Paper
In the Introduction to Linguistics class
last week, Professor Ivanoff asked if the students had any questions about
the material he had just discussed in his lecture. The preceding lecture
covered marked words (words that clearly define or describe only one object).
A student who seemed confused asked Professor Ivanoff how the use of marked
words was connected to our study of Linguistics.
A student said, “Everyone knows that when
you say table, a table is something with four legs and a flat surface.
So table is a marked word. In a sense we already knew that because we don’t
go around calling everything a table.” The student asked, “Is this just
a definition or will it be explained further at a later time?”
“I do not understand why you are asking
such a question,” Professor Ivanoff said. “I just explained to you what
marked and unmarked words are. Why do you ask such a question?”
“I am just wondering why you told us about
marked words. How is it important in our study?” the student asked.
“I explained it to you. There are marked
words and there are unmarked words. Marked words describe definite things.
Unmarked words are words that can be used to define more than one thing,”
Professor Ivanoff shouted. “You ask such strange questions. I hold a Ph.D.
in linguistics. Why do you question my authority on such subject?”
The student tried to explain one more time,
“I am not questioning your authority at all. I am just wandering what the
connection is between marked words and Ling-.”
Professor Ivanoff interrupted, “If you
want to question my authority you do so in my office. Please do not waste
class time.”
Unknowingly Professor Ivanoff and the student
provided a perfect example of “Conversational Narcissism” and how continued
habits can hinder the process of “true” dialogue. Conversational Narcissism
uses “structural” devices to dominate the conversation and shift the attention
from one partner to another. The shift response is the structural device
that Professor Ivanoff used to change the focus of attention from the student’s
question, to himself. This conversation shows that even in a simple conversation,
one person will shift the attention away from the other person to themselves,
allowing them to dominate the conversation.
The conversation portrayed the shift response
when Professor Ivanoff failed to answer the student’s question and put
forth effort to understand what the student was asking. Instead of attempting
to answer the question Professor Ivanoff felt personally attacked and attacked
the student in return. This shifted the attention of the conversation to
Professor Ivanoff and his concerns. The student no longer had a say in
the matter and her question would not be answered.
When Professor Ivanoff employed the shift
response, dialogue could no longer take place. To make dialogue happen
between two persons, four characteristics must be present. The first characteristic
is two-way flow. Each participant of the dialogue must have an equal chance
to speak their thoughts on the matter while the other listens intently.
Two-way flow allows each speaker to have the same amount of time to share
and express their ideas. The second characteristic for a dialogue is that
the topic of discussion must be “non-empirically” verifiable. The topic
must not scientifically proven. A third criterion asks that both speakers
engage in the conversation with a spirit of fairness. Each participant
needs to be willing to inspect their own position as vigorously as they
do that of the other speaker. Each speaker needs to have the attitude that
there is a possibility that the other person is correct. The final criteria
concludes that each speaker needs to have courage. Courage defined as a
willingness to put your self-identity on the line and lose your self image.
By examining the four criteria of a dialogue,
two-way flow, suitable topic, a spirit of fairness, and courage, and examining
the conversation taken place in Professor Ivanoff’s classroom, one can
see that what took place cannot be a dialogue. Professor Ivanoff did not
allow the two-way flow to be constant. He did not listen to the student’s
question or attempt to answer them. The two-way flow was disrupted when
Professor Ivanoff interrupted the student. The topic also is one that neither
has a right or wrong answer. To different professors the answer to the
student’s question may be different. The answer would depend on the objective
of the course. A spirit of fairness was not present either. When the professor
felt attacked, he would not listen to the student or answer her question.
He did not have the mind set “That there is a possibility that the student
is right and she is not attacking me.” Perhaps being a professor, and one
of higher rank than that of the student is why the professor was not willing
to put his self-identity on the line. He became angry when he felt his
sense of self attacked.
