Paper
Orestes, the Furies, Croesus, and Cyrus – What do all these disparate characters have in common? The answer is that divine justice decides the course that their lives will take. Divine justice plays a large role in both of the works that these characters are from – the Oresteia of Aeschylus and The Histories of Herodotus. However, the two works differ on what exactly constitutes divine justice, and how divine justice operates. Aeschylus would argue that divine justice is reactive. In other words, justice acts after man has committed some terrible act. Herodotus would argue that divine justice is proactive, striking before the culprit has actually sinned. Also, Aeschylus and Herodotus disagree about why divine justice affects men. Aeschylus argues that man must commit a sin for justice to be meted out. In the views of Herodotus, however, God strikes down those who are too rich and successful. It is not necessary for a man to have sinned to be punished, in the view of Herodotus.
Herodotus directly tells the reader his views on divine justice through the character of Solon. Solon is one of ” the great Greek teachers of that epoch.” (Histories Bk 1 Ch. 29) He was traveling around the world when he paid a visit to Croesus, the King of Lydia. Croesus gave Solon a tour of the palace, and then asked Solon a question. “Well, my Athenian friend, I have heard a great deal about your wisdom, and how widely you have traveled in the pursuit of knowledge. I cannot resist the desire to ask you a question: who is the happiest man you have ever seen?”(Histories Bk 1 Ch 30) Solon’s response to this question speaks volumes about Herodotus’s opinions on divine justice. The two examples that he presents of people having true happiness have one thing in common – all of the people in them are dead. Why is this significant? It is significant because in Solon’s opinion, no man can be called truly happy until he is dead. “But mark this: until he is dead, keep the word ‘happy’ in reserve.”(Histories Bk 1 Ch 32) In Solon’s opinion, man cannot be truly happy until he is dead because ” God is envious of human prosperity and likes to trouble us”(Histories Bk 1 Ch 32) In other words, God strikes down those who are too rich and successful. That is why Croesus did not get the response that he wanted to hear – that he, Croesus was the happiest person Solon had ever seen. Solon expounds upon his views when he says, “Great wealth can make a man no happier than moderate means, unless he has the luck to continue in prosperity to the end.”(Histories Bk 1 Ch 32) In a nutshell, Herodotus, through the character of Solon, is saying that divine justice strikes those that are too lucky. Therefore, until he is dead, no man can be called happy.
Solon’s views are confirmed a few pages later. “After Solon’s departure nemesis fell upon Croesus, presumably because God was angry with him for supposing himself the happiest of men.”(Histories Bk 1 Ch 34) Why did Croesus consider himself the happiest of men? Because he was rich and powerful, exactly the combination that God hates. Here the reader can see divine justice in action, as God strikes down Atys, the son of Croesus. Croesus himself can see the reason why Atys was killed, as he tells Adrastus, the actual murderer of his son, “Some god is to blame – some god who long ago warned me of what was to happen.”(Histories Bk 1 Ch 45)
Croesus, however, has not learned his lesson. He remains as greedy and ambitious as before. He first attempts to placate the gods with a huge sacrifice. However, he is merely trying to influence them so he can invade Persia. He receives favorable answers to his questions of the oracle, or so he thinks. In reality, because Croesus has not repented, the gods still have evil in store for him. He fails to recognize the ambiguous nature of the oracle’s answers. Thus, he foolishly invades Persia, and is defeated. Croesus did indeed destroy a mighty empire when he invaded Persia – he destroyed his own. Thus Solon’s views on divine justice are fulfilled, as Croesus; the gods destroy the powerful King of Lydia.
Contrasting with Herodotus’s views on divine justice are those views expressed by Aeschylus in The Oresteia. The justice presented by Aeschylus is not the justice of Solon, where God strikes down the powerful. Rather, it a sort of retributive justice, as the gods attempt to close the circle of violence that has engulfed the House of Atreus. At its heart, The Oresteia is about the inadequacy of the old system of justice, which called for kin to avenge their relatives. The trilogy shows the transformation of justice, as it moves from the old system under old deities to the new system, the Court of the Areopagus, under a new deity, Athene.
