The 12Th And 13Th Centuries Essay, Research Paper
The twelfth and thirteenth centuries were a time of great controversy for medieval scholars. New systems of thought were being developed and implemented that challenged the accepted teachings of the church. Some fought to preserve tradition, others fought to destroy it, while still others sought to find a common ground between the two. The greatest controversy of the times, it can be said, was that of faith and reason. Most philosophical debate revolved around these and to a lesser extent the opposition of realists and nominalists on the question of universals. The type of philosophy that was being taught in the Christian schools of the time has been given the name of scholasticism. Scholastics shared a common respect for the ideas of Aristotle, Plato, Boethius, Pseudo-Dionysius, and Avicenna. These were referred to by scholastics as the “authorities”. The views of the time were mainly Augustinian and Platonic although certain developments brought radical new ideas into contact with a fixed Christian dogma that was bound to oppose them. Whether a synthesis between them was possible remained to be seen.
Possibly the single-most important event of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries for medieval thinkers was the introduction of new translations of Aristotle’s works. The new translations were the products of work done by Arabic scholars. Up to that point Christendom knew only of Aristotle’s Logic. It had been widely accepted and was widely respected which meant the new works held great weight. The new translations provided a coherent view of the world that now challenged traditional views. On top of the controversy aroused by the works themselves, they were accompanied by the commentaries of non-Christian Arabic scholars holding unorthodox opinions. The excitement incited by the works was accompanied by a deep concern within the church over the effects of their assimilation.
Among the Arabic commentators was Averro?s. The multi-talented Islamic philosopher would become known as the commentator and interpreter of Aristotle. Averro?s had written the commentaries in response to a request from his ruler. His commentaries are very numerous and their effect on the Christian philosophical world immeasurable. In his personal philosophies he arrived at the conclusion that the two truths of faith and reason were irreconcilable.
Maimonides was at the same time an orthodox Jew and a firm adherent to Aristotelian philosophy. He was therefore in the same position as his Christian counterparts, particularly Thomas Aquinas, and faced the problem of combining the two. The result of his meditations on the issue is expressed in his Guide of the Perplexed, which appeared in approximately 1190. Maimonides stated that since God was responsible for the existence of both faith and reason the two must never be contradictory. Any semblance of contradiction between the two is therefore the result of misinterpretation of sacred writings or philosophy.
Albertus Magnus, an encyclopedic writer was probably the first to recognize the significance of the new translations of Greco-Arabic literature. Magnus greatly appreciated the writings of Aristotle and made great efforts to help his contemporaries understand him. His work made a terrific contribution to the future success of Aristotelianism.
A pupil of Magnus, Thomas Aquinas, would later be recognized as perhaps the greatest and most influential thinker and philosopher of the day. He was the first to view theology as a science where one accepts the word of God as the basis for further rational inquiry and research. He opposed the dualism of Averro?s and was appointed by the church to write the authoritative commentary on Aristotle’s works. The result was his Summa Theologiae in which he synthesized Aristotelianism and Christian belief. This was accomplished by adapting the former wherever it conflicted with the latter. For instance, Thomas would agree with Aristotle’s theory of a primary unmoved mover, although to him the unmoved mover was the Christian God.
The major opponent of growing Aristotelianism was the Augustinianism of Henry of Ghent. Henry believed that in any instance where human intellect was used, it was only God who would “illumine” the human intellect in question. Apparently Henry’s insistence on this issue did not gain him many followers .
Another important figure of the era was Roscellin. The man is often called the first nominalist and is therefore at the root of the nominalist-realist debate on the question of universals. Universals are words like “humankind” that refer to something abstract. A nominalist like Roscellin would argue that “humankind” is only real in the sense of its verbal expression and a realist would take the opposite view.
Peter Abelard found himself exposed to and influenced by well-known adherents of both views. He was a student of both Roscellin and Guillaume de Champeaux, a realist. Abelard has been called the “greatest champion of the nominalist-conceptualist point of view “, a conceptualist being someone who finds themselves between the extremes of nominalism and realism. Abelard attempted to combine secular teachings with his career as a monk. The results were that much of his work was judged to be heretical and he nearly faced trial with the king of France. Due to the influence of Bernard of Clairveaux a council at Sens condemned him and the Pope confirmed his condemnation in 1140. Later in life he made peace with Clairveaux.
Bernard of Clairveaux was the most influential figure in western Christendom of his time. He was personally conflicted by his desire to lead a solitary life of monastic studies and his desire to help others. He strongly opposed dialectical scholasticism and is almost the embodiment of the church’s opposition to growing intellectual movements of the time. Clairveaux believed that God’s mysteries are not meant to be discovered. Scientific inquiry was to him “scandalous curiosity “.