The conversational narcissism the professor
and student displayed led to a corruption of dialogue and dialogue simply
did not take place. This can be a potential problem in the classroom setting.
If conversational narcissism continues to take place, students will be
intimidated by the professor to ask questions about what they are learning.
The student should not question the professor’s authority or knowledge.
When a student does not understand the material and makes an attempt to
ask a question, in a spirit of fairness a professor should answer that
question. It will allow the student to ask the question and be listened
to by the professor and in turn the professor will be listened to by the
student.
If dialogue were present in the classroom
structure students and professors would be able to interact fairly and
in a respectful manner of each other. Dialogue would make the learning
experience for the students more comfortable and the job of the professor
more rewarding. Conversational Narcissism, as we have seen, hinders that
process of dialogue and should be eliminated from the student-professor
relationship.
Другие работы по теме:
Hucklebery Finn A Book Of Controversy Essay
, Research Paper Huckleberry Finn, a Book of Controversy Since its publication over one hundred years ago, Mark Twain?s Huckleberry Finn has caused many disagreements and much controversy. The style and language used by Mark Twain is found as offensive to some, uplifting to others and yet bittersweet to me.
Classroom Observation Essay Research Paper My middle
Classroom Observation Essay, Research Paper My middle school observation was with a seventh-grade English class at the New Boston Middle School on February 16, 2001. Mrs. Messer was the teacher and she actually remembered me as one of her students in the same class several years ago. The assistant principal, Mary Lovelace, was the one to assign where I was to observe.
Los Dias Essay Research Paper Lindsay Thibault
Los Dias Essay, Research Paper Lindsay Thibault 10-20-00 Project #4 Computer Graphic Los Dias de la Semana (The Days of the Week) I would use this in a second grade classroom (eight-years-old), so students could practice the days of the week in Spanish. Towards the beginning of the school year, I would spend time teaching the students the days of the week in Spanish by going over them every morning.
Mystification Essay Research Paper Mystification
Mystification Essay, Research Paper Mystification According to McNeil, mystification is a technique used by teachers who are not fully informed on the topic in which they are instructed to teach. Teachers
Narcissistic Personality Disorder NPD
) – Criteria Essay, Research Paper Sam Vaknin’s Psychology, Philosophy, Economics and Foreign Affairs Web SitesPlease read CAREFULLY! The text in italics is NOT based on the Diagnostics and Statistics Manual, Fourth Edition (1994).
Kinesiolgy Essay Research Paper How to go
Kinesiolgy Essay, Research Paper How to go about developing a community within a physical education classroom setting. Each physical education classroom setting makes up its own community. A
You Just Don
’t Understand Essay, Research Paper Deborah Tannen?s (1990) book, “You Just Don?t Understand,” contains facts about men and women?s communication styles. Tannen says once these gender differences are sorted out, men and women can recognize and understand how to confront real conflicts, rather than fighting styles.
School Violencespeech Essay Research Paper Remember the
School Violence_speech Essay, Research Paper Remember the Jonesboro, Arkansas incident? How about Columbine? Or maybe the most recent in Mt. Morris Township Michigan where a six year old girl was killed in her classroom. Should there be metal detectors in school? I believe so, a lot of people think not. I’ll debate their reasons with my own reasoning.
Philosophy Of Education Essay Research Paper A
Philosophy Of Education Essay, Research Paper A philosophy of education is very important in the teaching profession. All teachers have their own unique philosophies. My personal philosophy of education contains many different aspects. For instance, in my opinion all teachers are valuable. The younger the teacher the more current the knowledge, the older the teacher the better the wisdom.
Sex Roles Essay Research Paper Are boys
Sex Roles Essay, Research Paper Are boys and girls treated differently by the teacher in classroom situations? This is a question that has frustrated many psychologists and educators. In many cases, I think gender does play a significant role in the education process. Teachers may unconsciously give more attention to the boys in a classroom.
