Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper
Chris Karcz114-68-4634
Existence of God or the Lack There of
Philosophers and theologians have always searched a way to prove the existence or non-existence of God. Many of these philosophers have made valid points for their views on the subject. Philosophers such as Saint Thomas Aquinas, Decartes, and John Locke argued for the existence of God while others, such as Rowe and Hume, searched for ways to disprove the arguments that these philosophers stated.
Saint Thomas Aquinas had five ways in which he proved the existence of God. The first of which dealt with proving the existence of God through the idea of motion. By studying the works of Aristotle he concluded that an object in motion must be put into motion by another object or force. Therefore he stated that there must be an ?unmoved mover? (God) who initially put things into motion:
?When it is said that something moves itself, the same being is considered as both moving and moved. When, however, it is said that something is moved by another, one thing is considered as a mover and another thing as being moved. Now it is clear that when something moves another, the fact that it is moving another does not mean that it is the first mover. Whence to say that something moves another does not exclude the fact that it itself may be moved by another and have from this other the fact that it is a mover. So, in like manner, when something moves itself, this does not exclude the fact that it may be moved by another and have from this other the power to move itself.(Being and God, pp.235)?
The second way that St. Thomas proved the existence of God was through causation of existence. In this proof he says that no object creates itself so therefore something must have created it. There then must have been an ?uncaused first cause? (God) that started the chain of existence.
St. Thomas?s third way of proving the existence of God was through proving the existence of contingent and necessary objects. A Contingent being is an object that depends on the existence of a necessary being for its existence. Therefore a necessary being must exist to support the existence of the contingent beings. This necessary being is what we have come to know as God.
The argument from degrees and perfection, St. Thomas?s fourth way of proving the existence of God, states in order for something to appear as beautiful, there must be another one of these things to compare it to that is less beautiful then the next. St. Thomas then stated for any given quality, such as beauty or knowledge, there must be a perfect standard by which all these qualities are measured. All these perfections are contained in God.
St. Thomas?s fifth way of proving the existence of God was through the argument from intelligent design. In this proof St. Thomas states that common sense tells us that the universe was created by an intelligent designer, God. All physical laws and the order of nature and life were designed and ordered by God, the intelligent designer.
Decartes said, ?we exist and we have the idea of a most perfect being; and, as we are ourselves imperfect, that the idea is not produced by us-it must therefore have a cause. (Decartes & Spinoza, pp.74)? By saying this Decartes brings about the idea of innate ideas to prove the existence of God. He is saying that because we have an idea of a perfect being it must have been put in our minds for a purpose and therefore God exists.
Decartes then went on to give the example of the mountain without a valley. He stated that since he could not conceive of a mountain without a valley there must be no such thing. In regard to this he said that he would not be able to conceive of a God that did not exist therefore God must exist.
Spinoza tried to prove the existence of God in Proposition 5 when he says that the existence of God is known simply by the consideration of his nature. He states that ?the conception of God involves the necessary existence of God?. He uses the example of a triangle to demonstrate that it must or must not exist, and that the reasons for its existence or non-existence must be either in the nature of the thing in question or something external to it. Existence is part of the nature of substance, and it therefore has no internal causes to existence. Spinoza also states that the ability to exist is power and therefore God must exist because otherwise finite beings would have more power than infinite beings (Decartes and Spinoza, pp.167-169)
Anselm went by proving the existence of God by first defining God as ?that than which none greater can be conceived?. He proved it using Modus Tollens in this structure:
1. God is the greatest possible being.
2. If God did not exist, then being greater than God would be possible.
3. Suppose God does not exist.
4. Then a being greater than God is possible.
5. That is, it is possible for there to be a being greater than the greatest possible being.
6. But this is not possible.
7. The assumption made at step 3 must therefore be false.
8. It follows immediately that God exists.
Many people objected to this way of proving the existence of God, especially atheists, because they said that it can be used to prove the existence of all perfect things. Gaunilo offered a counter argument that proved this objection:
1. A Perfect island is by definition the greatest possible island.
2. An island that fails to exist in the actual world (while existing in other possible worlds) is less perfect that exists in all possible worlds.
3. So, a Perfect island exists necessarily.
Since nobody believes that there are such things as perfect islands then Anselm?s argument would not seem to work.
Pascal said that there is no real harm in the belief of a God whether he exists or not. This is true because if God does exist and you believe in him than you have eternal rewards and if he doesn?t exist than you have only wasted a portion of your life believing in it. However, if God does exist and you do not believe in God you will have eternal punishment and yet if he doesn?t exist you will have gained no reward and received no punishment. This is a good way to look at believing in the existence of God, in my opinion, because it shows that no real harm can come out of believing in a God.
?If the God does not exist it would of course be impossible to prove it; and if he does exist it would be a folly to attempt it(Intro to Philosophy: Kierkegaard, pp.342)?. I would like to open up this next section of this paper with that quote in order to show that I am not necessarily trying to prove that there is no God but just to show that the proofs dealing with the existence of God are nonsense. How can the above philosophers actually believe that they could prove the existence of God through reason when this topic is far beyond the reasoning of the human mind?
