Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper
?We Should Retain The Disease Concept Of Alcoholism Analysis Essay?
In ?We Should Retain the Disease Concept of Alcoholism,? George E.
Vaillant asserts that alcoholism should be treated as a disease. I think the
author has done an effective job in proving his case by using his own personal
experience that gives him authority to make an argument in this issue and his
use of rhetoric.
In his argument essay, he sets himself up as the authority by discrediting
most academics and scholars who have been considered to be ?the best and the
brightest? in discussing this issue. He claims they lacked personal
experience, the one qualification that was the most important in explaining why
alcoholism is not a disease. The effectiveness of using personal experience is
it gives the author merit while at the same time discrediting the scholars that
oppose his claim. It lets the reader know that Vaillant knows what he is talking
about and is able to give a valid argument.
In the writer?s reasoning, Vaillant gives support to his thesis by giving
refutations for each of the five objections that oppose his claim. He uses many
different rhetorical devices to prove alcoholism is a disease, such as
comparisons, figures of speech, rhetorical questions and an anecdote, as well.
Throughout the essay, the author effectively proves his point by using
comparisons. For example, in the author?s first refutation, he compares high
blood pressure, coronary heart disease and alcohol abuse. He explains that the
causes for alcoholics are similar to those diseases in that both are ?differently
weighted for different people and include culture, habits, and genes.? By
making this comparison, it immediately makes the reader see the similarities
between alcoholism and other diseases.
He also uses repetition in the diseases he uses for comparison. An example of
this is the use of coronary heart disease and hypertension more than once in the
essay. The purpose of this is to help the reader understand these diseases more.
It also serves as a reminder to the reader on how these diseases play a major
role in alcoholism.
In one point, Vaillant tries to prove if alcoholics are labeled with a
disease, they will become more willing to take responsibility for self-care. To
prove this, he uses a rhetorical question of leprosy. He asks the reader, ?Should
a doctor who knows that a person who has leprosy keep the fact secret lest the
patient be labeled a leper?? The obvious answer is no. It is important for
patients to acknowledge that they have a disease so they can take responsibility
for themselves. The same goes for alcoholics. He puts in the example of
Alcoholics Anonymous, placing alcoholism as a disease to support his argument.
The author also uses figure of speech to his advantage. In his argument, he
tries to point out that alcohol abuse causes depression, anxiety and poverty,
not the other way around. He states that ?Fingarette reverses the position of
cart and horse.? It is this particular phrase that catches the reader?s
attention. He first refers to Fingarette as one of the academics and then
discredits her by his figure of speech that she reverses the position of cart
and horse. She obviously views psychological problems as a cause for alcoholism,
when it should be the other way around. Her idea of alcoholism is wrong,
therefore she cannot be viewed as an authoritative figure in this issue.
Vaillant ends his essay with an anecdote that shows a contradiction between
ideas of his associate. In the anecdote, he shows how personal experience is the
most important factor in discussing this issue. His associate first believed
that alcoholism was a behavioral disorder and not a disease but after thinking
about the tortured lives she had been studying, she realized that she had been
wrong all along. It leaves the reader knowing that if you have worked in a
clinic for about two years that you would come to the conclusion that alcoholism
has to be viewed as a disease.
In conclusion to my analysis essay, I discovered that the author is a very
intelligent person that cares for this subject. Before reading the paper, my
opinion on this subject was impartial. After reading, I became convinced by the
writer that alcohol is a disease. I thought his uses of authoritative language
throughout his essay helps lure the reader into agreeing with him. Right from
the beginning of his essay, he approaches his topic with authority. He tells the
reader that he has the qualifications to present a good and intelligent
argument.
Другие работы по теме:
2Nd Law Of Thermodynamics Vs E Essay
, Research Paper Second Law of Thermodynamics vs. Evolution According to the second law of thermodynamics, when energy is converted from one form to another, the amount of useful energy decreases. In relation to the theory of evolution, this law is not contradictory. The second law of thermodynamics is not relating to energy within living things because living things retain energy from the sun.
