Running head: RECOGNIZING AND NURTURING INTRINSIC MOTIVATION
Recognizing and Nurturing Intrinsic Motivation: A Cautionary Tale
Article Critique
Recognizing and Nurturing Intrinsic Motivation: A Cautionary Tale
This article related to the pre-teaching experiences of educators and the necessity for training in the identification of intrinsic motivation in the gifted learner. For far too many years, gifted learners were only thought to be the achievers in the group. Those students that were able to excel in whatever assignment was given or any task at hand were generally those identified as the gifted and talented in the group. This paper implies that this belief continues to be widely held.
Those in teacher training are required to perform a given number of hours of observation in a mentor teacher’s classroom prior to the completion of their program. Without adequate training in the identification of internally motivated behavior, this writer concludes that many of the teacher-identified gifted students would be missed. From the author’s perspective, most of the “pre-teachers” doing the observations in this paper identified the “teacher-pleasers” as the intrinsically motivated in the classroom. Usually this type of student is most responsive to extrinsic motivation, according to the author.
Future teachers need to be trained to recognize the nonconformist gifted learner as well. Too often these students are allowed to fall between the cracks because their true intrinsic motivation is never identified. They are usually labeled early on as a troublemaker or as rowdy. Failure to identify those students that only faintly demonstrate characteristics of giftedness can lead to continual classroom disruptions and the loss of potential for the student.
I could not agree more strongly with the author. Having taught several “vocational” science classes in local high schools, I have met many students that are indeed gifted but are nonconforming ? holding little regard for those that do not seek to understand them on a personal level. There are many strong young minds lost every year because teachers and other professionals are not adequately trained or equipped to identify and differentiate curriculum for these underground students.
According to the author characteristics of the intrinsically motivated student include: students that accept challenges willingly, those that show persistence in difficult tasks, those who exhibit curiosity, remain task-committed, and reflect satisfaction in their own efforts despite the opinion of others. The author sees this motivation as “fueled by students’ psychoacademic needs to control their own decisions.” These students, almost by their very nature, do not exhibit the teacher pleasing characteristics so often identified with the gifted student.
In fact, the author sites research indicating that extrinsic rewards (teacher pleasing) can be devastating to the intrinsically motivated student. This system lessens the ability of the child to learn and work for the satisfaction therein. The author feels these students can lose their perceived power over their decisions much more quickly than the average learner can. In the paper it is described as a “fragile commodity, lost more easily than gained.”
The author concludes by reinforcing the need for teachers to be trained early on in the recognition and nurture of intrinsic motivation in order to foster self-esteem and a safe environment in which the gifted learner can prosper.
References
Lashaway-Bokina, N. (2000). Recognizing and nurturing intrinsic motivation: a cautionary tale. Roeper Review, 22(4), 225-229.
Lashaway-Bokina, N. (2000). Recognizing and nurturing intrinsic motivation: a cautionary tale. Roeper Review, 22(4), 225-229.
Другие работы по теме:
Right Theory Essay Research Paper Right Theory1
Right Theory Essay, Research Paper Right Theory: 1. Rights create obligations, type of moral discourse & involve agents, being who act & are acted upon. People are given obligations to respect your rights. There is no right to obligate other people rights. (Conventional rights: Created by group of people as law or regulation in our society.
Apa Crit Essay Research Paper APA Critical
Apa Crit Essay, Research Paper APA Critical Analysis: Teaching Students How to Learn Vol. 31, No. 6, June 2000 In ?Teaching Students How to Learn? it showed the correlation between high-achieving students and their self monitoring in classes. The article goes on to say that unlike high school, college students do not have the regulation in their classes.
Analysis Of Characters From Different Novels Essay
, Research Paper Throughout literature, the value of a story may be determined through the merit of the characters within. The merit of characters may be judged on three criteria, the first being plausibility or how feasible a certain character is – a characteristic perfectly exemplified in the story “I’m a Fool” by Sherwood Anderson.
Jane Eyre 8 Essay Research Paper Blanche
Jane Eyre 8 Essay, Research Paper Blanche Ingram: Villain? Blanche Ingram is the most important woman, other than Jane Eyre, in the novel. Arguably, she is the most important antagonist in this book. It is difficult to fathom how an absolutely horrid, conceited, venal, apathetic creature could be so vital to the book; but take her away, the motivation, conflict, and character itself crumbles.
