Socialism Vs. Capitalism Essay, Research Paper
Even before the beginning of the twentieth century, the debate between socialists and capitalists has raged. In The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair, he portrays capitalism as the cause of all evils in society. Sinclair shows the horrors of capitalism. In The Gospel of Wealth, by Andrew Carnegie, he portrays capitalism as a system of opportunity. However, both Carnegie and Sinclair had something to gain from their writings; both men had an agenda. Capitalism and socialism both have advantages and pitfalls; when capitalism is adopted using certain socialist ideals, a truly prosperous society exists.
A major theme of The Jungle is socialism as a remedy for the evils of capitalism. Every event that takes place in the novel is designed to show a particular failure of capitalism. Sinclair attempts to show that capitalism is a “system of chattel slavery” and the working class is subject to “the whim of en every bit as brutal and unscrupulous as the old-time slave drivers”(Sinclair 126). Sinclair portrays this view through Jurgis, a hardworking Lithuanian immigrant and his family. Sinclair uses the hardships faced by this family to demonstrate the effect of capitalism on working people as a whole. Jurgis’ philosophy of “I will work harder” is shown not to work in this system. No matter how hard Jurgis worked, he and his family were still stuck in the same squalor. These characters did not overcome the odds and succeed. That would defeat the purpose of the novel; to depict capitalism as an economic and social system that ignores the plight of the working class and only cares for the wealthy, as well as furthering his socialist agenda.
The main purpose for The Jungle is to promote Sinclair’s socialist agenda. In Sinclair’s views socialism is the cure for all the problems that capitalism creates. Sinclair sees capitalism as a system in which the wealthy exploit the working class for their material benefit. In chapter 28 when Ostrenski, a staunch socialist, is introduced Jurgis is transformed into the socialist way of thinking. Ostrenski tells Jurgis that his condition of poverty is not the result of his action or destiny; it is the result of him being oppressed by the wealthy merchants in Chicago. However, in a socialist society the plight of the working class s addressed. In chapter 31, Nicholas Schliemann is introduced. Schliemann is a socialist leader who acts as a voice for Sinclair in the novel. Schliemann claims once the public owns the means of production (socialism), inefficiencies will be eliminated. Thus, the working class will have to work less, in better conditions, and be paid more for their work. In the last few chapters of the novel, the story is abandoned. It turns into a socialist manifesto designed to show the evils of capitalism and illuminate how socialism can rectify those evils.
In “ The Gospel of Wealth” Andrew Carnegie sings the praises of the capitalist system. Carnegie came from poor background and turned himself into one of the largest industrial tycoons of the day. According to Carnegie everyone had an individual responsibility to, as well as the opportunity to rise, thus poverty should be temporary. The “Gospel of Wealth” argues that someone that has initiative, works hard and has ability should be able to overcome poverty. The socialist is regarded as someone who “is attacking the foundation upon which civilization itself rests”(Marcus and Burner 89).
Carnegie implies that the differences created by capitalism are what drive improvement. Without disparity, there would be no drive for advancement. In Communist or socialist societies things remain constant. There is no desire for improvement and progress is staled. An example of this is in Cuba. If one walks down the streets of Havana, it will look the same now as it did in the 1950’s, when Castro took over. In fact, Cuba basically is the same. There has been little or no technological advances coming into Cuba and the overwhelming majority of the people are still stuck in the same poverty that Communism was supposed to solve. Even though people have an education, there is no place for them to use it (Nucifora 24). However, Carnegie does not talk about the abhorrent conditions in his steel mills. That would defeat the purpose of the essay; to show that “ not evil, but good has come out of the race from the accumulation by those who have the ability and energy to produce it” (Marcus and Burner 89).
