Unethical People Essay, Research Paper
In the world of media today, an ethics code is one of the most important things to follow. Unfortunately, Mike Barnicle and Patricia Smith did not feel the same way. Mike Barnicle and Patricia Smith, both former workers for The Boston Globe, plagiarized and falsified information in order to bring forth newsworthy stories. Throughout this paper I will discuss the unethical acts of both Barnicle and Smith, the problems they caused for themselves, and the problems they caused for The Boston Globe.
“The following is what happens when a company lacks consistent response to, and enforcement of, its core values and standards”(Hoffman 1). The summer of 1998 became one of the worst summers The Boston Globe has ever seen. For thirty years The Boston Globe had built itself a great reputation and had won twelve Pulitzer prizes. “The Globe even outshone its cross-town rival, the Boston Herald” (Hoffman 1). In 1973 the Globe hired a writer by the name of Mike Barnicle. Mike wrote about the Boston?s working class. Including cops, single mothers, gas station owners, elderly immigrants and young veterans. Problems with Barnicle started to surface early in his Boston Globe career. The Globe settled two lawsuits stating that Barnicle plagiarized quotes of famous people. Also, a man by the name of Mike Royoko complained that Barnicle was copying his work. Many workers at the Globe then came to resent him and complained that he was arrogant.
Just when it seemed that Mike Barnicle?s problems were beginning to subside, on August 1, 1998, Barnicle wrote a column titled, “I was just thinking?..”. A reader called the Globe and alerted the Boston Herald that many of the excerpts in Barnicles column actually came from George Carlins book, Brain Droppings. The column Barnicle had written was not his own work..
This was the worst case scenario for the Boston Globe because their competitor released the story first and at the same time revealing the earlier problems the Globe had had with Mike Barnicle. “The thirty eight, one-liners in the column included eight items similar to George Carlin?s book, without citing Carlin as the source”(Jurkowitz 1). Here is an excerpt from the actual article that Barnicle wrote compared to the writings of George Carlin.
The book: “If cockpit voice recorders are so indestructible, why don?t they just build an airplane that?s just one big cockpit voice recorder?”(Carlin;Jurkowitz 3).
The column: “How come planes aren?t made with the same indestructible material used to assemble those black boxes that always survive crashes?”(Barnicle;Jurkowitz 3).
The book: “People who should be phased out: Guys who wear suits all day and think an earring makes them cool all night.”(Carlin;Jurkowitz 3).
The column: “I don?t get it when guys over forty think they?re cool because they wear an earring.”(Barnicle;Jurkowitz 3).
As you can see through this small excerpt, Mike Barnicle obviously took his column from George Carlin?s book, even though Barnicle claims to have never read Carlin?s book. This wasn?t the end to Barnicle?s unethical ways. In1995 Barnicle wrote a piece about two families with a child at Children?s Hospital. The story had been told to Barnicle, but was never meant for news and the story was embellished and flawed in the retelling. Barnicle wrote that one family lost a child and the other family generously gave them a personal gift of ten thousand dollars, when in actuality a gift of five thousand dollars was given and it was given to go toward a scholarship, not a personal gift. Also the race of the child was not accurate.
When The Boston Globe became aware of what Barnicle was doing they were outraged. The Globe immediately asked for Barnicle?s resignation accusing him of plagarism and falsification. Barnicle states, “Plagiarism is not the word to use here. Laziness or stupidity might be.”(Jurkowitz 2). Barnicle asked the Globe to run a final column so that he could argue his case. Barnicle?s request was denied, but he was allowed to write a column announcing his resignation.
So at the age of fifty-four in August of 1998, Barnicle resigned. In his resignation column he states, “My employment ended in forced resignation and personal disbelief this August when I could not immediately provide sources for a 1995 column that included the reconstruction of dialogue I had not actually heard directly.”(Barnicle 5). Barnicle had worked at the Globe for twenty-five years and said that they were wonderful, but now it was time for him to do something different.
Unfortunately the problems at the Globe did not stop with Mike Barnicle. Patricia Smith was also working at the Globe. Patricia was a fairly new employee, but she was well renowned. She had been a finalist for a Pulitzer Prize. During her work at the Globe, indications that she was making up material had surfaced, but the paper decided not to confront her about the issue. Readers said that her words sang to them, they were heartfelt and they were proud to read her columns. (O?Brien 1).
