’s Ethics, Part I Proposition 33 Essay, Research Paper
Baruch Spinoza believes the essence of God includes God’s existence and discusses the causality of God through his ontological work, Ethics. In Ethics, Spinoza is seeking a method of truth through the perfect being. The essence of what that perfect being expresses, using this method of truth, is God (i.e. the perfect being). In this essay I am going to give a detailed account of Part I, Proposition 33 of Spinoza’s book Ethics.
Part I, Proposition 33 of Ethics states that “things could not have been produced by any other way or in any other order than is the case.” This means that whatever does exist could not exist in any other way or in any other manner then it already exists. It certainly follows then, according to Spinoza that this proposition 33 follows from Proposition 16 and 29. Proposition 16 states that,
” From the necessity of the divine nature there must follow infinite things in infinite ways [modis], (that is, everything that can come within the scope of infinite intellect).”
Proposition 29 states that,
“Nothing in nature is contingent, but all things are from the necessity of the divine nature determined to exist and to act in a definite way.”
According to Spinoza, this provides proof that all things have necessarily followed from the nature of God (Proposition 16) and have been determined to exist and to act in a definite way from the necessity of that nature (Proposition 29). For example this means that I smoke cigarettes from the necessity of God’s will, and furthermore cigarettes, a cancer-causing agent, exist from God’s will. I will now talk about Spinoza’s further conditions of Proposition 33.
In Note 1, Spinoza is developing that there can not be a contingency or possibility of a thing existing because it either necessarily exists or is impossible for it to exist. Spinoza believes that everything has a cause. If it has no cause it contributes to the theory of doubt making a thing contingent. This lack of knowing, which makes a thing contingent is a contradiction, and since all that we know is or isn’t in existence. This means that there can not be any contingency of or about anything. For example, this means that it is possible for me to smoke without a reason. Spinoza responds to this criticism that our idea of contingency is made up of our lack of knowledge or more blatantly our own ignorance about the existence of that thing (i.e. we do not know the cause).
In Note 2, Spinoza reiterates from his proof that a thing can not be anything different then that which it is. Spinoza is careful to express that a thing is either perfect or imperfect, and they are just the way they are necessarily. It follows from that, if a thing was different from what it is already, God’s will would have made that thing the way it is and no other way necessarily.
Spinoza responds to G.W. Leibniz’s idea of the best of all possible worlds. Spinoza points out that there is an absurdity in Leibniz’s idea. Spinoza could say, How is it possible for God to create the best of all possible worlds when God is the Universe? If God could have created multiple worlds it would mean that there would have been two or more Gods in existence. Obviously it could not be possible for there to be two or more Gods since God is the Universe. Hence there are not two or more Gods in existence and a thing can be no different then what that thing already is in its entirety. Moreover, God’s will and essence cause a thing and that makes the thing true to God. Furthermore, if a thing is a perfect or imperfect (good or bad) thing it is that way already and no thought to what could have been will make any difference. It is what it is.
In conclusion, I have explained Proposition 33 and Note 1 and 2 of Part I of Spinoza’s Ethics. This essay shows that God created everything and that everything is the way it is because of the nature of God to will it. Furthermore, God is everything and all causes follow from God.
Spinoza, Baruch Part I Proposition 33 of Ethics. Cited in Modern Philosophy: Anthology of Primary Sources. Edited by: Ariew, Roger and Watkins, Eric. Hackett (Indianapolis/Cambridge 1998). Pg. 143.
Ariew and Watkins. Pg. 137.
Ariew and Watkins. Pg. 141.
Другие работы по теме:
Рационализм философия
Введение 1 Формальная и субстантивная рациональность 2 История философского рационализма 2.1 Сократ (ок. 470—399 до н. э.) 2.2 Рационализм и эмпиризм
Great Gatsby- Fitzgerald And The American Dream
Essay, Research Paper The life in the roaring twenties was the life of parties and social gatherings, full of entertainment, laughter, and simplicity of heart without a care in the world. Like Alfred, Lord Tennyson, wrote, “Dream are true while they last” in The Higher Pantheism, and Tennyson’s such thought was evident in the novel The Great Gatsby.
Gottfried Wilhelm Von Leibniz Essay Research Paper
Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz was born on July 1, 1646 in Leipzig. His father was a Professor of Moral Philosophy and Vice Chairman of the faculty of philosophy at the University of Leipzig. His father died when he was six, so his mother raised him. When he was seven, Leibniz attended the Nicolai School in Leipzig.
Moses And Exodus Religion Essay Research Paper
Were Moses and Samuel Prophet Material? To get a good idea of being a Prophet or what a Prophet is we must look at many sources. This means we must look at the events that happened in the Bible and make conclusions about each event or section. Were Samuel and Moses Prophets? Did they receive messages from God, or was it their imagination? We will hope to discover this in looking closer at all of their lives.