Tragic Situation In Innu Community Essay Research
Paper Until 30 years ago the Innu were nomadic hunters in the forests of eastern Canada. Today they live in communities with high rates of suicide, alcoholism, child abuse and family violence. Canada seems intent on destroying the Innu’s land – their sole hope of survival – with a series of mega-projects, which it is pushing despite the fact that the Innu have never signed away their land.
Booze And Loose Essay Research Paper Booze
Booze And Loose Essay, Research Paper Booze and Loose Alcoholism is a disease which can be found in many American homes. It can have both short and long term effects on the way a person thinks and acts. This in return can destroy a families relationship, a persons mental health as well as a person future.
AlcoholismA Essay Research Paper AlcoholismAlcoholism is a
Alcoholism(A) Essay, Research Paper AlcoholismAlcoholism, is a illness involving the excessive use of alcoholic beverages, whether it’s a can of beeror other sources such as vodka, and whiskey etc. It often affects a lot of people and their families. Iwill discuss the symptoms of alcoholism. I will continue into the effects of alcoholism.
Alcoholism An Intrepretation Essay Research Paper Alcoholism
Alcoholism An Intrepretation Essay, Research Paper Alcoholism has been a problem throughout the history of humanity, a disease which has caused many people to be overcome with burdens, problems, and debts. Alcoholism is a term that is widely recognized throughout the United States and the World. Alcoholism is a chronic disease, progressive and often fatal; it is a disorder and not due to other diseases or emotional problems.
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
Alcohol Essay Research Paper The Affects of
Alcohol Essay, Research Paper The Affects of Alcoholism Drinking for many starts as a seldom habit. We may drink for strictly social reasons, but for some the problem becomes uncontrollable. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn demonstrates the affect alcohol has on Huck. But, alcohol affects more than just one person it affects a whole community.
Problem Of Alcoholism Essay Research Paper The
Problem Of Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper The Problem of Alcoholism Alcoholism is a disease in which a person has an overwhelming desire to drink alcoholic beverages. A person who has this desire is called an alcoholic because he/she feels forced to drink. Alcoholism is considered one of the most serious problems in the world.
Alcoholism And Teens Essay Research Paper Alcoholism
Alcoholism And Teens Essay, Research Paper Alcoholism refers to the drinking of alcoholic beverages to such a degree that important things of an individual’s life – such as work, school, family relationships, or personal safety and health; are seriously and repeatedly interfered with. Alcoholism is considered a disease, meaning that it follows a characteristic course with known physical, and social symptoms.
Teenagers Problems Essay Research Paper Teenagers problemsToday
Teenagers Problems Essay, Research Paper Teenagers problems Today in the modern society, there a lot of problems, especially problems related with teenagers. A lot of factors influenced in this situation. For example some teenagers felt lack of love from their parents. Another factor is the lack of education because of poverty.
Hepititus Essay Research Paper Hepatitis ABCHepatitis is
Hepititus Essay, Research Paper Hepatitis A,B,C Hepatitis is a medical disease, which causes inflammation of the liver; your liver is an organ on the right side of your abdomen. The liver purifies your blood. The Hepatitis C virus is the second behind alcoholism among causes of liver disease and is the leading reason for liver transplants.
Underage Drinking Essay Research Paper Underage drinking
Underage Drinking Essay, Research Paper Underage drinking is a major problem for many of today?s youth. It can lead to teenage alcoholism and even death. It is not singled out to one race, age, or region. It can be found among the wealthiest doctors, lawyers, and businessmen?s children, and yet the poor factory worker?s child becomes that teenage alcoholic too.
Alcoholism Essay Research Paper HTMLFONT SIZE3
Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper HTML**FONT SIZE=3 PTSIZE=10*Clearly alcohol was in charge and had been for years. It led the way by making our decisions and settling all of our critical issues. I,
Sobriety Essay Research Paper SOBRIETYSevere mood swings
Sobriety Essay, Research Paper SOBRIETY Severe mood swings, violent rages, memory loss—each of these problems were a part of my family life during the past two or three years. These problems are the result of alcoholism. Recently, a member of my family realized his abuse of alcohol was a major problem to not only himself, but also to those around him.
