D-World Essay, Research Paper
Praise and Blame in World D
In World D, a world in which people recognize that they do not have
free will, it is still possible to maintain a system of praise and
blame. The implicit assumption is that praise and blame effect actions
such that a person praised for an action is more likely to repeat the
action while a person blamed for an action is less likely to commit the
same action again. Such a system, although possible, would look
different from the system which exists in the actual world because the
actual system is partially based on the notion that people do have a
sense of free will. Furthermore, although it is logically possible to
have such a system, establishing one in reality would require knowledge
of the inner workings of human psychology which is difficult to compile.
Before we can discuss the notion of praise and blame that would be
possible in World D, it is necessary to describe what such a world would
look like and how people in such a world would feel. First, it is useful
to examine the feelings of incompatiblist determinists in the actual
world because it is possible that the feelings held by such people would
be similar to those held by the people in World D. Simply put,
determinism is the belief that everything has a cause, including
everything that people ever do, think, or say. People who believe in
incompatiblist determinism assert that this definition of determinism
means that there is no free will. In World D, it is a given that there
is no free will, therefore incompatiblist determinism would be a
reasonable possibility.
Belief in incompatabilist determinism does not require that one know
all of the determining factors. Therefore, it is possible to have all
thoughts and actions completely determined and still not be able to
predict actions or thoughts. The theory merely requires that determining
factors exist, not that they be known to the individuals whom they are
determining. For example, suppose Bob from World D does not like
mustard. Because he inhabits World D, Bob knows that he is determined
not to like mustard. He may not have any conscious reasons for his
dislike of mustard, but he is confident that there are determining
factors which make him find mustard unpleasant.
Due to lack of knowledge of determining factors, one way in which
people without free will could live is under a system of praise and
blame similar to our own. One reason for our system of praise is to
encourage a person to repeat an action or thought. Therefore, in World
D, if people have reason to believe that praise affects the subconscious
mind to change the determining factors then there would be reason for
there to be a system of praise. The argument for blame is parallel. If
there is reason to believe that blame for an action will effect the
determining factors to discourage a person from repeating an action,
then there is justification for a system of blame.
This argument ignores a crucial piece of our actual system of praise
and blame, however. Implicit in our system is the belief that a person
is morally responsible because he or she could have done otherwise. In
World D, everyone recognizes that a person could have done nothing other
than exactly what he or she did. Therefore, some Kantians might object
that there is not justification for a system of praise and blame. If a
person is not free to choose to do otherwise, how can they be blamed or
praised for this choice?
This objection clarifies the difference between our actual system of
praise and blame and that which would exist in World D. The World D
system would be purely consequentialist. If praising someone for certain
actions will have good consequences, then it is done. Similarly, if
blaming someone for certain actions will have good consequences, then it
is also done.
In our current system, there is a judgement placed on the choice to
commit the action. If this choice is considered freely made, then
judgement is passed on the individual who made such a praiseworthy or
blameworthy choice. If everyone recognized a lack of free will, as they
do in World D, such judgement would clearly be unfounded. The World D
system would not reflect a judgement on the person committing the
action, or the choice to commit the action (because the choice was
determined, not chosen); rather the system merely judges the merit of
the action itself. Therefore, this consequentialist system is not
weakened by the objection that praise and blame cannot exist because the
person who committed a certain action did not have free will and
therefore could not have done otherwise.
This raises a further question, however. The reason that praise and
blame are believed to be effective is because they effect the human
desire to be liked and to be a good person. Yet if everyone accepts that
the praise and blame merely reflect on the action and not on the person
performing the action, then the praise and blame would not have the
desired effect on the subconscious desires and thereby alter the
determining factors. Basically, praise and blame are effective as
incentives and deterrents because people feel they could have done
otherwise and should the situation arise again, will be able to do
otherwise. If, however, the possibility of changing the action is known
to be out of one’s control, then to be praised or blamed for such
actions would not alter the motivations.
