Dante`S Inferno Essay, Research Paper
Dante’s Canto XXVIII
Dante begins the opening of Canto XXVIII with a rhetorical
question. Virgil and he have just arrived in the Ninth Abyss of the
Eighth Circle of hell. In this pouch the Sowers of Discord and Schism
are continually wounded by a demon with a sword. Dante poses a
question to the reader:
Who, even with untrammeled words and many
attempts at telling, ever could recount
in full the blood and wounds that I now saw? (Lines 1-3)
The rhetorical question draws the reader into the passage
because we know by this point in the Divine Comedy that Dante is a
great poet. What is it that Dante sees before him on the brink of the
Ninth Abyss that is so ineffable that he, as a poet, feels he cannot
handle?
In the following lines Dante expands on this rhetorical
position. He elaborates on why it is important for any man to offer a
good description of what he sees. No poet can achieve this
description: ?Each tongue that tried would certainly fall short…?
(L. 4) It is not just poetic talent that is at stake; poets do not
have the background to give them the poetic power for such
description. His reasoning is “the shallowness of both our speech and
intellect cannot contain so much.” (Lines 5-6) Once again the reader
is intrigued; how could a man of Dante’s stature criticize language
which is the very tool he uses to create the epic work of La Commedia
? If we cannot take Dante seriously with these opening statements, we
must pose the question of what Dante is trying to do by teasing us
with this artificial beginning to Canto XVIII?
Dante will now contradict himself and try to describe what he
says is impossible. But, if he were to go right into a description of
the Ninth Abyss, it would deflate his rhetorical position. Instead,
Dante first sets up a quite lengthy comparison of the sights he has
just witnessed with examples of bloodshed throughout human history.
Were you to reassemble all the men
who once, within Apulia1’s fateful land,
had mourned their blood, shed at the Trojans’ hands,
as well as those who fell in the long war
where massive mounds of rings were battle spoils–
even as Livy write, who does not err–
and those who felt the thrust of painful blows
when they fought hard against Robert Guiscard;
with all the rest whose bones are still piled up
at Ceperano–each Apulian was
a traitor there–and, and too, at Tabliacozzo,
where old Alardo conquered without weapons;
and then, were one to show his limb pierced through
and one his limb hacked off, that would not match
the hideousness of the ninth abyss. (Lines 7-21)
Dante gives historical examples of the destruction of war.
This is in contrast to the heroic qualities of war which Dante’s
predecessors most often focus on. Dante is acting less as a poet and
more as an historian. He takes the reader on a mini journey through
these wars. His first stop are the Trojan wars (Line 9). These wars
Dante refers to actually represent the final books of Virgil’s Aeneid.
Part of my experience in reading the Inferno, has been that there is a
great connection between the Inferno and the Aeneid. Furthermore,
Dante’s guide through hell is the author of the Aeneid, Virgil. (While
this topic is much too broad to address in these pages, it is
important too take note of this relationship.) On the one hand it is
important that Virgil is Dante’s first example because it is necessary
for him to leave the world of the poet (poets do not have enough
talent) and move to the world of the historian, whose objectivity is
supposedly more trusted in front of this horror. By this time the
reader can see the irony of what Dante is doing in this opening
passage. Dante the poet must give up to historical fact, but the
reader knows that Dante the poet is playing this game to entice the
reader into listening to him.
Dante moves on to the wars at Carthage in his next example.
This is material which Virgil deliberately does not deal with in the
Aeneid because this was a battle which the Romans barely come out
intact. The historian Livy is used as the narrator of these events.
Livy describes the destruction at Carthage:
The attention of all was particularly attracted by a living Numidian
with his nose and ears mangled, stretched under a dead Roman, who lay
over him, and who, when his hands had been rendered unable to hold a
weapon, his rage being exasperated to madness, had expired in the act
of tearing his antagonist with his teeth. (Livy, Book XXII)
Dante is legitimizing his poetry with these references from history.
In line twelve Dante writes “…even as Livy writes, who does not
err–.” He is explicitly giving credit to Livy for the ability to
describe the blood and wounds of war.
After referring to both Virgial and Livy, who are writers of
classical Roman battles, Dante moves on to a time closer to his
present. He refers to grotesque images which took place in the
thirteenth century.
By this point in the passage, Dante has assembled a tremendous cast of
hideousness spanding thousands of years. He has shown examples of the
most grotesque and gruesome things on earth, which is war. However,
he concludes that nothing is worse than the hideousness of the
underworld in hell.
