, Research Paper
The characters in Salinger’s “A Perfect Day for Bananafish” seem to exist in opposite worlds. On one hand, Salinger creates Muriel to represent materialism and superficiality and on the other hand, he creates Sybil to provide justification of the child-like innocence rarely found in society. Salinger’s main character, Seymour, is aware of the superficiality expressed in Muriel’s world and chooses not to be apart of it. Seymour wants to be apart of the simple immaterial world that Sybil represents. Nevertheless, Seymour find himself trapped between two worlds unable to regain the one he desires. Therefore, Salinger bases “A Perfect Day for Bananafish” on Seymour’s disillusionment with life and his inability to regain a child-like perception of the world. Salinger’s portrayals Seymour and his wold are described below.
Sybil is composed of all the characteristics Seymour is seeking. She is young, innocent and childlike and therefore not polluted by the materialism, mistrust and snobbery known to society. Furthermore, her actions suggest that she relates to Seymour because he seems to act like a child somewhat similar to herself (for example Sybil feels secure around Seymour but feels insecure when sitting with her own mother). This would imply that Seymour does not appear abnormal to her because she, unlike most, she has the ability to see through his exterior and is not intimidated by what she has found. In the later part of the story she continually repeats the phase “see more glass”(10) using the term “glass” to describe her own unique ability to see through the transparency of superficial people (much like her own mother).
What Seymour respects most about Sybil is that she is to innocent to apply or make judgments upon what she sees, she is only able to blindly comment on its happenings. For instance, when referring to how many tigers ran around the tree Sybil commented “Only six!”(14), similarly when asked how many bananas the banana fish were eating she exclaimed “Six!”(16). Firstly, Sybil’s use of the number “six” suggests that she is repeating the phase phrase six figure but in a simplified manner. Secondly, Sybil’s reference to the phrase six figure depicts her mothers monopolizing influence on her. For instance, the bathing suit purchased by Sybil’s mother, is composed of adult colors rather than the youthful “blue” that Seymour expects to see. A similar idea is expressed by Sybil’s mother when spreading suntan “oil” on Sybil’s back in a downwards motion. If yellow is then a adult color and symbolizes materialism, and “downwards motion” symbolizes oppression then Sybil’s mothers behavior may suggest that she is discouraging her daughter’s naive behavior and attempting to force her to grow up prematurely. Sybil is most likely unaware of her mother’s influence on her child-like manner and therefore she will never fully appreciate her present youth until it is lost. In contrast, Seymour is revived by Sybil’s innocence and near the end of the story “The young man suddenly picked up one of Sybil’s wet feet, which were drooping over the end of the float, and kissed the arch”(17). In essence, Seymour was thanking her for verifying to him that life can still be so simple. Seymour knows that if he was not branded by a painful adulthood “the tattoo”(10) that he would be able to see the Bananafish. But unfortunately most tattoos are permanent.
Seymour is not content in a materialistic society. Seymour, similar in pronunciation to “See more” suggests that he is in search of someone or something. Moreover, Seymour’s surname “Glass” refers to a form of transparency or, in contrast, maybe materialism. This is evident in Muriel’s statement “ She kept asking me if Seymour is related to that Suzanne Glass that has the place on Madison Ave – the millinery”(8) this comment suggests that Seymour has come from a wealthy family. It is ironic that as much as they approve of wealth both psychiatrists Dr Rieser and Dr. Sivetski, lead Muriel and her parents to believe that Seymour “may completely lose control”(7). Likewise, Muriel’s mother for example “The trees. That business with the window. Those horrible things he said to Granny about her plans for passing away. What he did with those lovely pictures from Bermuda — everything.” (6) Following these sentences Muriel’s describes Seymour’s actions as those of a ”raving maniac”(9). They are not taking into account that psychiatrists base their analysis on materialism and on the biased development of individual, such as Seymour, in society. Both the psychiatrists and Muriel’s mother base their analysis on the assumption that his pale color and unorthodox ways somehow suggests that he is unfit for society. Of course, if this were the case Seymour would be unable to differentiate between right and wrong. Semour’s behavior may not be within the realm of normal acceptability but it also cannot be categorized as irrational.
