Essay, Research Paper
“The democratic deficit is dual in nature”
Demos means people in Greek. Democracy was the name of a constitution in which the poor people exercised power in their own interest as against the interest of the rich and aristocratic. It is commonly accepted that democracy as it is defined by the Western world, is the most appropriate way of organising a society. Democracy as an ideal in the twentieth century has been taken for granted by European people. How can these citizens of Europe exercise their political rights in the ‘ever closer Union’? Democratic deficit is a new problem that the European Union has to face. The Belgian Prime Minister Leo Tindemans in his report to the European council first used this expression in 1974. The problem is becoming even more accurate in the 1990s. As the steps of integration lead the member states to more and more commitment in the region, the peoples of Europe have a growing fear that this United Europe will undermine their national sovereignty. The democratic deficit of the European Union should be understood as a dual phenomenon, horizontally at the European level and vertically at the domestic level.
First, it can be understood horizontally, where there are institutional problems at the European level. The lack of democracy at the European level results with deficits taking place at various institutional levels. The European Parliament is too weak, the Commission is not elected, and finally, the Council of Ministers and European Council are not properly controlled and accountable. When thinking of democratic deficit at the European level, one certainly comes across the weaknesses of the EP, although it is the only institution that enjoys legitimacy, as it is the only directly elected body within the EU. Although it has been elected directly since 1976, its power is the weakest of all EU institutions. Unlike a traditional parliament in a representative system, the EP has not the right to propose bills, enact laws or raise revenue. The EP has certainly increased its power over the years, in the 1984 Draft EU Treaty it obtained co-operation procedure with the Council. Since the Maastricht Treaty, it has the power if co-decision in ten policy areas. But it is only a negative power to block proposals in its entirety. Moreover, its new joint power over budget with the Council of Ministers is limited to non-compulsory expenditure. As Dinan argues, ‘The EP may have acquired some budgetary authority, but as long as the budget remains relatively insignificant and the Parliament cannot raise any revenue its power will remain correspondingly weak’1. The continuing demand for increasing power of the EP has lead to greater rights in amending laws and checking the activities of the other institutions. While the EP has the formal right to dismiss the entire Commission through a vote of censure with two-thirds majority, it is not a stable solution. It would lead to a “eurocrisis” which can destabilise the already fragile system of the EU. However, strengthening the EP would probably not be the best solution in order to democratise the EU. We can wonder just how efficient this institution really is? The EP is often described as a kind of monthly road show2, for MEP’s have to travel constantly between Strasbourg, Brussels and Luxembourg. In this condition, these “nomads” can hardly be efficient in dealing with major issues of the union. About 15% of its budget are actually spent on moving expenses. But most importantly, the relationship between the MEP’s and the domestic electorates and parties is problematic. The participation in EU elections is relatively low in most European countries. Overall, domestic issues dominate Euro-elections more than European issues do. The electorates are hardly aware of the EU parties position. The legitimacy comes from the people, but if these people are not conscious of what is going on at the European level, how can a Parliament emanated from this form of election be legitimised? And how will the EP represent the will of the peoples of Europe?
Then comes the Commission, which can be considered as the executive-bureaucratic body of the EU. It is responsible for developing proposals for new laws and policies. The Commission is responsible to the Parliament but the latter has no direct control over its functions. Article 28 of the Draft Treaty said that ‘the Commission shall be responsible to the Parliament’. And, ‘the members of the commission shall resign as a body in the event of Parliament’s adopting a motion of censure by a qualified majority’3. The Commission should draw its legitimacy from the EP, which is supposed to be the most legitimate institution, as it is the only directly elected body. Thus, the Commission can become a real government at the European level. Some have suggested direct election in order to stimulate popular interests. For the time being, there is a lack of balance of powers because the Council of Ministers is just too powerful. This is the consequence of national governments that do not want to loose their national sovereignty.
The Council of Ministers is no doubt the most powerful institution within the EU. It is the real decision-making body of the EU, and a completely independent institution; the members of the Council are neither drawn from nor directly answerable as a body to the EP4. The most powerful institution lacks in accountability as a collective entity. Often, its work is secret and opaque, which makes it even more difficult for the European people to understand the role and the work of the EU. The citizens of Europe have difficulties to identify who exactly governs in the Union and cannot exercise their own prerogative to dismiss them at elections.
