Essay, Research Paper
Travis Randall
Travis Randall
PS 208
1/31/00
541-21-0093
“The Obligation to Die for the State”
In his essay Michael Walzer discusses the political obligation citizens have to their state. In order to have a running community and society you have to work together and make difficult decisions. These decisions can alter you and the people around drastically in both positive and negative ways but are necessary to have a working “State.” It’s not only hard decisions but obligations you have to your state as a loyal citizen. Those obligations are there for a reason and must be followed even if they include death. As a loyal citizen you have obligations and duties. Everyone needs to make the necessary sacrifices and have the dedication to their State. “Society must be an agreement to die if necessary in order to live together in safety as long as possible?” (Walzer, 86).
As citizens we have a moral obligation to die rather than kill an innocent man. Walzer describes a court case in which Person A holds a gun up to Person B and orders him to kill Person C or he will be killed; B then proceeds to kill Person C. In the court of law Person B is responsible for the murder of Person C. No matter how fear and power influenced him, he is still guilty. With moral obligation, Person B should have died himself rather than kill an innocent person who has done no harm. The state wants citizens to feel that they will receive personal glory for dying for your state and receive the title of “Hero”. I do not think that personal glory is really worth dying for, rather the impact and betterment of your state due too a sacrifice of such a precious thing as life. ‘ A good intention is necessary, and we should love our county not so much on our own account, as out of regard to the community’ (Walzer, 79). If you have the proper motives the personal glory will be minimal compared to the effects you will have on filling your obligations to the State.
In Walzers view everyday citizens should be ready to die if the common wealth of the state is under attack. If they are not ready or willing to die for the common wealth of society then the society will not survive. It is completely necessary for people to put their lives on the line in order to have a strong and powerful state.
Walzer also believes that people have the social obligation to society to die for serious crimes such as murder through punishment. Capital punishment for instance is used on such cases and would most definitely have been used in cases such as the Wacco, Texas incident at which David Coresh killed 85 people including 23 children (a lot of whom where his). Had he not died attempting to justify his cause capitol punishment would most definitely have been used. Most of society would have deemed him such a deviant that he would need to die in an attempt to justify his actions. In fact, there is a movie addressing this sole type of punishment called Dead Man Walking in which the main character is sentenced to death by injection for the murder and rape of a young couple.
All in all Walzer, I think is correct in his ideas about having an obligation to die for one’s state. And although there are many different ways for that to happen-Military, Capitol Punishment etc.- the obligation remains for the most part the same. Such ideas date back as far as the Bible and will not change for a very long time, if at all. Courageous people die for their state; murderers die for their state and society as a whole yet the end result is the same.
PS 208
1/31/00
541-21-0093
Другие работы по теме:
Devotion And Commitment Essay Research Paper Devotion
Devotion And Commitment Essay, Research Paper Devotion and Commitment When a lover gives oneself to another, is it devotion or commitment? It is difficult to say because it would depend on what type of relationship the two have with each other. Ideal love should be based on devotion because it is in a sense that devotion is unconditional and flexible.
Sanctity Of Life Essay Research Paper BIRT
Sanctity Of Life Essay, Research Paper BIRT: The Individual ought to Value the Sanctity of Life above the Quality of Life ?Each person possesses an inviolability founded on justice that even the welfare of society as a whole cannot override.? It is because I so strongly concur with this quote by Joseph Thurof, that I compelled to affirm today?s resolution; be it resolved that the individual ought to value the sanctity of life above the quality of life.
Happy Days Essay Research Paper A farewell
Happy Days Essay, Research Paper A farewell to Arms I.Mans duty or obligation to avoid death at all costs ? acceptable action a.Critics say that rain in A Farewell to Arms represented death an sh dying and then being eaten in The Old Man and The Sea represents death. They go on to say that in both the representatives of death, the characters maintained dignity and honor
Same Thing Different Price Essay Research Paper
Same Thing, Different Price What can I say about college life? It is one of those times where you will spend the most money you will ever spend in your life. It becomes even more expensive when you have to pay out of state fees. Out of state students should not have to pay for these fees. Simply because the students are paying for the same classes that the in state students are paying for.
Thomas Hobbes Paper Essay Research Paper Thomas
Thomas Hobbes Paper Essay, Research Paper Thomas Hobbes Paper – What is the difference betweenobligations in foro interno and in foro externo, and when do wehave such obligations? According to Thomas Hobbes, there are certain laws of nature whichexist in the absence of an organized government. These laws are extremelycut throat, and place people in extremely dangerous situations where theirlives are in danger.
