The Republican Party Essay, Research Paper
Introduction
The Republican Party, since its first convention in Michigan in 1854, has had a philosophy that has remained
relatively unchanged. Its oath entices Americans to believe that “good government is based on the individual and
that each person’s ability, dignity, freedom and responsibility must be honored and recognized” How do the
Republican philosophies hold up to the ideas of some of the political thinkers that we have discussed in class. In the
selection to follow, I will examine the Republican’s main philosophies and will describe how Rousseau would agree
or disagree with their position. I will be using the Republican Platform of 1996 to aid in my discussion. Ideas that
will be of focus will be the role of the government, property rights, and freedom of the individual.
The Role of the Government
“We are the party of small, responsible and efficient government? We therefore assert the power of the American
people over government, rather than the other way around”.
The view of the Republicans across the Nation is that the role of government should be kept to a minimum. In this
section, I will discuss certain views of the Party and how they would be accepted or rejected by Jean-Jacques
Rousseau. The Republican notion has been that less government is better. Rousseau’s notion was that of extrication.
He states that the fundamental political problem is “to find a form of association that defends and protects the person
and the goods of each associate with all the common force, and by means of which each one uniting with all,
nevertheless obeys only himself and remains as free as before” (Cahn, 367). The Republicans would agree with
Rousseau’s idea. They (Republican Party) state that the Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution should
be the basis for the role of government. The Tenth Amendment states:
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to
the States respectively, or to its people.
Republicans, while holding the majority in both the House and Senate have taken it upon themselves to apply all
laws to Congress, so that those who make the rules have to live by them. Rousseau agrees in respect that no
association should be above the laws it makes. In his treatise entitled Of the Social contract or Principles of Political
Right, Rousseau states, “Indeed, each individual may, as a man, have a particular will contrary to, or divergent from,
the general will which he may have as a citizen” (Cahn, 426). What Rousseau is suggesting is that a person may feel
one way, but he/she must act in accordance with the general will of his/her fellow citizens. The Republicans would
insist that the proper role of the Government is to provide only what can be considered critical functions that can’t be
preformed by individuals or private organizations; and that the best government is that which governs least. They
plan to streamline the government and make it more effective by !
competition and privatization. Rousseau agrees by saying that simple government is best, because it is simple.
Democracy. On the subject of Democracy, Rousseau would point out that there has never been, nor will there ever
be a true Democracy. He says, “It is contrary to the natural order that the greater number should govern and the
lesser number should be governed” (Cahn, 448). Republicans would tend to lean towards the fact that people in the
United States need to have more say in how the government is ran.
Signs of a Good Government. Rousseau says that there is no way to find out the best Government, because there are
as many solutions as there are combinations. He does give people an idea on how to determine if when a
Government is working. “All other things being equal, the Government under which, without naturalizations,
without colonies, the Citizens become populous and multiply most is infallibly the best” (Cahn, 456).
Property
The subject of property and the rights to it have instigated many heated debates over time. Rousseau’s argument is
for that of first occupant. “The right of the first occupant, altough more real than that of strongest, becomes a true
right only after the establishment of property [ownership]” (Cahn, 428). Rousseau goes on to explain that the right of
the individual over his/her property is subordinate to the right which the community has over it. The Republicans
oppose the view of Rousseau. They consider private property rights to be the cornerstone in America. They plan to
safeguard those rights by the Fifth Amendment. This Amendment states that no man shall be deprived of property
without compensation. Rousseau agrees with the Republican Party claim by saying that, “Every man has by nature a
right to all that is necessary to him” (Cahn, 428). He agrees that the seizure of land without compensation is in itself,
not in the best interest of the government. In conclusion, the r!
ight of property to Rousseau was not as important as it is to the Republican Party.
Freedom of the Individual
Many people believe they have their freedom, but most do not know how much they have lost. In this section, I will
discuss the view of the freedom of individuals.
Slavery. Rousseau states from the beginning that every man born into slavery is born for slavery. He continues by
saying, “force made the first slaves?” (Cahn, 421). What Rousseau is arguing is man has no right to bind his fellow
man. He says that a man giving up his freedom, to him was an absurd idea. He also states that a person is not in their
right mind for doing so. “To renounce one’s liberty is to renounce one’s quality as a man” (Cahn, 423) Rousseau
closes his argument on slavery by stating the following:
Thus, in whatever way we view things, the right of slavery is null, not only because it is illegitimate, but [also]
because it is absurd and meaningless. These words, slavery and right, are contradictory; they are mutually exclusive.