Both the socialist and capitalist systems have advantages and pitfalls. The Jungle is symbolic for the competitive nature of capitalism. This is both an advantage and a pitfall. The competitive nature of capitalism leads to rapid progress. In this generation the world had items “of excellent quality at prices which even the previous generation” would think was incredible (Marcus and Burner 88). However, this competitive nature also inevitably leaves people behind. In this system much of the working class lives in poverty, not because they do not have the ability to get ahead, because they have not had the opportunity. Capitalism does lead to a great disparity in wealth. In a socialist society the government controls the means of production. The working class is taken care of. However, the desire to get ahead will always be prevalent. Especially in America, with her staunch individualism, a purely socialist or communist system will not work. America has the strongest economy in the world. Industry is what has driven the economy to where it is today. The reason the USSR collapsed is because its economy collapsed (Mau 207). If America turned to socialism or communism our output would decrease because goods would not go to their most useful purpose. Thus, the economy would stop growing. Therefore, a purely communist or socialist system would not work in America
The blend of capitalism with some socialist ideals leads to a truly prosperous society. The description of capitalism in The Jungle and “The Gospel of Wealth” are polar opposites. In The Jungle, the horrors of capitalism are exaggerated and its promise is non-existent. For example, Sinclair describes capitalism as a system that is “ relentless, remorseless … and cruel” and if someone tried to get in its way, it would “cut his throat and watch him gasp for life” (Sinclair 41). A character like Andrew Carnegie does not exist. There is not one single character that was impoverished and made it in the capitalist system. However, in “The Gospel of Wealth a person like Jurgis is scoffed at. He implies that anyone can climb out of poverty. He makes it seem like there are no faults with the capitalist system and everything is wrong with the socialist system. With both authors exaggerating their claims, the truth lies somewhere in between. Thus, a society that accentuates both systems strengths and minimizes its failures will be a prosperous one.
In modern America, there is the necessary blend of capitalist and socialist ideals that leads to a prosperous society. Our basic economic system is still capitalist, but there are some elements of socialism. It harder businesses blatantly exploit their workers, consumers or competitors in America, because of government regulation. Even though exploitation still exists, it is on a much smaller scale and not as extreme. Exploitation on the same scale as in The Jungle, now mainly exists overseas. Laws now allow collective bargaining, which gives unions and in turn workers power. Another element of socialism in American society is the minimum wage law, as well as overtime laws. Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, and Welfare are all socialist ideals that have infiltrated our capitalist society. Our uneven tax scale and universal healthcare for children are other examples. With this blend of capitalism with socialist ideals, the working class can be taken care of, but not at the expense of losing America’s capitalist identity.
In other countries socialism or communism has blended with capitalism. Capitalism has infiltrated China. Even though the politics of China are still Communist, its expansion of trade with the west as well as its open markets are capitalist ideals. This has enabled China to become a more prosperous nation. In Europe, almost every country has a government run national airline, a socialist principal. In Norway capitalism has been combined with socialism. There is universal health care, as well as free education through college. (“Remodeling Scandinavia: will economic recovery make the
nordic countries’ famous welfare states look good; only after further reform” 37). Both of these are socialist principals. This combination of socialism and capitalism has recently gotten Norway elected the most desirable country in the world to live in. Thus, combining socialism with capitalism leads to a prosperous society.
Capitalism and socialism are two opposite and unique economic and social systems. In Sinclair’s The Jungle and in Carnegie’s “ The Gospel of Wealth” one system is shown to be glorious, while the other is evil. However, both systems have merits and disadvantages. By adapting socialist ideals into a capitalist economic and social system a prosperous society results.
67c
Marcus, Robert D., and David Burner. “Gospel of Wealth.” America Firsthand. New
York: Bedford/ St. Martin’s, 5th ed., 2001.
Mau, Vladimir. “ The road to ‘perestrokia’: economics in the USSR and the problem of
Reforming the Solviet economic order.” Europe-Asia Studies. V48 (March 1996):
207
Nucifora, Alf. “Castro’s Cuba: Taking one long look before the U.S. capitalist invasion.”
Pittsburgh Business Times. V20 (April 20, 2001): 24.
“Remodeling Scandinavia: Will economic recovery make the Nordic countries’ famous
welfare states look good; only after further reform.” The Economist.
V344 (August 23, 1997): 37.
Sinclair, Upton. The Jungle. New York: Barnes and Noble Inc, 1995.
Другие работы по теме:
Cummunism Essay Research Paper Communism Communism is
Cummunism Essay, Research Paper Communism Communism is the idea of having a classless society of people where everything is supposed to be owned equally by all. In communism, unlike Marxism there is a peasant revolution instead of a proletariat revolution, and unlike in socialism there is a totalitarian government and there is no private property.
Marxism And The Revolution Essay Essay Research
Paper Marxism and the Revolution Essay Two important ideal s in Marx s ideas were the philosophies of Materialism and Dialectics. Materialism in philosophy is the recognition that the material word, the world we can see, hear, feel and touch is the only real world. Therefore it is logical to base our
CapitalimSocialism Essay Research Paper There are many
Capitalim-Socialism Essay, Research Paper There are many different economic systems that reside in someway throughout the world today like capitalism and socialism. Here in the United States, we live in a mixed economy ??one in which private enterprise and governmental participation coexist?. Currently Americans? lives are centered on the individual, according to Adam Smith.
Utopian Socialism Essay Research Paper Since the
Utopian Socialism Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the idea of money, there have been those who have wealth, and those who want it. Utopian socialism is not a new idea, and it has remained popular since its creation. Many people know what socialism is, but not that many know the principles Utopian Socialism.