The images Dante creates with his description of the ninth
abyss are truly more hideous than anything that could have been
written about the wars Dante compares them to
No barrel, even though it’s lost a hoop
or end-piece, ever gapes as one whom I
saw ripped right from his chin to where we fart:
his bowels hung between his legs, one saw
his vitals and the miserable sack
that makes fo what we swallow excrement. (Lines 22-27)
The image of a barrel, which has lost its end-piece, gives the reader
a concrete analogy for the man who has been split apart. A barrel does
not connote anything remotely to do with violence and the grotesque;
however, it fits perfectly here because it gives the reader a rather
plain image while Dante prepares to shock the reader with his language
of hideousness. He describes a man being split open “right from his
chin to where we fart…” The simplicity of the image in no way
warrants its use as an analogy for the horrible picture of the man
being split apart. The juxtoposition of the barrel with the torn body
creates a shock and a pathos because we know the barrel , but we can
hardly encompass the horror. He has used the barrel in the same way as
he used the examples of bloodshed in the previous sentence. In both
cases Dante introduces a comparison only to reject it.
It is at this point in the passage that we realize why Dante
compared earthly wars with the violence of the ninth abyss before he
even gave the reader a glimpse of this violence. By putting this
violence at such a grotesque level, he has made the reader form an
image in his mind before he describes it. By using the commonplace,
Dante forces the reader to resort to memory of things past.
Furthermore, Dante is asking the reader to strech his imagination
beyond its normal bounds. This effect ends up enhancing the words
Dante chooses when he does describe the act in lines 22 to 25.
The action of the man being split apart is also fairly
significant. Every little detail of the Divine Comedy has been worked
out and planned with the utmost precision. The ninth abyss is no
exception. The splitting of the men fits into the pattern of the rest
of the punishments in the inferno. These men who reside in this pouch
are sowers of discord and schism. To sow means to disseminate or
spread throughout the land. Schism means division. Thus, the physical
punishments literally express the philosophical sin.
The most interesting part of this passage comes at the end in
the last paragraph:
While I was all intent on watching him,
he looked at me, and with his hands he spread
his chest and said: “See how I split myself! (Lines 28-30)
The image of the man using his hands to pull his wound apart is
extremely vivid; it reminds me, for instance, of when Superman pulls
his shirt apart to reveal the capital S. Superman becomes another
example, like the barrel, which is useful to the reader in spite of
the fact it fails to express what Dante can.
As Dante watches the man who has just been split into two, the
man looks back at Dante. And as the man turns his attention to Dante,
so do we. Furthermore, when the man says “See how I split myself” we
also hear Dante say these words to us. Just as the man forces his
viewer (Dante) to examine his wounds, Dante forces the read to examine
the hideousness he has produced. The man has a strange pride in
splittng himself open. Dante also takes tremendous pride in describing
this scene, which he first claimed was impossible to ever put into
words. By pretending he could not express the image and then by fully
expressing it, Dante is reminding the reader of his extraordinary
talent and he is also forcing the reader to read more careful.
After examining this single passage from Dante’s Inferno, I
came to a new understanding of the relationship between Dante and La
Commedia , as well as between Dante’s images and his poetic task.
325
Другие работы по теме:
Symbolic Structure And Content Essay Research Paper
Symbolic Structure and Content The journey of Dante through hell, in both its structure and content, symbolizes the nature of sin and punishment. The structure of the book takes the reader step by step through greater and greater sins. The content of the book shows the different punishments for sins, which they are symbolic of the sins themselves; it also, through its language, shows how hell compares to life.
Monte Cristo Essay Research Paper In The
Monte Cristo Essay, Research Paper In The Count of Monte Cristo, Alexander Dumas places Edmond Dantes in the position to act as God around those whom he is associated with. It is common knowledge, that God is a kind, loving, all knowing, and wrathful. Dantes is shown to have all of these characteristics. Dantes first shows his kindness as the Abbe Busoni and Lord Wilmore as he rewards those who were once kind to him.
Gayism Essay Research Paper literary scholars have
Gayism Essay, Research Paper literary scholars have argued the fact that Dante had homoerotic tendencies. This poin Many t has been justified with the help of Dante s own work of art, the Inferno, a divine comedy where Dante goes down to visit the nine circles of hell. The sin of sodomy is seen in the seventh circle of hell, where sodomites, blasphemers and usurers are punished in three independent rings.
Count Of Montecristo Essay Research Paper Well
Count Of Montecristo Essay, Research Paper Well noticed in the novel The Count of Monte Cristo, as in The Merchant of Venice , The themes vengeance, conspiracy and love are clearly shown throughout the book. The
Movers And Shakers Dante Essay Research Paper
Movers and Shakers: Dante Have you ever thought about what comes next? What comes after life? The great Italian poet Dante Alighieri pondered this same question, and over the course of his 56 year life, he would come to change the world, touch lives, and question faith all with the power of his words. For this reason, Dante can be considered one of the greatest poets that the human civilization may have ever seen.
