Cultures’ Responses To The Same Disease Essay, Research Paper
Notes: This was written by Noah Feinberg for history 139A at UC Davis with Prof. Findlen It recieved an ‘A’ even though
I wrote it in a few hours. Hope it comes in handy, it possibly might be used for a religious studies class as well.
Secular medicine and its attitudes towards leprosy in medieval Christian and Islamic communities were
influenced by social and religious traditions. Lack of real medical knowledge allowed these influences to affect the
understanding and treatment of disease, as well as the status of the leper in society. Medieval views of leprosy in
Christian and Islamic societies illustrated these ideas. Despite their different cultures and religions, there were some
similar and analogous trains of thought in the understanding of this disease, but different attitudes prevailed as well.
Treatment and understanding of leprosy in European society reflected many Christian ideas. Fear of contagion
and the unpleasant sight of the disease’s symptoms led to the practice of separating the leper from the rest of society
(Palmer, p.80). This practice also reflected the biblical idea of the leper found in Leviticus, which calls for the “unclean”
leper to be cut off completely from society. In some areas priests performed Levitical rituals of separating the leper from
society (Palmer, p.81). Lepers had their own special hospitals and churches outside of town and city walls, and had to
dress in special garb identifying their affliction. Leper hospitals were under civic control, but religious influence
manifested itself in these institutions. At a hospital in Verona, Italy, statutes required incoming patients confess to the
hospital chaplain to gain admission (Palmer, p.85). Lepers could lose legal rights in some areas; being considered already
dead, their wives could remarry and they could lose control of their will (Palmer, p.81).
Ideas as to the cause and treatment differed, but there were two main conflicting themes regarding the cause
found in medieval Christian society. One idea of the cause of leprosy was sin. Sin in this case especially meant lechery.
Many physicians accepted the idea that leprosy was God’s punishment for sexual excess, and described lepers as sexually
depraved. Leprosy was though to be spread venereally (Palmer, p.82). However, another idea of leprosy conflicted with
the sinner scenario. The other idea regarded lepers as being singled out by God to suffer in their earthly life, redeeming
their sins for the afterlife (Palmer, p.84). Again, biblical precedent explained this view with the story of Lazarus and the
rich man: Sufferings in this world were compensated for in the next. (Luke 16: 19-25, as reprinted in Palmer, p.84). The
treatment lepers obtained often depended largely on their faith either in medicine or religion. The Christian church
advocated righteous living including vows, pilgrimages, processions, and charity work to prevent acquiring the disease.
This emphasized the importance the church placed on healing the soul over the body (Siraisi, p.8). For those already
afflicted, praying for forgiveness and acts of piety offered possibility of a cure. The most popular religious treatment
involved praying to certain saints, along with pilgrimages to their shrines with the hope that the saint would intercede
with God on their behalf. Lepers would eat and sleep outside the saints tomb, waiting to be cured (Palmer, p.87). If a
leper sought treatment from a physician, it would usually consist of phlebotomy, drug, and regimen therapy to rid bad
humors from the system.
Medieval Islamic society differed from European ideas, but parallel themes were evident. Islamic society dealt
with leprosy in many similar ways as Christian society did. Avoiding contact with lepers was one such way. Mohammed
the Prophet stated the Muslims should flee from a leper as they would flee from a lion. Another tradition stated that the
healthy should not be around lepers for long periods of time, and “should keep a spear’s distance from them.” (Dols,
p.895). Another parallel theme was the idea that leprosy was God’s punishment for immorality, but this idea was not
nearly as widespread and influential as it was in Christian Europe. Lepers in Islamic society also had their legal rights
limited in similar ways as European lepers. Despite these similar themes, there were many fundamental differences in
their place in society, treatment, and understanding of the disease.
Unlike Christian society, lepers did not always face total exile from the community, although in some areas
lepers were segregated in leprosaria (Dols, p.898). Lepers did not face stigmatization to the extent that European lepers
did. The Koran did not have any passages comparable to Leviticus, so Muslims did not have a religious reason to create a
special group for lepers and totally exile the afflicted as the Christians did (Dols, pp.913-914). Islamic society’s lack of
concrete social strata and need of belonging to groups as found in Christian society also helps explain why lepers did not
face such extreme persecution in Islamic society. Mild cases of leprosy could be treated in the home, reflecting the sense
of familial responsibility in Islamic society dating to antiquity (Dols, pp. 914-915). The medical treatment of leprosy was
different in Islamic society. Unlike most Christians in Europe, Muslims favored hot spring therapy for the disease.
However, many of these hot springs were shrines associated with religious deities, reflecting the hope of divine
intervention to cure the ailing leper in Islamic as well as in Christian societies (Palmer, pp. 903-905).
In conclusion, treatment and understanding of leprosy varied considerably in Christian and Islamic societies.
