In The House Of The Spirits And Like Water For Chocolate Essay, Research Paper
They are both domineering. They are both oppressive. They are both despotic. Esteban Trueba, in Isabel Allende’s The House of the Spirits, and Mama Elena, in Laura Esquivel’s Like Water for Chocolate, are two very similar authoritarian characters in their nature and function in much the same manner. Allende’s patriarch and Esquivel’s matriarch assist in the development of other characters through their interactions with these characters and the response each character has to living in that autocrat’s household.
Allende and Esquivel first differ in their treatment of rebellion against the authoritarian heads of the families. In The House of the Spirits, Blanca rebels while still living in her father’s household. She ignores her father’s demands and does as she pleases behind his back. Blanca is thus developed in her reaction to the rule of her father; she acts against his will and stays around to suffer the consequences. She is strong and stubborn, unwilling to allow a situation to worry her. Gertrudis, in Like Water for Chocolate, runs away from home rather than rebel in Mama Elena’s house and face her wrath and to obtain sexual freedom. She runs from the adversity and does not ever get to face her mother for she dies before Gertrudis returns home.
Esteban Trueba and Mama Elena are also developed in in the reader s view to have similar character traits in much different manners. Each of the family leaders disowns their daughter for their rebellion and neither gives her a second chance. This first demonstrates the characters stubbornness and unwillingness to deal with a problem. They both seem to want only to ignore their children and hope they just disappear. Also developed through the their autocracy is the pride Mama Elena and Esteban have when dealing with their families. Esteban disowns Blanca so that he can rid himself of his worthless daughter and thus make himself feel like a better father. Mama Elena disowns her daughter to try to get her out of her thoughts. She feels that she has somehow made a mistake in raising Gertrudis and by disowning her, she demonstrates that she is too proud to admit her mistake and that she would rather run from it.
In the Trueba family, Esteban’s violence and anger bring the rest of the family closer together, however, the under similar circumstances, the De la Garza family does not react in the same manner. The Trueba family gathers together when Esteban is angry and abusive. Together they make decisions on how to deal with him and they can face him better with the support of the rest of their family, including their mother. The family’s response to Esteban’s rage exhibits their bonds to each other and develops Clara to be a very strong character. She can not only stand up to her husband and his seething madness but also stand up for the rest of the family and inspire them to do the same. The De la Garza family does not come together under Mama Elena’s rule and grows apart. Gertrudis leaves and Tita and Rosaura compete for Pedro’s love. The family members are not close to each other and their despotic mother does not assist in their relationships as in The House of the Spirits. The only one who openly defies Mama Elena to her face is Tita, and she does not have any support as the Trueba family has in the aforementioned novel. Tita is thus illustrated to be the only strong member of the family for her ability to face her mother on her own.
Though he does not allow anyone to come too close to loving him through his life, Esteban Trueba eventually becomes very close to his granddaughter; Mama Elena never allows anyone to become close to her and even after her death continues to alienate her family. Alba and her grandfather become very close after the rebellion and he clings to her as all he has left. Esteban changes from his completely obstinate and temperamental character to being very needed and open. Esteban, who had previously shied away from opportunities to open his emotions, bears his soul to Transito Soto and his granddaughter, Alba. After pushing away the previous two generations of women in the family, Clara and Blanca, Esteban suddenly realizes he has no one left; even his political friends have abandoned him. Esteba changes to a needy man with an open soul from his former obstinacy. Mama Elena never shows in her life very much emotion toward anyone. She is not dynamic and even after her death continues to be cruel and overbearing. She haunts Tita after she dies until Tita confesses her hatred once and for all. Even then they are not rid of her; she does not leave until she has attacked Pedro and catches him on fire. Mama Elena’s cruelty never subsides and she is a completely static character.
The dominance and attitudes of the two despots in these novels assist in the character development of their own characters as well as that of the other characters. How the characters react to their parent s or spouse s attitude and anger reveals their character and their inner strength. Esteban assists in the development of his family to be very close and have members strong enough to remain in his house and either openly or discreetly disobey his orders. They also encourage each other and back each other in confrontations. Esteban finally changes to become caring and open because of the autocracy his family has lived under for so many years. The De La Garza family is not at all close when Mama Elena is alive. In fact, the sisters grow closer after their mother’s death. The girls also do not develop to be strong as they do not openly defy their mother. Gertrudis runs away and Tita cannot disobey her mother in front of her and always goes back to calling her mother Mami when she has annoyed her. Mama Elena never changes in her nature as does Esteban and she dies, and later disappears still mean and controlling as usual.
Works Cited
Allende, Isabel. The House of the Spirits. Trans. Magda Bogin. New York: Bantam Books, 1982.
Esquival, Laura. Like Water for Chocolate. Trans. Carol and Thomas Christensen. New York: DoubleDay Publishing, 1989.
Другие работы по теме:
The Meal A Poem By Susan E
. Berger Essay, Research Paper Melissa Doherty Professor Gregory EN-102 noon class November 2000 The Ties that Bind Fear, anxiety, and shame, these are just a few of the emotions instilled upon the innocent children and mother in Suzanne E. Berger?s poem titled ?The Meal.? These emotions have been brought forth from an abusive and domineering father with an insatiable need for perfection.
