All My Sons Essay, Research Paper
N. Rodriguez
Page 1
Nadia Rodriguez
Mr. Friedman
E5-25
December 11, 2000
All My Sons
All My Sons, a play by Arthur Miller, tells predominantly of the story of the Kellers. This play takes place after World War II, in the year 1947. It is a drama of actions and consequences and morality. This theme of actions and consequences is shown after Joe Keller ships out defective engine parts, which ultimately ends in the death of many pilots including that of his own son, Larry Keller, who kills himself in shame of his father? s actions. Joe Keller had two sons, Chris and Larry, who is dead. Chris and his father, Joe, have opposing morals and viewpoints on many of the issues that govern their lives, primarily the issue of the shipment of the defective engine parts. Chris?s criticism of Joe and his morals in juxtaposition to his own produces a revelation of Chris?s true character and his character flaws.
Chris?s main criticisms of Joe, his father, chiefly deals with the shipment of the defective engine parts. Joe plays a major role in this play. He is shown as the antagonist, the one who through his bad decisions, ends up killing many innocent pilots who were only defending their country. ?In All My Sons, Miller complicates the story in that the father becomes flawed morally to such an extent that the outside forces function as reflections or testimonies of the essential inner weakness.?
N. Rodriguez
Page 2
(Martin, 9) As Yorks shows in his essay, through Joe?s loyalty to his business and his family, Joe betrays the ?larger loyalties of the global conflict? [World War II] (21) by shipping out defective engine parts. Joe tries to defend his actions by saying, ?Who worked for nothin? in that war? When they work for nothin?, I?ll work for nothin??it?s dollars and cents, nickels and dimes; war and peace, it?s nickels and dimes, what?s clean? Half the Goddamn country is gotta go if I go!? (Miller, 67) Joe claims to Chris that almost all the businesses involved in the war, made a profit from it and if that is considered dirty, then nobody is clean. Chris says that is exactly why he is so upset. ?I know you?re no worse than most men but I thought you were better. I never saw you as a man. I saw you as my father.? (Miller, 67) Chris expected his father to be better than most men, and is shamed when he learns of what his father has done. Chris says to his father, ?What the hell do you mean, you did it for me? Don?t you have a country? What the hell are you? You?re not even an animal, no animal kills his own, what are you?? (Miller, 59) Miller, through the title, tries to make us understand that Joe commits suicide as a final recognition of all those who ?fought as his sons?. (Yorks, 22). Chris is the one who drives his father to see that all the fighting men were actually his sons.
While one analyzes Chris?s criticism of Joe and his morals, the focus then moves to Chris and his own morals. Though Chris preaches to his father about morality and his loyalty to his country, we see that Chris may be just as dirty as his father. He too has pocketed the profits of the family business, yet he continues to hold himself to be morally superior to Joe. Joe himself asks Chris, ?Exactly what?s the matter? What?s the matter? You got too much money? Is that what bothers you?? (Miller, 67) Chris claims all the money that his father has earned is dirty, yet Chris has taken the profits just as his father has. Chris is revealed as suspecting his father?s guilt all along, but as ?lacking the moral stamina to force the issue?. (Clurman, 24). ?It?s true. I?m yellow, I was made
N. Rodriguez
Page 3
yellow in this house because I suspected my father and I did nothing about it.? says Chris. (Miller, 66)
Flaws in Chris?s character are also shown when we examine the love of Chris?s life, Annie. It is Chris who, in reaching out for love and a life of his own with Annie, first weakens and destroys the sense of security his father has tried to upkeep for his family. Annie, who has become Chris?s fianc?e, was previously also Chris?s dead brother, Larry?s fiancee. One must wonder what kind of morals Chris must have if he wants to marry his deceased brother?s fiancee. Chris knows that
marrying Annie will destroy his mother, Kate, who still believes that Larry is not dead and will reappear one day. Kate refuses to allow Chris to marry his brother?s fiancee because that would acknowledge Larry?s death. As Joe tells Chris, ?From mother?s point of view he is not dead and you have no right to take his girl.? (Miller, 14) Yet despite the wishes of his parents, Chris still intends on marrying Annie.
