, Research Paper
Fodor begins his article on the mind-body problem with a review of the current theories of dualism and materialism. According to dualism, the mind and body are two separate entities with the body being physical and the mind being nonphysical. If this is the case, though, then there can be no interaction between the two. The mind could not influence anything physical without violating the laws of physics. The materialist theory, on the other hand, states that the mind is not distinct from the physical. In fact, supporters of the materialist theory believe that behavior does not have mental causes. When the materialist theory is split into logical behaviorism and the central-state identity theory, the foundation of functionalism begins to form. Logical behaviorism states that every mental feeling has the same meaning as an if-then statement. For example, instead of saying “Dr. Lux is hungry,” one would say “If there was a quart of macadamia brittle nut in the freezer, Dr. Lux would eat it.” The central-state identity theory states that a certain mental state equals a certain neurophysiological state. The theory works in a way similar to Berkeley s representation of objects. Both mental states and objects are a certain collection of perceptions that together identify the particular state or object.
Fodor develops the idea of functionalism by combining certain parts of logical behaviorism and the central-state identity theory. From logical behaviorism, Fodor incorporates the idea that mental processes can be represented by physical if-then statements. As such, behavior and mental causation are no longer distinct and unable to interact. Also, logical behaviorism provides a way for mental causes to interact with other mental causes. This, in turn, may result in a behavioral effect. The last point is also a characteristic of the central-state identity theory. One doctrine of the central-state identity theory is called “token physicalism.” Token physicalism states that all mental states that currently exist are neurophysiological. Thus, token physicalism does not place physical restrictions on the type of substance capable of having mental properties. When the points of logical behaviorism and the central-state identity theory, as described here, are combined, functionalism is the result. The theory of functionalism supposes that a mental state depends upon how a system is put together rather than upon the material which composes the system. Functionalism also states that the output of the system is related to both the input and the internal status of the system at a given time.
Based on the definition of functionalism, the mental processes of a human are not distinct from the systemic processes of a machine. Mental processes are defined as an operation on symbols to yield certain results. Thus, if the same symbols yielded the same results in two separate systems, then the mental states can be seen as similar, or even identical. Along this vein, consider a computer programmed with the same reasoning process as a mind. When the input “B” is entered, the output depends both upon “B” and upon the state of the system resulting from the computation of “A.” If the computer was programmed with the exact same reasoning process as a mind, then the result would be the same. Thus, the mental state of the mind would be indistinguishable from the systemic state of the computer. The computer metaphor upholds the theory of functionalism because the output is the result of interaction between the input and the current state of the system. The metaphor also demonstrates the insignificance of the physical state of the system when determining whether two mental states are alike. Thus, it shows that the processes, rather than the composition, of the system determine the mental state.
Searle disagrees with the view that the physical composition of the system does not influence the mental state of the system. To support this, he develops the Chinese room argument. Suppose a computer program is written that simulates an understanding of Chinese. Thus, when the computer is presented with a question in Chinese, it searches its memory and answers appropriately in Chinese. If the program is written well enough, the answers may be indistinguishable from a native speaker s answers. According to functionalism, then, the computer and the native speaker have the same mental state since the results would be identical. Suppose, though, that a person is placed in a room without knowing any Chinese. They are given a list of what symbols they should collect and how to order them in response to the presentation of a different set of symbols. Around the room, there are baskets containing Chinese symbols. When this person is given a set of symbols, they would be able to consult their list, gather and order their symbols accordingly, and pass them back through the door. If the list was comprehensive enough, then their answers would also be on a par with a native speaker s answers. Again, according to functionalism, the native speaker and the person who does not understand a symbol of Chinese would have the same mental state. Having a mental state is not simply ordering symbols, though. It involves the interpretation of symbols and an understanding of the meanings attached to them. Since the operation of a computer is based solely on its ability to implement programs, the computer only works with symbols without actually understanding what the symbols mean. Thus, this argument helps to demonstrate that syntax alone is not sufficient for semantics.
When we developed the theory of functionalism, we asked the question, “Could a machine think?” In the sense that a machine is just a physical system capable of performing operations, the answer is, “Yes.” This answer is not satisfactory, though, because we generally do not define thinking as simply being able to perform an operation. When we ask the question, “Is implementing a computer program with the right input and output enough to constitute thinking,” the answer is clearly “No.” Thinking refers to an understanding rather than something defined syntactically. No matter how fast or correct the program is, it still defines its operations by syntax rather than by consciousness and emotion. Thus, the computer is unable to duplicate a mind although it may simulate it. The idea of simulation is key here. We are able to simulate everything on a computer from the hypothetical path of a hurricane to the probable course of the stock market. We do not, however, believe the simulations to be real. In other words, we do evacuate a town or invest our life s savings based on a simulation. It may be a good approximation of the course of events, but it is not the actual course of events. If this is the case, then, why do we even consider whether the simulation of mental processes resulting from a computer program are real mental processes?