In order to clearly determine the effects that a consequentialist
system of praise and blame would have on the inhabitants of World D, it
would be necessary to have an understanding of the determining factors
surrounding actions and thoughts. Such information is unavailable to us
in the actual world, and could be unavailable to the inhabitants of
World D. Yet without such information, the system of praise and blame
could not be effective.
Perhaps they consequentialist system of praise and blame could still
work in World D if the people believe that it will have an effect on
their actions. Even if they recognize that they are not able to change
their actions, they would also know that if the determining factors are
different, the outcome may be different. Therefore, the system of praise
and blame could be based merely on the belief that praising or blaming
someone will change the determining factors and not on the belief that
the person could have done otherwise.
Furthermore, the system of praise and blame could be maintained on the
basis that although actions are caused by prior events, if a person does
something morally wrong, they are still morally responsible as long as
they know the difference between right and wrong. This system of praise
and blame is the same as that advocated by Carolyn in William’s
Dialogue. She says, “We do not absolve people of moral responsibility
when we realize that all of their actions are caused” (55). Clearly, it
is conceivable to hold people morally responsible for actions even in
World D.
The causes of actions may be things like internal wishes or desires,
which were themselves caused by previous factors. This fact does not
meant that people don’t know the difference between right and wrong. As
long as people can discriminate between good and bad and right and
wrong, it is logical to hold them morally responsible because no one
prevents them from acting differently. Even in our actual concept of
praise and blame, we do not consider internal determining factors to
prevent praise or blame. One is morally responsible for an action if one
causes it. For example, a woman is morally responsible for a crime
because she herself caused it (even though it was determined that she
would by her internal motivations).
Therefore, the system of praise and blame for World D could be based
upon both the consequentialist view that praise and blame would effect
people’s later actions and upon the belief that people are morally
responsible for those actions which they themselves cause, even if they
could not have acted otherwise under such circumstances. Such a system
stands up to the claim that praise and blame lose all meaning in such a
world. In fact, they retain much of the common meaning attributed to
them in the actual world.
Другие работы по теме:
Psalm 96 Essay Research Paper The AnalysisPsalm
Psalm 96 Essay, Research Paper The Analysis-Psalm 96 A Psalm of Praise When analyzing a psalm of praise it is important to keep in mind that Psalms are poetry; and therefore do follow some of the rules of poetry. There are usually identifiable elements and structures in a Psalm similar to that those that might be found in a literary poem much like many of us learned and studied in secondary education classes early in our lives.
College Essay Essay Research Paper It would
College Essay Essay, Research Paper It would be conventional to choose a parent, family member, friend, or teacher as a significant source of influence in ones life. However I am not conventional or at least I try not to be. I am very open-minded and observant. My personality and work exhibit eclectic-laden themes drawn from a chaotic world of sources in which I perceive.
Oedipus Essay Research Paper battles against Centaurs
Oedipus Essay, Research Paper battles against Centaurs, Amazons, also friezes of Athena figthing the giants. Interestingly these sculptures are all of either battle or celebrations, this in way show cased the Athenian ambitions.
A Certain Hunger Essay Research Paper In
A Certain Hunger Essay, Research Paper In the essay “A Certain Hunger”, by Maggie Helwig it shows how people can develop a negative body image about themselves because of the way society praise and glorifies models and “thin” celebrities. People would be more secure about themselves, if everyone would accept people as they are, and help the people who have these image problems before they lose control, lose self-confidence and lose hope in themselves.
Koljiol Essay Research Paper AUSTRIAN AVALANCHESRecently deadly
Koljiol Essay, Research Paper AUSTRIAN AVALANCHES Recently deadly avalanches have occurred and are still occuring in austria and Central Europe. Who’s to blame, the antithesis of El Nino or La Nina? Snow storms that usually occur in Scandinavia, have moved further south to Central Europe.