Descartes Vs Hume Essay Research Paper Rationalism
Descartes Vs. Hume Essay, Research Paper Rationalism and Empiricism are most likely the two most famous and intriguing schools of philosophy. The two schools deal specifically with epistemology, or, the origin of knowledge. Although not completely opposite, they are often considered so, and are seen as the “Jordan vs.
Existence Of God Essay Research Paper Chris
Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper Chris Karcz114-68-4634 Existence of God or the Lack There of Philosophers and theologians have always searched a way to prove the existence or non-existence of God. Many of these philosophers have made valid points for their views on the subject. Philosophers such as Saint Thomas Aquinas, Decartes, and John Locke argued for the existence of God while others, such as Rowe and Hume, searched for ways to disprove the arguments that these philosophers stated.
Sophie Essay Research Paper As the story
Sophie Essay, Research Paper As the story progresses in Sophie s World, Sophie Amundsen continues on with her philosophy lessons. As she gets more and more involved with these lessons she soon
Judiasm Essay Research Paper Judaism is an
Judiasm Essay, Research Paper Judaism is an interesting religion worth looking into for those who are interested in learning about other religions. The majority of Jews accept Christianity,and Jesus Christ.
Thesis Is There A God Or Is
He(?) An Illusion? Essay, Research Paper Thesis: Is There a God or is He(?) an Illusion? An illusion is one’s own interpretation and perception of someone or something.
The Dutch Maimonides
” Consider This Description Of Baruch Spinoza Essay, Research Paper The Dutch Maimonides: how ironic that this epithet, a name `synonomous with virtue, respect and religious devotion, should be `directed at a man villified and ostracized by the Dutch Jewish `community for heretical tendencies, and left to die in `circumstances bordering on the ignominious, among Gentiles.
Life After Death Essay Research Paper The
Life After Death Essay, Research Paper The Afterlife is an area of human consciousness we all enter upon leaving the physical world at physical death. Throughout history we’ve questioned if there is a life after death. Along the way, our religions and various philosophers offered beliefs and opinions to answer this commonly asked question.
Robin YamaguchiMath 13March 21 1999 Essay Research
Paper Rene Descartes In the recent hit movie The Net, the character played by Sandra Bullock has her identity erased. Everyone doubted her existence. This was not, however, the first time someone’s existence was questioned. In the early 17th century a philosopher, who is named Descartes, questioned his own existence.
Nature Essay Research Paper Descartes explains in
Nature Essay, Research Paper Descartes explains in nature that he exits by having such qualities and abilities to see, touch, taste and smell. Although existing in nature includes being able to walk, have perception and thinking, Descartes believes that he is a thinking thing. (Thinking includes understanding and reason).
Scientific Revolution Essay Research Paper AP European
Scientific Revolution Essay, Research Paper AP European History Lin Malaitham Period IV Discuss the different beliefs, attitudes of Cervantes, Bunyan, Milton, Spinoza and Pascal. Discuss their skepticism/Dogmatic beliefs, their reasons behind it and your opinions.
Hegel Essay Research Paper Georg Wihelm Friedrich
Hegel Essay, Research Paper Georg Wihelm Friedrich Hegel 1770- 1831 German Idealist Hegel was born in Stuttgart on August 27, 1770, which is now part of Germany. Hegel was the son of a revenue officer with the civil service. He studied the Greek and Roman classics while attending the Stuttgart preparatory school.
Leibniz And Spinoza As Applied To Baseball
Essay, Research Paper Essay 2 First we will consider the assigned baseball scenario under Leibniz?s system of metaphysics. In the baseball scenario, the aggregate of the player, bat, pitch, swing and all the other substances in the universe are one and all contingent. There are other possible things, to be sure; but there are also other possible universes that could have existed but did not.
Baruch Spinoza Essay Research Paper The task
Baruch Spinoza Essay, Research Paper The task of simply just surviving is for most of us a handful in itself in this life. However, only a few in a life time choose not to be satisfied with only just survival rather they assume the yoke of redefining life for themselves and for others. In philosophy of religion, pantheism is usually in conflict with traditional religious authority, which claims that the pantheistic belief is nothing more than a blasphemous form of idolatrous worship.
Descartes Leibniz And Spinoza Essay Research Paper
Erik Irre Modern Philosophy December 16, 1999 Paper 1, Section 2 If these great thinkers (Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibniz) were to discuss instead the soul?s connection to the body, what might each say (both on his own behalf and in response to the other)? Would they find any places where they might agree? If not, why not? (These are, after all, smart guys!)
