Energy Deregulation Essay, Research Paper
As we have witnessed the rolling blackouts and emergency alerts throughout many parts of our state of California within the past 12 months, there is a question waiting to be answered. Why do we have an energy crisis when there are other states that are doing just fine? Before we come to any hasty conclusion, let us ask ourselves what happened to the energy policy during the mid 90s? During that period the electric utilities went from being highly regulated to being deregulated following the trend in successful deregulation of many industries such as airline and telecommunication industries. The concept that deregulation will bring more competitive prices and better services to the public, undermined the negative potentials of the free market system. Deregulation bill must be abolished because it brings higher electricity prices, lower reliabilities of electricity, and also it threatens to drag down our economy along with it.
First, we have seen a nation-wide increase in both wholesale and retail electricity prices. In California as an example, the wholesale prices increased seven times last year compared to 1999 (Kahn and Lynch 13). The average residential electric bill almost doubled from $40 to $80 in San Diego when the SDG & E?s retail price freeze ended in June 2000.1 According to Washington Governor Gray Locke, ?the whole energy prices have gone up from ten to twenty times the prices of a year ago (1). In New York, more specifically in New York City and parts of Westchester County which are one of the first areas in the country to deregulate retail prices entirely, the retail rates have increased almost 30% (Eisenberg 47). This is bad when you consider that ones that are going to be most hurt from these unreasonably high electricity prices will be the individuals and families that are in the low-income bracket.
Second, the reliability of electricity was compromised throughout many parts of our state, affecting both residential and business sectors. On June 14, 2000, about 100,000 customers were blacked out in San Francisco Bay Area (Kahn and Lynch 9-10). According to Lorenco Goncalves, the CEO of California steel industries, ?We were interrupted 14 times this month [January] compared to not once from 1987 to 1998. So many other industries depend on what we send them?If they can?t depend on my products, they will [buy them] elsewhere? (Wood and Sherer). These uncertain interruptions are causing a lot of damage in our economy. Jack Kyser, director of the Los Angeles Economic Development Council, asserts that, ?Concern is rippling through every business in the state, because they are getting calls from customers wondering if they will be able to deliver? (Wood and Scherer). The estimated loss from the rolling blackouts in January is $1.8 billion according to Mr. Kyser (Wood and Sherer). A plan that was supposed to deliver better services, has in turn given more troubles to the public.
Finally, there is another problem associated with deregulation and that is price gouging. When the big three utilities were ordered to sell their generation plants to prepare for deregulation, many private companies purchased those power plants. These plants generate electricity that is then purchased by utilities that control transmission and distribution of electricity. However, many private companies who own the plants allegedly created an artificial shortage which results in price spikes (Sloan, Allan). This is a perfect example why public utilities, especially the electric utilities, should not be deregulated. When people take full advantage of the supply and demand such as in this case, the outcome is certainly instability and disorder of our public utility system.
Despite the fact that deregulation was a huge failure in California, the proponents of deregulation argue that it can work to bring more choices and competitive prices. The best real example comes from the state of Pennsylvania where its residents saved $3 billion on their electric bills after the state adopted deregulation bill (Eisenberg 46). Another example is the state of Texas. Eisenberg says that, ??state officials are guaranteeing a 6% rate cut from the get-go when retail deregulation takes effect next year? (Eisenberg 47). However, there are other states that had been deregulated but did not experience more competitive rates. According to Eisenberg, the electric bill in Massachusetts increased by 50% even though they were promised 15% cuts after deregulation (47). Also, it should be noted that municipally owned utilities in Los Angeles and Sacramento,which did not participate in the deregulation process, never faced any spike in electricity prices or blackouts (Ivins).
