, Research Paper
Both Feudal Japan and Ancient Sparta are
renowned for their outstanding soldiery. Each had distinctly different
military styles owing to the differences in their lifestyles and beliefs.
The Japanese soldier had a balanced view of himself as a whole person,
studying both martial and literary techniques, whereas the Spartan soldier
was born and raised to become a soldier. Both techniques were extremely
successful in developing a fighting force that was the elite of their times.
The Core of feudal japans military force
was the samurai. The development of the samurai in ninth-century Japan
occurred when the centralized aristocratic government lost power to the
local landowners who employed their own armed forces. The heads of these
armed forces were known as the “bushi” or “samurai”, and were for the most
part descended from the old clans (Sato, 1995). The samurai gave their
society moral values and acted as sentinels of peace.
During the shogunate of the Tokugawa family
the samurai as a class were transformed into military bureaucrats and were
required to master leadership skills as well as military arts (Wilson,
1994). This trend became more and more apparent as time went on.
The samurai no longer believed that being a good warrior was all that was
necessary. The samurai now believed that the complete man was one
with a balance of both martial and literate skills. Training now
involved leadership skills, meditation and poetry. By doing this,
the shoguns ensured an army of elite soldiers that had the capacity to
lead others or think for themselves if necessary. This training eventually
had the effect of many warriors reverting to a study of Buddhism.
The training of soldiers was perhaps the
biggest difference between the two civilizations. A Spartan male
was trained for fighting and nothing else from the day he was born, as
opposed to the more all-round training of the samurai. At age six, a Spartan
boy would leave the company of women to live in barracks with other boys
his age. They were given very slim rations and expected to steal whatever
else they needed to eat. The only shame was in getting caught or in not
being strong if punished. There were stories of Spartan boys who died under
punishment. They also were taught military discipline, obedience, toughness
and endurance. Spartans did not consider the arts of reading and writing
necessary. Boys learned the Iliad and songs of war and religion,
however, leaping, running, wrestling, and wielding a weapon with grace
and accuracy were believed to be much more important.
The whole way of life, the constitution
of the state, the system of education of ancient Sparta were calculated
to one end – the maintenance of an army of experts who were ready and able
at any moment to suppress sedition within the state or repel invasion form
without (Michell, 1952). The Spartan was a professional soldier and
nothing else, and his education was directed entirely to two ends – physical
fitness and obedience to authority. Within these two margins the
Spartan soldier was superbly capable. From the moment of his birth
to the time when he was too old to be of any further active use, the Spartan
was subject to discipline. His individuality was submerged to a degree
seldom, if ever, matched by any other country.
This method of training developed a finely
honed soldier that excelled in combat. However, because of the narrow
spectrum of skills studied, a Spartan soldier was simply an excellent soldier
and nothing else. This could be seen as an advantage or a disadvantage
for the Spartan soldier. In one regard he excelled in the art of
combat, on the other, he had little to no skill in any other area.
“The Spartan soldier was exactly that – a soldier. They had no knowledge
of how to do anything else.” (Michell, 1952, pg. 183). However, a
link does exist between the two civilizations – both were willing to die
if necessary to protect their masters.
The Japanese samurai followed their own
code of ethical behavior known as bushido, which remained orally transmitted
for generations (Koya, 1992). Bushido means “Way of the Warrior.”
It was at the heart of the beliefs and conduct of the Samurai. The philosophy
of Bushido is “freedom from fear.” It meant that the Samurai transcended
his fear of death. This gave him the peace and power to serve his master
faithfully and loyally and die well if necessary. Duty is a primary
philosophy of the Samurai. The following text was written in the seventeenth
century by a samurai who had become a Zen Buddhist monk.
“The Way of the Samurai is found in death.
When it comes to either/or, there is only the quick choice of death. When
pressed with the choice of life or death, it is not necessary to gain one’s
aim. We all want to live. And in large part we make our logic according
to what we like. But not having attained our aim and continuing to live
is cowardice. This is a dangerous thin line. To die without gaining one’s
aim is a dog’s death and fanaticism.”
(Wilson, 1994, pg. 253)
This sums up very well the thoughts of
the samurai. A samurai would rather die in battle than face the shame of
failing in his duty. It was this cold disregard for their own lives
that made the samurai and awesome figure in battle. With a clear
mind, a samurai was more prepared for the rigors of battle than any other
soldier he faced.
This was very similar to the Spartan soldier’s
willingness to fight for his state, or to die in the process. It is here
that a comparison of the two systems can be clearly seen. The ideology
of Sparta was oriented around the state. The individual lived and died
for the state. Their lives were designed to serve the state from their
beginning to the age of sixty. “The Spartan soldier was content to
live and die in service of the state.” (Michell, 1952, pg. 168).