Sadistic People Suck Essay Research Paper Your
Sadistic People Suck Essay, Research Paper Your inner demon turned you about, your inner demon burned you out. Torment, tease and frustrate you, your inner demon tears you apart. Little inner circle of hell is where you dwell inside and out of you there is no difference, your covered in shame yet your the one to blame.
Ozymandias C Despair Essay Research Paper Ozymandias
Ozymandias C. Despair Essay, Research Paper Ozymandias C. Despair changed from the feeling that the greatness statue would inspire despair in others through fear but it did the opposite, the passers by feel despair for the statue in it wrecked stat, it is situational irony.
Paradise Lost 2 Essay Research Paper Paradise
Paradise Lost 2 Essay, Research Paper Paradise Lost Milton is widely considered to be one of the five greatest poets in the English language and Paradise Lost, a religious epic, is his greatest masterpiece. As stated in the beginning of the first book of Paradise Lost, Milton’s intention for writing his religious epic is, among some other things, to justify the ways of God to men.
Give Subordinates The Honor When They Succeed
; Essay, Research Paper 1. Its 0630 and I’m in full service dress blues. I’ve been told that I must report to the Wing Deputy Commander to explain the actions of a Communication Security (COMSEC) incident that has occurred in my section. I am in charge of the account but did not personally have anything to do with the incident.
What Does The Grapes Of Wrath Say
About Results, Not Causes Essay, Research Paper As people get upset with something, they need to find another to blame. Most likely results stick out more than causes, and in turn the result gets the blame. If one is blamed for something that isn’t their fault, often the person will get upset and, in turn, find something or somebody else to blame.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Act IV Scene
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Act IV, Scene vii: Claudius convinces Laertes that he is innocent in Laertes’ father’s death and that Hamlet is to blame. A messenger enters with Hamlet’s letter and Claudius is amazed to find that
Illustrative Essay Stereotypes Essay Research Paper Illustrative
Illustrative Essay: Stereotypes Essay, Research Paper Illustrative essay (rough draft) Stereotypes can have excessive damage and it can have a very negative effect on the person in view or as a whole group. Stereotyping is not just another form of making fun of people, it also encourages rejection and outcast.
Smoking Essay Research Paper According to these
Smoking Essay, Research Paper According to these 2 article many teens decide to smoke because of peer pressure and looking cool. According to this recent article that was in the Detroit News about an Edsel Ford High School student they asked him why he started smoking and he said he didn t no he just did. All most every article I came across said that Joe Camel was to blame but researchers aren t sure if that s still the case.
Violence Essay Research Paper There has been
Violence Essay, Research Paper There has been a lot of controversy regarding the lyrics with negative messages, and they say it has an impact on our youth. Me being a teenager who listens to that kind of music, I don t agree with them. For years teenagers have been killing, and using drugs and doing violent things.
AngloSaxon Gods Essay Research Paper Anglo Saxon
Anglo-Saxon Gods Essay, Research Paper Anglo- Saxon Gods The Anglo-Saxon period was very interesting. Especially the ancient poems and mythology. While looking around, the Gods captured my attention. Three of them to be exact, Woden, Thunor and Tiw.
Parents Responsibilities For Children Crimes Essay Research
Paper Parenting is such a complex area involving efforts to help and change children. Many parents had little advanced warning of what an enormous task raising a child really would be. To produce happy well adjusted energetic self- controlled, friendly, achieving children parents have to show them more love, give them more praise than criticism, more rewards than punishment.
Immigration Reform Essay Research Paper Immigration ReformImmigration
Immigration Reform Essay, Research Paper Immigration Reform Immigration reform is a political idea construed to mislead our society into blaming innocent immigrant minorities for the current problems that plague our nation. It is well known that this country has prospered through centuries of economic and social misfortunes from the labor of immigrants who have made this country what it is today.