Seymour’s appearance is in sharp contrast to that of his materialistic wife. He, more specifically, is untouched by the sun and is not described as been preoccupied with superficial appearances, and so on. Muriel on the other hand, is extremely sunburnt. It is as if the yellow sun has dominated her. Do the gold effects of the sun symbolize materialism, esthetics, and superficiality?
Is Seymour’s wife unable to see past the surface of her shallow existence? Salinger seemed to have answered these questions when naming Muriel’s character. Muriel similar to “mural” or the Latin word “muralis” indeed suggests that her life pertains to or is like a wall. Secondly, Muriel is a static, flat character just like a painting. If she were dynamic she would have substance, she would change her opinion or attitude, but she never does. Muriel, known only by her obsession with the superficial aspects of life(fashion, sex, nail lacquer, etc.) leads us to believe that in fact she is a painting that was originally molded to portray the image society would expect of a “Lady” of her caliber. In turn, it does not seem to matter who Muriel is in Salingers’s story but what she represents.
In conclusion, Seymour is similar to the bananafish as he swam his way up the stream of life ingesting the materialism and superficiality that past him on his journey. Half way up the stream he stopped pondered why he had even bothered in the first place. Now he cannot go back down the stream (to Sybil) against the current and cannot bear to continue (with Muriel). At this point Seymour is described as having “banana fever” or becoming so engulfed in materialism. His only rational option would be to stay in the banana hole and die.
.
Bibliography
Salinger, J.D. Nine Stories: A Perfect Day for Bananafish. United States: Little, Brown and Company Limited, 1991.
Другие работы по теме:
Idealism Essay Research Paper IdealismEveryone has ideals
Idealism Essay, Research Paper Idealism Everyone has ideals. From the most insignificant aspect in our life, such as the perfect meal, to the most important, perhaps the perfect family, we all have ideals. As a result, we must all be idealists, although some are more extreme idealists than others, as evidenced by the actions of Dr.
JD Salinger Essay Research Paper Smiling children
J.D. Salinger Essay, Research Paper Smiling children clap their hands at all of the happiness in this great big world. Without a care, their imaginations run wild. They lose themselves in colorful stories and delight in life’s little things. As time goes by, however, stories end, little things become littler as people grow bigger, and innocence slowly breaks apart and disappears.
Nine Stories Essay Research Paper J D
Nine Stories Essay, Research Paper J D Salinger wrote Nine Stories with the same brilliance as Catcher In The Rye. His style is so unique and complex that all of his short stories are truly enjoyable. Two of those stories are A perfect day for a bananafish and For Esme with love and squalor. The main characters in both of these stories, Seymour and Sargent X, have served in World War II, and the fighting has taken its toll on them.
Albert Camus Essay Research Paper PHL 342
Albert Camus Essay, Research Paper PHL 342 2-15-99 Albert Camus’ quote reaches me in a meaningful way. I am going to analyze this quote by the sentence because each one carries significance in the way I interpret them. The first sentence, “ Society proceeds sovereignly to eliminate the evil ones from her midst as if she were virtue itself.” This seems to me like Camus is saying that our society is acting as if it were perfect.
Perfect Society Essay Research Paper I can
Perfect Society Essay, Research Paper I can only imagine the perfect society. I look around and all I see is violence and hate, our world at this point is disturbing. There are murders due to hate in this world everyday. The hate in today s real world society is appalling. It starts from the most senseless acts such as, some types of rock music, passing of uncouth comments, and lack of a structured family life.
