts out fear, by means of which everything he had observed anxiously before will now appear simple and natural. he will no longer act out of the fear of Hell, but for the love of Christ, out of good habits and with a pleasure derived of virtue. (7)
Many of the practical provisions of the Rule are intended to help the individual to be humble through obedience and through submission to and submergence in the community.
If anyone makes a mistake in chanting?he must immediately humble himself publicly. (45)
If a monk while working does anything wrong, breaks or loses something or offends someone?he shall go at once to the abbot and his brothers and confess, offering to make satisfaction. (46)
If anyone becomes proud of his skill and the profit he brings the community, he should be taken from his craft and work at ordinary labor. (57)
The ordained monk must be neither arrogant nor proud. (62)
All monastic concerns should be managed by the deans as the abbot has decided. With several in charge, no one will have the opportunity to become proud. (65)
Individual desires have no place in the monastery. (3)
The emphasis on silence is for the sake of humility, ?I held my peace and humbled myself and was silent, even from speaking good things.? (Ps 39:2 in 6).
The reader for meals ?will ask all to pray for him, that God may protect him from the sin of pride.? (38) Priests entering the monastery ?must give to all examples of greater humility.? (60).
Monks sent on a journey submit to public humiliation, presumably to counteract any tendency to be proud of their experiences:
On the day of their return they should prostrate themselves at the completion of each Hour of the Divine Office and ask the prayers of the entire community for any sins they may have committed by seeing or hearing evil, or by idle chatter. (67)
The provisions forbidding personal possessions act to encourage humility (as well as to encourage total reliance on the community).
Without the abbot?s permission a monk may not receive from or give to anyone, even his parents, letters or parcels. (54)
So that this vice of private ownership may be cut away at the roots, the abbot is to furnish all necessities: cowl, tunic, shoes, stockings, belt, knife, pen, needle, towel, and writing tablet. (55)
The vice of private ownership must be uprooted from the monastery. No one, without the abbot?s permission shall dare give, receive or keep anything. (33)
Some Implications of Holiness through Humility Under the Rule
At first glance the rank order in the monastery (63) would seem to act against the development of humility. The rank order provides plenty of practice for each monk in submission to others because obedience is ordered to any senior, not just to the abbot. ?The service of obedience is to be shown to all, not just the abbot. ? (71) If the community was one of equals, however, there would be no way for each monk to think himself inferior as the program of humility demands.
The link of holiness with humility implies that those who hold high position in the community, especially the abbot, will be less able to achieve holiness. Indeed, the qualifications for the position of abbot do not include holiness or humility, ?The abbot should be chosen for his virtue and wisdom.? (67). The goal of the monks is not to rise in rank or to have authority, but rather ?let them try to outdo each other in obedience? (72).
Holiness in the Rule is not primarily related to service to others in the greater community but to bring the individual to perfection, ?They have laid the foundation to fight, with the aid of God, against their own bodily and spiritual vices.? (1). The monastic community under the Rule is inward-directed. Although the virtues of service to others are listed in Chapter 4, ?The Instruments of Good Works?, they are to be applied wholly within the walls of the monastery:
?But the workshop in which we must diligently perform all these things is the seclusion of the monastery and our stability in the community.? (4)
Summary
Thus, the monks under the Rule are to be obedient so that they may become humble. Because they are humble, God will hear their contrite prayers in the Holy Office. Holiness then is humble obedience to the Rule and the community for the sake of being acceptable to God.
Другие работы по теме:
Abelard on Universals
The Abelards solution of the problem of universals is neither a realistic no a nominalistic one, or, in other words, it is in the same degree nominalistic as it is realistic.
Tycho Brahe Essay Research Paper Tycho BraheTyge
Tycho Brahe Essay, Research Paper Tycho Brahe Tyge (Latinized as Tycho) Brahe was born on 14 December 1546 in Skane, then in Denmark, now in Sweden. He was the eldest son of Otto Brahe and Beatte Bille, both from families in the high nobility of Denmark. He was brought up by his paternal uncle J?rgen Brahe and became his heir.
What Is Science Essay Research Paper What
What Is Science Essay, Research Paper What is Science? Several dictionary definitions of science in Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary define science as a system of knowledge about a specific topic. The systems come from systematic, or precise, observations of natural events; a random example would be the study of the movement of a caterpillar.