Spinoza Essay Research Paper This paper will
Spinoza Essay, Research Paper This paper will outline Spinoza s argument in Part 1 of his Ethics of substance. He argues that there is only one substance, which is the same as God, that includes everything in the universe. It will walk through each proposition and explain his proof of it, which relies of his stated definitions.
Spinoza Feat Descartes Essay Research Paper Spinoza
Spinoza Feat. Descartes Essay, Research Paper Spinoza at first worked in the framework of the Cartesian philosophy, publishing in 1663 a book entitled Principles of the Philosophy of Ren? Descartes. Another early work, the posthumously published Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect, contains themes that were central to Descartes? investigation of knowledge.
Judiasm Essay Research Paper Some of the
Judiasm Essay, Research Paper Some of the greatest persons ever to live were Jews. Several of the greatest scientists, writers, human rights activists, musicians and comedians were or are Jews: Baruch Spinoza, Sigmund Freud, Albert Einstein, Charlie Chaplin, Yehudi Menuhin, Woody Allen come to mind.
Beyond The Problem Of Evil Essay Research
Paper Beyond the Problem of EvilIntroduction:The problem of evil is, in my opinion, the best point of departure for a fruitful dialogue between Christianity, traditionally conceived, and those strands of modern philosophy which have been perceived–indeed, have sometimes perceived themselves–as a threat to that tradition.
The Cause Of Conflict Essay Research Paper
The Cause of Conflict Spinoza explained (p.3) ?violence by reference to human imperfection…and logically, the end of conflict must depend on the reform of man?. Spinoza believes that because man does not cooperate to achieve harmony without self-interest and self-gain, the ultimate result is incessant quarrels and physical violence.
Untitled Essay Research Paper We ought then
Untitled Essay, Research Paper We ought then regard the present state of the universe as the effect of its previous state and the cause of the one which is to follow. An intelligence knowing at a given instant of time
V.J. Jerome
–Biographical Note Essay, Research Paper [Biographical Note supplied by the Yale University Library, where Jerome’s papers are located.] Victor Jeremy Jerome, writer, editor and chairman of the
Labyrinths Death And The Compass Essay Research
Paper Upon my first reading of Jorge Luis Borges ?Death and the Compass? I found myself reacting to the chain of events not unlike the bland but efficient Inspector Treviranus. The Hotel du Nord with its hateful whiteness, numbered divisibility, and general appearance of a bordello seemed a natural place for a crime of greed and betrayal to have gone sour on a luckless criminal.
Spinoza And His Jewish Influence Essay Research
Paper Spinoza is considered one of the critical foundations of modern western thought. However, since he was of Jewish background and sought to expand on what he was taught by Jewish tradition, it is safe to say that much of modern western thought is based, partly, on Jewish ideas through Spinoza. Though there is not a whole lot written in English covering exactly what Spinoza learned and thought during his early years, a comparison of Spinoza s writings with Jewish writings offers a great deal of insight into how he was influenced by those ideas.
Logic And Truth Essay Research Paper Logic
Logic And Truth Essay, Research Paper Logic is the study of necessary truths and of systematic methods for clearly expressing and rigourously demonstrating such truths.
Hobbes Locke And Rousseau On Social Contract
Essay, Research Paper “Social Contract, agreement by which human beings are said to have abandoned the “state of nature” in order to form the society in which they now live. HOBBES, LOCKE, and J.J. ROUSSEAU each developed differing versions of the social contract, but all agreed that certain freedoms had been surrendered for society’s protection and that the government has definite responsibilities to its citizens.
The Enlightenment 2 Essay Research Paper 2
The Enlightenment 2 Essay, Research Paper “The Enlightenment” The period of the Enlightenment is dated to the middle of the eighteenth century and is primarily about the changes in the worldview of European culture. The term Enlightenment refers to a series of changes in European thought and writings. When writers, philosophers, and scientists of the eighteenth century referred to their activities as the Enlightenment, they meant that they were breaking from the past and replacing the obscurity, darkness, and ignorance of European thought with the light of truth.
Understanding People Essay Research Paper Different people
Understanding People Essay, Research Paper Different people see the world from different perspectives. In our society, there will always be misunderstandings between people and those people s reactions will differ. Some choose to mope, groan, and even get angry about the way that themselves or others are treated while some decide to try and do something about it.
History Of The Government In United States
Of America Essay, Research Paper In this essay I will give a short history of the government in United States of America (U.S.). Then I will describe each of the three branches of government in the U.S. and the relationship between
Hardy Where Did His Writings Come From
Essay, Research Paper A Question On Hardy: Where Did His Writings Come From Born into an agricultural community and untouched by industrialism, Thomas Hardy’s pessimism and determinism is what made his themes and styles stand out from other contemporary writers. According to Zabel, Schopenhaur inspired his pessimistic nature.