Others argue that although deregulation had failed in California, it is not the deregulation that directly contributed to the crisis but because it was badly planned and carried out inappropriately. Sloan sites,
?California put a cap on the rates that utilities could charge customers, but until recently, it forced utilities to buy all of their power in the short-term market. The utilities foolishly agreed to this deal. The problem: short-term markets are notoriously volatile. And notoriously ruthless. If there’s a small surplus of power, you have desperate sellers trying to sell power, which can’t be stored. But if there’s a shortage, everyone piles on. Had California utilities been allowed to do the rational thing and buy most of their power in long-term markets, they would have paid more initially, but they and their customers would be in far better shape now. Compounding the problem is that while the state deregulated the wholesale rates the utilities paid for power, they capped the retail rates utilities could charge. Combine that with total reliance on the short-term market and–voila! –you’re totally at the market’s mercy. And markets have no mercy.?
In addition to these flaws, what aggrevated these crisis is that California did not open more power plants to keep up with the demand. While electricity usage increased 15 percent from 1990 to 2000, no new power plants were opened in California?meaning California has to import between 10 and 30 percent of their electricity from other states (Gale Group). Another factor is that no one had ever anticipated the spike in rates for natural gas, which fuels half of California?s power plants and can account for more than half of the electricity costs (Greenwald 39).
The proponents of deregulation?s strongest argument is the successful results of deregulation in other industries. According to Winston, an economist, about “80 percent of airline passengers are paying lower fares than they would have under regulation”(Flanigan). Flanigan sites,
?Customer choice and employment have expanded in all those industries. In telecommunications, costs of long-distance telephone calls have come down dramatically as competitors offered consumers more and cheaper service. New technology has flourished, creating entirely new communications industries. In fact, the highest prices for telephone calls remain in the local systems, which are still largely regulated.?
But just because deregulation worked on many public industries, it doesn?t necessarily mean that it works for every type of industries such as in electricity. As far as electricity is concerned, we have seen more failures than successes so far.
Despite the successful deregulation transition of other industries, the public electric utility must not be deregulated because having more choices and competitions do not outweigh public safety. Also, it should be noted that no matter how beneficial deregulation can be, if it is not properly planned and when the dangerous potentials for disaster are overlooked, history will most likely repeat itself.Notes
1Retail customers of Pacific Gas and Electric company(PG&E), Southern California Edison company(SCE), and San Diego Gas and Electric(SDG&G) were temporarily protected from the impact of rate spikes caused by direct exposure to high wholesale prices. SDG&E?s rate freeze ended in June 2000, and PG&E and SCE?s must end by 2002 (Kahn and Lynch 12).
Eisenberg, Daniel. ?Which State is Next?? Time Jan. 29, 2001: 46-47
Flanigan, James. “Deregulation Is the Answer, Not the Problem.? The Los
Angeles Times Aug. 27, 2000: Commentary. .
Greenwald, John. ?The New Energy Crunch.? Time Jan. 29, 2001: 39-42.
Group, Gale. ?Proponents of Texas Energy Deregulation See No Parallels to
California Crisis.? The Dallas Morning News Jan. 19, 2001.
.
Kahn, Michael, and Loretta Lynch. California?s Electricity Options and
Challenges Report to Governor Gray Davis. 2001: 10-13
Другие работы по теме:
Energy Consumption Essay Research Paper ENERGY CONSUMPTION
Energy Consumption Essay, Research Paper ENERGY CONSUMPTION The United States of America uses more than one fifth of the world’s resources. Energy consumption doubled between 1952 and 1972 and although consumption has slowed it continues to rise at an alarming rate. In the 1940’s the U.S.A exported fuel but by 1952 it was importing large amounts of oil and coal.
Batteries Essay Research Paper BatteriesSince my project
Batteries Essay, Research Paper BatteriesSince my project is mainly about batteries, I decided toresearch the topic “battery.” Here is the research that I discovered. The first person ever to use the battery was Alessandro Volta.He was an Italian professor who devised the first battery in the1800’s. He created this device to provide steady electric currentfor study and practical use.
2Nd Law Of Thermodynamics Vs E Essay
, Research Paper Second Law of Thermodynamics vs. Evolution According to the second law of thermodynamics, when energy is converted from one form to another, the amount of useful energy decreases. In relation to the theory of evolution, this law is not contradictory. The second law of thermodynamics is not relating to energy within living things because living things retain energy from the sun.