Whether addressed by a man to a man, or by a man to a people, such a speech as this will be equally foolish: I make
a convention with you wholly at your expense and wholly for my profit, which I shall observe as long as I please
and which you also shall observe as long as you please (Cahn, 424).
The philosophy of the Republican Party has been to renounce the act of slavery. They have fought for the freedom
of individuals through the Civil War and as well as with the Civil Rights Era of the 1960’s. They believe that an
individual’s right to equality was important. This is one area where Republicans have remained solid.
General Will. The final aspect of freedom is the will of the people. Rousseau believes that the general will of the
people make the social contract possible. According to him, it is possible not to just act in self-interest, but for the
interest of people of the state. Rousseau goes on to state that you gain civil liberty in a social contract. He agrees
with the philosopher Spinoza in that we are slaves to our passions. With respect to the Republican Party, they
believe, like Rousseau that the will of the majority should take precedence. In regards to justice, the Republican
Party states the following:
The delicate balance of power between the respective branches of our national government and the governments of
the 50 states has been eroded. The notion of judicial review has in some cases come to resemble judicial supremacy,
affecting all segments of the public and private endeavor.
Conclusion
In closing, Rousseau envisioned several different forms of government. They were based on certain principles that
would make each one run effectively. The criteria of size and population mattered just as importantly as anything
else that has been discussed. He would probably think that the United States was not best ran in a democratic
structure due to its size and the diversity of its population. The Republican Party, contrary to Rousseau’s claim,
believes that the form of government is not the problem, but how that government has been ran ineffectively. They
continue by stating that their philosophy has been to let government, by which its people are free, run without
intervention of it’s representatives. Those people, who represent, should follow the laws that are made for the
protection of citizens.
Cahn, Steven M. Classics of Modern Political Theory. Oxford University Press. New York. 1997
Другие работы по теме:
Melville
’s “Bartleby The Scrivener”: Introduction Of Character Essay, Research Paper Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener”: Introduction of Character In the first three paragraphs of ?Bartleby the Scrivener,? Melville
Al Prediction On Demographics Essay Research Paper
Alabama Prediction Based on Demographics Demographics are the statistics of human population especially with reference to size, density, distribution, and vital statistics used to identify markets and patterns (Websters Dictionary). With the demographics of a particular state, voting predictions are determined through previous patterns.
Totalitarianism Essay Research Paper I IntroductionPrint sectionTotalitarianism
Totalitarianism Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction Print section Totalitarianism, in political science, system of government and ideology in which all social, political, economic, intellectual, cultural, and spiritual activities are subordinated to the purposes of the rulers of a state. Several important features distinguish totalitarianism, a form of autocracy peculiar to the 20th century, from such older forms as despotism, absolutism, and tyranny.
Two Party Politics Essay Research Paper In
Two Party Politics Essay, Research Paper In a democracy, people rule, but an individual’s voice is easily lost in a large and diverse nation, such as the United States. A way citizens can be sure the government hears their views is to organize themselves into groups. Once such group is a political party. A political party is a group of individuals with broad common interests who organize to nominate candidates for office, win elections, conduct government, and determine public policy.
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay, Research Paper Henry Cabot Lodge Henry Cabot Lodge was an American diplomat. He was born on July 5th 1902. He was born in Nahant Massachusetts. He did alot for our country so in the next few paragraphs I will tell you about Henry Cabot Lodge and some of his accomplishments.
LOTF Essay Research Paper Introduction
LOTF Essay, Research Paper Introduction The first main problem the boys have in the novel Lord of the Flies is that they are unprepared for survival on an uninhabited
Elections Essay Research Paper Election1 The reason
Elections Essay, Research Paper Election1. The reason why elections are less democratic is because some people say that money is taking away from our well known democracy, but in other instances we have the greatest democracy compared to other countries of our vast magnitude. 2. Throughout the nineteenth century campaigns were ran and geared toward the party.
Governmental Parties Essay Research Paper The Federalist
Governmental Parties Essay, Research Paper The Federalist and Democratic-Republican parties fought for control over the government in the early 1800s. Although these two parties had great differences, they each had many supporters.
The Garden Party Essay Research Paper Looking
The Garden Party Essay, Research Paper Looking at the plot in a garden party The Sheridan family is arranging a Garden Party a beautiful sunny day. In the poorer neighbourhood across the street, a young man gets killed in an accident. When the young girl Laura hears about this, she wants the garden party cancelled to show some respect for the exposed family.
