Lucas V. South Essay, Research Paper
Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council
Charles Adams
Problem: David H. Lucas purchased two beach front lots on Isle of Palms in Charleston county in 1986 for 900,000 with intent to later build one single family home on each lot. The following year when South Carolina conducted a survey of the coast line the rustles showed that the beaches of South Carolina were critically eroding. Due to the rustles of the survey South Carolina issued the Beachfront Management Act (BMA). The act placed restraints on the usage of land along the coast line, and because the building line was moved inward Lucas’ lots were affected with no exceptions provided. When he bought those lots the year before that particular zone was not required to have a permit to build. When Lucas went to build the proper permits were not given due to the BMA, and his lots were deemed 95% worthless.
Laws: The Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972
Passed in order to protect the country coastline from erosion.
The South Carolina Coastal Zone Management Act of 1977
Passed in order to protect the shoreline from erosion, preserve the beach and dune systems, and prevent further coastal damage. And said that before construction could take place in any designated, environmentally sensitive “critical area” an owner had to obtain permission from the South Carolina Coastal Council.
The South Carolina Beachfront Management Act of 1988
Passed to further enforce the South Carolina Coastal Zone Management Act of 1977, and extend the “critical area” further inland.
Case: Lucas submitted his suit to the South Carolina court of Common Pleas, and sued, alleging that the Beachfront Management Act of 1988 had effected a taking of the value of his property without just compensation. The court agreed that Lucas had suffered a total loss of the value of his property and concluded that regulatory taking had occurred. On appeal, the South Carolina Supreme Court revised the decision, on the grounds that the BMA had been passed to prevent serious harm to the public. Lucas petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case and the Court sided with Lucas saying that the Beachfront Management Act of 1988 had not been designed to benefit the state in obtaining land for public use, but was to prevent harm to the public. The Court ruled that Lucas suffered a taking, and that his property was rendered valueless by South Carolina statue and that he was entitled to just compensation as stated in the fifth and fourteen adamants of our Constitution.
Significance: Although the South Carolina Supreme Court decided that state regulations were designed to prevent serious public harm, the U.S. Supreme Court held that when a property owner suffered a taking, there were no exceptions from common rule ( the Takings Clause and the just Compensation Clause). Furthermore, when the state of South Carolina amended its original statute by including provisions that might permit limited construction, the U.S. Supreme Court held that property owners must still be compensated. Even when legislation later renders the initial act less restrictive, property owners still suffer from the original effects of a taking, thus, just compensation must be rendered. (Mikula 518)
Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council
Charles Adams
Problem: David H. Lucas purchased two beach front lots on Isle of Palms in Charleston county in 1986 for 900,000 with intent to later build one single family home on each lot. The following year when South Carolina conducted a survey of the coast line the rustles showed that the beaches of South Carolina were critically eroding. Due to the rustles of the survey South Carolina issued the Beachfront Management Act (BMA). The act placed restraints on the usage of land along the coast line, and because the building line was moved inward Lucas’ lots were affected with no exceptions provided. When he bought those lots the year before that particular zone was not required to have a permit to build. When Lucas went to build the proper permits were not given due to the BMA, and his lots were deemed 95% worthless.
Laws: The Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972
Passed in order to protect the country coastline from erosion.
The South Carolina Coastal Zone Management Act of 1977
Passed in order to protect the shoreline from erosion, preserve the beach and dune systems, and prevent further coastal damage. And said that before construction could take place in any designated, environmentally sensitive “critical area” an owner had to obtain permission from the South Carolina Coastal Council.
The South Carolina Beachfront Management Act of 1988
Passed to further enforce the South Carolina Coastal Zone Management Act of 1977, and extend the “critical area” further inland.
Case: Lucas submitted his suit to the South Carolina court of Common Pleas, and sued, alleging that the Beachfront Management Act of 1988 had effected a taking of the value of his property without just compensation. The court agreed that Lucas had suffered a total loss of the value of his property and concluded that regulatory taking had occurred. On appeal, the South Carolina Supreme Court revised the decision, on the grounds that the BMA had been passed to prevent serious harm to the public. Lucas petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case and the Court sided with Lucas saying that the Beachfront Management Act of 1988 had not been designed to benefit the state in obtaining land for public use, but was to prevent harm to the public. The Court ruled that Lucas suffered a taking, and that his property was rendered valueless by South Carolina statue and that he was entitled to just compensation as stated in the fifth and fourteen adamants of our Constitution.
Significance: Although the South Carolina Supreme Court decided that state regulations were designed to prevent serious public harm, the U.S. Supreme Court held that when a property owner suffered a taking, there were no exceptions from common rule ( the Takings Clause and the just Compensation Clause). Furthermore, when the state of South Carolina amended its original statute by including provisions that might permit limited construction, the U.S. Supreme Court held that property owners must still be compensated. Even when legislation later renders the initial act less restrictive, property owners still suffer from the original effects of a taking, thus, just compensation must be rendered. (Mikula 518)
Другие работы по теме:
George Lucas Biography And Works Essay Research
Paper Part I, Summary: THX 1138, American Graffiti, Star Wars, The Empire Strikes Back the list goes on and on. Although many have not heard of each of these films, everyone certainly has to know the man behind them. George Lucas has, in many cases, written, produced, and directed, not to mention edit, his own films.