Macbeth 17 Essay Research Paper In every
Macbeth 17 Essay, Research Paper In every story, there is always a protagonist, one who we blame for whatever takes place. In the play Macbeth, there are many different
Gatsby Essay Essay Research Paper Gatsby EssayWho
Gatsby Essay Essay, Research Paper Gatsby Essay Who is the real hero of the novel Nick or Gatsby ? discuss In the novel the great Gatsby we can look at two people as the heros, but they are both heros in a different manner . Nick could be seen as a hero because of the way he struggled to help Gatsby realize his dream and the other hero is Gatsby himself who we can see as a hero because of the way he took the blame for the woman he loved and she didn t even acknowledge him after his death .
Where The Blame Falls Essay Research Paper
Where The Blame Falls We go threw our lives hoping to do the right thing for ourselves and the right thing for others. Through our lives we take the blame for many things and sometimes we get the blame pushed upon us. This is shown in the book, The Scarlet Letter, by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Hester, Pearl, Chillingworth, and Dimmesdale are two of the main characters.
Perils Of Obedience Essay Research Paper The
Perils Of Obedience Essay, Research Paper The Perils of Obedience This experiment is a test to see if people are naturally aggressive. Milgram does not believe that people are naturally aggressive. Although some people think people are naturally aggressive. Ordinary people can be part of a bad course of actions without having any anger toward then victim.
Who Is Most To Blame For Macbeth
’s Downfall? Essay, Research Paper Who Is Most To Blame For Macbeth’s Downfall? I have chosen to write my essay about the cause of Macbeth’s downfall. I believe Macbeth had an immense build up of hatred inside him waiting to be
Gangs Essay Research Paper la Springer Parent
Gangs Essay, Research Paper la Springer Parent and Child Development Tuesday, December 5, 2000 Gangs a Violent Reality Gangs are a violent reality that people have to deal with in today?s society. Kids
Communication Roles Essay Research Paper In my
Communication Roles Essay, Research Paper In my life, the five most important roles I fill are as follows: father, head of household, son, student, and friend. Each role is very challenging and requires a lot of attention.
Motor Skills Essay Research Paper The Medieval
Motor Skills Essay, Research Paper The Medieval Holocaust was a terrible event for many people in communities of that time period. This was the greatest epidemic that ever happened. People could not figure out what caused the Plague. They started to look for someone to blame. They finally looked at the Jews and blamed them for poisoning the water.
Cruel Tears Essay Research Paper In reading
Cruel Tears Essay, Research Paper In reading the play Cruel Tears, you will find that there is definitely a tragedy. However, it is unclear as to what the tragedy is caused by. In looking at Johnny and Jack you can start to unwind this debatable event. Did Johnny s weakness or Jack s jealousy cause this tragedy? It is unfortunate that more history of the relation between Johnny and Jack is not available.
Serial Kill Essay Research Paper Who Is
Serial Kill Essay, Research Paper Who Is A Serial Killer? Who develops into a serial murderer? How does a serial killer operate? Is it genetics, biological, or cultural conditioning that makes these people killers? We all experience rage, yet we have all have the ability to control these behaviors. What sets us apart from a killer?
On MY Honor Essay Research Paper Marion
On MY Honor Essay, Research Paper Marion Dane Bauer, On My Honor. Clarion, 1986. 90pp. Marion Bauer certainly followed in the tradition of great novels. On My Honor is set in the hot summer of a small city. It explores the stress we put on ourselves to express blame and feel guilt when blamed. The biggest heartache is when you blame yourself for things that could not be prevented, or were not your fault.
Antigone Essay Research Paper 2
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Would you ever dare to disobey the law and risk your life for it just so you could do what you thought was right? In the play Antigone, the main character Antigone, had her actions rewarded by death. She had disobeyed the law made by Creon (the king) and therefore had to be punished.
Antigone Essay Essay Research Paper This paper
Antigone Essay Essay, Research Paper This paper is an essay on Antigone. The story Antigone is a great Greek tragedy. Sophocles, an ancient Greek playwright, is the author of the story. It is a great story. It is known throughout the world. This essay is going to trace the character of Antigone through the beginning, middle, and end of the story.