The Color PurpleGender Roles Essay Research Paper
Gender roles play a very important role throughout the Color Purple. Each character in this book are very different from each other. They guide one another through life and help each other figure out who they really are. Sophia and Shug both influence Celie, who is skinny, weak, and dependent of others, and we see her role change throughout the novel.
Latin Women Essay Research Paper During the
Latin Women Essay, Research Paper During the 19th century, public life for women was limited. Women were still considered minors. But there were some advances in education, which helped some women to enter into professions. There were also alterations of civic codes that ultimately abolished the laws in many countries.
How Does The Starving Time Of The
Colonists Relate To The Hebrew?S Exodus? Essay, Research Paper Many things in history can be connected to one another. The ?Starving Time? of the colonists and the Hebrew?s Exodus are two examples that relate so clearly. Their relation can be expressed through religious beliefs of the two or through the roles of the groups involved.
White Man Essay Research Paper Since the
White Man Essay, Research Paper Since the 1950’s, the labor force participation rates for women have increased a lot. Everyday, more women bring home a paycheck. On the other hand, families with
Greek Actors Essay Research Paper GREEK DRAMA
Greek Actors Essay, Research Paper GREEK DRAMA: the actors The actors in ancient tragedies were hired and paid by the state and assigned to the tragic poets probably by lot. By the middle of the fifth century three actors were required for the performance of a tragedy. In descending order of importance of the roles they assumed they were called protagonist first actor (a term also applied in modern literary criticism to the central character of a play), Dueteragonist second actor and tritagonist third actor .
My Antonia Essay Research Paper The Households
My Antonia Essay, Research Paper The Households in My Antonia Cather paints two opposite pictures when describing the Burden household and the Shimerda household. The two households reflect the two central women figures in each setting. The households show the values of the two women by the way the women keep and run the houses.
Hunters
& Gatherers Essay, Research Paper Anthropology 1010: Assignment 1 The Asmat, Headhunters, people are located in New Guinea’s West Iran. These people actually cut off people heads and eat their brains and wear their jaws as a necklace. People’s brains are not their main source of food. The major food of these people is the starch of the sago palm that they roast.
Red Star Vs. Room With A View
Essay, Research Paper The differences in views of women’s roles in society differ from E.M. Forester’s A Room with a View and Bogdanov’s Red Star, is what I believe to be a response to economic class in each society. I say this because in the society on Mars all persons were working towards a common goal and pull their resources together, which is a more conceivable of an idea that a group peasants would do than the middle class.
Hunger Essay Research Paper HUNGERIn Nepal hunger
Hunger Essay, Research Paper HUNGER In Nepal hunger is happing because of heavy monsoon rains. The heavy rain has been going on sense mid-June. It has caused serious flooding in most parts of the country killing at least 113 people. It has displaced more then 7,000 households in 62 districts. About 1,160 hectares of crops have been reported to have been destroyed from the rain and more then 300 cattle have been killed.
Internet Piracy Essay Research Paper In this
Internet Piracy Essay, Research Paper In this day and age where technology is rampant and advance, it is critical that we comprehend the possibilities that such technology has, no matter whether it is good or bad. From our very own households, we can now ?get connected? and experience this technology first hand.
Abigail In The Crucible Act 1 Essay
, Research Paper Within the Crucible, there lies a complex story involving the accounts and happenings surrounding the 1692 Salem witch trials in Salem, Massachusetts. Act 1 of the Crucible sets up the
Gender Roles Essay Research Paper A View
Gender Roles Essay, Research Paper A View on Gender Roles While having read “The Yellow Wallpaper”, by Gillman, I have realized that much is to be said about early roles of women and how psychology tied into them. The hardships of the lives of women were not dwelled upon as if it were a man’s life. Most if not all of the females of this era had specific gender roles that were followed.
Group Work Outline Essay Research Paper Group
Group Work Outline Essay, Research Paper Group Conflict Resolution Annotated Outline I. Introduction In this section, we will state our topic, which is group conflict resolution. We will present the subtopics we will focus on in the paper. We will briefly tie the four subtopics into each other under the umbrella topic of group conflict resolution.
Communication Roles Essay Research Paper In my
Communication Roles Essay, Research Paper In my life, the five most important roles I fill are as follows: father, head of household, son, student, and friend. Each role is very challenging and requires a lot of attention.
Fuctions And Roles Of Protiens Carbohydr Essay
, Research Paper In this assesment the student will identify the chareracteristics and roles of carbohydrates, proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids in a living system. Write a 4 paragraph report describing the atoms in the compound building blocks, types, structure, and function of each. The student must also describe what they would do if they were given a jar with an unknown substance to find out wether or not it contained any of the substances listed above.