In an essay written by Wells, it is shown that during and exchange between Chris and George, Chris has always suspected his father. ?Let me go up and talk to your father. In ten minutes you?ll have an answer. Or are you afraid of the answer?? asks George. ?I?m not afraid. I know the answer? replies Chris. (Miller 48) Chris has not allowed himself to admit what he knew because he would not know how to live with it. Chris could not love a guilty father, ?not out of moral fastidious but out of self-love? (Gross, 13) If as George says, Chris has lied to himself about his father?s guilt, it is more to deny what he himself is than what his father is. Chris has always known his father was guilty but could not handle the consequences- the condemnation of his father and also of himself because he too has been polluted. This is exactly what the ?exposure of his father forces upon him
N. Rodriguez
Page 4
and his father?s arguments all shatter upon the hard shell of Chris? idealism not simply because they are, in fact, evasions and irrelevant half-truths, but because they can not satisfy Chris? conscience.?
(Wells, 6) When Chris says that, ?I never saw you as a man. I saw you as my father. I can?t look you this way. I can?t look at myself!? (Miller, 67) ?An unwittingly, illuminating admission: he cannot look at his father as no better than most because he cannot look at himself as no better than most, he had never seen his father as a man because he has not wanted to see himself as one.? (Gross, 13)
At the conclusion of All My Sons, we see that Chris has come to a realization of what he has become. He has become a man, something he never wanted to see himself or his father as.
?I could jail him! I could jail him, if I were human any more. But I?m like everybody
else now. I?m practical now. You made me practical?the cats in that alley were practical, the bums who ran away when we were fighting were practical. Only the dead ones weren?t practical. But now I?m practical, and I spit on myself. I?m going away. I?m going now.? (Miller, 66)
Chris has become what he never wanted to be a practical man. The true Chris was always soiled, just as his father by his father?s actions and just like his dead brother, Larry, he could no longer stand himself. Chris tells his mother, ?You can do better! Once and for all you can know there?s a universe of people outside and you?re responsible to it, and unless you know that you threw away your son because that?s why he died.? (Miller, 69) At this moment, a shot is heard and we find out that Joe has committed suicide. Chris starts to apologize to his mother for being so harsh with Joe, but his mother stops him and says, ?Don?t, dear. Don?t take it on yourself. Forget now. Live.? (Miller 69) Chris has now been freed from his father?s immoral actions and can now live as the man he has become, a ?practical? man.
1. Clurman, Harold. ?Thesis and Drama.? Modern Critical Interpretations:Arthur Miller?s All My Sons. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea House Publishers, 1988
2. Gross, Barry. ?All My Sons and the Larger Context.? Critical Essays on Arthur Miller. Ed. James Nagel. Boston: G.K. Hall & Co., 1979.
3. Martin, Robert A. ?Introduction.? Arthur Miller, New Perspectives. Ed. Robert A. Martin. New Jersey:Prentice Hall Inc. 1982.
4. Miller, Arthur. All My Sons. New York: Dramatists Play Service Inc., 1947.
5. Wells, Arvin A. ?The Living and The Dead in All My Sons.? Critical Essays on Arthur Miller. Ed. James Nagel. Boston: G.K. Hall & Co., 1979.
6. Yorks, Samuel A. ?Joe Keller and His Sons?. Modern Critical Interpretations: Arthur Miller?s All My Sons. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York:Chelsea House Publishers, 1988.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth Essay Research Paper MacbethIf it hadn
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth If it hadn’t been for the three witches, Macbeth would never have killed Duncan nor Banquo. Macbeth, also would not have been killed my Macduff. The three witches are the
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Night 2
Night – Fathers And Sons Essay, Research Paper Night Essay- Fathers and Sons During World War II, millions of Jews went to work in concentration camps. Many were separated completely from their families. And some who were not still did not
The Movie Ran Essay Research Paper The
The Movie Ran Essay, Research Paper The differences that were peculiar to Japanese culture are the type of clothes they wore the status in the family rank, and the loyalty of the servants to their master.
