, Research Paper
Earning of Their Fates or Innocent Victims?
When arguing the statement, the character of Pentheus in the Bacchae is portrayed as earning his fate, whereas the character of Hippolytus in the Hippolytus is portrayed as an innocent victim of the god, I must both, agree and disagree with it. I would definitely agree with it on a shallow point of view, but would have to disagree with it upon dissecting both the stories. The stories tell of Hippolytus being killed for something he did not do, while Pentheus was killed for not accepting the god Dionysus. But when you look deep into the meaning of each story, the apparent black and white assumptions of innocents and guilt change from definitive to doubt to say the least.
When reading the story of Hippolytus, it would be very easy to label him as an innocent victim. His step mother, Phaedra falls for him, while he promotes celibacy. Instead of being praised for this belief his step mother, who commits suicide was found with a note framing him, telling of his love for her. Upon reading the note, Theseus, his father banishes him and prays to Posiedon to kill him. As Hippolytus leaves, he prays to Zeus to strike him dead if he has sinned and then a wave controlled by Posiedon hits him, almost rendering him dead. Artemis then tells everyone of his innocence, but Hippolytus ends up dying anyway. This may seem like a very open and shut case for him being an innocent victim, but when you look at Hippolytus throughout the story, I tend to think that he wasn’t as innocent as he was made out to be. Sure he never was infatuated with Phaedra, but he may have just been a victim of his own pride. Earlier in the story, he is warned to not just devote all his time to worshipping the goddess Artemis, but to also worship the goddess Aphrodite. He ignores these warning and sees them almost as a hollow threat and intensifies his worship for Artemis. Further along in the story, he ends up blaming Zeus for creating women and he also blames him after finding out about Phaedra’s feelings; which seems to me that he was even blaming Zeus for making her become infatuated with him. The infatuation was Aphrodite’s doing for lack of worship, not Zeus’. So even though Hippolytus did not sin toward Phaedra, he ends up sinning toward Zeus, by questioning his putting of women on the earth and blaming him for something he had no part in, and to Aphrodite by not giving her the respect she thought she deserved.
Then if read shallowly, the Bacchae also seems to be black and white, in the fact that the story tells of Pentheus earning his fate. The first step would be when strange things started to happen and the arrest of the stranger, Dionysus. Next, and the most important step in him earning his fate would be that Pentheus rejects the belief of Dionysus. Later on, more strange things happen, namely miracles and now Pentheus and Dionysus meet again, this time Pentheus is unable to reject him and starts to fall under his spell. They then meet for a final time and now Dionysus is in total control and humiliates Pentheus. When the chorus sees this, they invoke the “Swift hounds of Frenzy” to bring vengeance on Pentheus for failing to honor the gods. Pentheus is then finally killed by Bacchantes with the aid of his mother Agave. This seems to be a simple story of a man who rejected the gods and got what was coming to him, but if looked at on a deeper level, it may not be so simple. Sure Pentheus rejected Dionysus, but when they first met, Pentheus had no idea that Dionysus was a god since he was disguised as a stranger. Pentheus just did as probably all kings did, just assume he was right in his own belief because a king knows more then a stranger. It seems to me that Pentheus was more of an innocent victim in that he was just doing what all kings did at the time. Dionysus plays him like a fiddle which is shown when Pentheus’ authority becomes progressively lessened in relation to the power of the god, Dionysus. Dionysus continues his show off his power when the initial victim, himself, eventually becomes the aggressor or in simple terms the hunted becomes the hunter.
In conclusion, I believe the stories themselves tell of Pentheus as the deserver of his fate while Hippolytus is shown to be the innocent victim, but I believe the true meaning behind these stories are meant to be interpreted in polar opposites of the initial read through. Hippolytus actually ends up deserving his fate because he sinned against the gods and was too prideful of his own celibacy, while Pentheus was a victim of the social order practiced by humans, in that royalty was thought be above the peasants and strangers. So it seems as though Pentheus was tricked into his fate, while Hippolytus deserved his short comings due to his own faults.
Другие работы по теме:
Fates Warning
Сформированная в Хартфорде (США) в 1982 году под названием "Misfit" группа первоначально включала в себя Джона Арча (вокал), Джима Матеоса (гитара), Виктора Ардуини (гитара), Джо Дибиаса (бас) и Стива Зиммермана (ударные).
Artemis Essay Research Paper ArtemisArtemis was born
Artemis Essay, Research Paper Artemis Artemis was born of Leto and Zeus, on the island of Delos, later helping with the delivery of her twin brother, Apollo. Some sources state that her actual birthplace is not Delos, but an island called Ortygia. Although the two islands could be one and the same, it is not clear.
Why Hester Is A Whore Essay
, Research Paper Adulterous relationships always end in pain. Examples of such pain are present throughout the intricate web of time. From Shakespeare s star-crossed lovers, to the media buffet of Bill Clinton, adultery leaves pain. Hester embodies this pain. Not in pity but in cause. She embodies pain.