Dantes Cacus Essay Research Paper Character review
Dantes? Cacus Essay, Research Paper Character review: Of Cacus in Dantes? Divine Comedy Dantes? Cacus While on his famed excursion into the depths of Hell, Dante and his guide Virgil, have an encounter with the vile half-human Cacus. Whom is this one they call Cacus and what abominable thing did he have to do, to earn himself a place as one of the tormentors in the Inferno? Little is know about Cacus even in 1300s? because Dante had to have Virgil retell the legend of Cacus so people would understand how Cacus fit into this place of Hell.(Canto XXV line 25) Virgil himself had had this same legend retold in his work The Aeneid.
Literature Essay Research Paper Overtime peoples opinions
Literature Essay, Research Paper Overtime peoples opinions tend to change, as well as their views on situations. The waythat we view sins today and the way that sins were viewed around Dantes time hascompletely changed. My beliefs are that something is a sin if it is against God s will, or breaking theten commandments.
The Nature Of Humanity
– Dantes Inferno Essay, Research Paper The Nature of Humanity There are many differences between modern society and Dante s perception Florence, Italy. These differences are caused by the passage of time. The society depicted in Dante s Inferno is almost completely different than modern society, when taken at face value.
Paolo And Francesca
– Dante’s Inferno Canto V Essay, Research Paper Icee@itookmyprozac A Daughter of Eve As Eve was to Adam, Delilah to Samson and Cleopatra to Anthony, so was Francesca da Rimini to Paolo Malatesta.
Dante On Islam Essay Research Paper Divine
Dante On Islam Essay, Research Paper Divine Retribution ( in Italian contrapasso) is clearly shown in canto 28 by showing the punishment of the sowers of schism and scandal in the 9th bolgia of
Count Of Monte Cristo- Character Review On
Fernand Essay, Research Paper THE COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO By Alexandre Dumas Fernand Mondego was a simple fisherman who led a dull, monotonous life and was not very important in the social status. If he had just been content in all of his circumstances, his life might have been better. However, from the very beginning of the book, Fernand’s goal in life was to obtain things he could not obtain.
Punishments In Dante
’s Inferno Essay, Research Paper Cindy Kenney English 355 Burn in Hell The Comedy, later renamed The Divine Comedy was written by Dante Alighieri of Florence, Italy. In the early 14th century,
Dante Essay Research Paper Edmund Dantes a
Dante Essay, Research Paper Edmund Dantes, a strapping young sailor, was the prime years of his life during the nineteenth century. He was a good person, was well mannered and frankly had a lot of things going for him. He was affianced to the lovely Mercedes, he captained a good ship, the Pharon, and had whom he thought been good friends.
Dantes Inferno Essay Research Paper Johnson Brad
Dantes Inferno Essay, Research Paper Johnson, Brad# CRUEL PUNISHMENTS OF SINNERS IN THE RAGING INFERNO Dante Alighieri was born in Florence, Italy in 1265. In his life, he composed two major books of poetry: Vita Nuova and The Divine Comedy. The Vita Nuova is composed of love poems, sonnets, and lyrics. The Divine Comedy, is an epic poem segmented into three books, each of which recounts Dante s travels through hell, purgatory, and heaven.
DanteS Inferno Second Circle Of Hell Essay
, Research Paper Canto V In Dante’s Inferno, part of The Divine Comedy, Canto V introduces the torments of Hell in the Second Circle. Here Minos tells the damned where they will spend eternity by wrapping his tail around himself. The Second Circle of Hell holds the lustful; those who sinned with the flesh. They are punished in the darkness by an unending tempest, which batters them with winds and rain.
Inferno Versus Paradise Lost Essay Research Paper
Inferno vs. Paradise Lost The two stories Inferno by Dante and Paradise Lost by Milton were written about the biblical hell and its keeper; Satan. Both of these authors had different views about hell and Satan.
Dante S Inferno Essay Research Paper In
Dante S Inferno Essay, Research Paper In Dante s Inferno, hell is described as a place full of torture and hopelessness. Within the circular body of hell, each level contained unique punishments for various types of sin. The further Dante descended into hell, the worse the punishments became. Due to the time period in which Dante wrote the Inferno, only the individuals of that time, along with their respective sins, are addressed.
Dante Essay Research Paper Inferno Dante
Dante Essay, Research Paper Inferno Dante’s Divine Comedy, first titled La Commedia, is divided into three sections: Inferno (Hell), Purgatorio (Purgatory), and Paradiso (Heaven). Dante and Virgil, his companion, enter the gates of Hell on their journey through the afterlife and experience the terror and horrible punishments that correspond to the sins that were made in the previous life.
Political Context Of Dante
’s Inferno Essay, Research Paper The political context of Dante’s Inferno Dante’s “Inferno” was a great epic poem of the early Renaissance. It was known for its astute commentary on political and religious levels, both deeply woven into the work through allegory. Dante wrote his Divine Comedy in a specific historical and political context.