James Schoolcraft Sherman Essay Research Paper The
James Schoolcraft Sherman Essay, Research Paper The nation’s twenty-seventh vice president during William Howard Taft’s presidency was James Schoolcraft Sherman. Being a member of the House of Representatives for almost two decades, he stood firmly for the Republican Party as an influential role during the Progressive Era.
1984 Essay Research Paper 1984 by George 2
1984 Essay, Research Paper 1984 by George Orwel is a dramatic novel portraying a restricted society.Winston Smith is a thin, 39 year-old man who wears blue Party coveralls. Winston is sick of the Party’s rigid control over his life and world, and begins trying to rebel against the Party–writing defiant thoughts in a secret diary and starting an illegal affair with Julia.
Mom Essay Research Paper Death of an
Mom Essay, Research Paper Death of an Innocent I went to a party mom, I remembered what you said. You told me not to drink, Mom, so I drank soda instead. I really felt proud inside, Mom, the way you said I would.
Jackson In Office Essay Research Paper Jackson
Jackson In Office Essay, Research Paper Jackson sure did make the ages more democratic. 3 times more people voted in 1828 than in 1824. A lot of people won the right to vote because of suffrage. Jackson also
Political Attitudes Essay Research Paper Political attitudesA
Political Attitudes Essay, Research Paper Political attitudes A variety of factors, including but not limited to; family, peers, the media and education shape political attitudes. Many things influence the way people feel about politics, and depending on the immediate environments, views can change dramatically.
Abraham Lincoln Essay Research Paper LincolnThis book
Abraham Lincoln Essay, Research Paper Lincoln This book report was about the president Abraham Lincoln. He was born Feb 12, 1809. He walked to a log school house every day where he learned to read and write. In 1816 he moved to Little Piegon Creek in Indiana. His mother died of “milk sickness”. His father rode back to Elizabeth Ky., and married a widow named Sarah Johnston.
Laws Courts And Policies Essay Research Paper
Sep. 16 1999 Law, Courts, Politics Data/ Analysis The American President’s and Their Judges The appointing of judges to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals is the responsibility of the United States President. This responsibility does not go without its benefits. Because the law can at times be “flexible” when deciding a case, a president is most likely going to choose a judge with the same background and goals as he.
Political Parties In Us Essay Research Paper
Political Parties There are numerous political parties in the United States and they all have no strict requirements for membership. That means whatever group you want to belong to you can. There are also no membership lists that are maintained.
Bush Vs Mccain Essay Research Paper As
Bush Vs. Mccain Essay, Research Paper As expected, Governor George W. Bush of Texas has won the Republican Party nomination for the presidential election in November. All along, Bush was the predicted winner for the GOP, but Senator John McCain of Arizona gave the Governor a run for his money. Although Bush was able to defeat him, John McCain was, and still is, the best candidate for the presidency.
1984Winston Smith Essay Research Paper WINSTON SMITH
1984-Winston Smith Essay, Research Paper WINSTON SMITH Winston Smith, the main character in the novel 1984, rebels, acts stubborn, and shows braveness against the Party in many ways. The Party is a group who controls the people of Oceania. There are many rules that the people must abide by. If they don’t and they get caught, they will be punished.
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Politics In China In 1900
′S Essay, Research Paper POLITICS IN CHINA IN EARLY 1900′S The politics in China varies to republic and nationalism and communism. First of all, there is Republican China which evolved very
THE LIFE OF PRESIDENT BENJAMIN HARRISON Essay
, Research Paper Election of 1888 In 1888, James G. Blaine, the Republican party’s most prominent figure, declined to seek the presidential nomination. The national convention then nominated Harrison as the
The Republican Party Overall Issues Essay
, Research Paper The Republican Party: Overall Issues, 1860-1868 The Republican party during the 1860’s was known as the party more concerned with “civil rights” and the common American. This came about through
An AllImportant Introduction Essay Research Paper In
An All-Important Introduction Essay, Research Paper In the first three paragraphs of ?Bartleby the Scrivener,? Melville introduces a character who will be played upon and defined throughout his text. This introduction is crucial to the story and the fact that the lawyer introduces himself greatly increases its effectiveness.
Civil War Causes Essay Research Paper Causes
Civil War Causes Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Civil War Although some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political blunders and that the issue of slavery
A Critical Analysis Essay Research Paper A
A Critical Analysis Essay, Research Paper A Critical Analysis of Evelyn Waugh’s “Bella Fleace Gave a Party” In the introduction to “Bella Fleace Gave a Party”, extensive background is revealed to help the reader understand the times in which the character lived. It is a time of enormous change in the political and social structure of these people’s lives.