Paper
“Whether God Exists”
Countless philosophers since the beginning of recorded history have pondered the question of whether God exists. One such philosopher, Saint Thomas Aquinas, put forth his own theory on the existence of God. In his text “Whether God Exists”, he stated that through his five arguments he could prove God’s existence. His five arguments are from motion, from first efficient cause, from possibility and necessity, from gradation, and from design.
Aquinas begins his text with two objections as to why God does not exist. The first states that God does not exist because the word “God” has the meaning of infinite goodness. Therefore, if God actually existed there would be no evil in this world. Because there is evil, God cannot exist. The second objection states that all natural things can be attributed to reasons other than God’s existence. The objection states that natural things are the result of human reason or will, without need for God’s existence.
Aquinas then goes on to explain his first argument, the argument from motion. In this he states that it is evident to everyone that certain things are in motion, and were put into motion by something. He defines motion to be “…the reduction of something from a state of potentiality into a state of actuality…” (Bowie, 58, Col.1). Aquinas gives an example of this in his text. He states that something that is actually as hot as fire will make the potentially hot piece of wood actually hot. Furthermore he states that it is not possible to be in a state of actuality and potentiality at the same time from the same point of view. From different points of view, however, this is possible. In the case of the wood, it can be actually hot while at the same time being potentially cold. With this he is basically saying that nothing has the ability to move itself. According to Aquinas, everything has been put into motion by an original force or first mover, and this he believes to be God.
Aquinas’ second argument is the argument from the formality of efficient causation. In this he states that there is an order of efficient causes in things that occur. Aquinas says that there is no evidence “…in which a thing is found to be the efficient cause of itself…” (Bowie, 58, Col.2). He states that there must be a first cause, which creates one or more intermediate causes, which then in turn creates an ultimate cause. According to Aquinas, without a cause, there can be no effect. Therefore without a first cause, there cannot be an intermediate or ultimate cause, or an ultimate effect. So according to Aquinas, there must have been some First Efficient Cause, which he claims is God.
Aquinas’ third argument is from possibility and necessity. In this Aquinas states that things that can one day cease to exist could not have always existed. Aquinas says “…if everything could cease to exist, then at one time there could have been nothing in existence.” (Bowie, 59, Col.1). He stated that if this were true then there would be nothing in existence now. This is because according to Aquinas, if nothing had existed, there would be nothing there to begin to exist. So therefore, according to Aquinas, there must be some being in existence that has always been there. This something has its own necessity and causes necessity in others. This being he believes to be God.
Aquinas’ fourth argument is from gradation. Aquinas says that “Among beings there are some more and some less good, true, noble, and the like” (Bowie, 59, Col.1). But he states that more and less are dependent on the degree of most. An example he gives was that to be hotter, there has to be something that is hottest to judge it by. Aquinas also says “as fire…is the most complete form of heat…there must also be something which to all beings is the cause of their being…” (Bowie, 59, Col.2), and according to him, that something is God. He is thought of as the best, truest, and noblest being who is the cause for us being here.
Aquinas’ fifth and final argument is from the governance of the world, or simply put, design. He states that things in nature that lack intelligence act in a certain way to obtain the best result, which is to survive. As Aquinas says, “…not fortuitously, but designedly…they achieve their purpose.” (Bowie, 59, Col.2). He states that these things that lack intelligence cannot achieve their purpose without being directed by “…some being endowed with intelligence and knowledge.” (Bowie, 59, Col.2). Aquinas concludes that this being which gives purpose to certain things in nature must exist, and according to him this being is God.
After proposing his five arguments, Aquinas offers his reply to the two objections as stated in the beginning. To the first objection, he states that the evil in the world is all a part of His plan. He says that “…He [God] should allow evil to exist, and out of it produce good.” (Bowie, 59. Col.2). To the second objection, he states that everything in nature must be traced back to a first cause, which is God. He then states that human reason is changeable and things that change can only come from an immovable unchanged first principle, which he states is God.
Although Saint Thomas Aquinas wrote five arguments on the existence of God, to me all but one of them seemed to reiterate the same theory. His writings about the first mover, First Efficient Cause, possibility and necessity, and design all seem to say that nothing can be without Being first. I am not convinced by this theory. I believe that Aquinas’ text ignores the question of who is responsible for the creation of this “first mover”. I feel that science better explains why nature is the way it is. The theory of evolution gives a more plausible reason why things are the way they are. The environment wasn’t designed for everything in it. All living things in nature adapted to their surroundings.
As for the remaining idea of gradation, I believe that this does make some sense. I agree that there are different grades of people, best to worst. Since no one is perfect, I feel that there must be a perfect being of some sort. I can see that this is still relevant in today’s, and feel that this is Aquinas’ only valid reason whether God really exists. Since no one will ever know for sure whether or not He exists, anything said can only be opinion and everyone is entitled to his or her own. Without solid evidence, there can never be an agreement on this topic.