Covalent Bonds Essay Research Paper The first
Covalent Bonds Essay, Research Paper The first ionization energy IE1 is the energy required to remove the one electron from a gaseous atom. With this the effective nuclear charge increases and thus it takes more energy to remove the next electron. IE2 is always greater than IE1. Each subsequent electron becomes harder to remove.
Plur Essay Research Paper PLURthe land of
Plur Essay, Research Paper P*L*U*R the land of kandykidz, raves & happiness ?Children of the night? children of the night dreding to see daylight it all begins around eleven or
Anwr Essay Research Paper This web article
Anwr Essay, Research Paper This web article written by Ian Christopher, from CNN is a great reason why Bush is out to diminish our natural areas. This article is titled; In Debate Preview, Candidates outline Competing Energy Policies. This is about the energy portion of the debate. Gore is for environmental preservation; therefore, I am on Gore s side of the argument.
NanoTechnology Essay Research Paper One of the
Nano-Technology Essay, Research Paper One of the big problems not fully appreciated with current ideas in nano technology research is the energy requirement for the development of shuttles and using it to carry the bots to other planets. First of all, the design of the shuttle would have to be very intricate because it would have to be able to manage to intense cold since it has to travel farther and farther away from the sun.
Airline Deregulation Essay Research Paper Give credit
Airline Deregulation Essay, Research Paper Give credit where credit is due. Twenty years ago, the Carter Administration and Congress, behind the ceaseless efforts of Alfred E. Kahn, former chairman of the now defunct CAB (Civil Aeronautics Board), deregulated the airlines, a move that has saved consumers billions of dollars.
Element Essay Research Paper What is an
Element Essay, Research Paper What is an element: Simple substances that can not be broken down into simpler substances. What is an atom: smallest part of an element that can be identified as an element.
Econ Essay Research Paper When Virtue Pays
Econ Essay, Research Paper -When Virtue Pays a Premium Through the help of government deregulation, increase in technology, and increased awareness of global environmental issues, a transition from fossil fuels to renewable resources is imminent. The cost of renewable resources are on the decline and they are starting to become a real threat to compete with fossil fuels.
Nucelar Enargy Essay Research Paper nuclear reactornuclear
Nucelar Enargy Essay, Research Paper nuclear reactor nuclear reactor, device for producing NUCLEAR ENERGY by controlled nuclear reactions. It can be used for either research or power production. The reactor is so constructed that the fission of atomic nuclei produces a self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction, in which the produced neutrons are able to split other nuclei.
Mechanical Energy Essay Research Paper Have you
Mechanical Energy Essay, Research Paper Have you ever wondered how a jet aircraft lifts its tremendous weight off the ground, or what gives a runner the stamina to reach the finish line in a race? In order
Gibb
’s Free Energy Cycle Essay, Research Paper The second law of thermodynamics states that energy transitions are imperfect. No matter what, energy is lost. In machines an 75% loss of energy is considered average. In biological reactions there is usually a 60% loss. Since all reactions are constantly losing a percentage of the energy they give, it is necessary to have a constant intake of energy to make up for what is lost.
Should The United States Invest More Money
In Renewable Energy Research And Development As Opposed To Fossil And Nuclear Fuels? Essay, Research Paper The United States should invest more money into the research and development of renewable energy. These renewable resources would take the place of fossil fuels, which are non-renewable resources.
California Utility Essay Research Paper Chris Parker
California Utility Essay, Research Paper Chris Parker 482.004 Dr. Singer In 1996 deregulation allowed California utility companies to sell power plants and collect over 19 billion dollars in ratepayer subsidies. The money was used to purchase plants in other countries, reward executives with huge pay raises and buy back stock.
Electrical Energy Essay Research Paper Electrical EnergyA
Electrical Energy Essay, Research Paper Electrical Energy A capacitor can store electrical energy. Connecting it across a resistor or other device discharges it. Across the resistor there is a potential difference that creates the electric current. When the charge in the capacitor decreases, at the same time the voltage decreases.
Late 1990s American Essay Research Paper In
Late 1990s American Essay, Research Paper In the late 1990s Americans for the first time found themselves in the position of being able to choose an electricity provider, as the once staid and monopolistic electric utility industry entered an era of freewheeling competition and deregulation. In this book Richard F.
