Paper
Who Are We to Judge Anyone?
Sometimes it is easy to form an opinion about someone based on what you see from the outside, but by no means is this an effective way of assessing the way someone is inside. Just like you cannot judge a book a book by its cover, you cannot judge a person without getting to know them. Both Edwin Robinson’s, Richard Cory, and Wystan Auden’s, The Unknown Citizen try to do this. Who is to say that their analysis of the two characters is correct? The two poems are based only on what is observed, not what is known.
Richard Cory is structured in a very consistent, easy to read manner, but is as harsh and radical as the form is classical and neat. The poem is an extended description of a man, a very rich, successful man, named Richard Cory. The narrator of the poem spends a good part of the poem, the first three stanzas, doing nothing but genuinely praising this man. In the first stanza, Richard Cory is portrayed as the envy of all those around him, the object of everyone’s attention. He refers to Cory as a “gentleman from sole to crown”, and even uses language that sounds suited to describe royalty when he calls Cory “Clean favored, and imperially slim.”
The second and third stanzas go on in much the same way. In the second stanza, the narrator describes Cory’s social standing. In the narrator’s eye’s, Cory continues to be the perfect, polite gentleman, as he was “always human when he talked.”. Cory was certainly not the picture of a snobbish or rude man. Cory was also a very popular fellow, as he “fluttered pulses” with a simple “Good-morning”, Cory was an impressive social figure indeed.
However, the poem takes a sudden, dark twist in the last stanza. Robinson does this by first revealing a little more about the narrator. In the first two lines of the fourth stanza, the narrator says: “So on we worked, and waited for the light, And went without meat and cursed the bread . . ..” This is obviously a reference to the narrator’s own poor financial and social state. For the narrator, work is a place of darkness and hardship where you simple “wait for the light.” For the narrator, there is no meat to eat at dinnertime, and after so many meals without it, you begin to curse the cheap bread that you do have to eat. However, not one bad word about Cory passes from the narrator’s lips. This speaks volumes about Cory’s character, and makes the reader think that maybe this Richard Cory is as great a guy as he seems.
In the last two lines of the last stanza, with a minimum of detail and no explanation, Robinson simply tells how Cory “…one calm summer night, Went home and put a bullet through his head.” With that, the poem ends, but the questions remain. Robinson never even gives us a clue as to why this popular rich man would do a horrible thing such as this, but this just goes to show that not everything is as it seems. By taking what is viewed only from a distance, you cannot assume everything is right.
In comparison, just as Richard Cory was told from an outside standpoint, The Unknown Citizen was written in the same way. This time, instead of the story being told by someone looking up to him, admiring him, it is told from the perspective of an unemotional, unexcitable individual.
The speaker of this poem seems to be a government employee or an official from the State. He is someone who strictly follows rules and regulations. He makes sure that the unknown citizen obeys the rules and does everything in order. He shows no emotion in describing the events and records of the unknown citizen. His routine is highly emphasized. To the speaker, statistics are extremely important to grade and categorize the unknown citizen.
The unknown citizen is someone who pays his taxes, satisfies the employers, reads the newspaper daily, has the correct number of children, fights for peace and supports the war. In spite of all these facts, the subject remains “unknown”. We do not see any strong traits in this unknown citizen. He is merely like any other ordinary man we can find around us. We cannot see how special he appears or anything that could distinguish him from others. Although we know all of the facts, we might not be able to recognize him, but somehow the speaker is able to tell us who this person is.
Just as the end of Richard Cory showed us that things are not always as they seem, how is anyone able to judge what type of person the Unknown Citizen was. Nobody can, the description is based on the statistics that were gathered, not the person himself. What someone can see on the outside is not the same as what is within, the part of the person that makes them unique.
Другие работы по теме:
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft has had
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft has had a couple of though months since July last year, when Judge Thomas Jackson ordered the company to break up in two. However, since the beginning of this year things have just looked better for Microsoft.
It Is Based On The Quote
‘If Human Beings Are Evil, Then How Essay, Research Paper This is my Essay. If human beings are evil, then they can easily appoint themselves as judges, and from their point of view, the decisions they make are moral. These judges try to make themselves look better, by lowering the criminal below their level.
Jusstice For All Essay Research Paper When
Jusstice For All Essay, Research Paper When we are young, most of us are somewhat naive. We are inherently taught that good will always triumph over evil. A courthouse is the forum where evil should be dealt with. But, in reality, this is seldom the case.