The European institutions are incomprehensible for everyday people, the EU is seen as inaccessible and opaque, which exacerbates the problems of accountability. The EU does not conform to the ideal democracy, which is based on the balance of powers between legislative, executive and judiciary. It looks more like the American model where there is a strict separation between the different institutions of power.
The democratic deficit can also be understood vertically. In that sense it can be defined as the gap between the power held by European institutions and the ability of European citizens to influence the work and decisions of those institutions. The Maastricht Treaty defined that the goal of European integration is to create ‘an ever closer union among the people of Europe, in which decisions are taken as closely as possible to the citizen’5. Promoting a people’s Europe is the most urgent objective to achieve, then the EU can become more real and close to the citizens of Europe. If the EU is to be more accountable to its citizens, it still has lots to achieve. The deficit can be understood on the domestic scale where it is claimed that the transfer of power has diminished the internal accountability of government. Since the 90’s there is a growing distrust in public institutions at national level. In 1991, 72% of respondents claimed that their country’s membership was a good thing, that proportion was only 49% in autumn 19976. Moreover, the introduction of the qualified majority since 1987 by the SEA made the domestic control even more difficult. A national voter can find himself deceived by the representatives he has elected to represent his will when he is outvoted in the Council of Ministers. So how much is a government responsible for a policy on which it was outvoted? The voters have thus very little or hardly any impact on the decision-making process as well as national parliaments. Indeed, the EU, national governments are predominant to parliament. The executives have the monopoly of information and can decide not to inform the Parliament. That gives enormous advantages to the Executive over domestic politicians. For they do not need to consult the national parliament before agreeing to legislation. But increasingly, most parliaments try to secure commitments from their government that they will be fully informed and consulted on EU policies. Denmark provides a good example. It has a very rigorous parliamentary system, which ensures close co-operation between the Executive and the parliament in policy-making.
New developments within the EU lacked the support from its citizens. The deficit of knowledge is another problem that exists within the EU. Most people are not aware of the EU issues, which might affect them some how in their everyday life. In a 1997 poll, people where asked how much they knew about the EU, and 13% admitted that they knew nothing at all and only 6% thought that they have a good knowledge about it. In this context, it is very difficult to develop a sense of belonging to the EU. And as long as they know so little, they will not make their views known. This will perpetuate the democratic deficit7. In this perspective, the democratic deficit and the knowledge deficit are tightly linked to each other.
The democratic deficit can therefore be understood horizontally and vertically, at the European level as well as at the national level. That is why it is dual in nature. The debate about democracy leads immediately to the question of legitimacy. The EP enjoys direct elections but is the weakest institution of the EU. It is obvious that the EU needs to find a solution and that is precisely why institutional changes are programmed in the coming year. For the time being, there is only an indirect form of legitimisation via the EP and the member states. If the integration is to be lead to further transfer of power, it requires more than a basic debate on the need for more transparency and openness. The Amsterdam Treaty is no doubt a big step forward to democratising the EU, however to date it simply remains a written document, whose content must be implemented in the future. Nevertheless, the democratic deficit will not be resolved simply by increasing the EP power or by introducing direct election for the Commission. Regardless of these problems, the European Union is a unique, sui generis organisation and thus cannot be compared with existing features. It will demand lots of imaginations and creativity to ensure that this new regionalism will get the support of its citizens.
Другие работы по теме:
Financial intermediation
Financial intermediation is an activity of financial intermediaries. A financial intermediary is an institution that links lenders with borrowers, by obtaining deposits from lenders and then re-lending them to borrowers. The role of financial intermediaries in an economy, such as banks and building societies, is to provide means by which funds can be transferred from surplus units in the economy to deficit units.
High Schools Should Not Rely On Standard
Achievement Scores Essay, Research Paper High Schools Should not use Standardized Achievement Scores to Determine Whether Students Should be Promoted, Without Regard to Course Grades
Romantics Vs Realists Essay Research Paper Views
Romantics Vs Realists Essay, Research Paper Views of Nature Romantics verse Realists and Naturalists have different views of nature. In this essay I will portray how Romantics see nature, and then how Realists and Naturalists together see nature. It will show how Romantics had a deepened appreciation of the beauties of nature.
Where I Lived
&What I Lived For–Thoreau Essay, Research Paper In ?Where I Lived & What I Lived For,? Thoreau?s response towards nature is of admiration and value. His respect for nature is almost religious. This is depicted in the way he describes his love and adoration for nature.