Dantes Inferno Essay Research Paper Dante the
Dantes Inferno Essay, Research Paper Dante the Pilgrim was once a spiritual and holy man, but as of recently he had felt less than holy. Yet, he still wants to remain spiritual. To do this, Dante must recognize the true nature of his sin(s), renounce them, and pay penance for them by travelling though the nine levels of hell.
Dantes Inferno Essay Research Paper Canto XThe
Dantes Inferno Essay, Research Paper Canto X: The Perils of Pride In The Inferno, Dante describes his journey through hell. Throughout his pilgrimage, Dante learns from the sinners that he meets along the way. One influential group of sinners is those in Canto X. In this Canto, Dante is warned that those filled with pride suffer eternally.
Dante AlighieriS Inferno Essay Research Paper Dante
Dante Alighieri`S Inferno Essay, Research Paper Dante Alighieri was born in Florence in May, 1265, of an old family, of noble origin but no longer wealthy. He studied the triviun and quadrivium, he spent a year of so at the University of Bologna, and while there he came under the influence of some of the learned men of his day.
Dante And Homer Essay Research Paper Dante
Dante And Homer Essay, Research Paper Dante makes many references to Homer and the Iliad throughout the Inferno. The fates of favorite characters are described during the course of Dante?s
The Significance Of Virgil In The Inferno
Essay, Research Paper Ryan Henson Mind 180 Essay #2 What is the significance of Virgil?s relationship with Dante? The Inferno is an epic poem by Dante Alighieri, one of the greatest poets in the history of western literature. In it, he uses his mastery of language to blend elements of classical literature with a more contemporary Catholic viewpoint.
Allegory In The Divine Comedy Essay Research
Paper Dante wrote The Divine Comedy between 1308 and 1321. The Divine Comedy was written as an allegory, Which is a narrative that takes place on both a literal and a figurative or symbolic level. Dante uses himself as the main character and uses allegory to describe himself in the epic.
Inferno By Dante Essay Research Paper Although
Inferno By Dante Essay, Research Paper Although it is hard to read Dante’s triple rhyme, I am thrilled by the Inferno’s ambiguity and allegoric power. It is really “a three-dimensional art.” Just like Picasso in his paintings, Dante makes me think about the meaning of the situations and their implications.
Spiritual Journeys Essay Research Paper The Tale
Spiritual Journeys Essay, Research Paper The Tale of Saigyo and The Inferno both trace the unique journeys of two interesting figures, Saigyo and Dante. The two journeys are differing in that one is a journey through the life of a Buddhist monk, and the other is a journey through the different circles of hell.
Dante Reaction Paper Essay Research Paper Dante
Dante Reaction Paper Essay, Research Paper Dante Reaction Paper In his lecture, Professor Mark Dantmore says that Purgatorio is “almost science fiction” to people of the time it was written. I find it very interesting that a book in the Divine Comedy, something the Catholics take as truth, might be described this way.
Christianity In The Inferno Essay Research Paper
Shannon Burger Literature of the Western World Christianity in The Inferno In The Inferno, Dante Alighieri gives his audience a clear vivid presentation of what he as a follower of the Christian religion perceives to be hell. Dante shows that human sin is punishable in various degrees of severity and that this is dependent on the nature of one^+s sinful actions.
The Inferno Essay Essay Research Paper The
The Inferno Essay Essay, Research Paper The Inferno Essay The Inferno, translated by John Ciardi, is a poem of Dante s immortal drama of a journey through Hell. Sensory imagery is established throughout the poem in the course of Virgil s attempt to aid Dante through the different symbolic retributions that make up the structure of Hell.
The Inferno Essay Research Paper The Inferno
The Inferno Essay, Research Paper The Inferno The Inferno, written by Dante, is a poem that deals with the afterlife. It deals with the ideas that actions and practices taken up in this life will determine the
Dante Essay Research Paper Dante s InfernoDeath
Dante Essay, Research Paper Dante s Inferno Death and what comes after has always been a topic of great interest and uncertainty. Many have tried to depict their own vision of the afterlife, be it heaven or hell, paradiso or inferno. The inferno is more than just a fictional story about someone traveling through the universe; it s more like an autobiographical journey of life through its author, Dante.
Dante Essay Research Paper In Dantes Inferno
Dante Essay, Research Paper In Dante?s Inferno, Dante narrates his descent and observation of hell through the various circles and pouches. One part of this depiction is his descriptions of the various punishments that each of the different sinners has received.
Dante Inferno Essay Research Paper Dante Alighieri
Dante Inferno Essay, Research Paper Dante Alighieri s Divine Comedy is said to be the single greatest epic poem of all time. The opening story of the character of Dante the Pilgrim is told in the first of the three divisions: The Inferno. The Inferno is a description of Dante s journey down through Hell and of the several degrees of suffering and many mythical creatures that he encounters on the way.