In 1998 The Boston Globe for the second time fell apart. Patricia Smith was found out. Walter Robinson, then the Globe?s assistant manager, then editor for the local news was told that someone on the copy desk had raised questions about the level of truth in Smith?s work.(O?Brien 3). During this same time period Walter received a phone call from a reader who had doubt about the existence of a character in a recent column. The column in question was about a man named Ernie Keane from Somerville, Massachusetts who supposedly phoned Smith in the newsroom to talk about President Clinton?s upcoming visit to Boston. Keane allegedly wanted Smith to relay a message to the President which read like this in her column: “I ain?t real smart and I don?t have no fancy words to make folks sit up and take notice. I?m just ordinary, but there are a lot of ordinary folks here getting sick of screaming and no one hearing. Our country?s supposed to take care of us when we get old, that?s our reward for working all these years and living here in this so-called democratic place. Just tell him that.”(O?Brien 3).
After reading this article the Globe decided to conduct an investigation themselves. They attempted to contact the people that Smith had used in her articles, but to no avail. The Globe then found out that in 1986, while Smith was working for The Chicago Sun-Times, she covered an Elton John concert. She wrote negatively about the concert saying that he wore something that he had not and played songs he had not played. She also said that the audience wasn?t pleased although the promoters said that he was well received. The concert representatives also said that Smith never even picked up her tickets. Smith denied this allegation. After finding this out and revealing other stories the Globe was once again in a tight spot. They set up a meeting with Smith letting her know that they were going to try to contact all of the people she had written about in her stories. Smith was “shaken”(Storin;O?brien 5) by the meeting, and from then on the quality of her work went down.
The Globe conducted their investigation and was able to confirm fifty-two suspicious columns since 1995. After viewing the evidence the Globe decided to give her a second chance. In turn she had to bring in names and phone numbers so the characters in her stories could be contacted. From the beginning this didn?t work. On May 11th they came across another suspicious story. This story focused on a cancer patient named Claire who was excited about what may be a cure. She discussed new treatments that had been tested on mice and worked. This time the Globe was able to prove that her story was bogus. Smith cited people with occupations that required licensing and therefore they should have been able to be tracked down. “When they couldn?t be located, the game was over.”(O?Brien 7). The Globe asked Smith to verify the existence of six of the characters, and it was then that she admitted that they were fictitious.
Smith was then forced to resign. Before she left she wrote an apology to the people who read her columns. It read like this: “It?s not to late to apologize to you. From time to time in my Metro column, to create the desired impact or to slam home a salient point, I attributed quotes to people who didn?t exist. I could give then names, I could give them occupations, but I couldn?t give then what they needed most?a heartbeat. Anyone knows that this is one of the cardinal sins of journalism. Yet there are always excuses. It didn?t happen often, but It did happen and that was one time to many.”(O?Brien 11).
That may have been the end of it all for Patricia and Mike, but it surely wasn?t the end for The Boston Globe. When this ethical scandal erupted it threatened the integrity and core of the Globe. Many people felt that it was the Globe?s fault, not Mike and Patricas. Alan Dershowitz, one of the papers critics stated “It?s time to focus on Globe higher-ups. They really are to blame.”(Kalb 1). Many of the workers at the Globe were angry because the Globe did not make their decision fast enough. In turn it caused tension in the workplace. On the other side many felt that it was the fault of Patricia and Mike because they violated readers trust and the trust the newspaper had in them; and that the paper handled the crisis well.
In conclusion, having consistent ethical standards and enforcing those standards is the key to running an ethical business. Having no clear standards is what causes an ethical crisis such as the one at the Globe. The biggest problem with plagiarism is that the readers begin to doubt the truth of anything that they read in the Globe. Maybe Mike Barnicle and Patricia Smith either forgot the rules, if they were ever explained, or convinced themselves that what they were writing was acceptable. “It is up to management to remind employees of the rules and the values for which the company stands.”(Hoffman 5). By failing to state or enforce clear standards, The Globe?s management failed Barnicle, Smith, its readers and itself.
Hoffman, Michael. “The Boston Globe Ethics Crisis: Muddied Standards, Muddied Management.” Business and Society Review Summer 1999: 119
Jurkowitz, Mark. “Globe Asks Barnicle Fir His Resignation.” Boston Globe 6 Aug. 1998, third ed.: A1
Barnicle, Mike. “I Was Just Thinking.” Boston Globe 2 Aug. 1998, third ed.: B1
O?Brien, Sinead. “Secrets and Lies.” American Journalism Review Sept. 1998:40
Barnicle, Mike “My Way” Boston Globe 29 Oct. 1998, A27
Kalb, Claudia. “The Globe Scrapes Off Barnicle Mess.” Newsweek 31 Aug. 1998: 56
“Boston Globe Columnist resigns after admitting to fabricating people and quotes.” Jet 6 Jul. 1998: 6.
