Euthanasia-Mercy Or Murder Essay, Research Paper
Euthanasia:
Is it “mercy killing” or just plain killing?
“In keeping with the root definition of ‘euthanasia’- literally [meaning] ‘good
death’- [supporters] of euthanasia insist they are talking about helping terminally ill
patients in insufferable pain die a dignified death- at the patient’s request. But this
bears no resemblance to the true picture of the actual practice of euthanasia in the
United States” (Lyons np). Passive euthanasia is death by nonintervention, meaning
a health care worker can discontinue providing life-sustaining treatment to the
patient, thus allowing him to die more quickly. “In all actuality, [passive]
euthanasia often involves withholding food and water from a patient whose death is
caused by starvation or dehydration rather than the patient’s underlying disease”
(Lyons np). In active euthanasia, a physician or family member takes the life of a
patient by means of lethal injection, before he or she dies of a terminal illness or
injury. Currently, passive euthanasia is prohibited in most states, but not all.
Whereas, active euthanasia is illegal in every state. Although many people believe
that euthanasia is a way for people to die with dignity, it is the deliberate taking of a
human life and should be banned because it is a clear form of murder.
Of course, supporters of euthanasia do not agree that this is an act of murder,
but rather they see it as an act of mercy. They believe that when an individual’s
quality of life is severely diminished by debilitating diseases or terminal illnesses, he
or she should have the right to decide between life or death by euthanasia. They
strongly feel that their love ones should be allowed to die peacefully, surrounded by
family and friends. They believe that to assist a loved one with ‘mercy killing’ is an
unselfish act of compassion, and to grant their last wish allows them to die with
dignity. The most active group of supporters are members of the Hemlock Society.
These supporters are Christians and churchgoers and believe that the God they
worship is a God of understanding and love. They also believe that “as long as [the
act of ‘mercy killing’] was justifiable and met the conditions of not hurting other
people then they feel that God would accept them into heaven” (Humphry 19).
Sure, in the eyes of euthanasia supporters, even those who claim to be
Christians, ‘mercy killing’ is a noble and compassionate act, but what is the 5th
commandment? You shall not kill. Those four words alone seem to eliminate all
possible suggestions in favor of euthanasia. Derek Humphry, founder of the
Hemlock Society, “… helped his wife, who was suffering from incurable bone
cancer, to take her life by supplying her with a cup of coffee laced with a lethal
mixture of secobarbital and codeine” (Worsnop 156). “Our society, basing its
views primarily on the fundamental values of Judaism and Christianity, has always
forbidden the taking of innocent life and has considered that act one of the most
serious, if not the most serious, breaches of morality possible” (Bleich 41).
Judeo-Christians believe that a person has no inherent right to commit suicide and
that the life of man can be reclaimed only by God Himself. They feel that suffering
is a part of God’s life plan and that human’s should accept it and learn from it. After
all, if there were no suffering, how would humans know the value of peace and
happiness? They also believe in the importance and value of human life, that it is
precious gift and should be taken care of. David Bleich expresses the views of
those opposed to euthanasia by stating that, “Human life is a divine mystery and
man [has been] commanded to create, to nurture, to sustain, and to preserve the life
that has been [given] to him” (40).
However, not all religious believers feel that euthanasia is unethical and
immoral. For example, Rabbi Joseph Edelheit states, “I would support active
euthanasia and even some selected cases of physician-assisted suicides with the
awareness and participation of the dying person and his or her family and closest
friends. I make this statement fully aware that life is a unique divine gift” (45).
Rabbi Edelheit believes that God has granted us this final act of free will. He
believes that we must humanely support euthanasia requested by patients and
surrogates, especially those lying in vegetative states or those who cannot die for
various legal reasons. He asks, “How can we justify this indignity to them and their
families?” (47). He strongly feels that those suffering deserve to die with dignity.