At the end of the thirteenth century the controversies of faith and reason had not been resolved. If anything the two ideals had grown farther apart and they would merely be taken up by the next generation of scholars. The arguments had been forever altered however, marked by the developments of preceding centuries. The twelfth and thirteenth centuries were a time when those who provoked thought and interest often provoked fear and hatred. Controversy was the word of the day. Regardless, nothing in these times or any other could stop the evolution of human thought.
“Abelard, Peter.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Averro?s.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Bernard de Clairvaux, Saint.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
Crump, C. G. and E. F. Jacob, eds. The Legacy of the Middle Ages. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1969.
“Early Scholastic period.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
Hoffman, Ross J. S., and James J. Flynn. Medieval History. Totawa, N.J.: Littlefield, Adams and Co., 1965.
Hollister, C. Warren. Medieval Europe: A Short History. 8th ed. Boston: McGraw-Hill, 1998.
Knowles, David. The Evolution of Medieval Thought. London: Northumberland Press Limited, 1962.
“Late Scholastic period.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Maturity of Scholasticism.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Medieval philosophy: Jewish thought.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Medieval Skepticism.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Nominalism.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Roots of Scholasticism.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Roscelin.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Scholasticism.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Scholasticism: Nature and Significance.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“St. Thomas Aquinas.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Stoicism in Medieval and Modern Philosophy.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“The System of Aristotle and its Impact on Medieval Thought.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Thomas Aquinas.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Thomas Aquinas and Thomism.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
“Thomist Philosophy.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1999 ed.
Другие работы по теме:
Cambrian Medieval Celtic Studies
, ранее (в 1981—1992) Cambridge Medieval Celtic Studies (сокращённо CMCS ), рус. «Кембриджские», позднее «Камбрийские средневековые кельтские исследования» — научный журнал, посвящённый кельтологии, истории кельтских языков и истории античной и раннесредневековой Британии. Выходит два раза в год — летом и зимой.
Philosophers
l-Farаbi, Abu Nasr (872-950) Persian Islamic neoplatonist who employed Aristotelian logic in support of his arguments for the existence of god and used
The Four Humors Essay Research Paper Medieval
The Four Humors Essay, Research Paper Medieval doctors had quite an understanding of the human anatomy, considering their lack of equipment and knowledge. Most doctors in medieval times were philosophers more than actual medical doctors as most people know them today. Much of the knowledge they did acquire may have only been speculation, but quite a bit of it was due to concentrated observation.
The Church In The Middle Ages Essay
, Research Paper During the Middle Ages, the Catholic Church directed its main goal as a basis for unity. Ironically, they preached so much on this theme that more people looked to the
Timeline Essay Research Paper TIMELINETimeline by Michael
Timeline Essay, Research Paper TIMELINE Timeline by Michael Crichton, was a very exciting book about time travel and what the Dark Ages were like. Timeline also taught about the basics of quantum physics that would make it possible to achieve such a spectacular feat. Be prepared as you read this book to leap into the horrible, dangerous would of the year 1387.
Was Richard The Third Evil Essay
, Research Paper Was Richard the Third Evil Richard the Third was thought to be an evil mastermind here are three main reasons as to why. The primary reason he was thought to be evil, is on his accession to the throne, a few of is relatives were died and he was later accused of murdering them. The Princes in the Tower were killed but no evidence was ever found to pin Richard to their deaths.
Feudalism Essay Research Paper Feudalism began between
Feudalism Essay, Research Paper Feudalism began between the 8th and 9th centuries. It was first recognized in France, and later spread to most countries of western Europe. When Charlemagne died there was no strong ruler to take his place. That was when feudalism was established as the main system of government and way of life in Medieval Europe.
Medieval And Renaissance Art Essay Research Paper
The Medieval and Renaissance art vary greatly in terms of subject and technique. Medieval art produced works that were less free in theme and style while Renaissance art explored on various techniques and depicted reality in its truest sense.
Doctor Faustus By Marlow Essay Research Paper
Doctor Faustus is a significant and masterful play written by Christopher Marlow. It is a unique play that it written during the beginnings of the renaissance period and therefore neither solely Renaissance nor Medieval in
Harry Potter Essay Research Paper Harry Potter
Harry Potter Essay, Research Paper ?Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire?, written by J.K. Rowling, is an excellent example of a modern novel that uses medieval influences extensively. Many of the novel?s characters are based on medieval ideas and superstitions. The settings in the book resemble old medieval towns as well as castles.
The Rights Of Slaves During The French
Revolution Essay, Research Paper The Rights of Slaves During the enlightenment and the French Revolution, controversies arose over the issue of slavery. The trading of slaves was increasing. In 1783, under five thousand slaves were being transported and by 1792, the number was well above thirty thousand.
History And Culture Of The Renaissance Essay
, Research Paper Culture of the Renaissance The Renaissance was the beginning of political institutions with a commercial economy and the encouragement of education, arts, and music. It was a period of new inventions and believes.
