Logic Of Emptiness Essay, Research Paper
The forefather of Madhyamika Buddhism was Nagarjuna. T.P. Kasulis writes in his book, Zen Action, Zen Person that Nagarjuna was a predecessor to the development of Zen Buddhism. Nagarjuna is regarded though as a patriarch of the Zen tradition. He was the affecting principle to demonstrate logically the “emptiness”, or rather sunyata of philosophical distinctions. Kasulis also explores Nagarjuna’s “Logic of Emptiness.”
The Buddhist claimed that “to be concerned with speculative questions is like being concerned with the origin of a poisoned arrow while it is still in one’s flesh, contaminating the bloodstream.” Kasulis writes that a conflicting group supposed that nothing at all continued from the cause into the effect, that the two where completely distinct. The Abhidharma Buddhist scrutinized the principles behind the Buddhist teachings. Zen Action, Zen Person states that these became almost as important as practicing the teachings; that is the scrutnization of the principles. With all this wrangling over the principles and the debate on them, Nagarjuna came up with his “Logic of the Middle.” The origin of this came from the doctrine of sunyata or rather emptiness, which Kasulis states is the “Logic of Emptiness.”
Nagarjuna showed what was wrong the Abhidharma argument. He stated that the multiple philosophical divisions of Buddhism were created on “distinctions that must be seen as tentative rather than absolute.” Kasulis writes that Nagarjuna came up with a resolution to this argument. This solution was pure and simple. Nagarjuna wrote down all the key distinctions that the diverse philosophical “groups” assumed. He then took these distinctions and went through them one by one and showed that they had to be considered absolute. He went on to state that these distinctions lead the way to “ineluctable absurdities.” Ineluctable means, “being incapable of being evaded” or
something that is inescapable (Webster’s 1996). So what Nagarjuna was saying was that these distinctions that the Abhidharma Buddhist believed in eventually lead to absurdities that cannot be escaped from.
Kasulis focuses on two of Nagarjuna’s points or rather critiques against the Abhidharma; time and causality. Nagarjuna’s critique on time can be seen as a good introduction to his “methodology.” Nagarjuna argues four points against time.
The first critique is that “if the existence of the present and future depends upon the past, then present and future should be in the past” (Kasulis). An example from my life to help illustrate this point would be driving. The past is when I was 16 years old and I got my driver’s license. The present is me currently driving and the future is that I will have a wreck. If the present (driving) and the future (my wreck) depends on the past (my obtaining my drivers license), then my being able to drive (present), and my having a wreck (future) should be in the past.
Nagarjuna’s second critique against time is that if present and future was not in the past, how could present and future is dependent upon the past? It can be illustrated this way. If my driving (present) and my having a wreck (future) are not in the past then how could my driving (present) and my having a wreck (future) are dependent upon my obtaining my license?
Nagarjuna goes on to say that if we don’t depend on the past, then the present and future will not occur. If this is the case then present and future times also do not occur. We can also say that if I am not dependent on getting my driver’s license then my driving and my having a wreck will not occur.
Nagarjuna’s last critique against time was that “the remaining two periods of time as well as above, below, and middle, should be characterized.” What Nagarjuna was saying was that the relationship between past, present and future is contradictory. The relationship between my obtaining my driver’s license, me out driving on the road and my having a wreck is contradictory.
Basically what Nagarjuna was saying was that the relationship between past, present and future all depend upon each other. Let’s look at it this way; the past depends on the present, the present depends on the past, the present depends on the future and the future depends on the past. In other words, my getting my driver’s license depends on my driving. My driving depends on my getting my driver’s license. My driving depends on my having a wreck and my wreck depends on my obtaining my driver’s license. One thing cannot happen without the other one occurring also. Kasulis then goes on to focus upon Nagarjuna’s critique of causality.
Nagarjuna challenged causality by making evident that the relationship between cause and effect was not either absolute or unparadoxical. There are four replications to cause and effect. “Cause and effect is completely identical, cause and effect are not at all identical, cause and effect are both identical and not identical at the same time, and the last response is that cause and effect is neither identical nor not identical” (Kasulis).
Let’s use the example of driving again to better illustrate this point or critique. The cause of my having a wreck could be because I was speeding. The effect of my speeding is having a wreck. Nagarjuna says that these responses lead to absurdity. Or in layman’s terms, they are absolutely ridiculous.
Nagarjuna argues on point one that if the cause and effect are exactly the same “then nothing different was caused or brought into existence.” So if my having a wreck (effect) and the speeding (cause) are indeed exactly the same, then nothing happened. Nagarjuna says that for the causality to occur that a change has to happen. For me to speed and then for me to have a wreck, a change has to happen.