Bribes Essay Research Paper A bribe as
Bribes Essay, Research Paper A bribe as defined by Tom Carson is a payment to someone in exchange for special consideration that is incompatible with the duties of his position. An example of this would be if you offered a judge payment in secrecy, to rule in your favor. Your offer was accepted by the judge and you were not found guilty because of the payment received.
Bloody Merdian Essay Research Paper Blood MeridianThe
Bloody Merdian Essay, Research Paper Blood Meridian The ending of the Blood Meridian is both abstruse and compelling. The setting when the kid first walks into town (pp.324) seems almost too familiar. This town could be any number of different towns located throughout the Midwest, but it seems strangely related to the town of Nacogdoches.
Bessy Essay Research Paper Farmer Joe decided
Bessy Essay, Research Paper Farmer Joe decided his injuries from the accident were serious enough to take the trucking company (responsible for the accident) to court. In court the trucking company’s fancy lawyer was questioning farmer Joe. “Didn’t you say, at the scene of the accident, ‘I’m fine’?” said the lawyer.
Certainty Essay Research Paper The mind which
Certainty Essay, Research Paper The mind, which has grasped a right theory of knowledge, and has experienced it, that mind is on the road to certainty–the only kind of certainty that is open to the consciousness soul because it has begun to cross the threshold between the objective and sujbective worlds.
Sheppard V Maxwell Essay Research Paper The
Sheppard V Maxwell Essay, Research Paper The wife of Dr. Sam Sheppard(Marilyn Sheppard) was bludgeoned to death on July 4, 1954. She was found in the upstairs bedroom of her home in Bay Village, Ohio. The town mayor called the local police, Dr. Sheppard?s brother(also a doctor) and the next door neighbors.
Judge Dee Essay Research Paper The character
Judge Dee Essay, Research Paper The character of Judge Dee is largely molded by the ideas of his time. During his reign, the philosophies of Legalism, Confucianism, and Taoism, were heavily relied upon for the basis of ethics within the common people and magistrates alike. Judge Dee?s persona is derived directly from the strictest teachings of these philosophies.
Stereotypes Essay Research Paper StereotypesTo Judge or
Stereotypes: Essay, Research Paper Stereotypes: To Judge or Not To Judge If a man commits a crime is he bad? A person with pink hair is a drug user? Interracial relationships make unnatural children? These are all types of stereotypical comments that make life hard for people to deal with in many ways. To judge or not to judge it s a simple concept that many of us take for granted.
Judge Whom Essay Research Paper Judge WhomAll
Judge Whom Essay, Research Paper Judge Whom? All religions must deal with the idea of life after death. Whether their belief is that there isn?t life after death or they simply believe that everyone continues life somewhere. Two of the major religions in the world believe that there is life after death and that you must believe in God to receive everlasting life.
Superficiality Essay Research Paper Everyone is guilty
Superficiality Essay, Research Paper Everyone is guilty of it. even those who claim they’re not. think about it! EVERYONE cares about appearances. I care about appearance. I care about how I look, and though I try not to, sometimes I judge others on how they look.
Racism Black Issues Essay Research Paper Legal
Racism: Black Issues Essay, Research Paper Legal Environment of Business “Separate but Equal” summary It is hard in this time and age to be able to imagine a world of segregation of a people or a color, but that it happened in the time of our fathers is more amazing. There were many factors that lent themselves to the Supreme Court case involving segregation.
Underage Drinking Essay Research Paper Who is
Underage Drinking Essay, Research Paper Who is to judge whether or not someone underage is mature enough to handle the responsibility of consuming alcohol? The government has set twenty-one years of age as the legal drinking age. This is found to be a little odd by most teenagers. At the age of eighteen, young adults can sign their life away to the government and give their life for the country.
Good Grades Essay Research Paper Are people
Good Grades Essay, Research Paper Are people who get good grades and/or who get high scores on tests more intelligent than those who do not? Can we just distinguish people who get good grades and/or high scores on tests are more intelligent than those who do not get good grades? I firmly believe that it is not fair to judge people who get good grades are more intelligent than those who do not.
Caliban Essay Research Paper CalibanWhy are we
Caliban Essay, Research Paper Caliban Why are we, as a society, so quick to judge those who look or act differently than us? Is it a natural human instinct to either make fun or take advantage of those who seem so different? Are they looking for acceptance so badly that they would do anything to gain your approval? Caliban, one of the standout characters in Shakespeare s The Tempest , is one of these different people.
