Essay, Research Paper
The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism and Materialism
I am faced with the philosophical task of defending either dualism or materialism, depending on which one is most attractive to me. So either I support the theory of dualism, which is the belief that there is both a physical and a spiritual state, or I believe in materialism, which is the belief that everything that exists is material or physical. Although I believe materialism to be easier to prove, I find dualism more attractive to believe. Throughout the following, I will attempt to build a case for the theory of dualism giving insights both documented and personal. I will also shed light on the theory of materialism and the proofs that support this theory; showing that although materialism has a strong argument, essentially, it the less attractive of the two.
What I find most appealing about dualism is the belief in the soul and body, spirit and matter. Although materialism is a valid theory scientifically and philosophically, I find dualism to cover a wider spectrum of possibilities. I do not believe that our body and our thoughts and everything that surrounds us are a result of the physical. Materialism removes any problems of relatedness between mind and body by eliminating the spiritual altogether. But as I will show, materialism might have the upper hand in proof but it cannot fulfill or support my need for the spiritual like dualism can.
Dualism supports the possibility that when a person dies, their body might die but their soul continues. It allows one to at least consider this notion along with many others of the spiritual realm. The existence of God, miracles, and unexplained phenomena are just a few things dualism supports. I believe it is ignorant of a person to support materialism just because scientifically it makes more sense. So many people believe in some form of religion or God. Then why would it be illogical to find faith in something you cannot see and that cannot be proven, but there is an instinctive feeling that the possibility exists. For me, there is a great possibility for both a physical and spiritual realm and even though I take dualism on blind faith, I take it because my life makes more sense. With dualism, the existence of God seems possible and death does not seem so final, love seems more special and life seems to have more meaning. Materialism suggests to me that our bodies, our thoughts are a type of mechanical function, whereas dualism gives me a sense of meaning in my life.
There are many textbook arguments against materialism: the divisibility argument, the introspection argument, and the argument for measurement:
The Divisibility Argument
1. My body, which includes my brain, is divisible.
2. (a) I cannot conceive of my mind as divisible.
(b) I cannot conceive of my individual mental states as divisible, either.
3. Therefore, my mind is distinct from any part of my body.
The Introspection Argument
1. Mental states are knowable through introspection.
2. Brain states are not knowable through introspection.
3. Therefore, mental sates are not brain states.
Argument for Measurement
1. Brain states can be located and measured.
2. Mental states cannot be located and measured.
3. Therefore, by Leibniz’s Law brain states are not mental states.
All three of these arguments dispute materialism’s claim that brain states and mental states go hand in hand. The divisibility argument shows that the brain is divisible but not the mind. The introspection argument shows that the mind is knowable through introspection, whereas the brain is not. The argument for measurement shows that brain states can be located and measured, but mental states cannot be. Materialism also violates Leibniz’s Law: If an object or process x is identical with an object or process y, then x and y have all the same properties. That is, if x and y do not have the same properties, then x and y are not identical. So if the brain states are x and the mental states are y and the two are not identical as shown through the previous three arguments, then materialism violates Leibniz’s Law.
From an objective point of view I can see how someone would believe in materialism, but for me, dualism has so much more to offer. Dualism might not hold up as well scientifically as materialism, but to me it holds up better spiritually. So, obviously it is easy for a materialist to rule out dualism based on scientific knowledge. More than likely because he or she is looking solely at the physical and not even giving thought to the spiritual because materialism has ruled out this possibility. I guess I can see that if you accept the premise that everything that exists is material then there really is no validity to considering the spiritual. But to me, my life makes more sense if there is something to consider beyond the material because so much of my life revolves around the spiritual.
Другие работы по теме:
The Identity Theory Essay Research Paper The
The Identity Theory Essay, Research Paper The identity theory, also known as reductive materialism, is one of the views Churchland uses to describe mind-brain correlation. Churchland believes that
Man Who Mistook His Wife For Hat
Essay, Research Paper Men ought to know that from nothing else but the brain come joys, delights, laughter and sports, and sorrows, griefs despondency, and
What Does It All Mean The MindBody
Problem Essay, Research Paper Human beings have a conception of at least two different kinds of things that exist in the world, mental and physical. Any of us could generate a long list of obvious physical things and clear cases of psychological things. And we assume that both of these types of things, mental phenomena and physical phenomena, are part of our world.
Hate Literature Essay Research Paper Hate literaturematerialism
Hate Literature Essay, Research Paper Hate literature/materialism currently exists on the internet, and is expanding at a high rate, causing disturbance to society. Although the internet is known to be a free base to express opinions, thoughts, and general information, exploiting that particular use can be rather dangerous, especially when offending one’s culture.