Dorothy Essay Research Paper Dorothy Jean Dandridge
Dorothy Essay, Research Paper Dorothy Jean Dandridge was born on November 9,1922, in Cleveland, Ohio. Her parents (Cyril and Ruby Dandridge) had a troubled marriage, which eventually lead to them going their separate ways. Ruby met the new “love” of her life, a woman, later was much despised by Dottie. She was very domineering and abusive toward Ruby’s two children, especially Dottie.
Robert Browning Essay Research Paper My Last
Robert Browning Essay, Research Paper My Last Duchess, by Robert Browning, is an example of a dramatic monologue. A dramatic monologue is a kind of narrative poem in which one character speaks to one or more listeners whose replies are not given in the poem. The Duke is speaking to an envoy about his fisrt wife who is apparently dead.
Boys And Girls Essay Research Paper BOYS
Boys And Girls Essay, Research Paper BOYS AND GIRLS Alice Munro’s short story, “Boys and Girls,” is a story of the way of life in the 1940s, where men and women had specific roles controlled by gender. They were expected to learn those roles as children and conform to them as adults. As the title suggested, males and females played separate and distinct roles from each other, with no one role blending into the other.
Macbeth A Comparision Of Macbeth And Lady
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Many of William Shakespeare’s Elizabethan tragedies often have elements of fiery love affairs coupled with the somberness of violent death. The transformation of the mindset of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth take place within this format of love and its parallel of death. As the story of Macbeth unravels, Shakespeare sets the stage for the reversal of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth’s mentality: Macbeth goes from a content and cautious noble to a bold power hungry killer, while Lady Macbeth goes from an eager domineering wife to a scared guilt ridden wreck.
Women In Early Lit Essay Research Paper
Women play different roles in early literature. In The Illiad, Gilgamesh, and Oedipus Rex, their roles determine the different amounts of power they possess and how they use the powers to influence the events that occur.
Gender RolesHuman Sexuality Essay Research Paper Gender
Gender Roles(Human Sexuality) Essay, Research Paper Gender Roles While I was growing up, gender roles were highly defined by my parents and teachers as well as all other societal influences. Boys were taught to do ?boy? things and girls were taught to do ?girly? things. The toys that children play with and the activities that are encouraged by adults demonstrate the influence of gender roles on today?s youth.
Gender Essay Research Paper English 112 section
Gender Essay, Research Paper English 112 section 096 March 29, 1999 An in Depth Analysis of Gender Relationships Throughout history and in all cultures the roles of males and females vary. Relating to the piece of literature “Girl” written by Jamaica Kincaid for the time, when women’s roles were to work in the home.
King Lear The Roles Of The Fool
Essay, Research Paper The Roles of the Fool in King Lear Fools in traditional royal households were seen as imbecils and jesters, nothing more. The older role of a royal fool, which Shakespeare adopted from the pagan setting of King Lear, was to correct minor faults and incongruencies in their masters. By detatching the Fool from a conventional fool’s role, Shakespeare allows for the crowd’s suspention of disbelief in the Fool’s ability to get away with the comments he makes to the King.
Women In The Victorian Age Essay Research
Paper Suffer And Be Still, is a powerful collection of essays. This collection, edited by Martha Vicinus documents the state of women in the 19th century Victorian England. This time period is well known as a dark side in women’s modern history, because, as seen through this book, Women in the Victorian Age were discriminated, degraded and psychologically abused at this time.
Woman And Equal Opportunities Essay Research Paper
Woman in the sixties have had many different roles than woman in the nineties. Life for woman has changed dramatically, to their advantage throughout the years. Today woman have gained many new rights and responsibilities, and now have equal opportunities as men.
Womens Roles Now And What They Were
? In The Past? In Uzbekistan Essay, Research Paper ?Women?s roles now and what they were in the past? Women?s roles are not the same in different cultures. Most important is that women
Changing Roles Of Women Due To The
Revolution Essay, Research Paper changing roles of women due to the revolution. During the revolutionary era, American leaders decided to use economic boycotts in theirstruggle against Britain. The goal of these boycotts was to stop the purchase of imported goods(which could only be purchased from England).
Cable Tv Essay Research Paper Cable TelevisonThe
Cable Tv Essay, Research Paper Cable Televison The history of cable television has had a great jump from houses being able to have 12 channels in 1948 until modern day inventions like directv, which
Movie Review The Mirror Has Two Faces
Essay, Research Paper Movie Review: The Mirror Has Two Faces The movie stares Barbara Streisand as Rose Morgan a lonely, single, low self esteemed woman who lives with her domineering mother Hannah Morgan played by
Circular Flow Of Economics Essay Research Paper
The circular flow model is defined as the flow of resources from households to firms and of products to firms from households. These flows are accompanied by reverse flows of money from firms to households and from households to firms. The circular flow is comprised of the resource market, households, product market, businesses, and the government.
Latin American Women In The Workforce And
Family Living Essay, Research Paper Latin American Women In The Workforce and Family Living The European conquest of the New World altered the lives of indigenous women. European women did not arrive to the New World only for years after the initial invasions. Indian women were continuously exploited in the form of labor, catering, and sexual gratification.