Nagarjuna goes on to argue on the second point that since cause and effect is not identical at all, then there cannot be any continuity. So if the wreck and the speeding are at all identical then they cannot continue.
The third argument of Nagarjuna’s regarding cause and effect is that if cause and effect is identical and not identical then that is a precise contradiction to either of the earlier arguments made by Indian logic. If my speeding and my wreck are completely identical then this goes completely against all the other arguments, such as when they say they are not at all identical (point 2).
The last argument of Nagarjuna’s regarding cause and effect is that if cause and effect are neither identical nor not identical then this makes it a misuse of language. It seems to me that Nagarjuna is saying that this is almost a miss-print or a typo. If my wreck and my speeding are not identical nor are they identical then this makes the argument wrong. If this mistake were indeed true then it would make all the other arguments that Indians make about cause and effect null and void.
It seems to me after reading these points on causality that I definitely have to agree with Nagarjuna on points three and four. It is almost as if Indian logic says something about causality and then in the very next sentence they state something about causality that is a direct contradiction to what they previously said.
Kasulis writes “emptiness, which is the logical interdependence of opposing terms, lies at the basis of all philosophical distinction.” Nagarjuna believed that we could work inside the world of duality while we identify its relativity. Kasulis says that we should “consider Nagarjuna’s emphasis on the nondifferentiating, nonobjectifying insight or wisdom.”
Costello, Robert B. ed. Random House. Webster’s College Dictionary. Random
House, Inc. 1996.
Kasulis, T.P. Zen Action. Zen Person. The University Press of Hawaii: 1981.
Другие работы по теме:
BDSM Essay Research Paper BDSMBDSM stands for
BDSM Essay, Research Paper BDSM BDSM stands for Bondage Discipline Sadism and Masochism. Most regard this as a perverted form of sexuality limited only to gays who they also regard
Afermative Action Essay Research Paper In times
Afermative Action Essay, Research Paper In times of today most topics of conversation generally have something to do with politics and hot political issues. Everything from abortion to gun control to affirmative action and that?s exactly what I am going to talk about, affirmative action. What exactly is affirmative action? According to Dr.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper When it
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper When it comes to affirmative action I have mixed emotions and opinions. Although I hate what affirmative action does and what it represents I strongly support its continuance.
Global Warming Essay Research Paper Ocean SolutionsSolutions
Global Warming Essay, Research Paper Ocean Solutions Solutions to Save the Ocean Many years ago nobody would have thoought that the ocean would ever need saving. The covers over 90% of the earth’s surface. People would wonder how something so collosal ever be effected by their actions. Unfortunately, the oceans do suffer from mankind’s carelss, selfish acts.
Dharma Essay Research Paper Dharma is the
Dharma Essay, Research Paper Dharma is the moral law that Hindus follow throughout life. Through the teachings of Gita, one can find the right way of living and the correct attitude
The Character Of Hamlet Essay Research Paper
Hamlet identifies with an adolescent of the 1990?s more than he does with the youth of his own time. Hamlet is immature, sarcastic, and takes action during the heat of passion which is very much like the behavior of the youth in the 1990?s.Love, control over action, and the ability to overcome depression are just a few ways to prove maturity.
Affirmative Action And Its Downfalls Essay Research
Paper Affirmative action today, is considered to be one of the most controversial dilemmas facing our equal status of individual rights. As we all know, affirmative action was implemented with the idea and hope that America would finally become truly equal. So far, it has lasted for thirty years and has failed to solve any of our current problems concerning equal rights.
American Scholar By Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay
, Research Paper The American Scholar by Ralph Waldo Emerson In the essay the American Scholar, Emerson portrays the scholar as a person who learns from three main things. These things by which a scholar is educated are by nature, by books (the past) and by action.
Oroonoko
– The Narrative Shifts Essay, Research Paper A black African is captured and sold into slavery. It?s an unfortunate story, but one with approximately eleven million equivalents. Aphra Behn, however, brings this common piece of history to life in her story Oroonoko, the tale of an African prince tricked into slavery in the West Indies.
ComparisonRomeo Juilet Movie And Play Essay
, Research Paper The modern movie version of Romeo + Juliet is a lot better than the original Shakespeare?s play version. In the modern movie Romeo & Juliet, basically everything is easier to understand. The setting is simple and set everywhere. The characters actually go places and not just act every scene out.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper Effects of
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper Effects of Affirmative Action on Society and the Quality of Life of the People Now that we have been given a brief overview of the history of affirmative action, I will discuss the positive and negative aspects of the policy, which effect society and the quality of life of the people.
Affirmative Action 14 Essay Research Paper Affirmative
Affirmative Action 14 Essay, Research Paper Affirmative Action is not the same as Equal Opportunity. Affirmative Action is idea that minorities and women will have more of a chance to achieve positions in business and industry. I call this an idea because in the long run Affirmative Action in my eyes will only hurt people than improve their lives.