Central-State Materialism
& Functionalism Essay, Research Paper In my readings of the two chapters from the book, Body and Mind, written by Keith Campbell, I explored my mind to Central-State Materialism and Functionalism. Both these states have differences and similarities between them. Starting off with Central-State Materialism; then, I reflected my readings, and then viewed Functionalism and stated my readings.
MindBody Problem Essay Research Paper The Neverending
Mind/Body Problem Essay, Research Paper The Never-ending Question: Are We a Mind, a Body or Both? Of all the topics that are currently occupying the attention of philosophers, the Mind-Body problem is at center stage. It is one of the classical metaphysical issues concerning the relationship between that which is mental and that which is physical.
Age Of Reason Essay Research Paper The
Age Of Reason Essay, Research Paper The age of reason was a time of Empiricism and of Materialism, which brought out philosophers like John Locke and George Berkeley as well as authors like Swift and Pope. These philosophers and authors belong to the Age of Reason because of their use of anti-emotional thought and the idea of Occam’s razor.
Music Essay Research Paper As the time
Music Essay, Research Paper As the time ticks by, I am sitting here doing nothing. I am supposed to write an exemplary paragraph for my English class, but my mind is blank. I have nothing to write about, so I am just sitting here listening to all the other students type up their paragraphs and over-hearing what some of the students are talking about that are around my computer.
Schopenhauer Essay Research Paper Schopenhauer sought to
Schopenhauer Essay, Research Paper Schopenhauer sought to understand and describe the world and the things of the world. Building off of the ideas of Plato, Descartes, and Kant, however doing away with the aspect of dualism in their theories, he developed the concept of Will and Representation. The world as Will according to Schopenhauer is all that exists for knowledge, only object in relation to subject, perception of a perceiver, in a word, idea.
Reconstructing The American Dream Essay Research Paper
Reconstructing the American DreamThere is an old adage which says, “The root of all evil is money.” This, however, is not true in America. In America, money is not the problem, the love of money, or materialism, is the problem. Materialism is at the core of our American dream. We grow up learning that success is rooted in material wealth and power.
Violence On Children
’s Television Essay, Research Paper Are today’s children being exposed to too much violence via television? I think so. From the teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, to the Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers, kids are always being exposed to the rock-’em-sock-’em heroes of T.V., or the brainless violence of Beavis and Butthead.
Descartes And Searle Essay Research Paper As
Descartes And Searle Essay, Research Paper As a psychology major, one of topics that I find most interesting in philosophy is the mind/body problem. This can be defined as the relationship between the immaterial mind and the material body.
Themes Materialism Essay Research Paper In the
Themes: Materialism Essay, Research Paper In the novel, The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald successfully portrays that materialism as the corrupt source of the society. Like Fitzgerald, Jay Gatsby is a sensitive young man who idolizes wealth and luxury, and falls in love with a beautiful young woman while stationed at a military camp in the South.
Defending Materialism Essay Research Paper Defending MaterialismDualism
Defending Materialism Essay, Research Paper Defending Materialism Dualism means the complete separation of the mental world and the physical world. In philosophy, it is the theory that the world is explicable only as a world composed of two distinct and mutually exclusive factors: the mind and the body.
Rap Kills The Brain Essay Research Paper
“ROCK MUSIC AND RAP MUSIC IS SUPPOSED TO DESTROY THE MIND” An idea believed by many people is that music has a significant effect on the way people think. Professional psychologists say that the lyrics used in music today has a brain washing effect. This brain washing effect is supposed to make the listener become so overwhelmed with the lyrics of the song, that the person feels that they have to act on what was heard.
Computers Mimic The Human Mind Essay Research
Paper The mind-body problem has captivated the minds of philosophers for centuries. The problem is how the body and mind can interact with each other if they are separate and distinct.
The Universe In A Grain Of Salt
Essay, Research Paper The Universe in a Grain of Salt The universe is infinitely larger than the human mind therefore how could one understand the universe. Sagan compares the human mind and its parts to a grain of salt. He says that there are more atoms in the grain of salt than there are dendrites in the human brain.
Functionalism According To Fodor And Searle Essay
, Research Paper Fodor begins his article on the mind-body problem with a review of the current theories of dualism and materialism. According to dualism, the mind and body are two separate entities with the body being physical and the mind being nonphysical. If this is the case, though, then there can be no interaction between the two.