Другие работы по теме:
Gorgias Essay Essay Research Paper Gorgias EssayWhen
Gorgias Essay Essay, Research Paper Gorgias Essay When a person?s back is against the wall and the stakes are the highest, how should they handle the pressure? When the lines between right and wrong become so blurred, how is one to know what is the ethical choice in the matter? Imagine being accused of first degree murder, a crime in which you did not commit.
Christians Essay Research Paper I agree with
Christians Essay, Research Paper I agree with the Uncle that the Bible should be analyzed and interpret like any other book. Just because you are a Christian does not mean you can interpret it correctly. I come from a Christian family and we all have read the Bible. But I know that I have interpret parts of the Bible in a different matter then other members of my family, they have as well.
Stealing Our Rights Essay Research Paper Stealing
Stealing Our Rights Essay, Research Paper Stealing Our Rights From the dawn of the first organized communities, to the powerful United States of America today, there have always been power hungry people who
Philosophy On Life Essay Research Paper My
Philosophy On Life. Essay, Research Paper My philosophy on life begins with the subject of death, which infact terrifies most people. Many people believe after you die you go to ‘heaven’ or ‘hell’, my opinion is similar but in a way different. I believe that there is certainly an afterlife but not as limited to those two fictional places.
Was Milgram Ethical In His Obedience Studies
? Essay, Research Paper Was Milgram Ethical in his Obedience Studies? When trying to determine weather or not Stanley Milgram?s experiment on obedience vs. destructive obedience is ethical you need to know two things: One, determine a set of ethical means that Milgram must follow, in this case they were already laid out.
Fabricating Humans Essay Research Paper Cloning is
Fabricating Humans Essay, Research Paper Cloning is unethical and is not needed in society. Many, if not all, religions agree with the ban of cloning human beings. It has also been argued that cloning would diminish individuality as well. Whether or not cloning is ethical, at this time cloning human beings should be, and is, banned.
The Palace Walk Essay Research Paper Codes
The Palace Walk Essay, Research Paper Codes And Values There are certain standards, codes, ethics and values by which people live their lives. It is these standards and codes that determine what is right and wrong. In other words, they create a boundary that draws a line between what is considered unethical or immoral.
Bribery Is Bribery Ever Justified Essay Research
Paper CONCLUSION In conclusion bribery is not an issue that can be answered immediately at hand considering the type of situations that regulate its ethical character. We need to remeber that bribery is a constant ethical issue. And becuase briberyare only sometimes acceptable it is in a moral free space.
Medical Terms Essay Research Paper I agree
Medical Terms Essay, Research Paper I agree and disagree with genetic engineering. I feel that it is only fair to let somebody who can not get pregnant to able to use invitro-fertilization and to pick what the child would look like. However, to choose whether sperm was from an Olympic athlete or someone with very high intelligence levels is unfair and unethical.
Gun Control 2 Essay Research Paper We
Gun Control 2 Essay, Research Paper We the students of class 7-508 do not agree with the statement that people should carry weapons. We do not agree with this statement
Oroonoko Essay Research Paper Ethical Issues in
Oroonoko Essay, Research Paper Ethical Issues in Oroonoko: Slavery For years, man has illustrated his willingness to perform injustices to those weaker than he. From the bully in the schoolyard, to the king and his court, it seems that man has a desire to control and dominate others. Oroonoko, by Aphra Behn, illustrates that slavery is unethical, humiliating, demoralizing, and worse than death.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Is the
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Is the Death Penalty Right or Wrong? Should we be able to execute people that have been convicted of murder or should we give them a chance to break out of jail and maybe kill other people. Well the Death Penalty has been around for a while ever since the Old West use to hang people for punishment.
Ethics Of Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning
Ethics Of Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning humans is unethical because the clone is not born the normal way, but is created from one parent instead of two by duplicating someone s DNA. Therefore it is causing the clone to be neglected the two-parent family. Some of the scientist that cloned the sheep Dolly says cloning the sheep was a complete success but all are convinced that cloning humans is ethically wrong and should not be allowed. (Kestenbaum, David, 1965) Frank Monton explains that there is now worldwide recognition from governments, professional medical bodies and bioethics committees that to clone a human would be unethical (Monton, Frank, C4).
2 Chronicle Essay Research Paper solomon was
2 Chronicle Essay, Research Paper solomon was a king who had a hearts desire to have wisdom and knowledge from God so that he could lead his people whcih he says is Gods people. The significant
The Knight Essay Research Paper The Knight
The Knight Essay, Research Paper The Knight and the nun are two completely different people the knight is some one who wants people to think well of them so he dose things to make people thinks will of him where as the nun wants people to think well of her so she became a nun but in reality she is not living up to her vows.