The Temptresses Of Unconcious Enticements Essay Research
Paper ?Upon the heath.? [Act I, Scene I] is the first sight we see the three ?weird sisters.? They are ?beldams . . .saucy and overbold? [Act III, Scene V], the temptresses of evil who seemingly lurk behind all the dark thoughts and unconscious enticements. They seem to live for ?riddles and affairs for death? [Act III, Scene V].
Augiga The Charioteer Essay Research Paper Auriga
Augiga The Charioteer Essay, Research Paper Auriga, the Charioteer is the last of the autumn constellations with a right ascension of six hours and a declination of 41.73 degrees. Auriga is an ancient Northern
The Bachae Essay Research Paper The Bacchae
The Bachae Essay, Research Paper The Bacchae In the story, The Bacchae The dramatic conflict is how Pentheus goes against the nature and ways of Dionysus and his followers. Pentheus is an ignorant king who believes that he is the all-powerful and that Dionysus is not a god. Pentheus actually states to his father that Dionysus is no god.
Bacchae Essay Research Paper In the Bacchae
Bacchae Essay, Research Paper In the Bacchae, for whom do you feel more sympathy ? Pentheus or Dionysus? In the Bacchae, Pentheus and Dionysus have very different characters. They are both
The Bacchae Essay Research Paper The Ultimate
The Bacchae Essay, Research Paper The Ultimate Morality Test The Bacchae represents an authentic interpretation that is full of temptation in the natural world. I am going to compare the temptations of society that we as individuals encounter everyday with the allure of nature in the Bacchae, specifically focusing on temptation offered by Dionysos.
Bacchae Essay Research Paper MoralSocial Values in
Bacchae Essay, Research Paper Moral-Social Values in The Bacchae One prevailing argument about The Bacchae as with many of his other works is whether Euripides propounds a revolutionary or a reactionary message about society. This outlook, however, is skirting an essential element of The Bacchae’s theme.
Saint Clement The First Essay Research Paper
Feastday: October 14 Imagine that your biography was written by an enemy of yours. And that its information was all anyone would have not only for the rest of your life but for centuries to come. You would never be
Deeper Philosophical Meanings Of The Baccai Essay
, Research Paper One of ancient Greece s tragic plays in entitled The Bacchae , written by Euripides. Many larger and deeper philosophical views are expressed in the play. The plot contains many speeches, and one might think at certain points that they would be the moral. The actual moral, however, is almost impossible to define.
Phaedra
– Jean Racine Essay, Research Paper Jean Racine “Phaedra” is filled with irony. It is irony that serves as the faulty foundation for the entire story. There exists great care in following the right social morays. Although nothing physical has transpired between Phaedra and Hippolytus, the idea that one was thinking of the other inappropriately is punishable as if they had carried on in a torrid affair.
Phaedra 2
Phaedra’s Charactor Essay, Research Paper K.Watson Paper III Prof. Molinari 15 November 96 Phaedra s anguish is first experienced by her in her own mind. Her sense of morality is so highly developed that, even before the drama begins, before she has acted, prior to her committing symbolic incest with her step-son Hippolytus, she is guilty.
The Deserving Daughter Essay Research Paper Having
The Deserving Daughter Essay, Research Paper Having a genuine understanding of the true meaning of heritage is sometimes expressed in simple ways. In Alice Walker s short story Everyday Use, makes a far more effective statement in painting out that authentic black culture becomes artificial when its artifacts are worshipped for their own sake and not used as they were intended (Callahan 402).
Oedipus Vs Pentheus Essay Research Paper Oedipus
Oedipus Vs Pentheus Essay, Research Paper Oedipus and Pentheus are both tragic Greek characters who help create their own endings. Through their character’s flaws and blindness to what is going on around each of them, the story develops. The only consistent character in both plays who is able to understand past and present dangers is Teiresias, the blind prophet.
Phedre Essay Research Paper Can love be
Phedre Essay, Research Paper Can love be seen as something as bad as a disease? Evidently so, as depicted in the greek tragedy Phedre. Ironically, it is quite interesting how love is portrayed throughout the script as if it was evil and cursed. This, I believe, is the main theme of the play, the forbidden love.
Hippolytus Essay Research Paper HIPPOLYTUSThe acting is
Hippolytus Essay, Research Paper HIPPOLYTUS The acting is Hippolytus was very good. In particular, Caitlin Bopp, who played Aphrodite, and Keith Hale, who played Theseus, stood out. Caitlin did a great job in playing a seductive, vengeful Goddess. She fell into the role perfectly and I noticed little things such as eyes movements that made it seem like her character was in control of the scene.
