Essay, Research Paper
AbstractAccording to the Efficient Market Theory, it should be extremely difficult for an investor to develop a “system” that consistently selects stocks that exhibit higher than normal returns over a period of time. It should also not be possible for a company to “cook the books” to misrepresent the value of stocks and bonds. An analysis of current literature, however, indicates that companies can and do “beat the system” and manipulate information to make stocks appear to perform above average. An understanding of the underlying inefficient “human” factors in the market equation is necessary in order to account for the flaw in Efficient Market Theory.
Efficient Market Theory: A Contradiction of TermsEfficient Market Theory (EMT) is based on the premise that, given the efficiency of information technology and market dynamics, the value of the normal investment stock at any given time accurately reflects the real value of that stock. The price for a stock reflects its actual underlying value, financial managers cannot time stock and bond sales to take advantage of “insider” information, sales of stocks and bonds will not depress prices, and companies cannot “cook the books” to artificially manipulate stock and bond prices. However, information technology and market dynamics are based upon the workings of ordinary people and diverse organizations, neither of which are arguably efficient nor consistent. Therefore, we have the basic contradiction of EMT: How can a theory based on objective mechanical efficiency hold up when applied to subjective human inefficiency?
As a case in point, America Online (AOL) offers a classic example of how investors can be misled by a company that uses the market system against itself. AOL, up until early November of this year, used an accounting system that effectively “cooked their books” and provided misleading figures on the company’s performance. Instead of accounting for its promotion expenses and costs as a regular expense, as normal companies do, AOL spread them over two years. This let AOL report annual profits based on revenue figures derived from denying actual expenses (as cited in Newsweek, November 11 edition).
By deferring those costs, AOL over the years reported profits $385 million greater than they would otherwise have been. The company then used these non-existent profits to promote itself as a money-making opportunity for both stockholders and potential investors, artificially increasing its stock prices. This accounting practice is perfectly legal, but the information was kept private for over two years. The company has recently announced that, effective immediately, promotion expenses will be charged to earnings as the expenses are incurred, the way a normal company does. AOL will also take a one-time special charge of $385 million for the “deferred” promotion costs.
This effectively negated all profits reported by the company over the years and put them in a negative net cash flow situation. As a result, AOL’s stock is currently listed at 35 1/4, down from a high of 71 in May. This example clearly outlines a major flaw in Efficient Market Theory: If EMT relies heavily on information as the basis for determining market value, what happens if the information is manipulated? As a counterpoint, the clear assertion in the Newsweek article is that most normal companies do not use such accounting practices, however legal, to falsely report superior performance. EMT states:
Fundamental analysis cannot produce investment recommendations that will enable an investor consistently to outperform a buy-and-hold strategy in managing a portfolio (Malkiel, 1990).
The corollary of the theory must also then be true. An investor cannot be hurt by the market because the stock value of a poor or overvalued performer already reflects that fact in its price. The available information would indicate to investors that certain stocks are overvalued and subject to rapid decline. The availability of public information did finally force AOL into disclosing the ruse and changing its accounting practices, and coincidentally, lower the stock value to its true worth.
The argument that Efficient Market Theory was working in AOL’s case is that the investors were protected from precipitous loss because the system adjusted the stock price to reflect the actual value of AOL stock. The previously high price did indicate the value of the stock based on the accounting practices then in effect, however misleading they may have been. At the moment that the company decided to change the accounting practices, the value of the stock then was corrected to the actual lower value. This could, reasonably, be viewed as a repudiation of EMT.
369
Другие работы по теме:
The Keynesian Analysis Of The Demand For
Money Essay, Research Paper General Theory ? claimed money stock only important to the extent that it influenced the i. rate, which led to repercussions (stimulate
Alfred Wegener Essay Research Paper Alfred Wegener
Alfred Wegener Essay, Research Paper Alfred Wegener was an explorer and meteorologist, born in Berlin, who first came up with the “Continental Drift Theory” or the “Wegener Theory.” This theory stated that all of the continents came from one super continent, also known as Pangea, which spread apart gradually moving into their current positions on Earth.
Dual Labor Market Essay Research Paper Even
Dual Labor Market Essay, Research Paper Even with all the gains women have made on the job market, they will always be a step behind there fellow male coworkers. Women have made significant gains with their numbers in the workforce, but they still fall behind in the their average wages made. There a many major factors for this, but they are all brought about by the dual labor market.