Farmers Want Subsides Restored Essay Research Paper
Farmers want subsidies restoredThe Toronto Star, November 2000Marzena Brzyszcz In the early 1990s Ottawa had a $40 billion deficit, at which time it had slashed farm subsidies. Now that the federal government has eliminated the budget deficit, Canada s top farmer leader said, it is time to start helping farmers who are in need.
The Causes And Consequences Essay Research Paper
Mr. Chairman and members of the Senate Finance Committee: Thank you for allowing me to testify on the causes and consequences of the U.S. trade deficit. The economic turmoil in East Asia has thrust America’s trade deficit back into the news. Perhaps no aspect of American trade is talked about more and understood less than the trade deficit.
Attention Deficit Disorder Essay Research Paper The
Attention Deficit Disorder Essay, Research Paper The First Lady Hilary Rodham Clinton and the Clinton Administration has proposed to increase focus and funding for research on the use of psychotropic medications in very young children. The recent reporting of stories in the news media documenting the increased use of psychotropic medications in children under five years old, for conditions such as ADD and depression, has appropriately raised concerns among parents, health care professionals, and legislators.
Democratic Deficit In The EU Essay Research
Paper The European Union continues to play an important role in traditionally domestic areas of policy, but many people however see the union as distant, and believe they have
Surplus California Is Running A Deficit Essay
, Research Paper As California’s electricity crisis unfolded, there was much talk about using the state’s “surplus” to fend off high energy costs. Indeed, in recent years the surplus has been regarded as the answer to just about any social need in California. There is just one problem, evident in the governor’s budget documents but ignored by the public and the Legislature.
US Budget Deficit Good Or Bad
Essay, Research Paper Beginning with the “New Deal” in the 1930s, the Federal Government came to play a much larger role in American life. President Franklin D. Roosevelt wanted to use the full powers of his office to put an end the Great Depression. He and Congress greatly expanded Federal programs. Federal spending, which totaled less than $4 billion in 1931, went up to almost $7 billion in 1934 and to over $8 billion in 1936.
Attention Deficit Disorders Essay Research Paper Attention
Attention Deficit Disorders Essay, Research Paper Attention Deficit Disorder Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), and Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) are increasingly being discussed, at least to some extent, interchangeably. It has captured the attention of educators everywhere, and victims are most frequently referred to the case worker within the respective educational institution.
Famous People And Their Philosophies Essay Research
Paper 1. Thomas Hobbes - State of Nature- The state of nature is war. There are no morals in the state of nature, justice is non-existent. He claims that the supreme power determines justice, in a state of nature, there is no power.
Constitutionalism The Tyranny Of The Majority Essay
, Research Paper In this excerpt from Democracy in America Alexis Tocqueville expresses his sentiments about the United States democratic government. Tocqueville believes the government’s nature exists in the absolute supremacy of the majority, meaning that those citizens of the United States who are of legal age control legislation passed by the government.
Bill Clinton Redefines DemocraticRepulican Essay Research Paper
Bill Clinton - Redefines Democratic-Republican In the early 1800’s, the United States was but a promising seedling in search of viable political direction. The initial parties were known as the federalists and the Democratic-Republicans, the first of which soon diminished and the later eventually bisected.
What Is The Impact In The European
Union From A Democratic Perspective Essay, Research Paper What is the impact in the European Union from a democratic perspective? After World war two some European countries (Italy, Germany, France and the Benelux) in order to avoid new conflict started a process of economical integration that led nowadays to the E.U. .
The Dual Qualities Of Nature Romeo And
Julliet) Essay, Research Paper The Dual Qualities of Nature (romeo and Julliet) Everything in life has the potential to be both good and evil. In Shakespeare’s tragedy Romeo and Juliet, there are many contrasts between, people, words, things, and actions. Shakespeare warns us that nature is the source of both life and destruction.
Slavery Essay Research Paper SlaveryWhen I think
Slavery! Essay, Research Paper Slavery! When I think of government, the first type that comes to mind is a democratic government. I am most used to it because I live in, theoretically, a democratic society. So with that, my views are based on a democratic ideal. First, the reason I think people establish governments is so that they can work together as a whole to attain a better life.
Define Democratic Government Essay Research Paper 1
Define Democratic Government Essay, Research Paper 1. Define Democratic Government. Suggest three Democratic inadequacies in Britain today. Democratic government is a political system based on the principles of freedom and equality. Democratic government mental systems embrace multi-party Parliament.