The MindBody Problem Dualism Versus Dual Aspect
Theory Essay, Research Paper Abstract The mind-body problem, which is still debated even today, raises the question about the relationship between the mind and the body. Theorists, such as Ren? Descartes and Thomas Nagel, have written extensively on the problem but they have many dissenting beliefs. Descartes, a dualist, contends that the mind and body are two different substances that can exist separately.
Materialism Vs Dualism Essay Research Paper Materialism
Materialism Vs Dualism Essay, Research Paper Materialism vs. Dualism There is no doubt that we are physical beings, but there is a question as to where our consciousness comes from. Can this consciousness come from a completely physical make up or do we have another non-physical entity? Does consciousness come from a physical brain or a non-physical mind? The two competing views of this question are materialism and dualism.
Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay Research Paper In
Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay, Research Paper In the Sixth Meditation, Descartes makes a point that there is a distinction between mind and body. It is in Meditation Two when Descartes believes he has shown the mind to be better known than the body. In Meditation Six, however, he goes on to claim that, as he knows his mind and knows clearly and distinctly that its essence consists purely of thought.
Consciousness Essay Research Paper The relation of
Consciousness Essay, Research Paper The relation of consciousness to the material world is puzzle, which has its origin in dualism, a philosophy of mind which posits their fundamental separation. Dualism, in turn, has its roots in folk wisdom. The belief that humans are more than bodies and that there is something in human nature that survives bodily death has its origins in prehistory; it becomes explicit in the mythology of Ancient Egypt and Assyria and was formulated into a philosophical position in the Platonic thought of Ancient Greece.
Poem This Is Me Essay Research Paper
I am Jeff, my mind is very magical, My brain is like IBM compatible. My personality is worth knowing, While my heart is always glowing Soccer is my game, A lot of people want the fame.
Mind And Body Essay Research Paper The
Mind And Body Essay, Research Paper The mind and body are said to be two different entities that have different characteristics. Many have argued that each holds its own properties and can be without the other. In my opinion, the mind and body are distinguishable in there properties but are derived from the other.
MindBody Distinction Essay Research Paper MindBody distinction
Mind-Body Distinction Essay, Research Paper Mind-Body distinction We usually view the mind as the brain and body as something physical. The mind may be better known and understood when one is thinking. When thinking, the mind is made up purely of thoughts and the body is an extension. The mind is telling the body what to do.
Philosophers Essay Research Paper Philosophers
Philosophers Essay, Research Paper Philosophers Ever since Descartes said, “I think therefor I am” philosophers have been plagued by the problem of what it means to think and what or who is this ‘I’. The problem is how does the mind work, is the mind something tangible or intangible. Or, as a great philosopher put it “What is mind, doesn’t matter.
The Question Of An Answer What
It Is To Be Human Essay, Research Paper The Question of an Answer: What It Is To Be Human The body is socially constructed; and in this paper we explore the various and
Dualism Essay Research Paper DualismIn this paper
Dualism Essay, Research Paper Dualism In this paper I will be discussing the philosophical perspective of Cartesian Dualism. To draw upon reliable sources my information will be base from the textbooks Doing Philosophy as well as the Unfortunate Dualist found in the anthology Mind s I. I will make an attempt to show that Smullyan s theories based on anti-dualism do not hold weight in modern philosophy
Socrates And Descartes On Dualism Essay Research
Paper Socrates and Descartes on Dualism Dualism means the complete separation of the mental world and the physical world. In philosophy, it is the theory that the universe is explicable only as a whole composed of two distinct and mutually exclusive factors: the mind and the body. Socrates and Plato are called dualists because they think that mind and body are separate and distinct substances.
The Problem With Dualism Behav Essay Research
Paper Jeff Extra Credit Assignment #1 a.1) The main hindrance for dualism is to explain how something non-physical (mind, soul) is associated with something physical (body). According to dualism, the association between the person (mind, soul) and the body is so intimate that many people falsely believe they are indistinguishable from their bodies.
Dualism Essay Research Paper Dualism
Dualism Essay, Research Paper Dualism I believe that the popular or “ghost in the machine” form of substance dualism best solves the mind body problem. My views in this area have
Mind And The Brain Essay Research Paper
To ask the question ?Is the mind a function of the brain?, you first have to understand that the mind and the brain are two separate entities. The brain is the most important organ of the human body. It controls everything from waking up in the morning to walking to class. The brain is the message center of the body, it tells the heart to expand and contract in order to circulate blood; and the diaphragm to move up and down so that you are able to breathe.