Goodwill Essay Research Paper The definition of
Goodwill Essay, Research Paper The definition of an intangible asset is an asset that lacks physical substance and usually has a high degree of uncertainty concerning their future benefits, and they are unable to be touched (they are not physical objects). Patens, copyrights franchises, and goodwill are all examples of intangible assets.
Why Is There Gravity Essay Research Paper
When you pick up a stone and release it falls to the ground. This seemingly simple concept has been known throughout history as gravitation. Isaac Newton managed to explain gravity in terms of its effects, but few have come up with a working explanation for the driving force behind it. The mysterious nature of some of the more peculiar effects of gravity, as well as the simple ones, indicate that explaining why there is gravity will be a long, difficult, yet intriguing task.
Modern Portfolio Theory Essay Research Paper The
Modern Portfolio Theory Essay, Research Paper The term ‘portfolio’ is usually applied to combinations of securities, but the principles underlying security portfolio formation can be applied to combinations of any type of assets, including investment projects. Most firms diffuse their efforts across a range of products, market segments and customers in order to spread more thinly the risks of declining trade and profitability.
Critique On Whether God Exists Essay Research
Paper “Whether God Exists” Countless philosophers since the beginning of recorded history have pondered the question of whether God exists. One such philosopher, Saint Thomas Aquinas, put forth his own theory on the existence of God. In his text “Whether God Exists”, he stated that through his five arguments he could prove God’s existence.
William Roy And Contemporary Corporation Essay Research
Paper William Roy’s conception of the contemporary corporation focuses on the merger wave of the 1890’s during which which many large firms turned to public capital markets to facilitate mergers. The change that occurred in corporations was when they went from a public sphere to a private sphere. Two sectors, manufacturing and financial, came together at this time.
Competition And Economic Efficiency Essay Research Paper
Efficiency: refers to the relationship between the value of the benefit relative to the costs incurred to obtain the benefit. An activity is efficient if the total benefit exceeds the total cost. An outcome is efficient if there is no other outcome that makes someone better off without making someone worse off.
Beyond The Cult Of Fatherhood Essay Research
Paper Visual Media Review In a world of mass media people use new technologies to get their product/service out to the market. One such newer idea of distribution to the mass market is through television audience. To more fine-tune it, shop-at-home television. The idea is simple; you buy a huge surplus of product, so that you get large discounts.
Charles Darwin Essay Research Paper Charles DarwinOne
Charles Darwin Essay, Research Paper Charles Darwin One of the most famous names in science and in the economy today, is Charles Darwin. Darwin is best known for his contributions in science; his famous theory of evolution. He also contributed to the market and command economy with his belief, “survival of the fittest.”
Applications Of Game Theory Essay Research Paper
GAME THEORY One possible application of Game Theory is in advertising. Advertising involves the promotion of products and services so as to expose the product or service to a greater number of people. The goal of advertising is to make more people aware of a company s product or service so that more people would avail of this product or service, and this would mean more revenues for the company.
La Croix On Descartes Essay Research Paper
La Croix in his essay disputes the position set forth by Harry Frankfurt in his article “Descartes on the Creation of the Eternal Truths” (The Philosophical Review, 1977), charging that Frankfurt misrepresents Descartes? view of God?s nature and power. According to La Croix, Frankfurt holds that, in claiming that God created the eternal truths and could have done the opposite with respect to establishing the law of contradiction, Descartes conceived of God?s power as extending beyond the laws of logic.
Theories Of Inequality Essay Research Paper In
Theories Of Inequality Essay, Research Paper In briefly evaluating the classical and modern explanations of social inequality, it is essential that we step outside the realm of our own lives, class position, and discard any assumptions we might have about the nature of inequality. This process of critical pedagogy allows us to view our world, not from our perspective, but from a wider, more critical analysis of inequality?s nature.
Hong KongIndia Command And Market Economies Essay
, Research Paper The world is run with economic systems. Two of these economic systems are the market economy and the command economy. These economic systems both greatly differ and are similar in there ways of controling the
Positivism Essay Research Paper PositivismPositivism is the
Positivism Essay, Research Paper Positivism Positivism is the belief that “scientific naturalism” is the foundation of knowledge and truth. Leszek Kolakowski wrote “Positivism is a normative attitude, regulating how we are to use such terms as knowledge , science , cognition , and information . Positivism rejects the theories of theology and metaphysics because they don t have proof that they are true.
Saint Thomas Aquinas Writings Essay Research Paper
In “Summa Contra Gentiles”, by Saint Thomas Aquinas, one of the major proofs of the existence of God is the second proof. The second proof is based on the “everything has a cause” theory. He states that there are ordered lines of efficient causes, and nothing can be it’s own cause. Yet it is impossible for the line of efficient causes to extend into infinity.