Karl Marx And Frederich Engels Essay Research
Paper In their Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels applied the term communism to the final part of socialism in which all class differences would end and people would live in peace. Marx and Engels were said to have found a scientific approach to socialism based
Marxism Essay Research Paper Marxism is a
Marxism Essay, Research Paper Marxism is a type of scientific socialism. Karl Marx was a communist used this to differentiate his ideas from the utopian socialist. His main idea was ?Workers of the world unite.? Marx also wrote the book ?The Communist Manifest?, in 1848.
20THCENTURY CAPITALISM Essay Research Paper 20THCENTURY CAPITALISM
20TH-CENTURY CAPITALISM Essay, Research Paper 20TH-CENTURY CAPITALISM For most of the 20th century capitalism has been buffeted by wars, revolution, and depression. World War I brought revolution and a Marxist-based communism to Russia. The war also spawned the Nazi system in Germany, a malevolent mixture of capitalism and state socialism, brought together in a regime whose violence and expansionism eventually pushed the world into another major conflict.
Capitalism And Communism Essay Research Paper Capitalism
Capitalism And Communism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism and Communism are two totally different economic systems. Capitalism is a much better economic system than Communism. Capitalism is an economic system characterized by freedom of the market and is the economic system where you do not have freedom because the government will make most of your decisions for you.
Socialism Essay Research Paper Socialism is in
Socialism Essay, Research Paper Socialism is in the greatest intrest of the public. It calls workers to unite for a better community. This gives them a better work ethic. An early socialist said, “From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.” This is a very accurate summary of the basis of socialism.
Guatemala City Essay Research Paper Guatemala CityAs
Guatemala City Essay, Research Paper Guatemala City As with all countries, certain and continuous political systems is unlikely. Instead a mixture of systems (capitalism, socialism, communism, and traditionalism) seem to be the overall control of a nation. Guatemala, a small country in South America, proves true to the before-mentioned statement.
New Deal Essay Research Paper The New
New Deal Essay, Research Paper The New DealDuring the 1930’s American citizens witnessed a breakdown of the Democratic and free enterprise way of life. The government saw that the free enterprise system was failing. The New Deal increased the government’s regulation and intervention and the economic system, thus temporarily abandoning the capitalism system and turning toward socialism to find the answer.
Socialism 2 Essay Research Paper There are
Socialism 2 Essay, Research Paper There are many ways that countries are run. Obviously, most are run by officials–but what kind of system do they govern by? Some of the most important systems used today are capitalism, socialism, and communism.
Communism And Socialism Essay Research Paper Communism
Communism And Socialism Essay, Research Paper Communism and Socialism are types of governments that try to keep people equal. These governments grow in popularity when human society is split into the two classes of have and have-nots; thus, a struggle in social classes cause a reformation in the government.
Capitalisam Essay Research Paper The topic of
Capitalisam Essay, Research Paper The topic of my speech is, Capitalism has too high a price, and while stating the fact I am reminded of what the American humourist and essayist Elwyn Brooks White had said many years ago, The trouble with the profit system is that it is highly unprofitable to most people. For those among you who may doubt these words, let me remind them of what took place in June last year.
Socialism 3 Essay Research Paper 1 Overcoming
Socialism 3 Essay, Research Paper 1. Overcoming Capitalism The overall aim of all my political activity is to do the most to facilitate the transition of humanity from capitalism to a higher system based on the principle: ” From each according to his ability, to each according to his need. ” It is the capitalist mode of production which represents the great driving force of all social dysfunction in the modern world.
Industrial Revolution DBQ Essay Research Paper The
Industrial Revolution DBQ Essay, Research Paper The impact of the Industrial Revolution was a positive experience for some, but it was a great difficulty for others. Because of the demands for reform and protection for workers arose, government and unions began to take place. That was how the evils of the Industrial Revolution addressed in England in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
A Socialist Meeting Essay Research Paper SOCIALIST
A Socialist Meeting Essay, Research Paper SOCIALIST MEETING HELD A roar of agreement echoes from every member of the crowd, and is meant for the orator standing on the platform before them. Sweat running from the man s face, he has just delivered an inspiring speech on the advantages of socialism. This man has given similar orations for over twenty days consecutively, for hours on end.