Drugs And Alcohol Essay Research Paper Alli
Drugs And Alcohol Essay, Research Paper Alli Kelly Drugs in Society Drugs and Alcohol in the Life of Celebrities So you think most celebrities have such “perfect” lives? You are wrong. Many celebrities appear to have “perfect” lives with all the money, popularity and friends they have. But for many celebrities money, popularity, and friends just isn’t enough.
A Perfect God Essay Research Paper I
A Perfect God Essay, Research Paper I believe in an all mighty, all knowing creator. It is easiest to comprehend this being as a man or other human like form, but I do not believe this to be the case. God is perfect. God is perfect because he created perfection. This leaves only two options; 1. Everything is perfect because God created it. 2.
Him Essay Research Paper I think about
Him Essay, Research Paper I think about him day and night The though won’t go away And, oh, how I would hold him tight every second of the day He is perfect, that is true, not an average me or you
Bananafish Essay Research Paper In the short
Bananafish Essay, Research Paper In the short story A Perfect Day for Bananafish by J.D. Salinger, the fact that Seymour Glass is experiencing severe mental problems is undeniable. The way in which he conducts himself, and the way the order of events took place on the day of his death make for a bizarre scenario, which makes his strange sickness evident.
Perfect Day For A Bananafish JD Salinger
Essay, Research Paper The images of war remain imbedded in an individual’s mind, making it difficult for anyone who has faced the horrors of war to reassimilate themselves within society. People who have never faced the horrible images lack the understanding and compassion needed for a war veteran to reestablish themselves.
Perfect Man Essay Research Paper The perfect
Perfect Man Essay, Research Paper The perfect man is said to be hard to find, but I believe there is someone for every person. Sometimes a man is not perfect when you meet him, but he may have some qualities you like. If you are young some men will grow and mature into someone, you love. Dating is a search for the perfect man and a soul mate.
The Perfect Storm Essay Research Paper Heroism
The Perfect Storm Essay, Research Paper Heroism in The Perfect Storm The Perfect Storm by Sebastian Junger was an account of an immense storm and its destructive path through the North Atlantic. In late October of 1991, many a crew of several different fishing ships left their port for their final haul. Little did they know that they would soon cross paths with one of the greatest storms ever recorded.
Spinoza
’s Ethics, Part I Proposition 33 Essay, Research Paper Baruch Spinoza believes the essence of God includes God’s existence and discusses the causality of God through his ontological work, Ethics. In Ethics, Spinoza is seeking a method of truth through the perfect being. The essence of what that perfect being expresses, using this method of truth, is God (i.e. the perfect being).
Monology Vs Perfect Competition Essay Research Paper
Part 1 In a ?Perfect Competition? there are many firms that sell a product. Most likely it is a single product that they sell, competing against each other. They allow people to come in and out of the market very easily.
J D Salinger Essay Research Paper
J.D.Salinger Your Name COURSE TEACHER DATE “I Think that J.D.Salinger is the most talented fiction writer in America.”(Hyman, Edgar p.444) “”Salinger is an oddity, an obsessive, who commands respect..”(Kazin, Alfred p.446) These are just a portion of endless quotes which describe Salinger’s impact on typical modern day literature critic.
Who I Am Essay Research Paper Hi
Who I Am Essay, Research Paper Hi there. What?s going on? To answer a few of your questions, I live in Valley Stream in Nassau County. I will travel anywhere to be with the one I love. I am a very sensitive and caring guy. I love to go to the movies, I love to dance and no I do not smoke. Lol. I have perfect teeth and I want to keep it that way.
Perfection For An Imperfect World Essay Research
Paper Perfection For an Imperfect World Perfection is an objective that has never and will never be accomplished in this world. God made man with the ability to make his own decisions; unfortunately this also meant man could sin. This factor proves that while man is still on this earth, perfection is a hopeless goal.
Critical Lens Essay Research Paper Critical Lens
Critical Lens Essay, Research Paper Critical Lens: Loyalty is the test of a true friendship A true friendship is filled with though times, during these times loyalty is expressed and you learn who your true friends are. Life is all about ups and downs, the highs are high but the lows are even lower. Friends are the only things close enough to hold your feet to the ground and their loyalty is the sobering force in an otherwise hectic world.