But does euthanasia ensure death with dignity? In all actuality, “ ‘Death with
dignity’ has become a catch phrase, but there’s nothing dignified about the methods
[euthanasia activists] advocate. For example, one euthanasia organization
distributes pamphlets on how to cause suffocation with a plastic bag. Most of Jack
Kevorkian’s ‘subjects,’ as he calls them, have been gassed to death with carbon
monoxide and some have had their bodies dumped in vehicles left in parking lots”
(Euthanasia 1). Also, the most common method of ‘mercy killing’ is withholding of
food and fluids. This process of mercy killing can take up to forty days before the
patient dies of starvation or dehydration. When food and fluids are withheld, the
body’s organs fail, causing severe abdominal cramps, nausea and vomiting, along
with depression, confusion, and delusions. This must be one of the most agonizing
ways to die and could hardly be considered a ‘dignified’ means of death. Matthew
Roberts strongly expresses his feeling towards euthanasia by stating, “…‘Death with
dignity’ is the biggest scheme ever created, the greatest ploy ever concocted, to
purposely divert attention from the real problems facing the world” (1).
Those requesting euthanasia for themselves feel that their illness is
responsible for many problems in their world. They truly believe that to end their
life, through euthanasia, would be the best solution to the many problems they and
their families are faced with. Due to their physical illness, they see themselves as a
burden to their family and loved ones, both physically and emotionally. Financial
considerations also add to this concern about being a burden. The expense of
medical treatments, equipment, and life-sustaining machines are often times found to
be too overwhelming and costly. They see euthanasia as a cheaper alternative to
health care and less ‘burdensome’ on their family members. This belief is also held
by Mr. Richard D. Lamm, an euthanasia supporter , who states, “We must look
rationally at the phenomenal amount of resources we spend on the last few weeks of
people’s lives, only to prolong suffering” (132).
However, you cannot put a price on the life of a human being. Life is a gift to
be treasured and taken care of by whatever means necessary. “One of the most
common reasons used to justify active euthanasia or assisted suicide is to relieve the
patient from pain. Yet, improvements in pain control are widely recognized by
virtually all segments of the medical profession as rendering this argument virtually
obsolete” (Lyons np). Modern medicine should be used to provide the most
up-to-date means of pain control and not used to kill. The will to live and to survive
is the strongest of all life’s natural instincts. If given a choice between life and
death, the majority of people choose to live. “A scientific study of people with
terminal illness was published in the American Journal of Psychiatry found that
fewer than one in four expressed a wish to die, and all of those who did had
clinically diagnosable depression” (Brown 210). Often times, terminal illnesses are
not treatable, but the depression is, and it is the depression that causes the patient to
consider euthanasia. With the help of counseling, psychological assistance, and
medical care, patients with terminal illnesses often can find positive alternatives to
euthanasia. According to Dr. Kubler -Ross, the dying process has five (5) stages;
denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance. Many valuable lessons are
learned during each of these stages. To end life early, by means of euthanasia, robs
a person of these lessons, such as, understanding the meaning of one’s life,
resolving old disputes, mending relationships and fully appreciating all the good
things that have been a part of one’s life. Opponents of euthanasia believe that
every human being deserves to experience this complete passage during the last
precious moments of their life.
Although many people are opposed to the banning of euthanasia, both passive
and active, it should be prohibited in all fifty states because it is clearly immoral and
unjust. The name ‘euthanasia’, often reffered to as ‘mercy killing’ is a misleading
concept. For the translation suggests, euthanasia is a compassionate and noble act
which allows people to ‘die with dignity’ and to end his or her suffering.
Realistically however, should starvation, dehydration, and suffocation be considered
‘compassionate’? Even the hippocrates, as far back as 460 B.C., expressed the same
opinion when they created the Hippocratic Oath which states, “I will follow that
method treatment which, according to my ability and judgment, I consider for the
benefit of my patients, and abstain from whatever is deleterious and mischievious. I
will give no deadly medicine to anyone if asked, nor suggest any such counsel…”
(Hippocratic 1). “… the Hippocratic tradition has stood for the ‘sanctity’ of human
life. We can alleviate the unbearable in life better than ever before. We can do that
and not eliminate life itself, … medicine cannot be both our healer and our killer”
(Koop np ). This statement seems to summarize the beliefs of those opposed to
euthanasia, ‘mercy killing’ is just plain killing.
Другие работы по теме:
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia which comes
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia which comes from the Greek meaning of easy death is one of our societies highly debatable issues and the main reason for this argument is against active euthanasia, which is when a terminally ill patient is administered with a lethal drug or using other means to cause there death.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Is euthanasia the
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Is euthanasia the mercy killing of someone who is in extreme pain in order to end suffering, an immoral or amoral act? Simply put, it is an immoral act even though it is intended to help another person. It is assisting in killing another human being, and ending their existence.