Market Socialism Essay Research Paper In 1978
Market Socialism Essay, Research Paper In 1978, Deng Xiaoping opened the Chinese economy to increased foreign trade and investment. Under growing pressure from the international community, the bureaucracy under Deng moved towards economic reforms. This move towards capitalism was, in the words of Deng, socialism with Chinese characteristics.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper Capitalism faces several
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism faces several challenges and problems. Two main problems with capitalism are, property and income become unequal, and major industries suppress small entrepreneurs. The advantage and costs reflects the fist choice of the buyers that want to spend money. Instead the first choice should be more on the people who don?t have money to spend, like the poor.
The Jungle Socialism Essay Research Paper The
The Jungle Socialism Essay, Research Paper The Jungle: Socialism During the late 1800’s and early 1900’s hundreds of thousands of European immigrants migrated to the United States of America. They had aspirations of success, prosperity and their own conception of the American Dream. The majority of the immigrants believed that their lives would completely change for the better and the new world would bring nothing but happiness.
Capitalism Vs Socialism Essay Research Paper In
Capitalism Vs. Socialism Essay, Research Paper In order to debate between Capitalism and Socialism, it is necessary to understand what the differences, advantages, and disadvantages are of both systems. Basically, Capitalism advocates private property, and that society does better when an individual can purchase and produce as they see fit.
Capitalism Vs Socialism Essay Research Paper Christina
Capitalism Vs. Socialism Essay, Research Paper Christina HaselApril 22, 1999Economics Has Capitalism Defeated Socialism? Socialism and capitalism are not on different ends of the Economic Spectrum, but they could be, judging from the way each author defended his opinion and point of view on the subject.
Socialism And Capitalism Essay Research Paper What
Socialism And Capitalism Essay, Research Paper What is the difference between socialism and capitalism? Is socialism more moral than capitalism? To answer these questions we need to look at both systems and there definitions. Socialism is an economic system in which there is no private property and the state owns all the factors of production.
Politics Of The 1900 Essay Research Paper
The events that occur in Upton Sinclair?s book ?The Jungle? were same things that people in the early 20th century had to deal with everyday. For example labor was exploited to the employers benefit. Political corruption and prostitution were some main points in the book. The most important idea, the book supports socialism over capitalism as an economic and social structure.
Liberalism Vs Socialism Essay Research Paper Since
Liberalism Vs Socialism Essay, Research Paper Since the new development of ideologies in the nineteenth century, debates over the better political theory is still continued. Socialism and liberalism are two ideologies that attempt to provide a foundation for society, while both are critics of each other.
Post Soviet Russia Essay Research Paper In
Post Soviet Russia Essay, Research Paper In December of 1991, the Soviet Union disintegrated into fifteen separate countries. Its collapse was hailed by the west as a victory for freedom, a triumph of democracy over totalitarianism, and evidence of the superiority of capitalism over socialism. It was a relief for many to watch the Soviet Union brake down, finally bringing the cold world to an end.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper The protection from
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper The protection from force, that is, the protection of individual rights, would be achieved through the use of a police force to protect the rights of citizens at home; a military, to protect the rights of citizens from foreign aggression; and a court system to enforce contracts and settle disputes between citizens.
The Jungle 4 Essay Research Paper American
The Jungle 4 Essay, Research Paper American history has always been dominated by those individuals who have challenged themselves with causes. Sinclair used The Jungle as a way to make America aware of the corruption of Chicago s meat packing industry and the general corruption of capitalism. He did this by telling the story of a group of Lithuanian immigrants who came to America seeking fortune, freedom, and opportunity.
Marx Essay Research Paper Karl Marx and
Marx Essay, Research Paper Karl Marx and Max Weber have agreed and disagreed on numerous issues during their years as sociologists and political economists. An issue that they
Jungle Essay Research Paper The Jungle written
Jungle Essay, Research Paper The Jungle, written by Upton Sinclair in 1905, the author supports Socialism over Capitalism and used the struggle to keep the house in order to portray the evils of Capitalism on the family and the society in General.
Jungle Essay Research Paper Upton Sinclair
Jungle Essay, Research Paper Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle is the tale of a Lithuanian immigrant, Jurgis Rudkus, and his family. Jurgis and his family move to the United States in the middle of
The Jungle Essay Research Paper Sinclair
The Jungle Essay, Research Paper Sinclair’s book ,The Jungle probably had to do the most with the fact that he himself was a Socialist. He was brought up in Baltimore, and
Globalization Essay Research Paper Gripping his cup
Globalization Essay, Research Paper Gripping his cup of mocha as if it were a necessary drug, my friend Peppy LeHaji sternly versed his opinion at me one day, ??Globalization is the name of the game,?? he said, ??In today??s world, things change so fast that history is irrelevant.?? After stating his opinion, he repositioned the patch on his shoulder, in hope that it would better stop his craving for nicotine, in a new position.