The Gender Gap Essay Research Paper When
The Gender Gap Essay, Research Paper When a girl falls down, her parents immediately give their hands. However, when a boy does, his parents expect he rises for himself without their help unless he is very little and weak. Despite most parents’ saying that they do not want their children to behave and think in stereotypical ways, they treat their children differently based on the child’s gender.
Communication Differences Between Men And Women Essay
, Research Paper INTRODUCTION The differences in gender is the most significant biological difference within the human species. Yet, most of us know very little about how these differences affect work, intimacy and conflict. Starting at a very young age, these differences begin to shape our play, concepts of relationships, productivity, and in general the way we communicate with one another.
Araby By James Joyce Essay Research Paper 2
?Araby? By James Joyce Essay, Research Paper Love at a young age is just an obsession. As children, our first relationships are object relationships. The people we like aren’t people; they are objects of our obsession, and our obsessions are driven by vanity and narcissism. We are obsessed with what we consider an ideal, something we create.
School Violence Essay Research Paper Remember the
School Violence Essay, Research Paper Remember the Jonesboro, Arkansas incident? How about Columbine? Or maybe the most recent in Mt. Morris Township Michigan where a six year old girl was killed in her classroom. Should there be metal detectors in school? I believe so, a lot of people think not. I?ll debate their reasons with my own reasoning.
A Comparison Of The Mayor Of Casterbridge
? By Thomas Hardy And ?A View From The Bridge? Essay, Research Paper In this piece of coursework our class had to be split up into groups of three or four and have discussions about topics
Nervousness Essay Research Paper Nervousness I sat
Nervousness Essay, Research Paper Nervousness; I sat in the car on my way to the first day of kindergarten. My stomach was filled with butterflies and my mind with fears and unexplicable hopes. I remember begging my mom to keep me at home. I knew nobody in my class. All of my friends from my neighborhood were in the other class.
Bilingual Education Is It Hel Essay Research
Paper Bilingual Education: Is it helping or hurting? Bilingual education seems to be a rising topic that is currently up for debate. With the growing number of immigrants entering this country, the language barrier between individuals seems to be far greater when it comes to children in the classroom. On average it is said that here alone in Tempe, schools have about 45 different languages to one classroom.
Freud Essay Research Paper Sigmund Freud physiologist
Freud Essay, Research Paper Sigmund Freud, physiologist, medical doctor, psychologist and father of psychoanalysis, is generally recognized as one of the most influential and authoritative thinkers of the twentieth century. He elaborated the theory that the mind is a complex energy-system, the structural investigation of which is proper province of psychology.
Forgotten World Essay Research Paper Select a
Forgotten World Essay, Research Paper Select a reading assignment and teach it to the class, providing a short synopsis of the reading and raising questions that facilitate classroom discussion about how or whether the main character is struggling to recognize, reflect on, realize, and/or reinvent a particular self:the social,political, economic, or cultural factors that influence the selfexpression, experiences, and condition of the main characters the choices available to or made by the main character and how the story of the main charaxter has meaning for today’s women.
Inclusion In Classrooms Essay Research Paper Since
Inclusion In Classrooms Essay, Research Paper Since the 1980’s more and more school have began to practice the technique of inclusion in their classrooms. Inclusion is a term which expresses commitment to educate each child to the maximum extent appropriate, in the classroom he or she would otherwise attend.( Education Resources. “Special Education Inclusion.”www.weac/resource/june96/speced.htm.
School Girls Essay Research Paper In the
School Girls Essay, Research Paper In the book School Girls by Peggy Orenstein, the focus is on young adolescent girls in middle school, and the effects that the ?Hidden Curriculum? and other elements have on their self esteem. ?Hidden Curriculum teaches girls to value silence and compliance.? (pg.35) The hidden curriculum is a theory that boys often get more attention than girls in the classroom, and that even if it is negative attention, the girls learn that they are not as important, and they eventually give up hope, and stop speaking out in class.