Euthanasia Should Be Abolished Essay Research Paper
Euthanasia is the painless, intentional death of a person who is suffering. Euthanasia is wrong because it alters our natural way of survival, and upsets religous beliefs. By using euthanasia, ?miraculous? recoveries have been prevented. People think that the easy way out of their problems is by conducting euthanasia.
Ethnobotany Essay Research Paper An Available OptionTry
Ethnobotany Essay, Research Paper An Available Option Try to imagine yourself or someone you hold close to you being very sick, so sick that just being alive each day gives more pain and suffering than the previous day. Not one person should have to suffer from a disease that is incurable and leads inevitably to death.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Assisted SuicideA great
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Assisted Suicide A great deal of debate surrounds the practice of assisted suicide. Lately, laws against voluntary euthanasia have been eased, although serious moral and legal questions still exist. Most opposition of assisted suicide comes from religious groups, including Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.
Argument Essay Research Paper Quantity vs QualityMany
Argument Essay, Research Paper Quantity vs. Quality Many people see death is a bad thing. People don t like it and they don t want to hear about it. For many seriously ill and vegetative patients, death is a good thing for them. Death will end their suffering from pains and they can also die with dignity. Euthanasia traditionally means a good death.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Jason Adams
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Jason Adams Adams1 October 15, 1998 Mrs. Faulk English Per.4Euthanasia Euthanasia should be legal, because if it is their life, therefore, they have the right to be able to end their suffering. Euthanasia was formerly called Mercy killing . Euthanasia means intentionally making someone decease rather then allowing that person to die naturally.
Murder At Inverness Essay Research Paper Murder
Murder At Inverness Essay, Research Paper Murder at Inverness By Aaron Klugh Last night at Inverness, Macbeth?s castle, King Duncan was stabbed to death. Macduff was the first who discovered Duncan dead in his bedroom. Along with the King, the guards were also murdered. Macbeth said he killed the guards in a fit of rage.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper DAS
Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper D.A.S Murder, death, suffering. All these horrific terms are related to an extremely important and devastating issue. Doctor assisted suicide is a very important subject that many people know little about. We need to finally shut this murdering out of Oregon for good.
Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper
EUTHANASIA AND ASSISTED SUICIDE In today’s society, euthanasia and assisted suicide is a major discussion. People, who are terminally ill or are depressed, are sometimes looking for a way out. They feel that their only hope is to kill themselves. Other people in the world feel that euthanasia and assisted suicide are morally wrong.
Euthanasia In Australia Essay Research Paper What
Euthanasia In Australia Essay, Research Paper What is it and how is it performed?Euthanasia is the practice of ending a life so as to release an individual from an incurable disease or intolerable suffering. The term is sometimes used generally to refer to an easy or painless death. Voluntary euthanasia involves a request by the dying patient or that person’s legal representative.
Legalizing Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Legalizing euthanasia
Legalizing Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Legalizing euthanasia in the United States gives rights to the people. Rights to those who endure the irrefutable agony of pain and suffering, rights to those who want to be cured of their pain, and rights to those that struggle to end their suffering. Euthanasia is the answer to end their suffering.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In the United
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In the United States, by current individual state laws, any form of euthanasia is murder and considered a criminal offense (ACT). At this time there are still
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia is just
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia is just another word for ?mercy killing? as some people put it but it also means good death. I look at it as more of a good death if it is performed with the right procedures and if a person has a legitimate reason to be put to death but many people would not agree with me that it should be legal.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia killing life
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia- killing life painlessly to end suffering, mercy killing. This pratice was traced back as far as the Greek and Roman times. As time passed religion increased and life was viewed as sacred. All forms of Euthanasia was/is now considered wrong. In the year of 1935 a group of doctors formed the first Voluntary Euthanasia Society in London.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Retired professor and
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Retired professor and psychoanalyst Ernest Van den Haag, by defending the right to commit suicide, made an appeal to J.S. Mill?s principle. Van den Haag said that people should have the right to choose as they please, as long as no one else is hurt (Hallock 13). According to the constitution, people have the right to decide death, not the government (Dority 8).
Mercy Killing Essay Research Paper To start
Mercy Killing Essay, Research Paper To start my essay on mercy killing, I must say, there are too many situations to just have one opinion on the matter. Mercy killing, or the correct term Euthanasia , is currently illegal in Canada. Though activists keep trying to legalize it, it will be a long time before anything happens.