Bibliography
Text Reference:
Bowie, Michaels, Solomon. Twenty Questions. Orlando: Harcourt College Publishers, 2000
St. Thomas Aquinas. “Whether God Exists”. Pp. 57-59
Другие работы по теме:
St Anselm
’S Ontological Argument For The Experience Of God. Essay, Research Paper God’s existence may vary from philosopher to philosopher, but according to the late St. Anselm,
The Argument Culture Essay Research Paper In
The Argument Culture Essay, Research Paper In The Argument Culture, Deborah Tannen describes our adversarial society in debates and dialogues. Tannen discusses our culture?s style of seeing issues, questions, and conflicts as having two sides that battle each other for one goal, victory. She says that not only does this argument culture or culture of critique we live in make life more challenging and alienating, it also reduces the amount of information made available to viewers or information seekers.
Response To Emrich
’s Critique Of Hans Kafka’s The Essay, Research Paper Wilhelm Emrich has presented an unimaginative and misleading critical essay ofFranz Kafka s The Metamorphosis. Emrich s failure to make any daring insights providesmuch protection against any real opposition, but also serves to evince his occasionalblunders all the more.
Critique Of Recitatif Essay Research Paper Critique
Critique Of Recitatif Essay, Research Paper Critique of Recitatif Sometimes, the mere fact of being from a different race can influence people’s way of thinking or attitude toward other people with different color skin. That is the theme of Toni Morrison’s short story Recitatif. In the story, two eight year old girls, Roberta and Twyla, from different races (black and white) meet in an orphanage called St.
Leap Of Faith Essay Research Paper Critique
Leap Of Faith Essay, Research Paper Critique on Inherit the Wind and Leap of Faith (The Impact on Society) The world is filled with all sorts of people, with different ideas and views of living life. Different people have different methods of influencing other people, either indirectly or directly. People in today s present age have different perceptions of society than in the past.
Art Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Art Critique Essay, Research Paper The first artwork that I had had looked at was Radio Tori, a ceramic arch built by Peter King. It was my first time inside the WUWF radio station building. I found the building to be quite beautiful. The architecture was well done outside the building. Inside, there were various artworks inside the hallway.
Movie Arsenic And Old Lace Essay Research
Paper Movie: Arsenic and Old Lace The movie Arsenic & Old Lace is based on the play about a movie critique who’s two aunts , choose to put lonely men out of there reason by
God Existence Essay Research Paper I do
God Existence Essay, Research Paper I do not believe God exists. I have many reasons why I think that there is no God. One of my many reasons is that there is no way that one man could have
God Essay Research Paper To say that
God Essay, Research Paper To say that God does exist, is to say that we can prove God exists by describing some proof we have of this statement, or at least a being with what we think some of the attributes of a God would be. Since we cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that God exists we have to infer certain things about how we came to be.
The Myth Of Time Sumosaki Vs Enigma
) Essay, Research Paper Give me some time to think. You pressure me with your hourglass. Your concept, I am not supposed to believe in. But I am not given choices.
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
Anselm
’s Ontological Argument Essay, Research Paper As a theologian and philosopher, Saint Anselm strove to prove the existence of God in reality. The bulk of his argument is found in Chapter II of Proslogium.
Christian Reformation Essay Research Paper The Protestant
Christian Reformation Essay, Research Paper The Protestant Reformation Many ideas of the Renaissance like humanism, individualism and secularism stimulated a strong critique of the church+s policy and the clergy+s behaviour. Many people regarded it as a scandal that the catholic church sold indulgences.
Hunchback Essay Research Paper Film CritiqueThe Hunchback
Hunchback Essay, Research Paper Film Critique The Hunchback of Notre Dame Hugo was trying to say about the main character, Quazi Motto, that looks have nothing to do with personality and how well they should be liked. Quazi Motto was quite
Aquinas Essay Research Paper According to Aquinas
Aquinas Essay, Research Paper According to Aquinas everything is created was created by God. Aquinas made five proofs to proof the God exists and HE created everything. His five proofs are motion, efficient cause, possibility/necessity, gradation, and governance of the world.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet 2000 CritiqueWhen
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ?Hamlet? (2000) Critique When we watch movies, we look for entertainment. That is the only reason why theatrical movies are created. Movies create entertainment which creates money.
Archeo Essay Research Paper A Cross Cultural
Archeo Essay, Research Paper A Cross Cultural Perspective of Polygyny As an institution, polygyny, the social arrangement that permits a man to have more than one wife at the same
Marx Essay Research Paper After reading through
Marx Essay, Research Paper After reading through Marx?s German Ideology, I came to realize that it was not actually a critique on the faults of German thinkers or philosophers. It was more a critique on the nature of history, as we know it. For the most part, people see history reflected through ideologies that distorts reality.