Cad Essay Research Paper Explain what is
Cad Essay, Research Paper Explain what is meant by a Current Account Deficit and why is it considered ‘bad’ to have an increasing CAD? The Current Account Deficit generally means that our nation is spending more than it earns. This means that we have to borrow from other countries in order to pay for the things we purchase (imports).
Verdict Of Political Leaders Essay Research Paper
Verdict of Political Leaders Political leaders have many responsibilities. However their personal life should not be interfered with their business life. If political leaders make poor decisions pertaining to their personal lives, there?s a possibility that they will make poor decisions in their business life.
Adhd Essay Research Paper ADHDUnderstanding the ProblemUnderstanding
Adhd Essay, Research Paper ADHD Understanding the Problem Understanding the Problem | Getting Help | Sustaining Hope This three-part article provides an excellent overview of the current state of knowledge regarding a disorder that is often called the most “over-diagnosed” mental problem–attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or ADHD.
The Ancient City Essay Research Paper The
The Ancient City Essay, Research Paper The Ancient City Pompeii How democratic was Pompeian politics? In order to answer the above question, it is first necessary to consider the exact meaning of the term democracy . Whilst it is difficult to give an exact definition of the word, it is certainly possible to create a list of the implications of democratic government for a society and its citizens.
Election 1984 Essay Research Paper Thank you
Election 1984 Essay, Research Paper Thank you Let’s take a look back at the presidential election of 1984. The primary candidates in this election were Ronald Reagan for Republican, and Walter Mondale for Democratic.
Deficit Friend Or Foe Essay Research Paper
Deficit: Friend or Foe In the essay ?Why is the Deficit a God Send and Five Other Economic Heresies? by Walter Russell Mead he discusses the concepts of national debt and budget deficit. Both the debt and the deficit have some positive and negative consequences. The deficit can play a positive role in an economy in economic growth.
Declaration Of Independance And The Constitution Essay
, Research Paper Throughout the history of the United States of America, America has strived to find the best form of government to please its people. The founding fathers have felt firsthand the effects of bad government which is partially responsible for the need to establish their own country. The Declaration of Independence sets the standards for how a government should be set up.
Fiscal Policy Essay Research Paper Supposing the
Fiscal Policy Essay, Research Paper Supposing the status quo of the United States today states that: there is no real unemployment, the consumer price index is rising at 2 percent annually, and the federal government budget deficit, 200 billion dollars, is equal to 5 percent of the gross national product.
Mother Nature Essay Research Paper Nature has
Mother Nature Essay, Research Paper Nature has a certain presence or spirit. It s an almost indescribable feeling just to go out to the middle of the sea or into a forest and just sit there in awe of its beauty. Nature has a certain mystique and mystery to it that draws people to it. Nature, described as mysterious and secretive, is a recurrent theme throughout many stories.
Dual Education Programs Essay Research Paper In
Dual Education Programs Essay, Research Paper In the United States, more and more students are learning and achieving academic excellence in dual language programs. These two-way bilingual programs integrate students who were raised speaking different languages to promote and provide learning and language development in two languages (Christian).
Federalism Essay Research Paper The Change of
Federalism Essay, Research Paper The Change of Federalism Federalism is derived from the meaning of federal; which is defined as: pertaining to the nature of a union of states under a central government distinct from the individual governments of the separate states. What this explanation means in everyday terms is that, federalism consists of the national government, the state government and the local government all having one central body of government.
The National Debt Essay Research Paper The
The National Debt Essay, Research Paper The National Debt For the past centuries, the american people dug themselves into a big hole which is the National Debt. In this paper I will discuss the history of the national debt, effects on the debt/deficit, wais to reduce it and control the deficit. the national debt has increased every year from 1945 to 1995.
Napoleon Essay Research Paper NapoleonThere are never
Napoleon Essay, Research Paper Napoleon There are never ending inquiries on the nature of Napoleonic power. But reason can prove to one that the Age of Napoleon was infact a time of democratic rule. Through Political, Social, and Economical reforms, Napoleon Bonaparte did not only transcend France, but he changed the course of history for Europe and the World today.
Budget Essay Research Paper THE BUDGETTo pass
Budget Essay, Research Paper THE BUDGET To pass a budget deal takes a lot of time and work. There are many factors involved in this long process. The President first has to propose a plan to balance the budget. He has to look at the Federal deficit and talk with Congress. Congress then will negotiate or compromise a plan of their own with the President.