Euthansia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia has been
Euthansia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia has been a popular topic nowadays, but not many peo0le may know about this subject in depth. In my opinion, Dr. Philip?s idea is good as it can help the elderly people to get more information about different methods of euthanasia. As euthanasia is a new issue that came up recently, most elderly people may not know much about it.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia has brought
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia has brought great attention to the public eye since Dr. Jack Kevorkian was discovered for contributing to these horrible inhumane acts. At the present time, the state of Oregon has the world’s only law specifically permitting a doctor to prescribe lethal drugs for the purpose of ending a patient’s life (iaetf/faq.htm).
The Controversy Over Euthanasia Essay Research Paper
The controversy over euthanasia is based on the same ethical and social platform from which the debates for abortion and capitol punishment stem. These social dilemmas all revolve around the sanctity of life and how far government can go in making choices involving individual rights. Although the debate over euthanasia is just heating up in the American judicial system, the practice of assisted suicide has been around for centuries, Modern advances in medicine and technology have helped doctors in prolonging life.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia may be
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia may be defined as taking your own/someone’s life because it is inevitable that he/she/you will die because of some painful terminal illness. Some may see it as murder/suicide and others may see it as a way out, the best thing to do. Like abortion, it is very hard for me to take an “it is right/wrong” philosophical position, because situations vary from person to person.
Eutahnasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia is an
Eutahnasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia is an issue that has been debated on many occasions. Both ethical and political questions have been raised. It is the one issue that can touch anyone, even politicians. Euthanasia is an issue that is controversial from all sides and is such a deeply felt issue across society.
Creative Writing Exercise Essay Research Paper 1
Creative Writing Exercise Essay, Research Paper 1. How does one commit a successful murder? To commit a successful murder you first must have a motive. Then after you have established a motive you must create a plan of attack. You need to come up with a way in which you are going to go about committing this crime.
Euthenasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaImmoral or Human
Euthenasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Immoral or Human Right? Recent debates over active euthanasia, “killing” a terminally ill patient, in Holland, has risen the question whether euthanasia is immoral or a simple human right. Doctors seem to have no doubt. They made an oath.
Euthansia Article Analysis And Opinion Essay Research
Paper Euthanasia is the help with a death and is also known as ?mercy killing?. There are two types of Euthanasia: Active euthanasia and passive euthanasia. There is also active voluntary euthanasia and active involuntary euthanasia. Euthanasia is illegal in all states but Oregon, who passed a bill making it legal in 1994 under certain circumstances.
Euthanasia Today Essay Research Paper Euthanasia has
Euthanasia Today Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia has been, and always will be, a controversial moral and ethical subject. While the majority of both Americans and Canadians seem to support euthanasia as indicated by the latest polls, it is still illegal in both countries. I think it is important to first distinguish between passive euthanasia and active euthanasia.
Is Euthanasia Ethical Essay Research Paper Is
Is Euthanasia Ethical Essay, Research Paper Is Euthanasia Ethical? Euthanasia Comes from the Greek word meaning the good death. It is defined as The act or practicing the end of life of an individual suffering from a terminal illness or an incurable condition, as by lethal injection or the suspension of extraordinary medical treatment.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia should not
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia should not be made legally acceptable in the present society because there are important aspects that need to be considered and handled concerning who?s to decide, extent to which a physician can practice medicine, and religious opposition to this practice.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EUTHANASIAEuthanasiaRenaldo La FoucadeEducation
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper EUTHANASIA Euthanasia Renaldo La Foucade Education of America University Euthanasia Euthanasia Euthanasia is a topic that provokes as much controversy as capital punishment, primarily because it is irreversible. The question of euthanasia being right or wrong is one that most would prefer left alone.
Euthanasia Pro Con Catholic View Essay Research Paper Some
Euthanasia Pro+Con+Catholic View Essay, Research Paper Some have suggested that we legalize physician-assisted suicide in California. They argue that we should find death before it finds us, and that the right to die is the right-to-choose. They are supporting such an initiative because they fear that they will have to endure horrible pain and live out a life encompassed by absolute suffering.
Brief Look At Euthanasia Essay Research Paper 2
Brief Look At Euthanasia- Essay, Research Paper Brief Look at Euthanasia- Euthanasia is one of the most acute and uncomfortable contemporary problems in medical ethics. Is Euthanasia Ethical? The