Source Of Historical Information? Essay, Research Paper
The film The 300 Spartans is the story of the Battle of Thermopylai , where the 300 strong personal guard of King Leonidas defended a mountain pass at Thermopylai so that Xerxes of Persia couldn t conquer Greece.
As far as detailing how the events at Thermopylai went, The 300 Spartans was an accurate film. In real life, Leonidas and his men held the Persians back for two days, after which, they were sold out by a local Greek named Ephialtes. In the movie, Ephialtes is rejected by a Spartan women, which gives him the motif to lead the Immortals through the abandoned goat track. Whether this was actually his reason for helping Xerxes is irrelevant, as it probably isn t mentioned in any history books. It also adds a little more interest to the film for those who saw it for reasons other than watching men hack into each other with swords.
When news of the Immortal s back door attack became apparent, the Athenians were ordered to retreat. Only the Boiotians aided Leonidas and his men (the real Spartan army were sent only as far as the Isthmus of Corinth). This was included in the film not only because it was historically correct, but also because it made the out numbered side seem more heroic. The Boiotians were defeated first, then the King was killed in battle. His now unemployed personal guard formed a protective circle around his corpse, where they are finally finished off with arrows.
As a source of historical information, The 300 Spartans isn t as accurate as you might hope. The Spartans, in real life, fought their battles in the nude (with the exception of a small amount of armor). In the film, however, the soldiers are fully clothed, as are the women back home (they too wore few garments). This mistake is understandable, as no production company, now or then, would finance and release a mainstream movie where half of the extras, as well as central characters, are running around naked (good luck finding the actors, too). Also absent was the fact that the Spartan men were bi-sexual. Such a film could be made nowadays, but there would still be an enormous backlash against it from conservative groups. They could ve at least used Greek actors.
The difference in temperament between the two rival leaders was too big to be realistic. Xerxes was shown to have been the most black hearted man around, and even though he was a mean person, he probably wasn t as evil as he was made out to be. Leonidas had the opposite problem of being too squeaky clean, but that fault was common in all of the movies made in the sixties.
Spartan mentality was exhibited excellently. The disgraced soldier would rather have thrown himself from a cliff than leave his king. At the end, Xerxes promised that if the remaining warriors surrendered Leonidas body, they would be spared. Of course, they declined, choosing to die by his side rather than return home defeated. In my opinion, the Spartans would ve tried to take out as many Persians as possible before being killed, and not have juste stood there to be shot at.
In conclusion, The 300 Spartans portrayed the major events at the Battle of Thermopylai very well. Unfortunately, it wasn t a very reliable source of historic information.
Другие работы по теме:
550 Mhz Of Power Versus A 486
Loser Essay, Research Paper “550 MHz of Power VS A 486 Loser” Having a Pentium III 550 computer is very convenient for your everyday life. Compared to a 486 computer that has about 100 MHz of power, the most, a Pentium III
The Foundation Of Power And Justice In
International Law Essay, Research Paper Thucydides wrote The History of the Peloponnesian War believing that it was a good picture of “the past and which (human nature being what it is) will, at some time or other and in much the same way, be repeated in the future.” This paper will present a comparison between the time of Thucydides and how the International system has reflected certain aspects that are contained in the document.
Pericles 2 Essay Research Paper Pericles a
Pericles 2 Essay, Research Paper Pericles, a Greek Statesman, was the leader of the Athenian government for 30 years (Age of Pericles). Pericles was born into a noble family in Athens. His mother was a niece of Cleisthenes, a statesman who had made many democratic reforms in the Athenian government. After Cleisthenes death Pericles was determined to continue the reforms of his great-uncle and entered politics with the democratic popular party led by Ephialtes.
Greece Essay Research Paper The country of
Greece Essay, Research Paper The country of Greece, in 400-500 BCE was led to greatness by two city-states. These city-states, diverse in ideas and actions, were Sparta and Athens. Sparta and Athens were as different as night and day. Sparta glorified military tactics while Athens took relish in art and learning.
Lycergus Essay Research Paper LycergusIn ancient Greece
Lycergus Essay, Research Paper Lycergus In ancient Greece, the most feared named was Sparta. It was a total war machine willing to take on all comers. They rose above the rest by being well disciplined and educated. The man who brought them this glory was Lycergus. Like any great leader he was very idealistic.