As Kiekegaard later stated, he would not go about trying to prove that a rock exists but rather prove that a thing that exists is a rock. This makes perfect sense for this argument because there is no real thing that they can prove is God. No one really knows who, or what, God really is and therefore you cannot point at it and tell all that it is God.
Immanuel Kant, when preaching against the ontological argument for the existence of God, stated that you should not logically try to prove the existence of God. That is impossible. Instead you should say that if such a God were to exist he would have these certain characteristics. He also gives an example of an apple. He says that when describing an apple you do not say that it is red, round, tasty, and it exists because you know that it does. Kant did in fact believe in the existence of God but he felt that it was not something that you can prove but rather something that you know. That is why he said that you cannot use it as one of the characteristics. You must say that if it does exist than it would have certain things that would be true about it.
Другие работы по теме:
A Parrot In The Pepper Tree By
Chris Stewart Essay, Research Paper A Parrot in the Pepper Tree by Chris StewartWell, gosh, hello again. It’s me, friendly Chris, the bloke who wrote that book about moving to Spain. It did so well, you know, that my publisher reckoned I should have another go. So what can I tell you this time, then? Not so long ago I went up to do some sheep shearing in northern Sweden and my car broke down.
Chris Lancid Essay Research Paper Chris Lansid
Chris Lancid Essay, Research Paper Chris Lansid was born in Chareston, South carolina. He had 2 brothers and 1 sister. He was born on March 3, in 1824 and lived until January 9,1902. When he was growing up he had 3 jobs at a time when he was only 12 years old. His family was brought up in poverty. All of his family members had to work to make a living.
Chris Herren Fall River Dreams Essay Research
Paper CHRIS HERREN:Fall River DreamsG. O. Chris Herren was born on September 27, 1975 in Fall River, Massachusetts to Al and Cynthia Herren. Chris was very young when he picked up his first basketball. He had played in a youth league called the Milliken league since he was seven and had always made all the all-star teams.
St Anselm
’S Ontological Argument For The Experience Of God. Essay, Research Paper God’s existence may vary from philosopher to philosopher, but according to the late St. Anselm,
Death Of A Friend Essay Research Paper
It was February 15th, the morning my brother s best friend, Chris, took his life. I awoketo hear Chris girlfriend, Danica, screaming hysterically into the answering machine thatChris had shot himself and his blood and pieces of his head were all over the room. As Iwalked into the dark kitchen half-asleep, I thought I had only dreamed such a horriblevision.
Usama Is Gay Essay Research Paper usama
Usama Is Gay Essay, Research Paper usama is extremely gay please take cautionDomenico- “Son a fait il est finalement fait”, ma machine de temps travaille, maintenant que doit je vais vois du pass?. Je sais Chris Farley.
Carrie Essay Research Paper I read the
Carrie Essay, Research Paper I read the book, Carrie. It was about this girl that didn t have very many friends. Her mom was a religious freak and thought that almost every thing was a Sin. Carrie has telekinetic powers. One of the girls that made fun of her started to feel sorry for her and got her boyfriend to go to the prom with Carrie.
Slaves Essay Research Paper In what way
Slaves Essay, Research Paper In what way do proletarians differ from slaves? The slave is sold once and for all; the proletarian must sell himself daily and hourly.
God Existence Essay Research Paper I do
God Existence Essay, Research Paper I do not believe God exists. I have many reasons why I think that there is no God. One of my many reasons is that there is no way that one man could have
Into The Wild By John Krakauer Essay
, Research Paper Obligation to Family The book Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer is a story about a man by the name of Chris McCandless. He is a man who grew up in a DC suburb, graduated college and decides to change the ways of his life. He journeys across the country, and finds his way to Alaska. His means are to leave the material lifestyle and become at one with nature.
Tina 2 Essay Research Paper tina was
Tina 2 Essay, Research Paper tina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there will be consequences and reprocutina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there wiltina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. littina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little tina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there will be consequences and reprocutions.chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there will be consequences and reprocutions.tle
The Affair Essay Research Paper The AffairIn
The Affair Essay, Research Paper The Affair In this paper I will try to explain to you why Deborah Bronski had an affair with Christopher de Monti when she knew it was wrong. Deborah and Christopher are both
All My Sons By Miller Essay Research
Paper In the play ?All My Sons?, by Arthur Miller, the word ?father? means the personification of goodness and infallibility to Chris Keller. There was a
Johann Sebastian Bach Essay Research Paper Chris
Johann Sebastian Bach Essay, Research Paper Chris Kouffman February 11, 1997 Period 7 Johann Sebastian Bach Johann Sebastian Bach was a musical composer of the late 17th and early 18th centuries. He was one of the greatest composers of all time. He was born in Eisenach, Thuringia, in 1685. He spent his life in music and was known for his ability in that subject.
Into The Wild Essay Research Paper Chris
Into The Wild Essay, Research Paper Chris McCandless, the main character of Into the Wild, is searching for his true self. His numerous tests of both his physical and mental abilities are proof of his determination. He felt affected in his families presence so went on a road trip. He was criticized by many for this, but who could stop him from discovering who he is.