Jury Essay Research Paper Members of the
Jury Essay, Research Paper Members of the jury – you have been chosen because you are a captive audience. You will be required to submit a verdict of guilty or not guilty at the end of this trail by raising the appropriate card. The Foreman will tally the votes and tell the judge.
Celebrated Cases Of Judge Dee Essay Research
Paper Sung Yon Kim Asian Civilization Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee In by reading the Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee, I gained a perspective of the people and culture of China. This book showed the analysis of Chinese saw and the background of Chinese history.
Richard Corey Essay Research Paper Money can
Richard Corey Essay, Research Paper Money can t buy happiness and “You can’t judge a book by its cover” are two old adages that echo through time; however, they seem to echo so softly that they are quite often disregarded. For men, in their search for contentment and fulfillment, only see money as the main vehicle.
Coughing Effect On The Judicial System Essay
, Research Paper Juror’s Cough Misleads Judge CARDIFF, Wales – When a juror coughed, defendant Alan Rashid had a right to feel sick. The cough came just as the jury foreman announced a verdict of ”not guilty” in Rashid’s trial on a charge of threatening homicide. The cough coincided with ”not,” Judge Michael Gibbon only heard ”guilty” and Rashid was sentenced to two years in prison.
Personal Mission Statement Essay Research Paper I
Personal Mission Statement Essay, Research Paper I believe that the following statements are very true for my personal mission statement. Hear both sides before judging. This statement most people should remember. So often people judge and say what they are thinking at the spur of the moment before really thinking the situation over and hear other sides before speaking.
Alienation Essay Research Paper A L I
Alienation Essay, Research Paper A L I E N A T I O N I guess you could say I live off alienation. It seems in my life I have always asked to be alienated from my surroundings. Just like many great authors and artists I found alienation to be a great tool to teach people the age-old lesson that one should not “judge a book by its cover.”
Personality Essay Research Paper PersonalityWhat is personality
Personality Essay, Research Paper Personality What is personality? Personality is defined as a ingrained and relatively enduring patterns of thoughts, feeling and behavior. How can anybody be certain how his or her personality is going to turn out. I think people go through many different types an stages of personality throughout life.
Barbie Doll Essay Research Paper In today
Barbie Doll Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, many people have established an idea of how women should look. Certain characteristics such as how big their breasts are, how small their waist is, and how broad their hips should be are all physical aspects by which people judge women. The actions of men are also expected to be a certain way.
Judgement Essay Research Paper 1 In this
Judgement Essay, Research Paper 1. In this situation, the judge has many different options. These options include probation, placement in a group home, being sent to a juvenile detention center, restitution, being fined, or doing community service. Probation is when a judge sets conditions for a juvenile delinquent that cannot be violated and if they are the juveniles will be sent to a juvenile detention facility, until he is 18.
Fairness Of Jurors Essay Research Paper MUST
Fairness Of Jurors Essay, Research Paper MUST A JUROR’S MIND BE EMPTY TO BE OPEN?This article is about a concept of choosing the 12 jurors. In any case, jurors always play important roles in the court since they are the people who will come up with a verdict. Because of this, people believe that when the jurors are chosen for a certain trial, they must be aware of that case and know what is going on in that case.
Essay On The Short Story
“Divorce” By Ivan Klima Essay, Research Paper In the short story entitled “Divorce” by Ivan Klima a judge makes an important decision that will affect him for the rest of his life. The decision
Bob White Essay Research Paper Shariff Elkordy
Bob White Essay, Research Paper Shariff Elkordy 11/27 Professor Lang A case of negative impact: Bob White v. Texas After reading this article, I was surprised that this injustice happened in the United States not to long ago. Bob White had many of his civil rights violated. He spent seven days in jail with no charges being held against him.
The Judges Wife Essay Research Paper Throughout
The Judges Wife Essay, Research Paper Throughout the story ?The Judge?s Wife?, Isabel Allende presents Dona Casilda presented as a powerless woman although later she emerges as the most powerful character in the story.
The World Essay Research Paper In an
The World Essay, Research Paper In an important speech, oral delivery is key, ingredients to oral delivery are tone, volume, rate, enthusiasm and clarity, how
Friends Always Essay Research Paper what is
Friends Always Essay, Research Paper what is a friend ? one who is caring, sharing,open and honest. one who won’t judge you,one who will take you for you.one who will put up with all your ups and downsone who is totally understanding. one who knows who you really are and accepts everything about you, one who respects you