John Dalton Essay Research Paper John Dalton
John Dalton Essay, Research Paper John Dalton was born on September 6, 1766, in Eaglesfield, England. He was the son of a weaver and received his early education from his father also at a Quaker school in his hometown, where he began teaching at the age of twelve. In 1781 he moved to Kendal, where he conducted a school with his cousin and older brother.
Elizabeth
’s Visit To Pemberly Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth, the main and favorite character of Jane Austin’s Pride and Prejudice, learns much about Mr. Darcy’s character from her observations of his land and house and from her conversation with his housekeeper. She learns, contrary to her previous opinions of Mr.
Insights On De Tocqueville
’s Democracy In America Essay, Research Paper Insights on De Tocqueville’s Democracy In America It has been said that a French aristocrat Alexis de Tocqueville, who
Galileo And The Telescope Essay Research Paper
Galileo was not the person who invented the telescope, but he was the first one to use the telescope to study the heavens. He made many observations using the telescope that shocked the religious world. In this short essay, I will only focus on three observations and how an Aristotlean reacts to it. These observations played a very important role on the development of astronomy.
The Main Controversies Of Medieval Thought In
The 12Th And 13Th Centuries Essay, Research Paper The twelfth and thirteenth centuries were a time of great controversy for medieval scholars. New systems of thought were being developed and implemented that challenged the accepted teachings of the church. Some fought to preserve tradition, others fought to destroy it, while still others sought to find a common ground between the two.
ExpirementHuman Research Essay Research Paper Experiment
Expirement-Human Research Essay, Research Paper Experiment: Figure Voting ration from Gore to Bush (Al Gore to George W. Bush) First step is to watch or read something of politics having to do with the Presidential Elections. Than send out QUESTIONAIRES to RESPONDENTS to do some UNSTRUCTED INTERVIEWS on a possible 5 minute INTERVIEW.
West And Torgovnick Essay Research Paper West
West And Torgovnick Essay, Research Paper West and Torgovnick: Manichean Ideologies Both Cornel West and Marianna De Marco Torgovnick discuss the idea of supremacy, Manichean theologies, and
The Awakening
– Robin Williams Essay, Research Paper Throughout the movie The Awakening, Robin Williams demonstrates his knowledge of the scientific method. The scientific method is a procedure of steps that is used to
Henry David Thorea Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry David Thorea Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau conducted an experiment, living simple, and peaceful in a small cabin that he built himself. The observations about nature, the importance of the individual, value of a simple life, and more relevant today, as environment abuses multiply, the pressure to consume increases, and the pace o life continues to speed up.
Animal Essays Essay Research Paper All of
Animal Essays Essay, Research Paper All of the essays have one thing incommon, they all deal with observinganimals. And with their observation comes at times interaction. Theymight “mingle” with these animals. Or the observers would just sit thereand do what they are supposed to, observe.Our race, is naturally curious and interested in the unknown.
Theology In The Middle Ages Essay Research
Paper Who were some of the outstanding theologians of the High Middle Ages and what were their ideas? Why was theology so important in the Middle Ages? For about the first 1000 years after the death of Christ, paganism, propoganda and superstition were popular beliefs. The thoughts of two theologians of the time period, Peter Abelard and Thomas Aquinas, would change this belief system forever.
The Scientific Method Essay Research Paper In
The Scientific Method Essay, Research Paper In science, one system of deduction has brought about many significant breakthroughs, more than any other used. This system is called the Scientific Method, and without it, mankind would not be as advanced as it is today.
Abelard And Heloise Essay Research Paper The
Abelard And Heloise Essay, Research Paper The twelfth century was divided into two phases: Early Middle Ages or Dark Ages and the High Middle Ages. It’s during the High Middle Ages when things started to take a turn both mentally and physically. Churches developed more stamina and papal bureaucracy was created.
Albert Jung Essay Research Paper Abstract
Albert Jung Essay, Research Paper Abstract: This lab assignment is to observe certain substances and observe its physical and chemical changes in different environmental conditions. We first observed its physical properties, such as physical state and color and recorded it on paper. Then we did different types of experiments on some of the substances and observed the chemical changes.