At the end of chapter two, Searle summarizes his criticism of functionalism in the following way. The mental processes of a mind are caused entirely by processes occurring inside the brain. There is no external cause that determines what a mental process will be. Also, there is a distinction between the identification of symbols and the understanding of what the symbols mean. Computer programs are defined by symbol identification rather than understanding. On the other hand, minds define mental processes by the understanding of what a symbol means. The conclusion leading from this is that computer programs by themselves are not minds and do not have minds. In addition, a mind cannot be the result of running a computer program. Therefore, minds and computer programs are not entities with the same mental state. They are quite different and although they both are capable of input and output interactions, only the mind is capable of truly thinking and understanding. This quality is what distinguishes the mental state of a mind from the systemic state of a digital computer.
Другие работы по теме:
General History Of Essay Research Paper Psych
General History Of Essay, Research Paper Psych Two Take-Home Essay The study of Behaviorism dates can be traced back to the classical Greek philosophers, and goes into the nineteenth and twentieth-century psychology. Below is a list of fundamental psychologists and their contributions.
Central-State Materialism
& Functionalism Essay, Research Paper In my readings of the two chapters from the book, Body and Mind, written by Keith Campbell, I explored my mind to Central-State Materialism and Functionalism. Both these states have differences and similarities between them. Starting off with Central-State Materialism; then, I reflected my readings, and then viewed Functionalism and stated my readings.
Philosophy Of Mind Essay Research Paper In
Philosophy Of Mind Essay, Research Paper In this paper I plan to show that Searle is correct in claiming that his Chinese Room Analogy shows that any Turing machine simulation of human understanding of
Descartes And Searle Essay Research Paper As
Descartes And Searle Essay, Research Paper As a psychology major, one of topics that I find most interesting in philosophy is the mind/body problem. This can be defined as the relationship between the immaterial mind and the material body.
From Unilineal Cultural Evolution To Functionalism Essay
, Research Paper Several anthropological theories emerged during the early twentieth century. Arguably, the most important of these was Functionalism. Bronislaw Malinowski was a prominent anthropologist in Britain during that time and had great influence on the development of this theory. Malinowski suggested that individuals have certain physiological needs and that cultures develop to meet those needs.
Functionalism Essay Research Paper Functionalism is the
Functionalism Essay, Research Paper Functionalism is the sociological theory which holds that each part of society is necessary for the functioning of the social organism. There are several elements in the functionalist paradigm which explain how society functions to maintain the social organism and keep it alive.
Chinese Room Essay Research Paper Through the
Chinese Room Essay, Research Paper Through the use of his famous Chinese room scenario, John R. Searle tries to prove there is no way artificial intelligence can exist. This means that machines do not posses minds.
Psychology Theories Systems And Paradigms Essay Research
Paper Theories, Systems, and Paradigms Psychology is the study of the way people think and behave. The field of psychology has a number of subdisciplines devoted to the study of the different levels and contexts of human thought and behavior that includes theories, systems, and paradigms. Theories, systems, and paradigms have had an important effect on psychology.
Social Conflict Theories Essay Research Paper Conflict
Social Conflict Theories Essay, Research Paper Conflict Theory and Functionalism There are three main theories of sociology; functionalism, conflict theory and symbolic interactionism. This paper will focus on two of those theories, functionalism and conflict theory. The objective is to delineate the assumptions of two out of the three theoretical perspectives and apply these assumptions to an analysis of social stratification.
Functionalism Conflict Theory And Symbolic Interaction Essay
, Research Paper The functionalist thoery can be traced to a movement in the late nineteenth-century under the influences of Darwinism on the biological and social sciences. It is an attempt to understand the world, and it tests the cause and effect of sociological behavior. Some of the more famous functionalists are Charles Darwin, Emile Durkheim, and Horace Kallen.
The Dangers Of Aspartame Discussed And Validity
Of Relevant Studies Questioned Essay, Research Paper The Federal Drug Administration approved aspartame, an artificial sweetener surrounded by controversy, for widespread consumption in 1983. Its brand name, NutraSweet, is a division of Monsanto, a major drug company who acquired G.D. Searle, the original drug company affiliated with aspartame.
Consciousness Essay Research Paper The relation of
Consciousness Essay, Research Paper The relation of consciousness to the material world is puzzle, which has its origin in dualism, a philosophy of mind which posits their fundamental separation. Dualism, in turn, has its roots in folk wisdom. The belief that humans are more than bodies and that there is something in human nature that survives bodily death has its origins in prehistory; it becomes explicit in the mythology of Ancient Egypt and Assyria and was formulated into a philosophical position in the Platonic thought of Ancient Greece.