Electricity Produced By Ocean Waves Essay Research
Paper Day by day we look for alterntives to the many things we do. We tend to worry about the effects we have on the enviorment and more. This is why it is important to find different ways of producing electricity without producing a huge amount of pollution.Since 1799 man has tried to use the potential power of wave energy. only recently in the last few decades has man been able rto develope devices which could harness the power oif the ocean.
Energy Essay Research Paper The first question
Energy Essay, Research Paper The first question, which I must ask in order to write this essay, is, what is energy? Energy gives us the ability to do thing. Everything in the world needs a supply of energy, and so energy is used to make things work. The word energy is taken from the Greeks and means the work within and nearly all energy originally came from the sun.
Solar Essay Research Paper SOLAR ENERGY
Solar Essay, Research Paper SOLAR ENERGY — THE ENERGY OF THE FUTURE? About 47 per cent of the energy that the sun releases to the earth actually reaches the ground. About a third is reflected directly back into space by the atmosphere. The time in which solar energy is available, is also the time we least need it least – daytime.
Hydrogen Essay Research Paper Wild Bill
Hydrogen Essay, Research Paper Wild Bill’s Wild Bohr Quiz Niels Bohr’s model of the hydrogen atom, was the primary reason for the understanding of energy levels.
Deregulation Of Natural Gas Essay Research Paper
The Deregulation of the Natural Gas Industry The main objective of my paper is to discuss the key points surrounding the deregulation of the natural gas industry. I will lead into this discussion by explaining how the industry performed during a period of regulation and what transpired forcing a change to deregulate.
Pushing An Object Essay Research Paper Pushing
Pushing An Object Essay, Research Paper Pushing an object When an object with mass is moving, that it has kinetic energy is well known. Energy quantity can be expressed in two parameters of the mass and the speed. Generally definition of energy is difficult, though the quantity can be measured easily.
Nuclear Energy Essay Research Paper Nuclear Energy
Nuclear Energy Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Energy should be produced because it is an alternative to fossil fuel. Nuclear energy helps to conserve our national resources that we use as fuel such as coil, oil, and natural gas. Another pro of nuclear energy is that radiation that is given off by nuclear energy is mostly thought of a very dangerous thing but it can be used in positive ways too.
Solar Energy An Alternative Energy Essay Research
Paper Solar Energy: An Alternative Energy Imagine a perfect source of energy. One with which no pollution what-so-ever is associated with. No poisonous gasses or destruction of rain forests. This
Deregulation Essay Research Paper Electricity is one
Deregulation Essay, Research Paper Electricity is one of the largest selling commodities in the nation. In 1994, over $200 billion worth of electricity was generated and sold. In the same year, $30 billion in cattle were sold, and $6 billion in wheat changed hands.Electricity has traditionally been delivered through a tightly regulated monopoly where corporate profits were artificially established and assured by oversight panels.
Windmills Essay Research Paper Wind energy can
Windmills Essay, Research Paper Wind energy can be used to do work. When a boat lifts a sail, it is using wind energy to push it through the water. Farmers have been using wind energy for many years to pump water from wells using windmills. In Holland, windmills have been used for centuries to pump water from low-lying areas.
Alternate Energy Resources Essay Research Paper As
Alternate Energy Resources Essay, Research Paper As most people know our energy supply is slowly running out. We are using energy sources that either pollute the air, take up natural resources or cause damage to other forms of life. Today, we are working on other forms of energy that do not pollute or cause harm to the environment.
Alternate Energy Sources Essay Research Paper WINDMILLSThe
Alternate Energy Sources Essay, Research Paper WINDMILLS The reason why I chose to do a project on windmills is because I would always drive out to Palm Springs and I would see these huge thing’s that looked like something out of a
Fuel Cells Essay Research Paper Electricity is
Fuel Cells Essay, Research Paper Electricity is a vital part of in the present day economic based world and almost impossible to do with out in this modern age. Many problems arise over the most commonly used energy sources of today such as oil, coal and even the voltaic cells used as car batteries. These resources are often expensive and are not everlasting.