Asteroids Essay Research Paper Paper
Asteroids Essay, Research Paper Paper #1 The article that I have reviewed is on NASA’s close-up images of asteroid Eros. A CNN staff writer talks about the way the images of the asteroid looks and writes how scientists make observations. The scientists believe that the asteroid may have broken off from small planet from the observations of the images.
Visions And Voices Essay Research Paper Visions
Visions And Voices Essay, Research Paper Visions and Voices The biographical film of Langston Hughes is both informative and entertaining. It approaches Hughes s life with insightful observations from the people that personally knew him. The film goes into detail on his family background and early life before his poetic success, and continues through his life in Harlem, his literary achievements, and legacy.
Observations Essay Research Paper Ed munsterObservationsAll of
Observations Essay, Research Paper Ed munster Observations All of the essays have one thing incommon, they all deal with observing animals. And with their observation comes at times interaction. They might “mingle” with these animals. Or the observers would just sit there and do what they are supposed to, observe.
Abelard And Heloise Essay Research Paper Physical
Abelard And Heloise Essay, Research Paper Physical tragedy turns to sp Abelard and Heloise – Essay on any aspect of Abelard and Heloise, by Chaucer – Abelard Heloise Chaucer Literature English Canterburry Tales Anthology Letters Lover
Skull Comparison Lab Report Essay Research Paper
Skull Comparison Lab Report We were recently assigned the task of examining, note taking, comparing, and contrasting three different types of skulls. All three had the same basic makeup, but each had its own special features similar to us. The theory that all of us are different in some certain way by form of variation; which set the one apart from the others and made it obviously a different type of organism or species.
Book Report On Novel
“Uh-Oh” By Robert Fulghum Essay, Research Paper Uh-Oh SOME OBSERVATIONS FROM BOTH SIDES OF THE REFRIGERATOR DOOR Book By Robert Fulghum Report by (Your Name Here)
The Letters Of Abelard And Heloise Essay
, Research Paper In the story of “The Letters of Abelard and Heloise” is thought to be one of the world’s most greatful and tragic love affairs. In the realm of critical thinking, Abelard undoubtedly ranked highly in his day. He was an expert dialectician, philosopher and theologian, and as a result led a movement towards individual thinking.
Is Evolution A Fact Or A Theory
? Essay, Research Paper Is Evolution a Fact or a Theory? Both. In Darwin’s day, and before, many naturalists theorized that living things were somehow related in a manner beyond that of their obvious common differences from non-living matter. These speculations, including those of Darwin, are appropriately termed theories: speculations about nature that were informed by observation and subject to test by additional observations.
Social Observations Essay Research Paper For my
Social Observations Essay, Research Paper For my social observations paper I attended a high school football game and observed how students interacted with fellow classmates, namely students from other towns, teachers, parents and even the town “super-fan”. I also observed how they interacted with classmates of different race and ethnicity and how they didn’t interact with the elderly.
Piaget Theory Of Speech Development Essay Research
Paper Piaget theory of Speech Development There are two classical theories of Speech development. The one that I will focus on is Piaget’s theory of Speech development. Jean Piaget, a Swiss, educated, mollusk biologist lived from 1896 to 1980. He hypothesized that learning is a physical, biological function of dealing with successfully with the environment.
Why Do You Want To Be A
Teacher? Essay, Research Paper David Heine MW 2:00-2:50 Group #27 EXAM IV 1.Do you still want to become a teacher? Why? Be specific and thorough about your reasons.
Cell Theroy Essay Research Paper The cell
Cell Theroy Essay, Research Paper The cell theroy is made up of three main ideas: 1. All organisms are composed of one or more cells. An organism may be a single cell, such as the organisms Van Leewenhoek saw in water. Others, like most of the plants and animals with which you are most familiar, are multicellular, or made up of cells.
Minnows Essay Research Paper Low Temperature Effects
Minnows Essay, Research Paper Low Temperature Effects on Minnows (Phoxinus phoxinus) and juvenile Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar) Studies have shown that freshwater minnows and juvenile Atlantic Salmon become nocturnal with increased low temperature. To determine if these species are nocturnal at low temperatures, counts of individual fishes would be taken by how many fishes are observed during the daytime taking refuge underneath rocks.