The combination of this ideology, the education of Spartan males, and the
disciplined maintenance of a standing army gave the Spartans much needed
stability. Although there were great differences in the two methods,
the basic premise was the same. The Japanese samurai obeyed his lord
unto death, the Spartan soldier obeyed his state unto death.
Another similarity between the two civilizations’
warriors was that of their attitudes towards themselves. Both were
content to live without luxuries that other civilizations found necessary.
The life of a Spartan male was a life of discipline, self-denial, and simplicity.
The Spartans viewed themselves as the true inheritors of the Greek tradition.
They did not surround themselves with luxuries, expensive foods, or opportunities
for leisure. This is the key to understanding the Spartans.
Discipline, simplicity, and self-denial always remained ideals in the Greek
and Roman worlds; civilization was often seen as bringing disorder, enervation,
weakness, and a decline in moral values. The Spartan, however, could point
to Spartan society and argue that moral values and human courage and strength
was as great as it was before civilization (Williams, 1994). As a
result of this, the Spartan men became tough, proud, disciplined, and noted
for obstinate conservatism and for brevity and directness of speech (Michell,
1952). From childhood, life was one continuous trial of endurance
and all gentler feelings were suppressed.
The same was the case for the samurai.
Although the shoguns and the emperor found it necessary to surround themselves
with riches, a samurai’s life was often very harsh. However, a samurai
could, and did during the Tokugawa period, become more influential and
gained a title similar to a Baron. Although there was a trend away
from the more simplistic life of the earlier samurai, they were still prepared
to deal with any situation, no matter the consequences. Their reasons
for doing this were very similar to the Spartan soldier, a matter of honour
and morals.
Clearly, a similarity exists between these
two civilizations’ climaxed warriors. Both had a very strong sense
of duty and honour towards their masters that ultimately showed itself
in the willingness of the soldiers to die if necessary. However, one main
contrast between the two civilizations was their attitude towards training.
The way of life, training and attitude of the Japanese warrior was aimed
towards the complete man as being both martial and literate, whereas the
Spartan soldiers’ training was aimed solely at martial skills. No
matter the method, clearly both civilizations produced a fighting elite
that was one of the best of their times.
Другие работы по теме:
The Movie Ran Essay Research Paper The
The Movie Ran Essay, Research Paper The differences that were peculiar to Japanese culture are the type of clothes they wore the status in the family rank, and the loyalty of the servants to their master.
Lycergus Essay Research Paper LycergusIn ancient Greece
Lycergus Essay, Research Paper Lycergus In ancient Greece, the most feared named was Sparta. It was a total war machine willing to take on all comers. They rose above the rest by being well disciplined and educated. The man who brought them this glory was Lycergus. Like any great leader he was very idealistic.
The Red Badge Of Courage Essay Essay
, Research Paper The Red Badge of Courage is not a war novel. It is a novel about life. This novel illustrates the trials and tribulations of everyday life. Stephen Crane uses the war as a comparison to everyday life. He is semi-saying that life is like a war. It is a struggle of warriors the every day people against the odds.
Athenians Vs Spatans Essay Research Paper Through
Athenians Vs. Spatans Essay, Research Paper Through out history there has been a great deal of great societies to rise and fall from power and fame. Two of the greatest societies still studied to this day are the Athenians and the Spartans. Both societies differ and many different ways but they where both very alike.
Jewish Essay Research Paper Beowulf EssayThere were
Jewish Essay, Research Paper Beowulf Essay There were many differences between Beowulf the play and 13th Warrior the movie. In the play Beowulf was depicted as a soul warrior who?s strength and ability was
Ancient Greece Essay Research Paper Sparta one
Ancient Greece Essay, Research Paper Sparta, one of the powerful city-states, retains this name for good reason. They took over Messenia and used the land wisely, by making a government using the Code of Lycurgus. The Spartan women were given a lot more freedom compared to other Greek city-states; thus, every person provided a part in the development of their city.
Alexander Popes The Rape Of The Lock
Essay, Research Paper Alexander Popes The Rape of the Lock – Write a 3-page critique of Alexander Pope s The Rape of the Lock. Give Examples. – Alexander Pope Rape Lock Comparison Epic Battle Traits Mock Characterization
Akira Kurosawa A Biography Essay Research Paper
Akira Kurosawa was born in Tokyo. His father was a former army officer who became an athletic instructor. At 17 Kurosawa enrolled at an art school and then worked as a commercial artist. In 1936 he got a job as an assistant and scriptwriter to director at Photo Chemical Laboratories, which became better known as Toho Studios (the production company also behind Godzilla, among other films).