Narcissism Essay Research Paper
“Is our negative branding of narcissism a defense against a demanding call of the soul to be loved?” Thomas Moore – Care of the Soul Narcissism is the egotistic sense of self-importance, but paradoxically underneath this attitude, the narcissist is simply a victim of a fragile low self-esteem. It is the underlying sense of inferiority that is the real problem of the narcissist, and their pretense is just a disguise used to cover their deeper feelings of inadequacy.
Perception Of Others Essay Research Paper Perception
Perception Of Others Essay, Research Paper Perception of others and myself has played a big role in my life. It has changed the way society thinks. It has us thinking twice about someone or something, before we can make an assumption. Without perception everyone would probably be boring. It was my first day at Walter J.high school.
Rogers Essay Research Paper Drawing from our
Rogers Essay, Research Paper Drawing from our experiances with formal education , we have come to agree with Rogers to some degree, but also disagree with some of the points that he made concerning freedom in the classroom. There are many components of the theory that would be helpful to the learning process of the student.
Performance Assessment Essay Scale Essay Research Paper
Classroom Self Esteem Scale This scale will attempt to estimate the level of self-esteem a person has in the classroom. Notice the instrument has no center or neutral point?the respondent has to declare whether he/she is in agreement or disagreement with the items.
Cognitive Development Of School Age Children Essay
, Research Paper Cognitive Development of School Age Child The cognitive development of the school age child is progressing rapidly. The two main cognitive processes at this time, which allow the child to become a more effective communicator during the school age years are non-egocentrism and decentration.
Computers In The Classroom Essay Research Paper
Computers In The Classroom In Postman s essay, Virtual Students, Digital Classroom, he argues about the technology in the classrooms. Postman comes to the conclusion that high-technology (computers) in the classroom is just another thing that will not solve anymore of our problems and will also take over his job as a teacher.
Classroom Management Essay Research Paper Philosophy Of
Classroom Management Essay, Research Paper Philosophy Of Classroom Management I believe that a good classroom management system is essential for any teacher who wishes to have a productive learning environment in their classroom. It is my goal to have a well managed classroom. I want to establish a productive working environment that allows student involvement and cooperation in all classroom activities.
Managing Classroom Behavior Essay Research Paper MANAGING
Managing Classroom Behavior Essay, Research Paper MANAGING CLASSROOM BEHAVIOR REPORT #1 Managing classroom behavior can be a difficult task, especially if you have a child who is always causing disturbances. Once you have identified that there is a problem, you should ask yourself six simple questions.
Observation Report Essay Research Paper Christopher TippinsObservation
Observation Report Essay, Research Paper Christopher Tippins Observation Report Dr. Kibria April 26, 1999 During the month of March, I observed a special education classroom at East Elementary School. This was a third grade class containing only disabled students. Although this class was labeled a third grade class, the students were on different levels in certain subjects.
School To Work Essay Research Paper The
School To Work Essay, Research Paper The School-to-Work Opportunities Act was signed into law in 1994 and is administered under the auspices of the U.S. Departments of Education and Labor. The Act provides funds to States and local communities to develop School-to-Work systems. School-to-Work is a method of attaining high academic standards through applied, contextual, and focused learning.
Liberation And Narcissism
’s Essay, Research Paper For centuries, women have gone to extreme measures to please men. Women seek acceptance and respect from men. One method used by women to obtain this respect and acceptance is narcissism. Adrienne Rich s essay When We Dead Awaken: Writing as Re-Vision as well as Susan Douglas essay Narcissism as Liberation discusses women s narcissistic attempts to become liberated.
What Is An Effective Teacher Essay Research
Paper What is an effective teacher? An effective teacher is one who runs an effective classroom, and touches the lives of children. An efficient teacher is one who knows what they are doing and does the right thing consistently. To be and effective and efficient teacher you must have three very important characteristics for student success.