Ran Essay Research Paper Ran
Ran Essay, Research Paper Ran–Movie Review–Ryan Bobo At the age of 70, after years of consolidating his empire, the Great Lord Hidetora Ichimonji (played brilliantly by Tatsuya Nadakai) decides to abdicate the throne and divide his domain among his three sons. To illustrate his demand for family unity, Hidetora shows that a single arrow can be easily broken, but three arrows held together are strong.
Lotus Sutra Essay Research Paper One of
Lotus Sutra Essay, Research Paper One of my questions is in regards to the assembly which is referred to in the section on Devadatta. Who makes up this assembly? Is this assembly composed solely of Buddhas? Or is the assembly comprised of Bhodisattvas as well as Buddhas?
Who Should Be King Three Boys Essay
, Research Paper Who Should Be King Three boys: Richard, Jeffery, and John. Their your only sons. Which one would you choose to be king of the kingdom you have had for years? All three of them are great in certain areas, but how could a person choose between their sons. If you pick one then the other two will feel like they have been shafted.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper William Shakespeare s
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare s Hamlet is a tragedy set around the murder of the king of Denmark. One of the main themes of the story is revenge. Within the story, there are three sons who must avenge their respective father s death. Hamlet, the prince of Denmark, Fortinbras, the prince of Norway, and Laertes, the son of the Danish king s advisor, all are examples of the typical sons of this period in time.
Dianne Day Essay Research Paper Dianne Day
Dianne Day Essay, Research Paper Dianne Day isn t as famous as Mary Higgins Clark but she had a childhood similar to her. When she was a baby in Mississippi her father died. Dianne went on to live with her grandparents and they also were not a well-financed family. When Dianne was seven she rejoined her mother was now remarried.
Beloved A Review Essay Research Paper Beloved
Beloved (A Review) Essay, Research Paper Beloved I decided to delve into the issue of slavery in this novel. SETHE, the mother of Beloved, and was owned by the character Schoolteacher . SETHE had three children by another slave. Schoolteachers sons would take her milk so she couldn t feed her children. She grew tired of this mistreatment so she decided to run away.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
All My Sons Essay Research Paper Essay
All My Sons Essay, Research Paper Essay – “All My Sons” "There?s nothing? he could do that I wouldn?t forgive. Because he?s my son. Because I?m his father and he?s my son." That is a quote about forgiveness, whether or not deciding to choose to forgive is a very personal, and sensitive subject. Imagine what it would be like to have to decide to forgive a close relative for the murder of 21 men.
Samuel Adams Essay Research Paper 427Revolutionary America
Samuel Adams Essay, Research Paper (427) Revolutionary America was an extraordinary time. The Revolution changed many unsuspecting men into heroes; our founding fathers. One of these men was Samuel Adams, a man with unsurpassed dedication and the political intellect to make a difference in America s revolution.
Absalom Son Of David Essay Research Paper
Absalom’s story unfolds in the household of King David. The key members of this household were Absalom, Amnon, and Tamar. Absalom and Amnon were David’s sons and Tamar was David’s daughter.
You Can Lead A Horse To Water
, But Can’t Make Him Drink Essay, Research Paper Walters, Luther ENG 161-68 Thurs. February 02, 1999 You Can Lead A Horse To Water, But You Can?t Make Him Drink.
Haiku Poetry Essay Research Paper HaikuCan
Haiku Poetry Essay, Research Paper Haiku Can’t write poetry I bang my head on the wall Endless frustration Another Haiku Hey, this is easy I could do this all day long
Medea Essay Research Paper Love and Deception
Medea Essay, Research Paper Love and Deception There are many pieces of literature that may entail more than one theme throughout the story. The tragedy, Medea, by Euripides is very good example of this. Throughout this story, the themes of betrayal and love, revenge, and women s rights arise. Euripides brings these points up to help the reader to realize that women are powerful also.
MacbethWho Killed Duncan Essay Research Paper MacbethWho
Macbeth..Who Killed Duncan Essay, Research Paper Macbeth Who Really Killed Duncan ? Who really did kill Duncan? This has been a question asked by many historians of Shakespeare. There are many theories that have developed over the years. Some say it was MacDuff, Lady Macbeth, or even Duncan’s own two sons.