Role Of Parenting Essay Research Paper Role
Role Of Parenting Essay, Research Paper Role of Parental Motivational Practices in Children?s Academic Intrinsic Motivation and Achievement (Gottfried)Article SummaryI chose to write my journal article research paper on the role of parents in children?s academic motivation and achievement. The article relates the parent?s role and at home practices, and the effect of these practices on the child?s performance and motivation.
Hunger Essay Research Paper Ever since the
Hunger Essay, Research Paper Ever since the beginning of time, all people have been motivated. Motivated to succeed, motivated to conquer, and motivated to be the best. But what is this thing we call motivation? Motivation is the energizing and directing of behavior, the force behind our yearning for food, our longing for sexual intimacy, and our desire to achieve.
Motivation Speech Essay Research Paper IV BROADCAST
Motivation Speech Essay, Research Paper IV. BROADCAST PROGRAMMING: BASIC LAW AND POLICY The First Amendment and federal law generally prohibit the FCC from censoring material in broadcasting. Stations choose the material they determine as best for their community. The FCC does not advise on artistic standards, formats, grammar or the quality of their programming.
Seregas Essay Essay Research Paper The life
Seregas Essay Essay, Research Paper The life stories of many today s New Yorkers are amazingly similar and different at the same time. For those of us who can call New York our new home, the choice to move to this city has certainly been one of the most important decisions of our lives. Whether or not we came from fifty or five thousand miles away, the hopes for success and brighter future were the sources of our motivation.
Satndpoint Theory Essay Research Paper Standpoint TheoryI
Satndpoint Theory Essay, Research Paper Standpoint Theory I. Introduction A) Dating back to 1800’s Standpoint theory claims that social groups within which we are located powerfully shape what we experience and know as well as how we understand and communicate with ourselves, others and the world.
Good Or Evil Essay Research Paper Is
Good Or Evil Essay, Research Paper Is Man Inherently Good, Bad, Both? Psychologists often struggle with the question does man have inherently good characteristics, or do they lead to the negative. What makes a man act the way he does? Is it nature, hormone imbalances, or the way he is raised? Man s intrinsic characteristics can be good bad or both.
Aristotle On Ethics Essay Research Paper 1
Aristotle On Ethics Essay, Research Paper 1) Explain fully Aristotle?s approach to Ethics. What is the goal of the ethical life? What type of soul is capable of realizing the good life? How do we
My Left Foot Essay Research Paper Often
My Left Foot Essay, Research Paper Often enough, it is very hard to muster up enough courage to begin working on that lab report or thesis paper that is becoming closer to being due. I experienced this feeling when putting my own thoughts together for the writing of this particualr paper. The ambition needed to commence a writing is often very hard to come across for many people, while others find it very easy to become motivated to write that paper.
Kants Morality Essay Research Paper Kant starts
Kant`s Morality Essay, Research Paper Kant starts off making two distinctions regarding kinds of knowledge, empirical/rational and formal/material. Empirical or experience-based knowledge
Evil Is The Nature Of Mankind Essay
, Research Paper “Evil is the nature of mankind” Every man, at a time in his life, is born knowing evil. Evil constitutes the actions and consequences resorted to man. Men, using their natural instincts, are evil by heart but are taught otherwise. The nurturing love and discipline of others transforms evil men into the pure souls they are.
Freedom Essay Research Paper FREEDOM The definition
Freedom Essay, Research Paper FREEDOM The definition of freedom is “the power to act, speak, or think without externally imposedrestraints.” Living in the land of the free gives opportunity to the people to exercise free choice. Interms of education, it means allowing students to learn by intrinsic motivation.
The Nurturing Instinct Essay Research Paper The
The Nurturing Instinct Essay, Research Paper The Nurturing Instinct Can a male survive without his mother at college as well as a female can in performing simple tasks? I believe that it is more difficult for a male to go away to college than it is for a female. A female may inherit a mothering gene, which could give her some ideas of what to do while on her own.
Recongizing A Liar Essay Research Paper
Eng 101-032 25, October 1999 Recognizing a Liar Over the years, I have been exposed to many varieties of liars. From this exposure I have acquired the talent of recognizing the characteristics of a liar. I have managed to separate them in
Kant Essay Research Paper KANTKant begins to
Kant Essay, Research Paper KANT Kant begins to claim that there is nothing in the world that can be regarded as good without qualification except good will. He says that qualities of temperment such as
Divine Command Theory Essay Research Paper Divine
Divine Command Theory Essay, Research Paper Divine Command Theory The divine command theory is the view that moral actions are those which conform to God’s will. Charity, for example, is morally proper because God endorses it, and murder is wrong because God condemns it. One way to test to see whether any action is right or wrong is first to determine if it conforms to God’s will, it is morally permissible, if it does not, then it is impermissible.