Is Alcohol Harmful To Our Life Essay
, Research Paper So much information about adverse effects of alcohol is known. Yet, a large number of people condone what is known to them. Overlooking the negative effects of alcohol can turn the alcohol into a deadly weapon. Alcohol can cause deaths, diseases, and family problems.
Major Harris Essay Research Paper Anthony Paletti
Major Harris Essay, Research Paper Anthony Paletti Com 103 I wanted to inform the audience about the dangers of alcohol, and how alcohol effects pregnant mothers, the brain, and the liver. I also wanted the audience to know what alcoholism is and what kinds of behaviors can cause alcoholism. I think the audience knows a little bit about alcoholism and the other risks of consuming alcohol, but I think the audience does not take these dangers seriously.
Alcoholism Essay Research Paper AlcoholismAlcoholismAn overwhelming desire
Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper Alcoholism Alcoholism-An overwhelming desire to drink alcohol, even though it is causing harm. Alcohol is a drug. In the United States alcoholism is the most widespread form of drug abuse, effecting at least 5 million people. About one third of high school students in the US are though to be problem drinkers.
Alcoholics Anonymous Essay Research Paper Alcoholics Anonymous
Alcoholics Anonymous Essay, Research Paper Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is perhaps the best known and most successful alcoholism recovery program. Founded in the United States in 1935 by Dr. Robert Smith and Bill Wilson, by the 1990s the organization had grown to more than 93,000 groups in 131 countries, with an estimated membership of over 2 million.
Effects Of Alcoholism Essay Research Paper Effects
Effects Of Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper Effects of Alcoholism Growing up in a family with daily alcohol use as a way of life can have a profound effect on a young child’s mind. Most of the time this situation would seem to have a negative effect on all the people surrounded by this problem. Sometimes it can be a blessing in disguise depending on how it is looked at.
Alcoholism Essay Research Paper AlcoholismAlcohol is a
Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper Alcoholism Alcohol is a legal drug and is readily available, yet alcohol is more powerful and addictive than most drugs in the black market. It is also found in almost every society. Alcohol has been defined as the inability of a person to guarantee its behavior after the first drink.
Causes Of Alcoholism Essay Research Paper Causes
Causes Of Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper Causes of Alcoholism Alcoholism is a disease that affects many people. It not only affects the alcoholic, but also their family, friends, co-workers, and strangers. The symptoms are many, as are the causes and the effects. Alcoholism is defined as an addiction to alcohol.
Alcoholism Essay Research Paper AlcoholismBy Andrew Dana
Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper Alcoholism By Andrew Dana Allen “What is alcoholism?” Alcoholism itself is a chronic illness that is characterized by the habitual consumption of alcohol to a degree that interferes with physical, mental and social health. Alcohol is a depressant that will release feelings of guilt, anxiety and remorse if taken in heavy quantities.
Alcoholism Essay Research Paper Alcoholism
Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper ALCOHOLISM “It discloses secrets; ratifies and confirms our hopes; thrusts the coward forth to battle; eases the anxious mind of its burthen; instructs in arts. Whom has not a cheerful glass made eloquent! Whom not quite free and easy from pinching poverty!” (Horace first century B.C.) Initially, I wanted to write this paper on substance related disorders.
College Alcoholism Essay Research Paper Alcohol consumption
College Alcoholism Essay, Research Paper Alcohol consumption has been an issue across college campuses for many decades. College students have made alcohol the representation of student life at colleges throughout the nation. Students believe that getting intoxicated is necessary to make their college experience unforgettable.
Functions Of Memory Essay Research Paper THE
Functions Of Memory Essay, Research Paper THE FUNCTIONS OF MEMORY Memory is the ability to remember past events, images, ideas, or previously learned information or skills. Memory is also the storage system that allows a person to retain and retrieve previously learned information.
People With Disabilities Essay Research Paper My
People With Disabilities Essay, Research Paper My Left Foot, The Elephant Man, and Mask are all movies about people with disabilities. These three movies depict the lives of three men and the way