The Chinese Room Revisited Essay Research Paper
Sam Vaknin’s Psychology, Philosophy, Economics and Foreign Affairs Web SitesWhole forests have been wasted in the effort to refute the Chinese Room Thought Experiment proposed by Searle in 1980 and refined (really derived from axioms) in 1990. The experiment envisages a room in which an English speaker sits, equipped with a book of instructions in English.
Computer Intellect Essay Research Paper A new
Computer Intellect Essay, Research Paper A new issue has come about since the building of computers. But the idea behind it is not such a new issue, for as long ago as Plato and Aristotle, the idea of
Deviance Essay Research Paper Theories of Deviant
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Theories of Deviant Behavior examines various theories and perspectives on conforming and deviant behavior which are products of Western scholarly thought: anomie, functionalism, social disorganization, social conflict, social control, psychoanalysis, status politics, differential association, labeling theory, etc.
Bla Essay Research Paper The democracy we
Bla Essay, Research Paper The democracy we have in America today is very complex. This democracy starts out with political ?parties whose main purpose is to gain control of the government by winning elections?
Philosophers Essay Research Paper Philosophers
Philosophers Essay, Research Paper Philosophers Ever since Descartes said, “I think therefor I am” philosophers have been plagued by the problem of what it means to think and what or who is this ‘I’. The problem is how does the mind work, is the mind something tangible or intangible. Or, as a great philosopher put it “What is mind, doesn’t matter.
Divorce Essay Research Paper Whatever happened to
Divorce Essay, Research Paper Whatever happened to the picture that perfect traditional families portrayed? Television has had such an influence over us when we begin wishing we had families like
The Problem With Dualism Behav Essay Research
Paper Jeff Extra Credit Assignment #1 a.1) The main hindrance for dualism is to explain how something non-physical (mind, soul) is associated with something physical (body). According to dualism, the association between the person (mind, soul) and the body is so intimate that many people falsely believe they are indistinguishable from their bodies.
PostModern American Family Essay Research Paper A
Post-Modern American Family Essay, Research Paper A postmodern family is a family, which has been stripped down from the extended family model consisting of grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins all living together. The postmodern family is an “anything goes family.” It can include stepmothers, stepfathers, half brothers and sisters, and many aunts, uncles, and grandparents.
Individiual Understanding Essay Research Paper Individual UnderstandingI
Individiual Understanding Essay, Research Paper Individual Understanding I agree with functionalists, specifically the strong Artificial Intelligence (AI) camp, concerning the concept of understanding. While John Searle poses a strong non-functionalist case in his AChinese Room@ argument, I find that his definition of Ato understand@ falls short and hampers his point.
Key To Multicultural Education Essay Research Paper
Broadening Our Children?s Horizons: The Key to Multicultural Education John Searle addresses the ?major debate? going on at present concerning? a crisis in the teaching of the humanities.? [Searle, 106] He goes on to defend the canon of works by dead white males that has traditionally made up the curriculum of liberal arts education.
Advanced Artificial Intelligence Essay Research Paper Artificial
Advanced Artificial Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Artificial Intelligence: Cognitive Ability or Information Processing Computers have become an integral part of our everyday lives. We rely upon these machines to perform innumerable tasks that we often take for granted. Most people realize that computers are able to perform the multitude of functions as a consequence of the programming they receive.
The Three Key Concepts Of Sociology In
A Single Parent Family Essay, Research Paper Please do not plagiarism my paper The Three Key Concepts of Sociology Applied to Analyzing Single-Parent Families
How Do You Evaluate One Or More
Of The Approaches To Language Development: Associationist, Cognitive Essay, Research Paper Language development is a very important part of the overall development of the child, and has been a focus of attention for many years. Within the last forty years, there has been a progression of theories which attempt to account for the speed and success of the young child’s acquisition of language – the most recent of which is the functionalist (social interactionist) theory.
Assess The Functionalist And M Essay Research
Paper Functionalism is a predominant perspective in which to analyse the British educational system. The functionalist sees education as a miniature society, where the individual develops a sense of commitment to the social group; it is a place to learn rules where the individual learns to conform to societies cultural norms and values.
Is Sociology Essay Research Paper Is Sociology
Is Sociology Essay, Research Paper Is Sociology a Science? To decide whether or not sociology is a science we must first understand the terminology of the word science. Science literally means knowledge. Systematically observing and analazing a theory made. The information gathered must then be validated over a period of time and the final data then correlated.