The Birthmark Essay Research Paper In Nathaniel
The Birthmark Essay, Research Paper In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark,” Hawthorne focuses on the single imperfection of Georgina, the bride of Aylmer. Alymer insists that with the removal of the hand shaped birthmark from her cheek, she will be flawless. Aylmer was “a man of science” (qtd. in 100).
Perfect World Essay Research Paper New advancements
Perfect World Essay, Research Paper New advancements in science happen everyday. Products may include medicines, fertilizers, household cleaners, durable materials, and more. One of the most controversial issues in the world of science is genetic engineering. Scientists say genetic engineering may bring large advantages to humans and the way they live.
Mr Essay Research Paper Aspects of the
Mr. Essay, Research Paper Aspects of the Perfect Female The ideal woman of today’s society would contain the following qualities: intelligence, honesty, a sense of humor, spontaneity, assertiveness,
A Perfect Day For Bananafish Essay Research
Paper Picture walking into a hotel room and finding a man dead on a bed. Upon closer inspection it becomes obvious that he has supposedly taken his own life with the gun that lay beside him. In talking to his wife who was asleep on the bed next to him when this incident occurred, it is learned that he just walked in the door and shot himself late the previous night.
Picture Perfect Essay Research Paper I have
Picture Perfect Essay, Research Paper I have always found my good friend, Dustin, to be very attractive, but once I fell in love with him, his presence turned to perfection. I have tried, yet I cannot seem to find one single flaw. I know he is only human, but in my mind he will always be above any other. Love is not finding the perfect person, but seeing an imperfect person perfectly.
JD Salinger Essay Research Paper J D
J.D. Salinger Essay, Research Paper J. D. Salinger In each short story by J. D. Salinger, a main character struggles with a question concerning different factors in their own life. Some of the noticeable and repetitious themes in Salinger?s stories are Appearance vs. Reality; Adults vs. Children; Sanity vs.
An Essay On A Dolls House Essay
, Research Paper In the play, A Doll?s House, by Ibsen, a standard of behavior was not followed. The main character, Nora shocks the readers with her behavior. She does not behave as she is expected to during that time period. Her and her family must face consequences, which effect the overall work.
The Giver Essay Research Paper The GiverBy
The Giver Essay, Research Paper The Giver By Lois Lowry I think that the book The Giver by Lois Lowry is a book that shows that it isn?t good to be perfect or live in a perfect world. You don?t get to experience many things that you experience in regular life. One example from the book is how Jonas doesn?t like the job that the elders assigned to him.
Catcher In The Rye
– Holden Essay, Research Paper In JD Salingers’ Catcher in the Rye, a troubled teenager named Holden Caufield struggles with the fact that everyone has to grow up. The book gets its title from Holden’s constant concern with the loss of innocence. He did not want children to grow up because he felt that adults are corrupt.
An Ideal Society Essay Research Paper An
An Ideal Society Essay, Research Paper An Ideal Society There is no real way to describe an ideal society many authors have tried to write what they believe it might be like, but by the end of every story the perfect society all most always fails . The only real way we could have a perfect society is if the people who made up the society were perfect.
Creative Writing Exercise Essay Research Paper 1
Creative Writing Exercise Essay, Research Paper 1. How does one commit a successful murder? To commit a successful murder you first must have a motive. Then after you have established a motive you must create a plan of attack. You need to come up with a way in which you are going to go about committing this crime.
Human Nature Essay Research Paper Human NatureThere
Human Nature Essay, Research Paper Human Nature There is no perfect person in the world, but the celestial and most sacred person has their faults. But my belief is that everyone was born free of sin, because of course, when you’re a baby, you don’t do anything wrong. But I believe that humans aren’t essentially good or bad, but rather, both.