Medieval Drama Essay Research Paper Medieval Drama
Medieval Drama Essay, Research Paper Medieval Drama was an era of religious beliefs. In this time the mysteries of god were studied and presented to the communities in a play form to instill the knowledge in a pleasurable way with morals and themes. Abraham and Isaac blends with this in many ways, by which cultures formed in medieval times.
Tragic Hero Of Julius Caesar Essay Research
Paper Tragic Hero Throughout many of Shakespeare s plays, a tragic hero is identified; a heroic figure that possesses a character flaw that leads to his defeat. In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, there has been controversies over who is actually the tragic hero. Many people agree that Marcus Brutus is the tragic hero.
Midevil Times Essay Research Paper Highlights of
Midevil Times Essay, Research Paper Highlights of the Medieval Times The Medieval period was a time of many great accomplishments. Even though “kings struggled for land power”(Holt, 186), and people struggled just to stay alive, it was a time that will always mark a spot in history. Of the Middle Ages there were three main topics; government, manor and town life, and the role of the church.
Medieval Times Essay Research Paper Medieval TimesMy
Medieval Times Essay, Research Paper Medieval Times My research topic is on the different periods of the Medieval Times, and summing up the main events that happened in each period. These periods, in order, are the Early Middle Ages (A.D. 500-1000), the High Middle Ages (A.D. 1000-1300), and the Later Middle Ages (A.D. 1300-1500).
Medieval And Modern Universities Essay Research Paper
Medieval and Modern Universities Sean Rundle Medieval and Modern Universities are institutions of higher education. Universities were originally established as a way to foster a new generation of leaders and still today, hundreds of years later, universities are still based on the same basic purposes as they were in medieval Europe.
The Monkey
’s Paw Essay, Research Paper THE MONKEY’S PAW By (author) W.W.Jacobs The mystery of the Monkey’s Paw is a cleverly thought out short story. This story had three main parts. These parts were the first wish, the second wish, and the third wish.
The Difference Between Post Modern Age And
Medieval Age Essay, Research Paper I feel that medieval times and today?s times differ extremely. Many people seem to think that it is much better in today?s times, but in some ways I feel differently.
Presidential Pardons Essay Research Paper PRESIDENTIAL PARDONSIn
Presidential Pardons Essay, Research Paper PRESIDENTIAL PARDONS In recent weeks, there have been controversies concerning presidential pardons. These controversies are causing people to think that the President has too much authority by being able to grant a pardon or clemency to a person. One of the most controversial is the pardon of Marc Rich and Pincus Green by former President Bill Clinton.
Medieval Devastators Essay Research Paper The period
Medieval Devastators Essay, Research Paper The period of 1000 years in Europe between the 5th and 15th centuries was the time known as the Medieval Ages. During this time, most of Europe was under the control despotic feudal overlords, and the land was infested with pestilence and war. Living under the threat of invasions from foreigners, the people of Europe developed a different kind of weaponry.
Machiavelli Essay Research Paper In The Prince
Machiavelli Essay, Research Paper In The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli, Machiavelli goes against the traditional mindset that a prince derived his power from God. Machiavelli believed that the rulers were given no divine right. He said that a ruler achieved his power through hid own efforts and skills.
Medieval Music Essay Research Paper Music in
Medieval Music Essay, Research Paper Music in the middle ages is similar to the music that we listen to today in the way that there are many different types of music for different types of people. There were many types of music in the middle ages including Slavic, Jewish, Popular, middle eastern, and many other types of religious music as well as music for entertainment.
The Treasure Of The City Of Ladies
Essay, Research Paper Christine de Pisan’s book, The Treasure of the City of Ladies, explains in detail the various aspects of women’s lives during the late Medieval and Renaissance culture. She addresses all women of this time from those with power and authority to the poorest peasant women. Christine de Pisan focuses on three main areas of a women’s life during this time period.
Motor Skills Essay Research Paper The Medieval
Motor Skills Essay, Research Paper The Medieval Holocaust was a terrible event for many people in communities of that time period. This was the greatest epidemic that ever happened. People could not figure out what caused the Plague. They started to look for someone to blame. They finally looked at the Jews and blamed them for poisoning the water.
Napster Essay Research Paper There are many
Napster Essay, Research Paper There are many different controversies when consulting the topic on Napster. Napster is a computer program that lets people download mp3 music files from other people with the program. Lots of people and music companies believe that this is bad and Napster should be stopped or should charge people.
Magic Vs Science Essay Research Paper Magic
Magic Vs. Science Essay, Research Paper Magic vs. Science What is magic and science? These two subjects have been around for several hundred years and many controversies have come about when the
Big Daddy Essay Research Paper Big KidOne
Big Daddy Essay, Research Paper Big Kid One of the most recent movies that i have seen is Big Daddy. When this movie came out in theaters I knew that it was going to be a hit because the main character (Adam Sandler)