The Importance Of Marriage Pride And Prejudice
Essay, Research Paper In Jane Austen s novel, Pride and Prejudice, marriage is a very serious topic, it determines a woman s class, their happiness for future life or even if they will have a life at all. Marriage Forms alliances between families as land, income and title are extremely fruitful topics.
Reconstruction Era Essay Research Paper Reconstruction EraThe
Reconstruction Era Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction Era The Reconstruction period can be defined as the time after the Civil War when states were debating on what to do with a partially seceded nation. The Union, known as the North, wanted to come to agreements with the Confederacy, or the south, on how to successfully bring the states together again as one nation.
The Soviet Breakup Essay Research Paper When
The Soviet Breakup Essay, Research Paper When on December 21, 1991, the Soviet Union ceased to exist and broke into a fragmented group of independent countries (Byrnes), the world breathed a sigh of
Falling Essay Research Paper FallingANNE PROVOOSTHes a
Falling Essay, Research Paper Falling ANNE PROVOOST ?He?s a skinhead, a second one added. I knew they wouldn?t talk to me any more, only about me?(p111) Falling is a book that contains many complex scenarios and interpersonal
An Argument Of The Lack Of Lawyers
Morals Essay, Research Paper Manuel Lopez English 333 Synthesis Paper I clearly remember one wild and crazy Saturday night, I had just turned 19 years old and was out celebrating with my buddies. On my way home I decided to act like if I was on an episode of ?COPS? and was arrested for drunk driving, reckless driving, evading police, resisting arrest, and underage drinking.
Lucas King Of Film Essay Research Paper
Davis 1 Lucas: King of Film Whether it be through his epic Star Wars saga, or through the exalted special effects crew he pioneered, Industrial Light and Magic, he continues to amaze audiences world wide. His name in synonymous with famous directors/producers in the world. His impacts reach out in more fields than just film.
Apartheid Essay Research Paper What Is ApartheidThe
Apartheid Essay, Research Paper What Is Apartheid? The word Apartheid means separation. Apartheid was a form of living in South Africa. It was the process of segregating different races. Not only did it separate the Afrikaans, and other tribes in South Africa, but it also separated the whites from the non-whites.
Love Has Nothing To Do With It
Essay, Research Paper What?s Love Got to Do With It In Pride and Predjuice life is not all fun and games. There are many pressures in life: mothers with high expectations for a good marriage and a girl?s own expectation of
The South Essay Research Paper The South
The South Essay, Research Paper The South The South has many objects associated with it, to where it is considered either a beautiful place or very disturbing. In The South , Langston Hughes describes his feelings of the south from the point of view of a black man who
Starwars Essay Research Paper MY STAR WARS
Starwars Essay, Research Paper MY STAR WARS: EPISODE 1REVIEW CHARLES SANFORD ENG. 11 As I sat in the huge theater awaiting the movie that I had been awaiting so long to
Pride And Prejudice What
’s Love Got To Do With It Essay, Research Paper Pride and Prejudice: What’s Love Got to Do With It In Pride and Prejudice life is not all fun and games. There are many
High Performance Training For Track And Field
Essay, Research Paper Phillip Lucas Mr. Tarlow 120 English The book I have chosen to research is High Performance Training for Track and Field. Every since the age of nine I have been in love with track. My uncle would make bets with the other guys in the neighborhood that their kids couldn’t beat me in any all out sprint.
Misconceive
’o By John Leo Essay, Research Paper Misconceive o by John Leo John Leo is a columnist and contributing editor that has been writing for U.S. News & World Report since 1988. Prior to that he worked for Time magazine and The New York Times covering topics such as social sciences and popular culture. The thesis of John Leo s latest U.S.
Being Literate Essay Research Paper Phillip LucasMr
Being Literate Essay, Research Paper Phillip Lucas Mr. Tarlow English 120 Being Literate Being literate means the ability to read and write. To strictly speak, the ability to read and write which if I wasn’t able to do that I would make it in this world. To me literacy is every thing because if you weren’t able to read and write you would be able to fill out job applications, type resumes, and terms papers.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper Faulkner grew
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper Faulkner grew up in Mississippi in the beginning of the twentieth century ( William Faulkner 699). He was the son to Murray C. and Maud Butler Faulkner (Hoffman 13). Growing up in the South in the early 1900 s meant being exposed to harsh racism. He watched the blacks endure unbelievable amounts of cruelty and was amazed at how the blacks conducted themselves with such dignity.
