Divisibility Argument Essay, Research Paper
This paper will discuss the dualism?s Divisibility Argument. This argument
relies on Leibniz?s Law and uses a different property to prove the
distinctness of brain states of mental states. Mary, who is a materialist,
presents several objections to that argument. Her main objection corresponds to
the first/third-person approach. She believes that Dave presents that argument
only from the first-person approach, which is introspection, and totally
disregards the third-person approach, which is observation of another mind.
Mary?s objections will follow by the Dave?s response on them from the
dualist?s point of view. The purpose of the Divisibility Argument is to prove
that mental states are different from the brain states. My body, which includes
my brain, is divisible. However, I cannot conceive of my mind as divisible.
Therefore, my mind is distinct from any part of my body. Descartes was the first
who established the Divisibility Argument. He held that the two components which
constitute man had an independent origin and are of a fundamentally different
nature. The body is divisible, since it can be separated for example, my leg or
my hand can be cut off; my brain can be cut on half. However, the idea of the
divisible mind is inconceivable. This argument relies on the Leibniz?s Law. It
is a principle about identity, which says, ?if an object or event X is
identical with an object or event Y, then X and Y have all of the same
properties.? So if X and Y have any different properties, then X can not be
identical with Y. Divisibility Argument uses a different property to prove the
distinctness of brain states and mental states: the property of being
indivisible. In this case, the mind has a property and brain lacks it. The body
can be divided, however, it cannot be done with the mind. Mary has several
objections to this argument. First, she believes that the mind is an entity,
which is composed of several mental states: thoughts, beliefs, memories,
desires, etc. Mary strongly disagrees with Descartes? claim that the mind
employs itself in its different properties: willing, desiring, understanding,
and so on. Secondly, she clarifies the meaning of the word ?conceive? in the
Dave?s argument. The term ?conceive? might mean either ?imagine? or
?understand.? Imagining literally involves ?forming an image of? or
?picturing? in one?s mind, whereas understanding is more ?conceptual?
and does not require the ability to picture something. In case, Dave interprets
the word ?conceive? as ?imagine? in the second premise of the argument,
this premise becomes untrue. The fact that he cannot imagine something to be the
case does not make it true in everyone?s case. Different minds can imagine
different things. However, if Dave implies ?understand? as a meaning of
?conceive? the second premise still remains doubtful. The fact that Dave
cannot understand it does not exclude the possibility that someone else is
capable to think of his mind as having parts. The next major objection to the
Divisibility Argument concerns first/third-person approach. Mary rejects
Dave?s assumption that the true nature of the mind can be understood solely
through introspection or from the first-person approach. She claims that things
that cannot be conceived through the first-person approach, which is
introspection, can be understood or investigated through the third-person
approach, which is observation and science. Therefore, even if it is true that
the mind cannot be conceived as divided from the first-person perspective, it is
possible that it would be the opposite from the third-person perspective. The
perfect example of that case is the multiple personality disorder. This is the
clear case where the third-person perspective reveals the true nature of a mind
as divided regardless of how it seems from the first-person perspective. As a
response to Mary?s objection, Dave agrees that the second premise in the
argument does not have always a true value that makes the argument unsound.
Therefore, he changes it to ?I cannot conceive of my individual mental states
as having parts.? In the case of the first/third-person approach, Dave relates
to the multiple personality disorder as a case with several minds rather than
one divided mind. In my opinion, Dave does not satisfactorily respond to the
Mary?s objections since he does not give a good reasoning for his point of
view. However, I do believe that the mind is indivisible since there is no such
thing as part of mind. Mind and matter have fundamentally different natures:
matter, which is extended, divisible, passive, and law-like; and mind, which is
unextended, indivisible, active, and free. I definitely agree with Descartes
that the soul occupies the whole body in all its parts, so the reduction of the
body in any way does not reduce the soul. Thoughts, feelings, desires and so on,
are all properties of the mind but not its parts.
Другие работы по теме:
The Argument Culture Essay Research Paper In
The Argument Culture Essay, Research Paper In The Argument Culture, Deborah Tannen describes our adversarial society in debates and dialogues. Tannen discusses our culture?s style of seeing issues, questions, and conflicts as having two sides that battle each other for one goal, victory. She says that not only does this argument culture or culture of critique we live in make life more challenging and alienating, it also reduces the amount of information made available to viewers or information seekers.