Christian Europe adopted Levitical law in dealing with lepers, influencing physicians as well as citizens with the idea that
lepers must be expelled from society. Lepers in Europe were encouraged by the church to pray and repent in hope of a
divine cure. Pilgrimages to various shrines of different saints also reflected this idea. Islamic societies did not have such
religious zeal in their dealings with the disease, and their lack of highly defined social groups allowed the leper more
freedom in society. Islamic society’s traditions also placed more emphasis on the responsibility of the family in caring for
the afflicted. Pilgrimages to hot springs associated with religious beings played a large part in the treatment of Islamic
lepers. Lastly, this was analogous to pilgrimages to religious shrines in Christian Europe.
Bibliography
R. Palmer, “The Church, Leprosy and Plague in Medieval and Early Modern Europe,” Studies In Church History, 19
(1982): 79-99
M.W. Dols, “The Leper in Medieval Islamic Society,” Speculum 58 (1983): 891-916
Siraisi, Nancy G. Medieval and Early Renaissance Medicine: An Introduction to Knowledge and Practice. Chicago: The
University of Chicago Press, 1990
Другие работы по теме:
Cambrian Medieval Celtic Studies
, ранее (в 1981—1992) Cambridge Medieval Celtic Studies (сокращённо CMCS ), рус. «Кембриджские», позднее «Камбрийские средневековые кельтские исследования» — научный журнал, посвящённый кельтологии, истории кельтских языков и истории античной и раннесредневековой Британии. Выходит два раза в год — летом и зимой.
Philosophers
l-Farаbi, Abu Nasr (872-950) Persian Islamic neoplatonist who employed Aristotelian logic in support of his arguments for the existence of god and used
Perceptions Of Islam Essay Research Paper How
Perceptions Of Islam Essay, Research Paper How the West Perceives Islam and what Mazrui thinks is the Reality Most Westerners tend to view the Islamic societies as somewhat backward in their beliefs according to Mazrui. Commonly Westerners believe that this is due to the oppressed religious beliefs of Islamic’s.
Isolation Of Islamic Families Essay Research Paper
The presence of European thought could be observed in most societies throughout the world’s history. Therefore, from a historical aspect, European culture has affected the Islamic society, although not as intensely as it was in the case with other non-Western cultures. In the novel Palace Walk, Naguib Mahfouz helps to understand how the people of Egypt were affected by the country’s status as a British protectorate.
Islamic Spread Essay Research Paper From its
Islamic Spread Essay, Research Paper From its beginnings in Arabia to its extensive empire encompassing the Middle East, parts of Asia, North Africa, and parts of Europe,paul duffy is fat the
Medieval And Renaissance Art Essay Research Paper
The Medieval and Renaissance art vary greatly in terms of subject and technique. Medieval art produced works that were less free in theme and style while Renaissance art explored on various techniques and depicted reality in its truest sense.
Harry Potter Essay Research Paper Harry Potter
Harry Potter Essay, Research Paper ?Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire?, written by J.K. Rowling, is an excellent example of a modern novel that uses medieval influences extensively. Many of the novel?s characters are based on medieval ideas and superstitions. The settings in the book resemble old medieval towns as well as castles.
Medieval Drama Essay Research Paper Medieval Drama
Medieval Drama Essay, Research Paper Medieval Drama was an era of religious beliefs. In this time the mysteries of god were studied and presented to the communities in a play form to instill the knowledge in a pleasurable way with morals and themes. Abraham and Isaac blends with this in many ways, by which cultures formed in medieval times.
The Kung Shoshone And Mbuti Tribes Hunting
And Gathering Societies Essay, Research Paper The Kung, Shoshone, and Mbuti Tribes: Hunting and Gathering Societies As in many societies different groups of people are connected by similar
Overcoming Patriarchy Essay Research Paper Overcoming patriarchy
Overcoming Patriarchy Essay, Research Paper Overcoming patriarchy Wherever and whenever we look back in history, we see women being oppressed. Either in times of slavery, or in medieval times, or during the discovery of the Americas, women suffered the control of men in many ways. The term patriarchy in Greek refers to “the ruling of the father,” which translates directly into the ruling of the men over women.
Midevil Times Essay Research Paper Highlights of
Midevil Times Essay, Research Paper Highlights of the Medieval Times The Medieval period was a time of many great accomplishments. Even though “kings struggled for land power”(Holt, 186), and people struggled just to stay alive, it was a time that will always mark a spot in history. Of the Middle Ages there were three main topics; government, manor and town life, and the role of the church.
The Difference Between Post Modern Age And
Medieval Age Essay, Research Paper I feel that medieval times and today?s times differ extremely. Many people seem to think that it is much better in today?s times, but in some ways I feel differently.
Byzantine Islamic Empires Comparison Essay Research Paper
Byzantine and Islamic Empires q Introduction Both the Islamic and in the Byzantine Empires had very important social structures. There are differences between the two Empires in all aspects, however both were successful. The Byzantine was part of the great Roman Empire and the Islamic Empire was built on religious belief.