Gummo
– Movie Critique Essay, Research Paper The film Gummo is intended to be a symbolic movie in which fantasy and reality intertwine. Initially, the film opens in a small town in Ohio after a tornado has swept through and destroyed it. Economically the small region is wrecked. Like the buildings around them, the social fabric that is holding the town together is coming apart at the seams.
Stephen KingS Why We Crave Horror Movies
? Essay, Research Paper A Critique of Stephen King?s ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? Elliot Potter In Stephen King?s essay ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? he suggested that
Church Existence Essay Research Paper The Church
Church Existence Essay, Research Paper The Church exists to call sinners out of the muck and mire of an evil world system that has pitted mother against daughter, father against son, woman against man, man against nature and all humanity against God into a transforming and healing community that can undo the damage that the world has done to us through the building of GOD Kingdom here on Earth.
A Moment Essay Research Paper A moment
A Moment Essay, Research Paper A moment exists in what we call time. Time in itself, is a figment of our imagination. The only part of time that actually exists is the present moment. All other moments become memory or expectation, leaving them to be non existent. In truth, the present moment is the only part of time that can be experienced by the six senses.
SummaryCritique Essay Research Paper
fde__________COURSEfde______SECTION/TIME______ SUMMARY/CRITIQUE FORM REFERENCE: Darley, J. M., & Latane?, B. (1968). Bystander intervention in emergencies: Diffusion of responsibility in R. Hock (Ed.), Forty Studies That Changed Psychology (295-303). Upper Saddle, N. J.: Prentice Hall.
Op Essay Research Paper Article Critique
Op Essay, Research Paper Article Critique ? New Hotel Project The article talks about the possibilities of making ?One card, For Many Doors?. They are trying to make a room key with an internal credit card. Using a new system guests will be able to check in and issue a room key (double encoded) using their own credit card.
Sexual Harassment Shouldn
’t Go Undetected Essay, Research Paper Although businesses and schools know sexual harassment exists, they appear unsure and unaware of how to deal with and prevent it. Sexual harassment is a reference to sex or anything sexual by any statement made or taken. There are many types of sexual harassment, but school and work, are the most common.
Book Of Job Essay Research Paper The
Book Of Job Essay, Research Paper The Book of Job, including the epilogue, argues justice is retributive in its nature. Retributive justices states that a just distribution of fairness exists. Throughout the book, Job portrays the idea that good things happen to those who are good, while bad things happen to those who are bad.
American Dream Essay Research Paper scribes the
American Dream Essay, Research Paper scribes the defeat of the American dream, and that the American ideals differ with the actual social conditions that exist in society. For the American constitutions stands for the freedom, and equality among people, but the truth of the matter is that social discrimination still exists and the grouping among the classes can never be overcome.
The Graduate Essay Research Paper Veronica CombsThis
The Graduate Essay, Research Paper Veronica Combs This paper will be both a critique as well as an analysis of the relationships between both my generation and the time period in which the movie took place. In the critique, I which to look at the movie score and the dependency that I felt Ben and Katherine had for each other.
Advertising Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Advertising Critique Essay, Research Paper The first of the three ads that I have selected is from The New Yorker magazine. It is an ad for Russell Athletic. This is a company that makes sports wear. In the ad, you see a man wearing their product. The man is vigorously working out and is in good shape. The outfit from Russell Athletic is supposed to perform, according to the caption on the left.
Critique Of Essay Research Paper Critique of
Critique Of Essay, Research Paper Critique of “Clara Barton s Finest Hour By Stephen B. Oates” Clara Barton is best known for establishing the American Red Cross. However, as Stephen Oates points out, her greatest achievement came during the Civil War, as an independent wartime nurse. He tells of her struggle to be accepted in a field that was exclusively male.
Demonstration Critique Essay Research Paper Demonstration Critique
Demonstration Critique Essay, Research Paper Demonstration Critique During my demonstration speech, I was affected by my speech anxiety. Some of the viewable symptoms were the shaking of my hands and also the stuttering of speech. I was able to control myself and relax after I started getting into my information.
Critique Essay Research Paper This critique is
Critique Essay, Research Paper This critique is divided into three sections: structure, content, and positive attributes. On the basis of structure the essay is not of high caliber. This is primarily because the thoughts within each paragraph did not correlate to the topic sentence. Within each subtopic the paragraphs supports were also separated and organized poorly.
Robert Frost Critique Essay Research Paper Choices
Robert Frost Critique Essay, Research Paper Choices are never easy- men face multitudes of them in their lifetime. Some decisions to these choices are clear while others are sometimes more difficult to effectuate. The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is a first person narrative tale of a monumental moment in the speaker s life- Frost can be considered the speaker.
The New Deal Essay Research Paper FDR
The New Deal Essay, Research Paper FDR and the Great Depression Critique the efficiency of FDR’s administration at alleviating the suffering of the great Depression