Financial Article Essay Research Paper Goldman Sachs
Financial Article Essay, Research Paper Goldman Sachs is the last big Wall Street investment bank to go public. In this story they are explaining how is the timing of its IPO (Initial Public Offering) going to be affected by the market at this moment. The market at this moment is very volatile. Some people think that the market is too high and that a correction is in our way very soon.
Consumer Decision On Phones Essay Research Paper
Due to the speed of technological advances nowadays, it is increasing difficult for anyone to predict the marketing strategy for an electronic device. As for telephones today, they are becoming more and more sophisticated in both capabilities and application of these capabilities. A potential buyer is nevertheless confronted with decisions cordless or non-cordless, caller ID or no caller ID and so on.
Euclid
’s 5Th Postulate Essay, Research Paper Euclid s Fifth Postulate One of the most fascinating aspects of Mathematics is that there exist statements that are both true and false. Perhaps the most famous of these is Euclid s controversial fifth postulate. Throughout history, almost from the postulate conception, mathematics have tried to prove or disprove it.
Charles Darwin Essay Research Paper Charles Darwin 2
Charles Darwin Essay, Research Paper Charles Darwin, a 19th century biologist believed in a theory of survival of the fittest. The theory of Darwinism says that whoever is best fit for their surroundings will survive. This theory was used to explain how animals came about and survive and brought about the theory of evolution.
The Modified Market Economy Essay Research Paper
What is a modified market economy? What factors have been responsible for the emergence of this kind of economic system? How do governments influence economic decision making in such systems? Use Australian examples to illustrate your answer.
Market System Essay Research Paper
“Land, labor, and capital are the essential components of a market system” (Heilbroner 33). Due to the fact that these major components were nonexistent, the market system at one time did not exist. The catalyst for the market system was the idea of gain, “which is a relatively modern idea” (H 24). There were many factors of society that prevented the market system and the idea of gain from entering.
What Is God Who Is God Essay
, Research Paper What is God? Who is God? Why do some people conclude that a God exists? Saint Thomas Aquinas goes from the fact that there must be a first efficient cause to the conclusion that God is that cause. Why must Aquinas make the extraordinary jump from there being a cause, to assuming that this cause must be God? Would it not be just as plausible to make matter the first cause? Matter is the substance that any physical object is composed of.
Controlling Corruption Essay Research Paper Corruption is
Controlling Corruption Corruption is the method government officials implore to extract rents from businesses. This paper uses the functionalist-modernization theory of corruption to examine governmental corruption. The primary argument is that the functionalist-modernization approach is the most efficient method of controlling corruption.
England Industrial Revolution Essay Research Paper First
England Industrial Revolution Essay, Research Paper First British Industrial Revolution The manufacture of military munitions and the development of a home market were critical underpinnings of the first industrial revolution in Britain. Military manufacturing supported by the British Government contributed directly to technological innovation and spurred industrialization.
Theories On Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper
Theories of Drug Legalization If Drugs were legal they would be easily accessable and legal, Goverment would receive revenue, It deters crime of people obtaining drugs, and gives better emotional state of americans. The other side of this is the highly possible death by overdose, psychological problems because of drug abuse, anarchy over the alleged govermental control over drugs increase the number of drug addicts, lead to more children using drugs,increase the number of hard-core addicts, increase drug-related problems and costs, and increase crime There is another argument of Prohibition, and the war on drugs in theory isn’t valid, because like in 1919 , when alcohol was outlawed, all that prove to do was defeat the purpose of prohibition by glamorizing Drugs and Alcohol through the black market because people need Drugs and Alcohol, and that’s reality.
Econmfyg Essay Research Paper MARKET FAILURE AND
Econmfyg Essay, Research Paper MARKET FAILURE AND UNCERTAINTYIn this essay I would like to argue that market failure is the reason for hierarchy. I willargue that market failure leads to uncertainty and that uncertainty leads to incompletecontracts. To explore the notion of incomplete contracts I have used the ideas of Milgromand Roberts.
Recent Drops In The Stock Market Essay
, Research Paper Recently, the stock market has been very unstable. After a period of extremely good business and market highs, it seems we are experiencing just the opposite. The market has
SWOT Essay Research Paper Question A
SWOT Essay, Research Paper Question A ? Analyse Market opportunities using S.W.O.T analysis. STRENGTHS Meadow Lea is regarded as an icon brand ? awareness is high and it has been a top selling brand for 26 years. Consumers clearly understand that that it is positioned as a family brand.