At the beginning of The Oresteia the old system of justice is firmly in place. Murder still demands blood vengeance, and there is a murder that has not been avenged, Atreus’s murder of the children of Thyestes. In the view of Aegisthus, it is his duty to avenge that murder. He does so by plotting the death of the son of Atreus, Agamemnon. When Agamemnon finally dies at the hand of Clytaemestra, the sin of Atreus is apparently avenged. However, the murder of Agamemnon is merely another step in the cycle of violence. The murder of Agamemnon, justified or not, calls out for vengeance. Revenge falls on the shoulders of the son of Agamemnon, Orestes. However, now the current system of justice begins to become inadequate. Is it justifiable to murder one’s kin to avenge one’s kin? Orestes is faced with this dilemma, one to which the current system of justice has no answer.
On one hand, Orestes is commanded by Apollo to avenge the murder of his father. “For he (Apollo) charged me to win through this hazard told me to cut them down in their own fashion ” (Libation Bearers 270,275) On the other hand is the ancient law against matricide, and the Furies. With either choice Orestes will be committing a grave sin. He will disobey the gods with either choice. Orestes chooses to avenge his father by murdering Aegisthus and his mother. Did he make the correct choice? The answer is that neither choice he could have made was correct. The dilemma of Orestes shows the inadequacy of the old system of justice, and the necessity of a new one.
In steps the divine, Athene, with the solution. She establishes a court to decide the fate of Orestes. In the end, the court decides in favor of Orestes, but that is not what is really important. What is significant is that Greece cast off an old system of justice based on private murder and run by the old gods (the Furies). It then establishes a new system where the public decides the fate of the accused. The old gods and their ways are rejected, and the new gods are ushered in. At its heart, The Oresteia is about changing from one system of justice to another.
In conclusion, divine justice is a major theme in both The Histories of Herodotus and The Oresteia of Aeschylus. Herodotus has a fixed view of divine justice that is articulated by Solon, where the gods punish rich and powerful who presume themselves to be happy. The downfall of Croesus, whose only sin was to presume himself to be happy illustrates this. Aeschylus, on the other hand, sees divine justice as something that needs to be changed and updated as necessary. When the old system of justice based on blood vengeance become inadequate, it is replaced by a new system where reason prevails over bloodlust, and public justice replaces private murder.
Другие работы по теме:
Herodotus`
` “The History” Essay, Research Paper Herodotus, in his book The History, tells us a good deal about how, in the course of the 5th Century, the Greeks came to define themselves by casting “barbarians” as a negative foil for those traits which they admired in themselves. By ?barbarians?, Herodotus means the ?Others?, those who were not Greek or European.
Justice Essay Research Paper Justice
Justice Essay, Research Paper Justice… Oedipus is not formally charged with any crimes. He does manage however to commit incest, and murder. His father is cursed. The curse states that his son will kill him and marry his wife. These facts are discovered in the introductory, “…if laius , king of thebes, had a son by jocasta, his queen, that son would kill his father and marry his mother.
Greek Tragedy Essay Research Paper The Greek
Greek Tragedy Essay, Research Paper The Greek Tragedy The tragedy was a large part of people’s lives in ancient Greece. Tragedies became prominent long before Christ was born. A tragedy, or goat-song, usually were seen during festivals in ancient Greek times. Tragedies gradually increased in seriousness until they were given utmost importance.
The Eumenides Essay Research Paper Throughout the
The Eumenides Essay, Research Paper Throughout the ages, there have been many different laws and punishments used to bring order to societies. In America today we use a system of justice, which we modeled after the Greek states of thousands of years ago. In Aeschylus’ The Eumenides, we see the birth of the civil justice system as we use it today.
Playwrights Aeschylus Sophocles And Euripides Essay Research
Paper The starting point when discussing comedy and tragedy would be to define the main terms. Comedy is the dramatic genre that focuses on human weakness through humor. Comedy celebrates the regeneration of life through love and reconciliation. Tragedy is the dramatic genre initiated by ancient Greek playwrights such as Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides.