Aliens Essay Research Paper Aliens
Aliens Essay, Research Paper Aliens What are aliens? There are illegal aliens. Their are UFO aliens. You have to ask yourself one question, do you think there could be intelligent life
Critical Thinking Essay Research Paper Critical thinking
Critical Thinking Essay, Research Paper Critical thinking would be important to the well being of our society for many reasons except for the fact that hardly anyone ever uses it. If people used critical thinking all the time society would be a very different place. People would actually think about what they were going to say and what it means before they said it.
Miss Everetts Boys Essay Research Paper Miss
Miss Everetts Boys Essay, Research Paper Miss Everett?s Boys My reaction to Miss Everett?s Boys is one of disgust and utter disbelief. I feel that the government is responsible for the colored men who lost their lives to syphilis during the time of the Tuskegee experiments located within Tuskegee, Alabama.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning 1999 Cloning
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning 1999 Cloning is the process of creating a genetic duplicate of an individual. Since the February 1997 announcement of the birth of Dolly, a sheep cloned by Ian Wilmut, cloning research
School Violence Essay Research Paper Every day
School Violence Essay, Research Paper Every day a child is hurt purposely, or accidentally by another classmate. There are many things that cause people to take violence out on other people. It could possibly be parenting, bullies, television, and even video games.
Cheating Essay Research Paper Students of all
Cheating Essay, Research Paper Students of all ages have been caught cheating. Recent news reports that cheating among students has risen to ?epidemic proportions?. Cheating is a contagious behavior that can be corrected through home, school, and national levels of intervention.
Fastpitch Softball Essay Research Paper Softball is
Fastpitch Softball Essay, Research Paper Softball is a sport alot of people take for granted. A majority of people think it is a simple game. It is not. There is a gtreat deal of stratagy and concentration.You can not walk out on the field and expect to do as well as expirienced players.
Mythology Essay Research Paper What is mythology
Mythology Essay, Research Paper What is mythology? Mythology is like a fib that started many years ago in the olden days. It is still around due to people still continuing to use a myth as the truth. They seem to not know the difference between a myth and a legend. People these days are so naive it is ashame to know the rate of people that actually believe those myths.
People And Machines Essay Research Paper People
People And Machines Essay, Research Paper People and Machines The problem is not with the machine: it is with the man who allows himself to become mechanical. People work on machines all day long. Many of
Euthenasia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia
Euthenasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia has become an issue of increasing attention. Euthanasia should be legalized so, if we ever have a loved one that is suffering and death is certain, that we have the choice to ease their pain if they want. Those who are against euthanasia argue that the doctors must always be on the side of preserving life.
Disabilities Essay Research Paper I have had
Disabilities Essay, Research Paper I have had the opportunity to work with individuals who suffers from a disability. This has advanced my personal growth. They have helped to teach me that all people are the same. I respect them. People just don’t realize that just because someone suffer from, they could have the same IQ as a normal person.
THings Fall Apart Essay Research Paper No
THings Fall Apart Essay, Research Paper ?No Government Could Long Subsist without the Compliance of the People? Government now days if you look at it is run by the people. Senators and House of Reps. play off what people want to get elected, then after they get into office some get right to work, while others go into offices and procrastinate.
What Is Poetry Essay Research Paper I
What Is Poetry? Essay, Research Paper I think poetry is a part of everyone. It can express fellings and emotion. Some people write poems to express their feelings or just because they like and
Aboriginal People Essay Research Paper Many of
Aboriginal People Essay, Research Paper Many of the Aboriginals have developed a way of life that they are satisfied with, but by these big organizations taking control over their communities they have no way of stopping them, without the support of other people in the community. Many aboriginals have lived on these reservations most of their lives, so much of their history has been from living there.
Assited Suicide Essay Research Paper The man
Assited Suicide Essay, Research Paper ?The man who, in a fit of melancholy, kills himself today would have wanted to live had he a week.?(Voltaire) In the U.S. assisted suicide has become all too common. Mr. Jack Kevorkian, otherwise known as Dr. Death, might be the reason for this unethical uprising. Assisted suicide in those who fear they are too old, mentally unstable, or suffering from an incurable illness, doesn?t solve any problems.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.
Active Euthenasia Essay Research Paper The difference
Active Euthenasia Essay, Research Paper The difference between active and passive euthanasia are not quite as cruel and malicious as commonly thought. Passive euthanasia is the fairly common practice of withholding medical treatment from a patient whose biological chances of surviving are obsolete.