Athenians Vs Spatans Essay Research Paper Through
Athenians Vs. Spatans Essay, Research Paper Through out history there has been a great deal of great societies to rise and fall from power and fame. Two of the greatest societies still studied to this day are the Athenians and the Spartans. Both societies differ and many different ways but they where both very alike.
Ancient Greece Essay Research Paper Sparta one
Ancient Greece Essay, Research Paper Sparta, one of the powerful city-states, retains this name for good reason. They took over Messenia and used the land wisely, by making a government using the Code of Lycurgus. The Spartan women were given a lot more freedom compared to other Greek city-states; thus, every person provided a part in the development of their city.
A Spartan Or An Athenian Essay Research
Paper I would rather be Athenian. Too many simple reasons factor in on this decision. The Spartans were a much poorer society, and had less intellectual inventions- saying something about their education. All Athenian boys were expected to get a great education, while Athenian girls were taught such things as weaving and cooking.
How To Be A Reliable Friend Essay
, Research Paper The ability to build a satisfying interpersonal relationship and to get along with other peoplecontributes to our mental and emotional health. Research has suggested that signs of emotional wellbeing include respect for others, concern for others, and a realistic and positive attitude towardsrelationships.
How Were Spartans Different From Athens Essay
, Research Paper This is a comparing on two city-states in Greece. In Greece Sparta and Athens were different in so many ways such as in religion, government, culture, beliefs, education etc.
Lycurgus
’ Constitution Essay, Research Paper Philosophy is a study that tries to define and explain how people in a community should live wisely. In his ?Life of Lycurgus?, Plutarch wrote ??Lycurgus produced an inimitable constitution,? showing? the spectacle of an entire city acting like philosophers?? (Readings, p.185).
Sparta Essay Research Paper Sparta Uncultured Discipline
Sparta Essay, Research Paper Sparta: Uncultured Discipline The Spartans were the most formidable warriors in all of history. They dedicated their entire lives to warfare. They were taught to endure cold, hunger, pain, their courage on the battlefield was second to none. The Spartan code was to fight hard, follow orders without question and to die rather then retreat or surrender.
Sparta 3 Essay Research Paper SpartaSparta one
Sparta 3 Essay, Research Paper Sparta Sparta, one of the powerful city-states, retains this name for good reasons. The Spartans faced the problems of overpopulation and land hunger. Their solution was to conquest to gain more land. Almost defeated, the Messenian war cost Sparta a high price. A half-century of war, so hard fought, had ground the military life deep into Spartan consciousness.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper Singer
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper Singer s Gimpel the Fool is written in first person point of view, and the narrator, Gimpel, is the main character in the story. In the opening paragraph in the story Singer shows how reliable of a narrator that Gimpel is. Gimpel shares many of the nicknames he has had given to him in school, including imbecile, donkey, flax-head, dope, glump, ninny, and fool.
Ancient Spartan Government Essay Research Paper During
Ancient Spartan Government Essay, Research Paper During the time in which Sparta existed, Spartans were well aware of what to expect in their life. Spartan life was simple, yet disciplined. The government of Sparta was harsh, however it was orderly and stable. Spartan government provided a life in which Spartans were offered few choices, instead, many choices would be made for them.
How American Music Has Changed Over The
Past 50 Years Essay, Research Paper How American Music Has Changed Over The Past 50 Years People have often wondered if music has always been around. Well, to answer that question I did some research to find out where our music originated. Our first reliable music records came from the Greeks and the Romans.
Militaristic Nature Of Spartan Society Essay Research
Paper Spartan society was structured around the army, always ready to fight or defend if the need arose. Spartan males were the only ones permitted to serve in the army though, and due to the males devotion to warfare the lives of everyone in the polis of Sparta were also greatly affected. This militaristic nature of the Spartans had an impact on the female members of the polis, the helots and the perioeci.
Greek Essay Essay Research Paper Greek Legacy
Greek Essay Essay, Research Paper Greek Legacy Essay The Greek culture of 2000 BC through 146 BC was one of the most sophisticated, intellectual, and had some of the great thinkers of their time. Their architecture, writing, military tactics, lifestyle and philosophy were copied by countless civilizations to come.
Sparta Vs Athens Essay Research Paper Sparta
Sparta Vs Athens Essay, Research Paper Sparta and Athens – Explain and Contrast Both Sparta and Athens were Greek city-states. Sparta was a strict military ruled city-state where the people established themselves as a military power early. However Athens was more of a political city-state that was more involved with their economical stature than their military forces.