Justice Essay Research Paper The concept of
Justice Essay, Research Paper The concept of justness is a subjective reality. Justice is not present in any one person, justice appears to be present only in consensus. There is no just,
Herodotus Essay Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus of Halicarnassus was born about 484 B.C. he died 60 years later. For the time he lived in this age was very old though by today’s standards it is not. The reason why his age was so outstanding was in his time the average man live for maybe half that because of the harsh living conditions.
Herodotus Essay Research Paper Herodotus 484424 BC
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper Herodotus (484-424 BC ?) a Greek historian, known as the father of history, who was the first historian to apply critical evaluation to his material, while also recording divergent opinions. He made his prose style resemble the finest poetry by its persuasiveness, its charm, and its utterly delightful effect.
Herodotus Essay Research Paper Herodotus was a
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper Herodotus was a Greek historian, generally called the Father of History. The work of Herodotus is the oldest surviving major Greek prose and the first history in Western civilization.
Corruption In Greek Works Essay Research Paper
In many works of literature there contains the nature of corruption and what the characters do to redeem themselves. Because these characters are human, they submit to corruption. In the books The Oresteian Trilogy by Aeschylus, “Hecuba”,The Republic ,”Euthyphro”,” Apology” ,and Crito, by Plato and Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle, the authors show different forms of corruption, and how it relates to the character.
Herodotus Essay Research Paper As Herodotus develops
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper As Herodotus develops his History he diverges from the main aspect of his narrative many times throughout the text. Many wonder why Herodotus diverges from the main point by introducing minor characters who do not seem relevant to the central theme. Some consider this method of narrative confusing and pointless but I believe that Herodotus has a purpose for including these minor figures and that these characters help express Herodotus ideology towards proper moral and political systems.
Blood Bonds Antigone And The Eumenides Essay
, Research Paper Every human on this earth has a bond to another. These bonds, as well as their significance, differ between people. This paper will focus on the bonds of marriage and blood, and their role in the plays Antigone and The Eumenides. How do they relate to each other? Is one more important than the other? How does the divine and mortal world interpret these? Through a review of the two plays and a comparison of their presentation of the bonds of blood and marriage, this paper will answer these questions.
Unfair Justice Essay Research Paper Unfair Justice
Unfair Justice Essay, Research Paper Unfair Justice? In spite of the horrible results the newly acquitted Mr. Elliot’s actions had, he didn’t do anything “wrong”. It is thisdilemma the U.K. have raged over the past few weeks after thejuvenile delinquent killed the father to three, Mr. Osbourne. Thereal problem here is that the people have felt deceived by theirown law, so what consequences are we now facing? No matter how unfair the acquitting of Mr.
Criminal Justice Essay Research Paper In this
Criminal Justice Essay, Research Paper In this paper I will attempt to explain how the United States Criminal Justice System and Ireland has some different characteristics. They both share some of the same practices in each system. I will give a brief history of both countries and the way their system works.
Agamemnon Essay Research Paper In Agamemnon
Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper In Agamemnon by Aeschylus, Clytaemnestra is the character with the majority of the power because of her ability to manipulate the other characters. She is not influenced or swayed by Aegisthus to murder her husband. She kills to gain justice for her daughter s death, as she feels their law justifies her acts.
Imbalance In The American Justice System Essay
, Research Paper Imbalance in the American Justice System The United States of America probably has the best justice system throughout the entire planet but; Is this true? There is corruption within this system, which causes it to be constitutionally imbalance.
Prometheus Essay Research Paper Hesiod and Aeschylus
Prometheus Essay, Research Paper Hesiod and Aeschylus both tell the tale of Prometheus, the god that stole fire from Olympus and gave it to man. Each author takes a different position on the matter: Hesiod condemns Prometheus and man, while Aeschylus celebrates them, which is evident in several characteristics of the myth.
Upgrading Justice Essay Research Paper Taylor E
Upgrading Justice Essay, Research Paper Taylor E. Schuss English 205 31 August 2000 Upgrading Justice What is justice? By definition the word Justice can mean different things. To most Americans, justice is when someone who has committed a crime goes before a judge or a jury of his or her peers and is punished for their actions.