The Forms And Limits Of Adjudication Essay
, Research Paper Adjudication is the process of judgement within the government as well as within relations in common society. Any person who stands to judge an action of another person is participating in adjudication. Creating social order if the defining principles of adjudication, The The relation of men to regulate one another.
Kant Essay Research Paper KANTKant begins to
Kant Essay, Research Paper KANT Kant begins to claim that there is nothing in the world that can be regarded as good without qualification except good will. He says that qualities of temperment such as
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper In years
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper In years past, Americas of every race, color, and nationality have been pushing for equal rights and equal representation in everything from politics, to professional sports coaches, to jobs, and colleges. In American colleges there is a little thing called affirmative action.
DWorld Essay Research Paper Praise and Blame
D-World Essay, Research Paper Praise and Blame in World D In World D, a world in which people recognize that they do not have free will, it is still possible to maintain a system of praise and
Affirmative Action Reverse Discrimination Essay Research Paper
Affirmative Action = Reverse Discrimination We are all aware that discrimination took place over 50 years ago. What some might not be aware of is that because of the actions of our ancestors, we, white males, are held responsible and are penalized because of these actions. Affirmative action is a way to help minorities in sex and race to get accepted into colleges or get hired for jobs while the white males suffer from what took place over 50 years ago.
Aquinas
’ First Proof Of The Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper I have chosen to write St. Thomas Aquinas proof citing motion as proof of the existence of God. Although I must admit to being a little confused the wording, I see it as being in terms of ability too, act of, and the first to act.
Aristotles Virtue Theory Essay Research Paper Aristotles
Aristotles Virtue Theory Essay, Research Paper Aristotle?s Notion of Virtue According to Aristotle, virtue primarily involves rationality and the use of a person’s rationality. Rationality and happiness are activities of the soul, and virtue is the excellence of these activities. Humans are the only life forms that have a soul, the source of rationality.
Premarital Sex Essay Research Paper Premarital SexPremarital
Premarital Sex Essay, Research Paper Premarital Sex Premarital sex, an act that is practiced excessively in the world today, is not all that it is caught up to be. It definitely has more side effects than benefits. Premarital sex is an action that causes one’s emotional, social, spiritual and physical being to become corrupted.
Eastern Philosophy Essay Research Paper Philosophers of
Eastern Philosophy Essay, Research Paper Philosophers of Eastern Religions Does anybody have any answers to the question of what is our purpose? Is there life after death? What do we need to accomplish while we are alive? What is real or moral? Is there a God? These are main philosophical questions that the human race has been trying to answer.
Thoughts On
“A Person/A Paper/A Promise” Essay, Research Paper A Person/A Paper/A Promise is by far my favorite poem. It may not be the best poem ever written, but it expresses feelings and situations that I, as a human being and especially as a teenager, can relate to very deeply. The author describes a series of situations in the life of a person that resemble our own experiences or those of people we know.
Dmy Definition Of A Hero Essay Research
Paper Descriptive: A Real Hero Most people hear the word hero they think of a super hero in a comic book leading a secret live. A person who has super human powers and flies around a big city fighting crime everyday or night. The type of person that never makes a mistake in there lives, and was destined for fame from the moment they were born.
Movies Essay Research Paper Many people go
Movies Essay, Research Paper Many people go to the movies. The movies are an escape into a fantasy world. Everyone has a different preference on what kind of movie is the best. Romance, horror, action, and comedy are different types of movies. The kind of movie someone goes to see can give clues to what kind of person they are.
Why We Need Affirmative Action Essay Research
Paper I. Why do we need affirmative action? Unfortunatly, this country still very much needs affirmative action and the arguments used to attack affirmative action, both overt and covert, are dead wrong.
Philosophy Hume Essay Research Paper Philosophy HumeAn
Philosophy, Hume Essay, Research Paper Philosophy, HumeAn Enquiry Concerning the Principles of MoralsWhat is a moral? This is a question that has plagued philosophers for many years. Is it possibleto have a set of universal morals? There are many questions that surround the mystery of morals. Theyseem to drive our every action.
Attribution Theory Essay Research Paper Attribution Theory
Attribution Theory Essay, Research Paper Attribution Theory: Is It Really Fair? One of the easiest theories to accept and understand is Heider’s Attribution Theory. This theory is used to explain how a person comes to a quick decision about someone or their personality, based on that person’s behavior.
Hume An Enquiry Concerning The Principles Of
Morals Essay, Research Paper Philosophy, Hume An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals What is a moral? This is a question that has plagued philosophers for many years. Is