All My Sons Larry
’s Importance Essay, Research Paper Never Seen But Still Important, How? We never meet the man yet he still plays an integral role in the plot. How can this be? This concept is exactly what happens in the play All My Sons as pertains to the role of Larry. Although Larry never actually appears in the play, he affects the plot and the characters, specifically Kate, in key ways.
Bangle Essay Research Paper In an article
Bangle Essay, Research Paper In an article from Harvard Business Review entitled How BMW Turns Art into Profit, Chris Bangle describes his goal to give the designers of this company direction and insight. This skillful man has developed a procedure to keep two completely different departments of the company happy and successful.
Beneath The Wheel Essay Research Paper As
Beneath The Wheel Essay, Research Paper As it did every school day of my junior year, 11:12 AM had come once more to mark the end of my academic morning, and the beginning of my lunch period. After paying my one dollar for a small cherry vita-pup slush drink and a strawberry fruit roll-up, I would take my place at the usual lunch table.
Church Existence Essay Research Paper The Church
Church Existence Essay, Research Paper The Church exists to call sinners out of the muck and mire of an evil world system that has pitted mother against daughter, father against son, woman against man, man against nature and all humanity against God into a transforming and healing community that can undo the damage that the world has done to us through the building of GOD Kingdom here on Earth.
Metaphysics Essay Research Paper METAPHYSICSTHEORY OF KNOWLEDGE
Metaphysics Essay, Research Paper METAPHYSICS THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE AND BEYOND The complex knowledge of metaphysics ? once comprehended ? is capable of helping an individual reach self-realization. Aristotle, a renowned man of thinking, conjured metaphysics to help understand the theories of intelligence – - it?s core of existence and where it comes from, truth, and cause.
Weekend Catastrophique Essay Research Paper L
Week-end Catastrophique Essay, Research Paper Lґйtй dernier je suis allй le Dordoigne, dans le sud de France, avec mes parents, ma sœur et mes amis : Chris et Ben. Nous sommes allйs en avion et en le bus. Je joue au football sur la plage avec mon pиre et Ben. Je tombй et jґai cassй mon poignet. Mon pиre а pris moi au lґhospital.
Speech And You Essay Research Paper Mrs
Speech And You Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Sirof Chris Medici English 3r Per 1 From the memior of Jenn Gooley As the sun rose up that summer day on the beach of Fire Island, Jen
Go Ask Alice Essay Research Paper I
Go Ask Alice Essay, Research Paper I read the book, Go Ask Alice. The author was anonymous. The main character was a girl, and her name was not mentioned. It was written as a diary. I thought that this book was very interesting because it was true; it is based on an actual diary of a fifteen-year-old drug user.
Can The Existence Of God Be Proved
A Priori? Essay, Research Paper The existence of God can be proved a priori by a logical deduction from the concept of God, when we think about the idea of God we realise that real
Facts Of Life
: “Existence Is Truth” Essay, Research Paper The Facts of Life “Existence is Truth” Everything we know of is the third dimension, and its properties. Everything is composed of atoms, and atoms are composed of smaller particles. All particles are threedimensional because they have the dimension of height, the dimension of width, and the dimension of depth.
Did The Deed Essay Research Paper Member
Did The Deed Essay, Research Paper Member Name:”Lien”, Weino, Chris?-nope Location:NY Sex:Male Hobbies:working on Cars, Riding my Motorcycle Computers:Gateway 400
Assessment Of Into The Wild Essay Research
Paper Although precisely on target in his assessment of Chris McCandless being “in touch with the bare-bones essence of nature”, Gordon Young’s preceding description of Chris should be rephrased: A profoundly Un-American figure, uncompromising in his approach and thoroughly optimistic about the future.
What Is The Public Interest Essay Research
Paper Chris MW 10-1150 a.m. What Is The Public Interest? Public interest to me means simply, what the general consensus or attitude is of a body of people with similar attributes and/or backgrounds. Thus, if a policy gets passed and the general feel is one of disapproval there is a push to reform toward a more favorable outcome
Argentina Essay Research Paper ArgentinaBy Chris OjedaArgentina
Argentina Essay, Research Paper Argentina By: Chris Ojeda Argentina is a South American country with a population of thirty one million people. Argentina?s capital is Buenos Aires, which is one of the largest cities in South America. Buenos Aires is situated on the coast of Argentina, which makes Buenos Aires a major trade route in Argentina and in South America.
Chris Moss Vs Dr Terry Preece Essay
, Research Paper Chris Moss vs. Dr. Terry Preece and the Edgewoord Unified School District May it please the court, counsel: My name is Zach Keeton and along
Into The Wild Essay Research Paper Into
Into The Wild Essay, Research Paper Into The Wild The name of this book is Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer. This book is based on a true story about a young man who goes on a journey. The author takes the real story of what happens to this boy and actual quotes written by real people to show why this boy would want to go on such a journey and what his purpose was.