Tarnished Thoughts Essay Research Paper TARNISHED THOUGHTS
Tarnished Thoughts Essay, Research Paper TARNISHED THOUGHTS A hot smile rose from the tarnished thoughtsPerched high to display the providence in anarchyRusting noises in the weeds yonderHeavy breath and retreating sighsEvery thought is rendered useless and torn and disposed of like a waste paper sailing in the brisk windWish this could be easier;But in the mirror man only sees what he want;Brainwashed by his own infamy.There is poetry where one addresses his shortcomingsSitting peacefully and recognizing our many incompetences, we re relieved of our need to be better
Personal Statement Essay Research Paper Brendan FarrellPersonal
Personal Statement Essay, Research Paper Brendan Farrell Personal Statement In all circumstances a good academic record is desirable. There are, however, certain conditions in which I find learning is much more enjoyable. An instructor that is excited about teaching young people impacts the mood of the classroom in an astounding way.
Douglas M Mcgregor Essay Research Paper Douglas
Douglas M. Mcgregor Essay, Research Paper Douglas M. McGregor Mr. McGregor theorizes that management views an employee s motivation toward work in two distinct ways Theory X and Theory Y. Theory X managers believe the following: (1) The average worker naturally does not like work and will avoid it whenever possible. (2) Managers must always control, motivate, and direct their employees to perform well. (3) Most workers prefer being directed, avoid responsibility, and seek job security.
Casablanca Essay Research Paper 2
Casablanca Essay, Research Paper “Casablanca:” A New Perspective Throughout history, the film industry has seen many directing styles and techniques. The early part of the 20th century saw a factory style of film production, but as the years went by, director’s began to employ new and untried techniques in their pictures.
Motivation Essay Research Paper Currently Essays
Motivation Essay, Research Paper Currently Essays All SubjectsEnglishHistoryScienceMathReligionGeography Your search found 6 essays. Iago’s Motivation and Malicious Revenge Against Othello – This essay is about the reasons for Iago’s hate for Othello with sited support from the text and other sources.
Grade Essay Research Paper There are a
Grade Essay, Research Paper There are a lot of paths one can take in answering the question What grade would I find acceptable and why? To some D is acceptable. To me, D means barely passing, which means the student has the lowest knowledge of concepts needs to pass. If one has enough will power and motivation, acceptable for them would mean that A would be the only acceptable grade they would deserve.There are a lot of paths one can take in answering the question What grade would I find acceptable and why? To some D is acceptable.
An Essay Analysis Of Learning To Read
? Essay, Research Paper Summary and Purpose ?Learning to Read? depicts how Malcolm X teaches himself to become more than a street hustler. His mere dislike of his lack of writing ability, and his envy of a fellow inmates?(Bimbi) book collection motivates him to become a better writer. Bimbi was his initial motivation.
Is Financial Compensation Beneficial Or Detrimental In
? An Empowerment Program ?? Essay, Research Paper Introduction What is an Empowerment ? Basically empowerment means giving the employee the ability to do their work, i.e. through the right training, the right environment, the right information, the right tools and the authority that they need.
Creative Writing Exercise Essay Research Paper 1
Creative Writing Exercise Essay, Research Paper 1. How does one commit a successful murder? To commit a successful murder you first must have a motive. Then after you have established a motive you must create a plan of attack. You need to come up with a way in which you are going to go about committing this crime.
Parent Essay Research Paper What does the
Parent Essay, Research Paper What does the word parent mean to you? The definition of this word is, one who begets, gives birth to, or nurtures and raises a child; a father or a mother. Yet, one interprets this word difrently depending on what life has had to offer us.
Employee Motivation Essay Research Paper Employee MotivationIn
Employee Motivation Essay, Research Paper Employee Motivation In the following essay I?m going to explain the type of motivation I would choose to motivate employees if I was the manager of a store. I would give examples, highlighting personal experiences that I had as an employee. However, if the motivation method that I intend to use dose not exists, companies should do research to find out which types motivation methods work for each ethic group.