Hobbes And Locke On Natural Rights Essay
, Research Paper According to the natural right theory, the state of nature is the original condition of human beings in regard to any common authority. In the state of nature, according to Thomas Hobbes, each individual has a right to everything, even the body/life of the other. The state of nature can lead to the state of moral chaos.
Theories Of Poverty Essay Research Paper Does
Theories Of Poverty Essay, Research Paper Does the government have an obligation to help the poor? What are the causes for poverty? These are questions that have been asked repeatedly over time. Some people believe that the government has no obligation to help the poor, and that the poor are in that situation because of their own choices.
Ancient Greece Essay Research Paper Sparta one
Ancient Greece Essay, Research Paper Sparta, one of the powerful city-states, retains this name for good reason. They took over Messenia and used the land wisely, by making a government using the Code of Lycurgus. The Spartan women were given a lot more freedom compared to other Greek city-states; thus, every person provided a part in the development of their city.
Us Democracy Essay Research Paper Ant V
Us Democracy Essay, Research Paper Ant? V. Williams Political Science 1101 February 1, 2001 It’s Not Right, Get Rid of It In theory, the United States became a democracy when we signed the Declaration of Independence in 1776. This theory is not true. The textbook defines a democracy as a system of government in which ultimate political authority is vested in the people, of course you know that this is just not so.
Into The Wild By John Krakauer Essay
, Research Paper Obligation to Family The book Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer is a story about a man by the name of Chris McCandless. He is a man who grew up in a DC suburb, graduated college and decides to change the ways of his life. He journeys across the country, and finds his way to Alaska. His means are to leave the material lifestyle and become at one with nature.
The State Essay Research Paper The state
The State Essay, Research Paper The state is like God, some believe that it?s the all mighty powerful being that controls all and others just think it?s a big overblown idea. The idea of the state (and God) is fairly confusing but rarely ever challenged, except by those rare few who seem to form their own opinions.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Analysis of Crito
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Analysis of Crito The question is raised within the dialogue between Socrates and Crito concerning civil disobedience. Crito has the desire, the means, and many compelling
Employee Loyalty Essay Research Paper Professor MarensBM
Employee Loyalty Essay, Research Paper Professor Marens BM 327 November 5, 2001 Loyalty seems like a quality that is becoming increasingly harder to find. People today are feeling less and less of an obligation to their employer. Years ago, employees believed that when they were hired that they would be with that same company until they retired.
State Vs Nation Essay Research Paper STATE
State Vs. Nation Essay, Research Paper STATE VS. NATION State, as we know today is a political term, which could be define as an institution that organises and makes countries or nations being governed. We could add to this definition that state as institution is a need of society at a certain stage of development to control and to enforce society into a common will.
The Japanese Family System Essay Research Paper
During the pre-war period, it was an obligation to look after ones parent when they became elderly and could no longer perform the daily tasks of living. However,today’s generation lives in a post-war period, which encourages democracy, rather than the former imperialistic government. This new government encourages the new generation to make choices of their own, which in the past
Good Citizen Hobbes Vs Rouseau Essay
, Research Paper For one to be a good citizen, there are certain expectations a person must follow to achieve this goal. While many people have their own ideas of what makes a good citizen, there is little consensus to exactly what this would be. Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in their books The Leviathan and The Social Contract, create a system of political governing where the citizen plays a certain role and has certain expectations to carry out this role for the governmental system to work properly.
Fergie Jenkins Essay Research Paper FERGIE JENKINS
Fergie Jenkins Essay, Research Paper FERGIE JENKINS: WHAT IS JUSTICE? “Justice: Fairness. A state of affairs in which conduct or action is both fair and right, given the circumstances. In law, it more specifically refers to the paramount obligation to ensure that all persons are treated fairly.”
Is Nationalism An Infantile Disease Essay Research
Paper Nationalism is a political concept that provides a bridge between people and their sense of obligation and duty for their country. I disagree with Mr. Albert Einstein s notion that nationalism is an infantile disease. I believe that nationalism is an extremely powerful and unifying tool for nations and states, because without it many of the colonized nations in Africa and Asia would still be colonized, and there would be fewer democracies in existence.
Aquinas
’ First Proof Of The Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper I have chosen to write St. Thomas Aquinas proof citing motion as proof of the existence of God. Although I must admit to being a little confused the wording, I see it as being in terms of ability too, act of, and the first to act.