Night Essay Research Paper There are many
Night Essay, Research Paper There are many themes in the novel Night, by Elie Wiesel; some of these include loss of faith, father-son relationships, food and hunger, and disbelief. One of the most interesting theme is the father-son relationship. This theme can be seen throughout the novel with many fathers and sons.
Letters Of War Essay Research Paper Letters
Letters Of War Essay, Research Paper Letters of War ?Spartan mothers of old, who, when their sons went forth to battle for freedom and their native land, said to their sons:
EuripideS Medea Essay Research Paper EuripidesMedeaI see
Euripide`S Medea Essay, Research Paper Euripides Medea I see Medea as a woman who took a chance and stood up for herself. The kind of behavior that Medea displays was very rare for these times: she doesn’t accept the dramatic change in her life; she does something about it. On the other hand, Medea becomes so obsessed she loses herself to revenge.
All My Sons Larry
’s Importance Essay, Research Paper Never Seen But Still Important, How? We never meet the man yet he still plays an integral role in the plot. How can this be? This concept is exactly what happens in the play All My Sons as pertains to the role of Larry. Although Larry never actually appears in the play, he affects the plot and the characters, specifically Kate, in key ways.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper In Macbeth I
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper In Macbeth, I believe the story would have been completely different. Why? If it hadn?t been for the three witches, Macbeth would never have killed Duncan nor Banquo.
The Murder Essay Research Paper 121096 The
The Murder Essay, Research Paper 12/10/96 The Murder In the beginning of the play, Macbeth and Banquo meet three witches. The witches predict that Macbeth will be Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor, and king. They tell Banquo that his sons will become kings. At that point Macbeth was already Thane of Glamis because of his father.
Macbeth Witches Essay Research Paper Macbeth who
Macbeth Witches Essay, Research Paper Macbeth, who is hailed by the three witches as the ancestor of kings. Macbeth is an intelligent spiritual likeness of a villain-hero who feels his own guilt
Death Of A Salesman Theme Essay Essay
, Research Paper Throughout Death of a Salesman the males of the Loman family cannot distinguish between the reality of the American Dream and the illusion of it. Willy cannot see who Happy and Biff actually are as individuals or himself for that matter. Therefore, Willy and his sons believe that they all know and have what it takes to be a success in life and in business.
Shang Dynasty Essay Research Paper Social Classes
Shang Dynasty Essay, Research Paper Social Classes and Daily lives 1.Social Classes a. Nobles 1.The King owned everything.2.The King and the family ruled.3.The King Lead the worriers into battle.b. Commoners1.Rich men had several wives each with a family and servants.2.The head of the family was the oldest most likely the grand father orfather of the house.a.
Princess Di Essay Research Paper THERE ARE
Princess Di Essay, Research Paper THERE ARE MANY IMPORTANT PEOPLE IN OUR SOCIETY TODAY. FOR EXAMPLE, THERE ARE MOVIE STARS, ATHLEATS, PEOPLE WHO INSPIRE OTHERS, AND PEOPLE WHO HELP OTHERS. ONE PERSON WHO I BELIEVE EXCELLED IN OUR WORLD WAS PRINCESS DIANA. PRINCESS DIANA WAS A LOVING, CARING, AND HELPING WOMEN WHOM A LOT OF PEOPLE ADMIRE.
Willy Loman Is The Cause Of His
Own Misfortune Essay, Research Paper Willy Loman is the cause of his own misfortune Many characters in literature are the cause of their own misfortune. In the play Death of a Salesman by author Miller, Willy Loman is responsible for his misfortune as well as the misfortune of his two sons Happy and Biff. Willy creates his own small world in which he is the boss, everything goes around him, nothing will change and nothing will go wrong.
Good Earth Essay Research Paper The Good
Good Earth Essay, Research Paper The Good Earth Pearl S. Buck / Historical Fiction The Good Earth is a saga about the life and death of Wang Lung. The story starts out on his wedding