John Proctor Internally Conflicted Essay Research Paper
John Proctor is internally conflicted throughout the entire play, The Crucible. His struggles evolve in each act. But, he is not a character deserving of pity because all of his struggles are self-inflicted. His affair with Abigail is at the root of most of them, the others are a result of stubborn pride.
Phaedra Essay Research Paper Phaedra The Power
Phaedra Essay, Research Paper Phaedra: The Power of Guilt and Shame In neo-classical works of literature, the themes are often based on reason and passion. The two factors of influence collide in a struggle that an individual character or group of characters must overcome and decide which to follow, and this conflict usually leads to suffering, guilt, and shame.
Comparison Of Bacchae Essay Research Paper Comparison
Comparison Of Bacchae Essay, Research Paper Comparison Of Bacchae and Hippolytus In the plays Bacchae and Hippolytus, many similarities and differences exist between the relationships of the characters. One similarity between the relationship of Pentheus and Dionysus in Bacchae and that of Hippolytus and Aphrodite in Hippolytus are the tragedies caused by the gods to these characters.
Dante And Homer Essay Research Paper Dante
Dante And Homer Essay, Research Paper Dante makes many references to Homer and the Iliad throughout the Inferno. The fates of favorite characters are described during the course of Dante?s
Bill Clinton Essay Research Paper Award WinnerThe
Bill Clinton Essay, Research Paper Award Winner The most deserving person in the world to receive the Swift Silken Thread for Meaningless Achievement Award is former president William Jefferson Clinton. He was
The Greeks Vs Their Gods In Hippolytus
Essay, Research Paper The Greeks vs. Their Gods in Hippolytus The play Hippolytus by the Greek playwright Euripides is one which explores classical Greek religion. Throughout the play, the influence
Macbeth Essay Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth Essay Essay, Research Paper Macbeth – Tragic Villain or Victim Of Fate The story of Macbeth, by William Shakespeare, is one of many tragic plays he composed. Macbeth is about a sadistic general that takes a prediction to the limits. In most stories, we root for the good guys…but in this story, get ready to root for the dark side.
Theseus Essay Research Paper Anne Kucera
Theseus Essay, Research Paper Anne Kucera Classics 180 11-9-00 Theseus The character Theseus portrayed in the epics Hippolytus and Oedipus at colonus have some similarities but quite a few differences.
Echo Essay Research Paper Echo was a
Echo Essay, Research Paper Echo was a nymph who lived in the forest. She romped and played with all of her fellow nymphs. One day she came across a beautifull man named Narcissus. At first she was scared of him, but soon grew quite attached. The gods looked down upon an infatuated Narcissus with disdain. They sentenced him and his new love to horrible fates.
Marriage Is A Private Affair Essay Research
Paper Marriage is a Private Affair In China Achebe?s ?Marriage Is a Private Affair?, the discrepant values of Namesake and his father dictate their fates. However, this assumption rests on the premise that fate is a transient and alterable condition. Originally, Okeke?s steadfast Christian beliefs and commitment to tradition prompt a fissure between father and son.
Responsible Fates Essay Research Paper In the
Responsible Fates Essay, Research Paper In the play Romeo and Juliet and the musical Wet Side Story, the two pairs of lovers were part responsible for their tragic fates. First, Romeo?s and Juliet?s families were enemies. In comparison, Tony and Maria of West Side Story were practically apart of gangs that were enemies as well.
Defining A Tragedy Essay Research Paper Defining
Defining A Tragedy Essay, Research Paper Defining a Tragedy Greek philosopher Aristotle proposes components of an ideal tragedy in his work, Tragedy and the Emotions of Pity and Fear. According to Aristotle, there are six components of a great tragedy: plot, character, thought, verbal expression, song, and visual adornment.
Role Of Women In GrecoRoman Society Essay
, Research Paper The Role of Women in Greco-Roman Society: As Reflected in Classical Mythology The Greco-Roman society was a very patriarchal society. This is reflected throughout the myths in classical mythology. By looking at the classic mythology we will see that the roles women portrayed are very different than women’s roles in today’s society.
Dionysus Essay Research Paper Dionysus
Dionysus Essay, Research Paper Dionysus–Bacchae The god, Dionysus, fills an integral role in Grecian Myth. According to Euripides’ Bacchae, Dionysus represents the animalistic and mystic life force that connects humanity to its innate earthy roots—roots that are illogical, chaotic, and instinctual.
Fatal Flaws In Macbeth Essay Research Paper
Macbeth and its Fatal Flaws Anyone who is not a god, is not perfect. Everyone has a weakness or a flaw. Some flaws are more deadly than others. Some are addicted to heroin while others are unable to remember
The World A Destroyer Essay Research Paper
The world is empty, an endless void Swirling, twirling, and hurling us all Facing the downfall no one foresaw. The world, a temptress, a taker of fates Fighting us all, giving unto the hate.