Samurai Vs Knight Essay Research Paper Many
Samurai Vs Knight Essay, Research Paper Many people often see little similarity between the country of Japan and Europe. However, there are actually several similarities between these two countries. In fact, Reischauer and Jansen note that Feudal Japan had departed so far from East Asian norms that it was more similar to medieval Europe than it was to China.
The Japanese Samurai Essay Research Paper The
The Japanese Samurai Essay, Research Paper The Japanese have always been known throughout the world for their excellence in battle and warfare. Since Japan is such a small country they needed to use their situation to their advantage. For example, to get an edge over invading attackers they had to use there island as a defense fortifying defense.
Comparative Of Samurai And Medevil Knights Essay
, Research Paper A Brief Comparative Essay on European Knights and The Samurai Warriors The Knights of Medieval Europe and the Samurai of Feudal Japan were similar in some ways and very different in others. Two broad topics I will discuss in this paper are the comparatives in the weapons, armor and tactics; and perhaps most importantly, each warrior-class? code of conduct and ethics.
Growing Up In Samurai Japan Essay Research
Paper Summary ?Growing up in Samurai Japan? by Brenda Ralph Lewis is about the society and history of Japan. This book gives you specific details on the actions of the traditional way of the samurai and Japanese (which are the same, but samurais have different beliefs). This book also mentions how they treat their newborn child, and how strong and strict they follow their beliefs in life.
The Samurais The Ultimate Stoics Essay Research
Paper The Samurais, The Ultimate Stoics For seven centuries, the Samurai were Japan’s warrior class. As a class of warriors and knights, they dominated society in feudal Japan. Their code or ?
Athens And Sparta Essay Research Paper The
Athens And Sparta Essay, Research Paper The country of Greece in 400-500 B.C. was led to greatness by two great city-states. These city-states were Athens and Sparta. These two states were as different as night and day. They were rivals and very diverse. As you read you will find out their differences between their form of culture and government.
Sir Lanval Essay Research Paper Intro paragraph
Sir Lanval Essay, Research Paper Intro paragraph: A warrior is a person that values his country and will protect it at all costs. He is brave and valient and does not care whether he dies in battle just as long as he’s fighting for his country and for a good cause. Sometimes warriors sacrifice their beliefs in the case of love or religion.
Comparison Of The Illiad
’s Achilles And Hector Essay, Research Paper Two of the main characters in Homer s The Iliad, Achilles and Hector, compare very differently in many ways. Although they were both war heroes, they came from different sides of the battle and fought each other under different beliefs. These two brave warriors fought to the death in Book 22, where Hector eventually lost to Achilles.
Massive Monsters Essay Research Paper Massive Monster
Massive Monsters Essay, Research Paper Massive Monster Murders The monster that they call Grendel is on the loose. He has been causing terror to many civilians in Herot for the past 12 years. Murdering and spreading blood shed all across the town. He likes to strike at night, and he will only come out at night when everybody is at rest not expecting the kill.
Comparison Essay Essay Research Paper Comparison EssayThere
Comparison Essay Essay, Research Paper Comparison Essay There are many different ways to explain the beginning and creation. Genesis and Edith Hamilton?s ?Mythology,? are two of many literary works you can find. Both show how characters were created and formed. They give detailed understanding and examples of creation.
Feudal Japan Essay Research Paper During the
Feudal Japan Essay, Research Paper During the period of Japanese history known as Feudal Japan, there were many warring fiefs, orstates, with different lords. Their objective was unifying Japan. and, it couldn’t have been donewithout the help of samurais and ninjas. Samurais had masters and went by a code of conductknown as Bushido.
Sparta Essay Research Paper Sparta Uncultured Discipline
Sparta Essay, Research Paper Sparta: Uncultured Discipline The Spartans were the most formidable warriors in all of history. They dedicated their entire lives to warfare. They were taught to endure cold, hunger, pain, their courage on the battlefield was second to none. The Spartan code was to fight hard, follow orders without question and to die rather then retreat or surrender.
Sparta 3 Essay Research Paper SpartaSparta one
Sparta 3 Essay, Research Paper Sparta Sparta, one of the powerful city-states, retains this name for good reasons. The Spartans faced the problems of overpopulation and land hunger. Their solution was to conquest to gain more land. Almost defeated, the Messenian war cost Sparta a high price. A half-century of war, so hard fought, had ground the military life deep into Spartan consciousness.