Athens Vs Sparta Essay Research Paper Athens
Athens Vs. Sparta Essay, Research Paper Athens Vs. Sparta Athens and Sparta were both City-states in Greece in ancient times, yet they had no social similarities. They were constantly at war, and at one time at a stalemate. They existed in the same time and place, but had totally different views on life and lifestyles.
The Marshall Decision Essay Research Paper Who
The Marshall Decision Essay, Research Paper Who: Donald Marshall (a Mikmaq fisherman), Native and non-native fisherman, Supreme Court of Canada and Herb Dhaliwal (minister of Fisheries and ocean).
MindBodySoul Essay Research Paper MindBodySoulMind body and
Mind-Body-Soul Essay, Research Paper Mind-Body-Soul Mind body and soul; three sections of a living being that make it complete. When all of these parts are healthy, people can reach their true and full potential. Unfortunately, when one of these divisions is weak and underdeveloped, like team of assembly line workers, everything can t work optimally.
Persian Wars Essay Research Paper The Persian
Persian Wars Essay, Research Paper The Persian Wars In the 5th century BC the vast Persian Empire attempted to conquer Greece. If the Persians had succeeded, they would have set up local
Persian Wars Essay Research Paper Persian Wars
Persian Wars Essay, Research Paper Persian Wars In 519 BC Darius I ascended the throne of the expanding empire ofPersia. A group of people called the Ionians, lived along the coast of AsiaMinor. They were under Persian rule, having been conquered by EmperorCyrus (ruled 550-530 BC), and at this time were unhappy about theirconditions.
True Friendship Essay Research Paper True FriendshipBut
True Friendship Essay, Research Paper True Friendship But not us! An why? Because I got you to look after me, and you got me to look after you, and that s why. (Page 14) This quote came from Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck. Lennie and George can trust and depend on each other because they are true friends. George is the smart, sophisticated and reliable one of the two.
Critical Fiction Questions Essay Research Paper 1What
Critical Fiction Questions Essay, Research Paper 1.What kind of Narrator tells the story? Is the Narrator’s information reliable? Of you think the Narrator is not reliable, explain why and what the author’s purpose would be for using an unreliable Narrator.
Perisan Wars Essay Research Paper Persian Wars
Perisan Wars Essay, Research Paper Persian Wars The Persian Wars started due to some of the cities in Ionia revolting against Darius I, Persia s king, around 499 BC. Greeks has settled there for many years, but around 520 BC the Persians conquered it. The Greeks after awhile revolted against the Persians and Darius.
Thucidides Not In The 19th Century Essay
, Research Paper Jeremy Foust 10/04/98 Thucydides, Not in the 18th Century Thucydides wrote the History of the Peloponnesian War believing that it was a good picture of “the past and which (humane nature being what it is) will, at some time or other and in much the same ways, be repeated in the future.”(Thucydides 48) In this paper a comparison between the time of Thucydides and the classical balance of power in 19th century Europe will be examined.
Pros And Cons Of Spartan Culture Essay
, Research Paper Pros and Cons of the Spartans PROS 1st- A positive aspect of the Spartan Code was the idea to train their young beginning at a young age, by giving power to the state to control the youth. This allowed many of the children to have an equal opportunity in the situation given although they did not have many options.
Knowledge Essay Research Paper KnowledgeWhen discussing the
Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Knowledge When discussing the concept of knowledge it must be made clear what type of knowledge is being discussed. Three types of knowledge are proposed in philosophy; object knowledge, know-how knowledge, and propositional knowledge. Object knowledge involves a person, place, or thing.
Email And Standard Mail Essay Research Paper
Technology has brought us new advantages with e-mail today. Many people prefer electronic mail rather than postal mail now because it is much simpler and easier to use. The ease of delivery is satisfactory, and there are even some services that are free. Revolutionary changes occur when new advances in e-mail are made.
Cars Essay Research Paper A Persuasive Essay
Cars Essay, Research Paper A Persuasive Essay- By Krystal Have you ever been to a dealership to buy a car and come away discouraged by the outrageously high prices on new cars? Don’t worry-there is hope! You can get a reliable, good-looking vehicle for thousands less than the new car dealerships charge. The answer? Buy a used car.