Fergie Jenkins Essay Research Paper FERGIE JENKINS
Fergie Jenkins Essay, Research Paper FERGIE JENKINS: WHAT IS JUSTICE? “Justice: Fairness. A state of affairs in which conduct or action is both fair and right, given the circumstances. In law, it more specifically refers to the paramount obligation to ensure that all persons are treated fairly.”
Plea Bargaining Essay Research Paper Plea bargainingWhen
Plea Bargaining Essay, Research Paper Plea bargaining When dealing with the Criminal Justice system plea bargaining is something that is a common occurrence. When some type of a negotiation between the prosecutor and the defense attorney takes place and there is no trial, this would be considered a plea bargain. (Criminal Justice, Pg.454) Although the defendant does loose some of his constitution rights by accepting it, he does have some benefits.
A Comparison Of A Tragic Hero From
Euripides?s Medea And Aeschylus?s Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper A Comparison of a Tragic Hero from Euripides?s Medea and Aeschylus?s Agamemnon Tragic heroes from Greek tragedies almost always share similar characteristics.
Agamemnon Essay Research Paper Agamemnon Agamemnon
Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper Agamemnon Agamemnon is the first book in the Orestiean Trilogy written by the famous Greek tragedy writer, Aeschylus. Agamemnon is a story of justice and revenge. The story takes place in a city called Argos. It starts with Agamemnon, the king of Argos, away at the Trojan War.
Agamemnon Essay Research Paper Agamemnon is the
Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper Agamemnon is the first play in a trilogy, the Oresteia, which is considered Aeschylus’ greatest work, and perhaps the greatest Greek tragedy. Of the three plays in the trilogy, Agamemnon contains the strongest command of both language and characterization. The poetry is magnificent and moving, and major and minor characters alike are skillfully portrayed.
Aeschylus Agamemnon Essay Research Paper Aeschylus Agamemnon
Aeschylus? Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper Aeschylus? Agamemnon tells the story of what happened to the Greek hero Agamemnon when he returns home to Myceneae. Cassandra, daughter of Priam, king of Troy, plays a powerful figure in the play because she foretells the doom of Agamemnon and of herself through visions of a curse upon his household. ?Agamemnon, you will see him dead?, (p.544, l. 1262) Cassandra tells the reader.
Justice In Aeschylus
’ Eumenides Essay, Research Paper Justice in Aeschylus’ Eumenides The main point in “Eumenides,” is the issue of justice. Orestes stands accused of murdering his mother. Like any case, there are two sides. However, the argument against Orestes is strong. He admits to striking down his mother, in violation of the sacred bond of kinship. “I will not deny it-exacting the penalty of death in return for my dear father.”(Eumenides lines 463-464) This signifies that Orestes was fully aware of the act he was committing and he willfully committed it.
Book Of Job Essay Research Paper The
Book Of Job Essay, Research Paper The Book of Job, including the epilogue, argues justice is retributive in its nature. Retributive justices states that a just distribution of fairness exists. Throughout the book, Job portrays the idea that good things happen to those who are good, while bad things happen to those who are bad.
Justice Essay Research Paper In the Republic
Justice Essay, Research Paper In the Republic, Plato attempts to answer one of philosophy’s most central questions: What is justice or right conduct? Thrasymachus, who is upset at
Justice Essay Research Paper JusticeJustice What
Justice Essay, Research Paper Justice Justice. What is justice? In this world where many people look out only for themselves, justice can be considered the happiness of oneself. But because selfish men do not always decide our standards in society, to find a definition, society should look at the opinions of many.
Sophocles Essay Research Paper Sophocles was born
Sophocles Essay, Research Paper Sophocles was born in Colonus, near Athens, c.497 B.C. Sophocles father was a wealthy armorer named Sophillus. When he reached adulthood he was already established as a great tragic playwright, and the citizens of Athens loved him. He was nicknamed Attic-bee by the Athenians because he could take pure honey from words.
Tale Of 2 Cities Justice Vs Injustice
Essay, Research Paper Justice VS Injustice Justice versus injustice, a battle fought since the time of man. Dickens’ most valuable message in A Tale of Two Cities is that justice will always triumph over injustice.