Korean War Essay Research Paper Causes of
Korean War Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Korean War Essay # 2 By: Dylan Foreman After the Japanese gained control of Korea in and made it part of Japan. The Allies defeated Japan in World War II (1939-1945) and U.S. and Soviet forces moved into Korea. Soviet troops occupied North Korea and American troops occupied South Korea.
Mandella Essay Research Paper Nelson Mandela has
Mandella Essay, Research Paper Nelson Mandela has played an important and controversial role in the history of South Africa and establishing South Africa as a Democratic country. Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was
Star Wars Episode I The Phantom Menace
Essay, Research Paper Being a Star Wars fan for many years, I was greatly interested in the upcoming prequels (Episodes I, II and III). So, when Episode I was released, I was at the theater the opening day and I was just absolutely mesmerized. The movie was like a fine quilt, beautiful in color, smooth and comfortable.
Novel Critique
— Star Wars Essay, Research Paper The novel Star Wars: A New Hope by George Lucas is one of the fashioning elements in modern Science Fiction. It shaped and moulded sci-fi into the popular genre it is today. The novel starts off about a boy on a dessert planet of tattoine. He lives with his uncle and aunt on a moisture farm.
The Origins Of Star Wars Essay Research
Paper The Origins of Star Wars In the movie Star Wars, Director and Screenplay writer George Lucas creates a very complex, believable universe. Lucas borrows many things from different places to create his universe.This paper will show whether or not he succeeds and how does he does it. The origins of the much of Star Wars will be explained and the symbolic nature of the characters will be touched upon, as well as a brief history of the most important part of the story line.
Star Wars Essay Research Paper Star WarsByGeorge
Star Wars Essay, Research Paper Star Wars George Lucas Paperback, November 1998 Star Wars is a science fiction adventure novel. The symbolism and characterization was really excellent in the story. The story gives a great look into the future as it has many different types of things we have not yet invented; blaster rifles, space ships that go the speed of light, fat alien slugs, and beam swords.
John L Lewis Essay Research Paper Allan
John L Lewis Essay, Research Paper Allan Breden February 24, 2000 A working man’s man John L. Lewis John L. Lewis started life in Lucas County, Iowa February 12, 1880 the son of Thomas Lewis, a coal miner and policeman. John was welsh born. In the 1880’s and the 1890’s their family lived in a company owned shanty with an outdoor privy.
Media To The Masses Essay Research Paper
Lucas Forgue 11-10-99 Media to the Masses What is the mass media? Mass media is defined by means of public communication reaching a large audience. It is a combination of television broadcasts, radio shows, newspaper headlines, and magazine articles. To some, it is a way of learning what is happening in the world.
Escaping The Fog Of Pride And Prejudice
Essay, Research Paper Escaping the fog of pride and prejudice The words of the title of Jane Austen’s novel, Pride and Prejudice, shroud the main characters, Elizabeth and Darcy in a fog. The plot of the novel focuses on how Elizabeth and Darcy escape the fog and find each other. Both characters must individually recognize their faults and purge them.
John Wilkes Booth
’s Escape Rou Essay, Research Paper John Wilkes Booth’s Escape Route After exiting Ford’s Theatre, John Wilkes Booth mounted a horse that was being held by Joseph “Peanuts” Buroughs, an innocent theater employee. Booth rode down the alley, turned left up another alley, turned onto “F” Street, and headed toward the Navy Yard Bridge.
No Future Essay Research Paper No Future
No Future? Essay, Research Paper No Future? When looking into the future people see many different things. Whether it be flying cars, buildings floating in the air, or people walking around in space suits, everyone has their own idea. Most of the time when people look into the future they look far into it, not in the next several years.
Civil War Causes Essay Research Paper Causes
Civil War Causes Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Civil War Although some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political blunders and that the issue of slavery
Korean Conflict Essay Research Paper North Korea
Korean Conflict Essay, Research Paper North Korea and South Korea was once one country combined. That changed soon after World War II. Since the Soviet Union controlled North Korea it was mainly
Is Star Wars A Modern Day Fairytale
? Essay, Research Paper Nathan Cathey Marilyn McDowell English 102 March 30, 1999 Is Star Wars a Modern Day Fairy Tale? The Star Wars trilogy has been labeled as a groundbreaking science fiction, space opera, and swashbuckling adventure. But it is hardly ever recognized for what it truly is, a fairy tale. At first thought, it is difficult to acknowledge Star Wars as a fairy tale because of its label as a Science Fiction movie.
Oedipus The King Essay Research Paper Even
Oedipus The King Essay, Research Paper Even though Oedipus the King didn?t detail all of Oedipus? adventures, I thought it was a good book. I think it was smart of Sophocles to pick out the most
The Wild DuckA Essay Research Paper Wild
The Wild Duck(A) Essay, Research Paper Wild DuckIn the Wild Duck, Henrik Ibsen employs the image of light to portray certain characteristics of the actors and to adjust the mood for each scene. This report discusses each presentation of light, and its function, be it for moodsetting or character implication.