How To Argue A Point Essay Research
Paper Writing a persuasive paper can be very simple if you have the right outline and understand how to go about arguing a point. There are three key steps to writing a good persuasive paper. The last key is to clearly state your position so that the reader is not confused as to what position that you are taking.
God Essay Research Paper To say that
God Essay, Research Paper To say that God does exist, is to say that we can prove God exists by describing some proof we have of this statement, or at least a being with what we think some of the attributes of a God would be. Since we cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that God exists we have to infer certain things about how we came to be.
Analyzing An Argument Essay Research Paper Analysis
Analyzing An Argument Essay, Research Paper Analysis of an Argument In Attacking Faulty Reasoning, T. Edward Damer defines an argument as a group of statements, one or more of which (the premises) support or provide evidence for another (the conclusion). The premises of an argument are those statements that together constitute the grounds for affirming the conclusion.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Nature Vs Science Essay Research Paper In
Nature Vs Science Essay, Research Paper In the article The Myth of Beneficent Nature: The Risks of Herbal Preparations , is a persuasive article by Ryan J. Huxtable. In the article Huxtable is arguing that herbal teas and medicines are not healthy and should be band. After reading the article, I disagree with Huxtable, and he was not able to convince me.
Decartes Meditations Essay Research Paper In Descartes
Decartes Meditations Essay, Research Paper In Descartes Meditations he talks about many different things. Two things he talks about are his arguments on Dreams and what he calls the “Evil Demon”. Both of them have to do with deceiving the mind into believing in things that may be untrue.
Aquinas Essay Research Paper According to Aquinas
Aquinas Essay, Research Paper According to Aquinas everything is created was created by God. Aquinas made five proofs to proof the God exists and HE created everything. His five proofs are motion, efficient cause, possibility/necessity, gradation, and governance of the world.
Beef It
’s What’s For Dinner Essay, Research Paper Abstract #1: American Beef Consumption in the United States In my research argument, my working thesis claim will be that American people should consume more of American beef products and be less afraid of, and more correctly informed about, the benefits of eating beef products.
Logic
– Features Of Argumentation Essay, Research Paper Features of Argumentation The logic of everyday argumentation should be based upon common data or information that is accepted by everyone. A warrant need to be used in order to relate the evidence that is presented in an argument to the claim that is being made.
SameSex Marriage Essay Research Paper Samesex Marriage
Same-Sex Marriage Essay, Research Paper Same-sex Marriage The 8th Amendment talks about freedom of speech and freedom of living life. It is not true for everyone to live his/her life by choice. When one ask someone, he/she will tell that they are in favor of equal rights for homosexuals. They will all say that gay should have equal access to government benefits and equal protection of the law, but if someone ask them about gay marriage, all this talk of equality stops.
Indians Essay Research Paper In her argumentative
Indians Essay, Research Paper In her argumentative essay, Jane Tompkins, an avid reader and researcher of the European-Indian relationships, delves into one of the most perplexing aspects of studying history in our world. Because we are such a diverse society–continuously prioritizing the fight for our own causes, there is much room left for the entrance of cultural subjectivity and perspective.
Four Arguments For The Immortality Of The
Human Soul Presented By Plato In The Phaedo. Essay, Research Paper In Plato s Phaedo, he argues that the soul will continue to exist, and that it will go on to a better place. The argument begins on the day of his execution with the question of whether it is good or bad to die. In other words, he is arguing that the soul is immortal and indestructible.
Argument Essay Essay Research Paper In today
Argument Essay Essay, Research Paper In today s society there are many couples that live together. Why let unmarried couples live together? There isn t a specific problem with unmarried couples that live out in the American Society. People are getting divorced left and right in today s age. More than 50% of marriages broke up during the decade of the 90 s.
Socraric Method Essay Research Paper The Socratic
Socraric Method Essay, Research Paper The Socratic Method of philosophy is basically a series of question leading to an answer. In order for this method to work though, two conditions must be met. The first one is that the interlocutor has to say what he believes. The second is that the answers must be kept short.