History Essay Research Paper 4 discuss the
History Essay, Research Paper 4. discuss the values which helped the Romans build an empire from a city-state.From a city-state to Roman Empire, the values such as individualism and Greek idea helped the Romans build an empire from a city-state. During a city-state period, the Romans were very concerned about maintaining the customs or traditions of their ancestors.
Developing The Under Developed Essay Research Paper
Developing the Under Developed The desolate and scorched soil of a vast empire that once ruled lay wasted in the dim morning sun. This is symbolic of a newly developed nation that grew at a pace that the environment could not stand. Human life in future generations depends on the judgement of the civilizations prior to the existing generation.
Communist Manifesto Essay Research Paper The Communist
Communist Manifesto Essay, Research Paper The Communist Manifesto, written by Karl Marx and Fredrich Engles describes a theory of an economic system of a utopian society. Marx’s view was that the system could work through the abolition of the bourgeois class. The book states many criteria for the system to work, including an equal obligation of all to work, setting up a national bank, abolishing inheritance rights, free education for all children, child labor laws. .
Social Change Essay Research Paper In the
Social Change Essay, Research Paper In the article, “The Rhetorician as an Agent of Social Change”, written by Ellen Cushman, I believe that the way I feel about ACCESS is shown. “A gift that is not returned can become a debt, a lasting obligation. Depending on the terms of the exchange, this obligation can either be in the form of a monetary debt, which imposes “overtly economic obligations by the usurer”, or in the form of ethical debt, which produces “moral obligations and emotional attachment created and maintained by the generous gift.” (380)
Eastern Europe
– From 1970 To 1990 Essay, Research Paper From 1970 to 1990, Eastern European nations realized they needed a change in their governments as well as economies. Politically, reformers and dissidents wanted to end party-state dictatorships and move towards a pluralist democracy. Economically, centrally planned economies were unsuccessful due to increased bureaucracy, excessive centralization, and debt obligation.
The Good Earth Character Analysis Olan Essay
, Research Paper A Eulogy to O-lan What is loyalty? Loyalty by definition means being constant and faithful in any relation or obligation implying trust of confidence. The type of people who
Individuality Essay Research Paper IndividualityKarl Marx and
Individuality Essay, Research Paper Individuality Karl Marx and John Locke both analyzed individuality using different concepts. Marx s ideas concerned species being, alienation, and private property. Whereas, Locke s ideas dealt with human nature, state of war, and property. Both Marx and Locke only looked at men as individual.
Laws
– Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau Essay, Research Paper Laws. We all must obey them, but why? For fear of going to jail, or being fined? Those are the individual effects of civil disobedience, but what happens what is the purpose of law in society? Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau all attempted to interpret the need for laws in society, in order to maintain the good of the whole and the individual.
Should Rich People Help The Poor Essay
, Research Paper As we enter the millennium, the gap between rich and poor has never been wider. While some people have more money than it is possible to spend in a lifetime, no matter how lavishly they might make purchases; others are not able to provide even for their most basic needs. On all the continents of the world, people starve to death for lack of food; freeze death for lack of shelter, die of diseases that could be prevented.
Machiavellis View Of Human Nature Essay Research
Paper Title: Machiavellis View of Human NatureContent: It is an essay on Machiavellis view of human nature based on the book The PrinceDescription: To write about Machiavelli the man based on the book The PrinceIn The Prince Niccolo Machiavelli presents a view of governing a state that is drastically different from that of humanists of his time.
Our Trip To Miami Essay Research Paper
Our trip to Miami, Florida We are traveling to Miami, Florida. We are leaving from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. We will be traveling through 7 states. The capital of Pennsylvania is Harrisburg. Independence Hall is in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The states we are flying over are Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, And Florida.
Charles River Bridge Essay Research Paper The
Charles River Bridge Essay, Research Paper The Proprietors of the Charles River Bridge Company erected the Charles River Bridge in 1785. It was used to link Charleston to Boston. A toll charge was placed on the bridge for forty years under the corporation charter issued by the state of Massachusetts. The bridge opened on June 17, 1786.
Utopian World Essay Research Paper Philosophers have
Utopian World Essay, Research Paper Philosophers have forever been concerned with political and social matters. Not only have they asked how politics work but mainly, how they should work. These philosophers have been concerned with the nature and justification of political obligation and authority and the goals of political action.
Rawls Essay Research Paper Can the Unjust
Rawls Essay, Research Paper Can the Unjust be Rectified Can the Unjust Be Rectified? Robert Nozick, in his essay Rights and the Entitlement Theory, discusses the rights of individuals and just acquisition. He makes it clear that these rights and/or acquisitions cannot be taken away by anyone, either by an individual or by a collective identity such as the state.