Leprosy Essay Research Paper Disease ProjectLeprosyOut of
Leprosy Essay, Research Paper Disease Project-Leprosy Out of all the diseases that exist today, one of them has always been considered a curse of the damned. It did not kill people, nor did it seem to end. In biblical times, the
Leprosy Essay Research Paper Leprosy ReportLeprosy has
Leprosy Essay, Research Paper Leprosy Report Leprosy has been around for thousands of years, since the biblical times. It was first identified by Gerhard A. Hansen in 1873. It was the first bacterium to be identified as disease
Islamic Women Essay Research Paper Many times
Islamic Women Essay, Research Paper Many times when feminists looked at Islamic women they criticized the man for not treating women properly. However, as Jane I. Smith states, women of Islam are not really offended by that fact, on the contrary, they believe that it is better for them.
Asian Affirmation And Islamic Resurgence Essay Research
Paper Two civilizations that were challenging the theory of Western supremacy and stressing the importance of their own culture in relation to that of the West were the Asian and Islamic civilizations. Both the Asian culture and the Islamic religion entered a great stage of revival and expansion which led to an increase in their self-confidence.
Leprosy Essay Research Paper Leprosy or Hansen
Leprosy Essay, Research Paper Leprosy or Hansen’s Disease, is a disease that affects primarily the skin and nerves. It was discovered in 1874 by a Norwegian physician Gerhard Henrik Armauer Hansen.The disease was thought to have started somewhere in India and then was past on to Africa and Europe. In the late 1800’s leprosy was very common throughout Europe.
Islam Affects Our World Essay Research Paper
The Islamic religion, founded by Muhammad, has affected this world with a variety of ways. In 732, the religion was in full effect with people from the Middle East to North Africa learning about Islam and the Koran. The Islamic people, Muslims, had different attitudes toward life and what life was about compared to other religions across the globe.
Sasanian Silver Essay Research Paper In the
Sasanian Silver Essay, Research Paper In the broad world of islamic art its not always easy to tell were the piece your looking at comes from, what period it was created in and what materials were used to make it. It can be complicated as islamic art differs from country to country and in some cases from city to city.
Persia Essay Research Paper Influence of Islamic
Persia Essay, Research Paper Influence of Islamic Art The art of Europe, or ‘Western art’ is of a totally different type and style as what is known as ‘Islamic art’. It is difficult to have samples of both together in one place, observe the patterns of one and the narrative form of the other and say, “Islamic art influenced the art of Italy”.
Islamic Holy Days Essay Research Paper The
Islamic Holy Days Essay, Research Paper The Islamic religion’s holiest city of Mecca (also known as Mekka or Makkah) is located in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. It’s importance as a holy city for Muslims harks back to it being the birthplace of the founder of Islam, Mohammed.
Islamic Religion Essay Research Paper I do
Islamic Religion Essay, Research Paper I do not agree with the Islamic beliefs that God is the enemy of unbelievers. As an outsider to this religion this does not sit well with me. I believe God has no enemies. Wait, I mean he loves everyone, but I?m kind of unsure of his feelings towards child molesters, rapists and murderers.
Islamic Law Essay Research Paper The religion
Islamic Law Essay, Research Paper The religion and the practices of Islam have often been seen in a negative light in the Western world. This can be attributed to the effects that Islamic fundamentalists have had on society through their attacks on the Western world. For this reason many Westerners have developed an Islamophobia .
From Hotel To Hospital Essay Research Paper
FROM HOTEL TO HOSPITAL Hospitality, shelter, foreigners, strangers; all these words bring the meaning hotel to mind. At first, that is exactly what a hospital was. The word hospital derives from the Latin word hospes meaning guest. Gradually these places catered to the aged and sick, and a variety of institutions came into being.
Uzbekiston Essay Research Paper UzbekistanCentral Asia has
Uzbekiston Essay, Research Paper Uzbekistan Central Asia has one of the world?s earliest civilizations. Archeological research shows and proves that humans lived in Uzbekistan long before 2000 B. C. The first agricultural societies developed in 2000 B. C. farmers started breeding sheep cattle and horses.
Sociology 101 Essay Research Paper Sociology 101By
Sociology 101 Essay, Research Paper Sociology 101 By: Chris Reeh This article is about Spanish rabbi-poet named Judah Halevi. He lived in a society in which Jews were socially powerless. They were also influenced heavily by the dominant Islamic culture. He wrote many poems and books. His poetry brought a deeper sense of the Jewish spirituality to many people.
Islamic Art
& Architecture Essay, Research Paper Two dominant features of Islamic art and architecture, the importance of calligraphic ornamentation and the form of the mosque, are intimately related to the Islamic faith and were developed in the early days of the religion. The part about Islamic art and architecture that stands out the most is it’s uniform style, its symmetrical and stands out more boldly than other buildings and art work.