Rulers According To Plato, Machiavelli And Aristotle Essay, Research Paper
Political philosophy is part of the most influential and enduring texts in all of history. The Aristotelian tradition, following from the philosophy of Plato and continuing in the writings of other modern political philosophers such as Machiavelli, has formed the setting against which all succeeding political and moral philosophy has founded its orientation. The respective rights and duties of the citizens and the ruler as described in Plato’s Apology, Machiavelli’s Prince, and Aristotle’s Politics can be compared and contrasted in various ways.
According to Socrates in Plato’s Apology, citizens have the right to philosophize in pursuit of truth and perfecting the soul. Socrates was charged with preaching this message to the youth of Athens (Jowett 4). Machiavelli, on the other hand, did not concentrate on the right of philosophizing but rather on the right of citizens becoming dependent on the prince. If citizens were dependent on the prince, then revolts were less likely to occur (Wooton 32). Aristotle’s reasoning of citizen rights dealt with participation in office. He believed that citizens had the right to participate in the affairs of the city only if their parents were both citizens as well (Reeve 65). Despite the fact that Socrates, Machiavelli and Aristotle have different beliefs about the rights of citizens, it can be inferred that they would all agree on the right of citizens to be ruled by a greater and wiser force.
Along with the rights of citizens are the duties. Socrates believed that an important duty of citizens was to improve the state through self-knowledge. In Socrates’ view, the health and prosperity of the state would follow if every one of the citizens were wise and virtuous, but no set of laws can ensure such health and prosperity if the citizens act unjustly. Besides the citizens’ duty of obtaining virtue, Socrates feels it is his personal duty in to the God of the oracle to continue questioning men who think they are wise in order to show them that they are not (Jowett 15). Machiavelli also believed that citizens had a responsibility to obtain virtu. In Italian, the word virtu means strength, ability, courage, and vitality. Machiavelli suggested that the maintenance of liberty in a republic depends on the virtu of the citizens (Wooton 18). Aristotle believed that citizens had a duty, along with the right, to hold office and make decisions. He further explains the duties of citizens in chapter four in his book Politics’ with the examination of the virtue of a good man in comparison with that of a good citizen. Aristotle stated that a citizen is somewhat like a sailor, one among a number of partners on a ship, each with different tasks and functions. Although each has a specific virtue according to his capacity and duty on the ship, there is also a general virtue similar to them all, which is the preservation of the ship. In a similar way, the virtue of the citizen is with a view to the regime (Reeve 70). Despite the different interpretations, all three philosophers can agree that if citizens fulfill their duty of having virtue or virtu, the city will thrive.
Citizens are not the only ones with rights. As indicated by Socrates, rulers have the right to question and clarify knowledge rather than to affirm it (Jowett 15). While Machiavelli takes a different approach and implies in chapter seventeen of his book, The Prince that a ruler has the right to be feared than to be loved. He believes that when forced to choose between being feared and being loved, rulers have the right to choose being feared because it is a safer way out, since he thinks men cannot be trusted (Wooton 52). Aristotle believed that the rights of ruler depended on the type of regime. For example, a mastery type of political rule had the right to rule with a view to the advantage of the master. Although Aristotle did not believe this should be the case, he did provide that right to mastery political rule (Reeve 72). Aristotle believed that successful political rule had the right to rule with a view to the advantage of the city as a whole. While Aristotle wanted to avoid rule by a single man because it was apolitical, he does not deny that if such an outstanding person or group of people existed, it would be irrational not to allow them to rule. Rulers can have different rights according to Socrates, Machiavelli and Aristotle, but one thing found in common among all three philosophers is that they all propose the rights of the rulers with respect to the citizens of the city, which can be further explained through the duties of citizens.
Socrates believed that the supreme moral duty of philosophical life was to question people regarding their own supposed knowledge and to show them that their wisdom extends only as far as their acceptance of their ignorance. In this respect, Socrates believes he is helping people gain wisdom and overcome ignorance (Jowett 14). Machiavelli believed that the ruler had various duties. One obligation included that a ruler who intended to by successful must be prepared to do bad things on occasion, when political realities demand such actions. Machiavelli also believed that it was the duty of a ruler to have characteristics of both the lion and the fox. He thought that the bravery and strength of the lion would not be enough to enable the ruler to escape the traps set by his enemies and therefore the slyness of the fox would also be needed. Machiavelli offered Septimius Severus, who served as Roman emperor from 193-211A.D. as an example of a new prince who effectively used the techniques of both the lion and the fox to maintain himself in power (Wooton 55). In addition, Machiavelli believed that it was a ruler’s duty to achieve the art of war. He held that the cultivation of this art was the chief means of gaining and keeping power, and that the neglect of this art was the chief means of losing power (Wooton 43). Aristotle was not as complicated in that he believed the duty of a ruler was to rule for the sake of the common good. He believed that rulers with this obligation were from the correct regimes and the regimes that look to the advantage of the rulers are unjust (Reeve 73). The duties of rulers are diverse according to the three philosophers, but it can be assumed confidently that they all agree on the duty of rulers having knowledge in order to govern.