Warrior Cultures Essay Research Paper Warrior Cultures
Warrior Cultures Essay, Research Paper Warrior Cultures: The Samurai Through the ages every culture has had their warriors. These warriors have defended and fought for their land, homes, countries, and deeply held beliefs (either political or spiritual). The samurai were self-proclaimed warriors. “The members achieve their reputations by fighting, even killing”(Bohannan 1992).
Ancient Spartan Government Essay Research Paper During
Ancient Spartan Government Essay, Research Paper During the time in which Sparta existed, Spartans were well aware of what to expect in their life. Spartan life was simple, yet disciplined. The government of Sparta was harsh, however it was orderly and stable. Spartan government provided a life in which Spartans were offered few choices, instead, many choices would be made for them.
Militaristic Nature Of Spartan Society Essay Research
Paper Spartan society was structured around the army, always ready to fight or defend if the need arose. Spartan males were the only ones permitted to serve in the army though, and due to the males devotion to warfare the lives of everyone in the polis of Sparta were also greatly affected. This militaristic nature of the Spartans had an impact on the female members of the polis, the helots and the perioeci.
Thematic Analysis Of Kurosawa
’s Sanshiro Sugata And Seven Samurai Essay, Research Paper It is not difficult to speak of thematic dualities in Akira Kurosawa’s Judo Saga (Sanshiro Sugata, 1943) and Seven Samurai (Scichinin no samurai, 1957), and upon inspection, a thematic presentation evolution is identifiable. This giant of the world cinematic community has inspired much discussion, much praise, yet little unified thematic analysis.
Get In Essay Research Paper Click Here
Get In Essay, Research Paper Click Here If YOU Have Friends! Can’t find the paper you need? Try Collegiate Care Comparing Casablanca to 1984 Charlie Parker at Storyville
Comparison Essay Essay Research Paper Comparison EssayTwo
Comparison Essay Essay, Research Paper Comparison Essay Two individuals dominate the late night airwaves, Jay Leno and David Letterman. Leno uses a conservative humor and Letterman’s humor is progressive. While the two shows claim to be different, they both follow the same format. Both shows include a ten-minute stand up routine, strange co-hosts and interviews with celebrity guests.
The 300 Spartans Was It A Reliable
Source Of Historical Information? Essay, Research Paper The film The 300 Spartans is the story of the Battle of Thermopylai , where the 300 strong personal guard of King Leonidas defended a mountain pass at Thermopylai so that Xerxes of Persia couldn t conquer Greece.
Did Sparta Achieve Her Goal Essay Research
Paper Did Sparta Achieve Her Goal? Sparta is the most formidable city known in history. Famous for her impressive military power, she proved that strength didn t lie in numbers, it lay in Spartan discipline. Sparta started out as a small city fighting only to survive against enemy invaders. Her goal was to avoid defeat from other city-states and she very nearly succeeded in achieving it.
Once Were Warriors Essay Research Paper Go
Once Were Warriors Essay, Research Paper Go Back In the movie, Once Were Warriors by Alan Duff, he explains how a family is ruined mainly because of alcohol. Once Were Warriors is a movie that is all about the truth in cultures. As we all know, alcohol usually causes negative behavior. For example, in the movie it shows how alcohol causes violence, poverty, and child abuse in a family.
The Shogun Dynasty Essay Research Paper The
The Shogun Dynasty Essay, Research Paper The term Shogun means general. Later, it refered to the leader of the Shogunate (Samurai’s government). From 1192-1867, the Shogun ruled Japan. The Emperor reigned but did not rule. The Shoguns were a type of warlords that governed providences and states as a type of Japanese check and balance of the 16th century.
The Code Of Bushido Essay Research Paper
In my essay on the Code of Bushido, I will attempt to explain the different sections of the code as well as who used the code that defined Japan’s warrior class, the general history of the code and the honor that accompanies it.
Capture The Satellite Essay Research Paper It
Capture The Satellite Essay, Research Paper It was late in the evening when two astronauts approached the spinning 3,000 pound satellite. They reached out to grab the lost satellite and bring it safely back to the U.S. space shuttle. This may sound like a clip out of a recent science fiction movie, but this is the story of the lost SPARTAN satellite.The SPARTAN satellite was sent up in the U.S. space shuttle.
Saki Essay Research Paper grave set Kira
Saki Essay, Research Paper grave set Kira’s head before it, thus declaring their Lord’s honour redeemed. The Shogun was deeply impressed with the loyalty demonstrated by the 47 ronin. While sympathetic to their heroic act,