The Spread Of Nuclear Weapons More May
Be Better Essay, Research Paper The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More May Be Better ??????????? Kenneth Waltz, produces an interesting and semi compelling argument for the use of Nuclear weapons as a way of maintaining the
Censorship Essay Research Paper Probably the most
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Probably the most obvious example of intolerance in our society today is the existence of censorship. I have yet to encounter a valid argument for any form of censorship. Such arguments as are presented invariably take the form of concern for the well being of others , children frequently being the alleged victims quoted .
David Hume Essay Research Paper In reading
David Hume Essay, Research Paper In reading the ideas of David Hume, I have came to believe that he was telling us the miracles don?t exist. They are sort of a ?Mission impossible.? We
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
Descartes Essay Research Paper Descartes
Descartes Essay, Research Paper Descartes’ “Wax Argument” In this essay I will refer to the “wax argument” presented by Rene Descartes and explain that it is a valid argument, but not so sound. In Descartes argument, he observes a piece of wax, from a hive, and using his judgment and senses, analyzes the structure and properties of the wax.
The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism And Materialism
Essay, Research Paper The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism and Materialism I am faced with the philosophical task of defending either dualism or materialism, depending on which one is most attractive to me. So either I support the theory of dualism, which is the belief that there is both a physical and a spiritual state, or I believe in materialism, which is the belief that everything that exists is material or physical.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper Regents for
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper Regents for the University of California v. Bakke The Constitutional grounds which each side based its arguments the 14th amendment s equal protection clause and the civil rights of 1964. The argument for Bakke was based on a policy built on racial quotas. The argument for the University of California was that certain minorities are disadvantages from the day they are born.
Womens Brains Essay Research Paper English 104Essay
Womens Brains Essay, Research Paper English 104 Essay This is a brief summary of the essay “Women’s Brains” by Stephen Jay Gould, published in The Panda’s Thumb in 1980. Gould feals that the study of this is irrelevant to the field that they are studying and that the experiments should not have been conducted.
Human Nature Is Inherently Bad Essay Research
Paper Human Nature Is Inherently Bad There are many theories as to Human nature. One of which exists, under the thoughts of a prominent philosopher, and founder of Psychoanalysis Sigmund
Argument About The Exist Of God Essay
, Research Paper Argument About The Exist of God The following paper will provide a sound argument in favor of the existence of God. By demonstrating that an Atheist world cannot account for the
Cosmological Argument Essay Research Paper How Well
Cosmological Argument Essay, Research Paper How Well Does the Cosmological Argument Hold Water? The Cosmological Argument is one of the most heavily disputed arguments for God’s existence of our time. The argument in its simplest form is: “Everything has to be caused by or created from something else . . . therefore there must be a first cause, namely God.” The very basis of the argument, everything is caused, is what makes it an argument.
Social Role Essay Research Paper About Its
Social Role Essay, Research Paper About Its Social Role Waxing eloquent about stakeholder management and corporate social responsibility is in some circles the surest way to stifle a business conversation, if not a business career. Corporate philanthropy brings satisfaction to those who give and receive, the argument goes, but let us not get carried away by talk of give-aways.
Gffdg Essay Research Paper B A B
Gffdg Essay, Research Paper B A B paper is generally focused on a more particular problem or issue; it reveals that the author has gone through brainstorming
Argument From Design Essay Research Paper Hume
Argument From Design Essay, Research Paper Hume s criticism in regard to the Design Argument, although complex, can be summarized quite simply. It is first important to understand the main elements of the Design Argument. Hume s theory in opposition to that of the Design Argument contests the suggestion that the simple things in the universe must be compared with the greater to appreciate their complexity as a component of the system of the universe.
The Fallacy Of Personal Attack Essay Research
Paper Fallacy of Personal Attack The fallacy of personal attack involves assaulting the arguer rather than the argument. This fallacy is very common. Personal attack is like not accepting a argument
Crosscultural Communication Barriers Essay Research Paper Thesis
Cross-cultural Communication Barriers Essay, Research Paper Thesis: A number of different factors contribute to cross-cultural communication barriers. This thesis will be proven through the examination of Canada?s past history, current policies and future plans concerning immigration and assimilation of immigrants into Canadian society.
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better