While Socrates, Machiavelli and Aristotle all propose different views on the rights and duties of citizens and rulers, their ideas can be taken out of context to find that they do indeed share some similar ground. Personally, I think that Aristotle had the strongest ideas about the rights and duties of citizens, while Machiavelli had the most powerful ideas about the rights and duties of a ruler. Overall, all three philosophers have contributed to the foundation for all succeeding political and moral philosophy because whether based on similar or different views, they have set the ground rules for the rights and duties of citizens and rulers.
Plato’ Apology
Machiavelli’s The Prince
Aristotle’s Politics
Другие работы по теме:
American Citizens Essay Research Paper George Washington
American Citizens Essay, Research Paper George Washington bravely fought so that our country, The United Stastes of America, could be called a free and independent nation. As American citizens it is our duty and responsibility to use that freedom to better undertsatnd ourselves, our community and our country.
A Republic Is A Better Form Of
Government Than A Democracy Essay, Research Paper “A Republic is a Better Form of Government than a Democracy” I agree that a republic is a better form of government than a democracy. In order to come to this decision I had to research the definitions of each. A republic, according to Webster’s Dictionary, is a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law.
Election Ballot Problem Essay Research Paper The
Election Ballot Problem Essay, Research Paper The election of 2000 has showed America and it?s citizens a major problem in the election process. There are multiple levels of problems inside this election process. The major problem is with the way that the ballots are cast. Through out America old and tired methods are in use to record and tally the votes of Americans.
Baseball
’s New Rules Essay, Research Paper Baseball’s New Rules I started to watch baseball again since the World Series is starting but I have noticed that there are a couple of new rules in
Amendment Seven Essay Research Paper The 7th
Amendment Seven Essay, Research Paper The 7th Amendment is very unusual. It speaks to trials at Common Law (civil trials), rather than criminal trials. It states that in trials where the value of the potential award is greater than twenty dollars, the accused has the right to demand that they be tried by a jury; and that no facts tried by a jury shall be reconsidered in any court in the United States other than by the rules of common law.
Legal And Illegal Essay Research Paper Ok
Legal And Illegal Essay, Research Paper Ok, there are 3 types of people that live in the country, Residents (both legal and illegal), citizens of the U.S., and Citizens of the
14th Amendment Essay Essay Research Paper More
14th Amendment Essay Essay, Research Paper More often than not, most Americans look upon the constitution as the guiding light of our country. Recent events occurring in our national election no doubt prove that. There are many important amendments to our Constitution regarding our rights as citizens and the delegation of powers to branches and states.
The Obligation To Die For The State
Essay, Research Paper Travis Randall Travis Randall PS 208 1/31/00 541-21-0093 “The Obligation to Die for the State” In his essay Michael Walzer discusses the political obligation citizens have to their state. In order to have a running community and society you have to work together and make difficult decisions.
Outline Of The Constitution Of The USA
Essay, Research Paper I. ARTICLE I– CONGRESS A. Section 1. 1. Establishment B. Section 2. 1. House Membership and Qualifications a. selection and composition
Boxing Rules Essay Research Paper Marquis of
Boxing Rules Essay, Research Paper Marquis of Queensberry Rules Governing Contests for Endurance That s right, there s a new set of standard rules out for the fighters. They were created by, John Sholto Douglas and John Graham Chambers, two of the worlds best boxers ever seen to hit the ring.
Gangs And Police Essay Research Paper Term
Gangs And Police Essay, Research Paper Term Paper Ensuring peace among citizens should be the top priority of any government. In the United States, especially in New York City, race relations have been a subject that has constantly been brought up, usually in a negative subject matter. What kinds of disputes, exactly, are causing these tense situations? The fact that the minorities feel that they can not trust the police officers, combined with the fact that many of the officers fear for their lives when on duty in a minority neighborhood both contribute to the constant feuding between New Your City’s citizens.
Nurse Essay Research Paper The occupation of
Nurse Essay, Research Paper The occupation of a Registered Nurse seems to take an enormous amount of responsibility. The duties of a Registered Nurse are many. The R.N. “helps individuals and groups take steps to improve or maintain their health.” Other duties of a Nurse is to administer medications, assist in convalescence and rehabilitation, and “instruct patients and their families in proper care.” Nurses also “assist physicians during treatments and examinations.” Most important of all the nurse “helps people stay well and care for sick and injured people”(O.O.H. 159).
Anthem Essay Research Paper Ayn Rand
Anthem Essay, Research Paper Ayn Rand’s Anthem shows us her view of our world united under what seems to be communist rule. For example their view of right and wrong; which Anthem portrays is a system of very strict rules which mainly make sure that everyone is involved in a collective role within the society in this system no one is considered an individual or that they can even think as an individual.
How To Be A Good Citizen Essay
, Research Paper Mike Schmidt ICE-Social Science Community Tuesday September 26,2000 revised 2nd draft How to be a Good Citizen Every citizen in our society has the right to freedom and to be happy. In order to preserve that right to be happy, you must be a virtuous citizen and fulfill and promote civic rights.
Totalitarian System Of Government Essay Research Paper
A totalitarian system of government is a one party dictatorship where the government has complete and total control over the lives of its citizens and the society. This system of government influences the citizens of a nation because citizens lose all control over their lives with government controlling every aspect of business, family life, labor, housing, education, the arts, religion, and youth groups.
Senior Citizens Safe Drivers Or Roadway Hazards
Essay, Research Paper Senior Citizens: Safe Drivers or Roadway Hazards Driving is a simple task that many of us perform on a day to day basis. Most people are safe drivers, while a few are incapable of driving safely. Safe and capable is how most senior citizens can be viewed, however, there are some exceptions.
Responsibilities Of An American Citizen Essay Research
Paper An American citizen has many responsibilities to keep America and his/her community going. Some of these responsibilities might be -1. Duty : Every citizen has a duty to vote!Reason : As citizens you have the duty to beinformed about the issues and hold an opinionon them that is for the benefit of the wholesociety.
Lord Of Flies By William Golding Essay
, Research Paper Imagine that you are in charge of setting up a civilization. What would be the first thing that you did? Many people might choose to set up a system of rules and regulations to better control the way the civilization acted and regulated it. After all, a civilization cannot grow and prosper without rules.
Problems Caused By Mercantilism For The American
Colonists Essay, Research Paper Problems caused by mercantilism for the american colonists Essay submitted by deanna dunker According to the theory of mercantilism, the colonies only existed to serve the
British And Control Of New World Essay
, Research Paper Control The British new there was riches to be had in the new world. They weren?t happy with everyone getting a piece of the action. They wanted it all for themselves. In order to ensure that no one else was getting rich they put many rules and regulations on how things were to be done in the colonies.
Does Voting Make Sense Essay Research Paper
To be an American means that certain rights are guaranteed by the government, but these rights comes with certain duties. The first duty as an American citizen is not to serve in the armed forces; it is not to pay taxes. The first duty as an American is to get out there and rock the vote. Although the ability to vote is what separates America from other countries, many people choose not to fulfill their duties and give up their right to vote.
Freedom Of Speech And Internet Essay Research
Paper The United States of America was founded over two hundred years ago on the basis of freedom. Freedoms, which were wrote into, and are yet a part of the Constitution of the United States. Under the First Amendment of the Constitution, many freedoms are granted to the citizens of this great nation. Such freedoms as those of speech, religion, press, petition, and assembly are granted to all free citizens.
Puerto Rico Essay Research Paper PUERTO RICOPuerto
Puerto Rico Essay, Research Paper PUERTO RICO Puerto Rico, many good things come from there. Beautiful beaches, beautiful women, and a beautiful culture. However, one thing that does not come from Puerto Rico is money, tax dollars to be exact. Why is it that the United States sends millions of dollars in financial aid to Puerto Rico and nothing comes back? The Puerto Ricans are a commonwealth, not a state, that’s why.
Defining Democracy Essay Research Paper DEFINING DEMOCRACYDemocracy
Defining Democracy Essay, Research Paper DEFINING DEMOCRACY Democracy is defined as rule by the people. It is the form of government that our country chooses to use. There are five main parts to our democratic form of government: individual rights, freedom, equality, majority rules, and limited government.
Duties While In A Lab Essay Research
Paper Duties While in the Lab (1) Read chemical labels. (2) Walk with care in the lab. (3) Food beverages, chewing gum, cosmetics, and smoking are NEVER allowed in the lab.
Amish Essay Research Paper The Amish have
Amish Essay, Research Paper The Amish have maintained their identity for centuries. Do you think they will be able to continue to do this? Give reasons for your answer.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper The protection from
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper The protection from force, that is, the protection of individual rights, would be achieved through the use of a police force to protect the rights of citizens at home; a military, to protect the rights of citizens from foreign aggression; and a court system to enforce contracts and settle disputes between citizens.
Government 2 Essay Research Paper In order
Government 2 Essay, Research Paper In order to have a good government, the people are the most important part. It is ultimately the people who have to live with what they choose. The government has to protect the people’s natural rights and beliefs. It has to do whatever is necessary to look out for the peoples best interests.
What Justoce Means To Me Essay Research
Paper To me, justice means defining what is right and what is wrong. In our everyday life, rules and laws govern our world. The purpose of these laws, are to enforce mandatory rules for acceptable behaviour where justice prevails and conflicts are avoided.
Antigone Essay On Creon Essay Research Paper
Creon was a powerful leader of the city-state of Thebes who was viewed as a tyrant. Whether his qualities were good or bad, the people listened and obeyed him. The qualities of leadership he possessed were very strong and evident. The potential to be a good leader was within his ability, but his hubris stood in his way.
Civics Essay Research Paper Civics is the
Civics Essay, Research Paper Civics is the study of citizenship and government. The word comes from the Latin word CIVIS, meaning “citizen.” In ancient Rome, where the word was first used, only wealthy landowners were allowed to be citizens. As such, they enjoyed special privileges that the common people did not share.
My Duties about the house
My name is ...... I am 17 years old. I have already finished my school. My duties about the house are to clean the rooms, to wash the dishes after meals, to do shopping.