Henry Davis Thoruea/Compare Essay, Research Paper
Henry David Thoreau was an American writer who is remembered for his attacks on the social institutions he considered immoral and for his faith in the religious significance of nature. The essay Civil Disobedience is his most famous social protest. Thoreau believed that each person must be free to act according to his own idea of right and wrong, without government interference. Sharing some of the same political beliefs as Thoreau, Martin Luther King Jr. was also an American civil rights leader who worked to bring about social, political, and economic equality for Africans by peaceful means. In 1963, he led a march in Birmingham, Alabama, to protest citywide racial discrimination. In the authors essays, Thoreau s Civil Disobedience and King s Letter from Birmingham City Jail both share similar feelings but also differ in some. Both believe society needs to abandon the machine of government . Thoreau, as well as King, have similar thoughts based on the idea that the only obligation an individual has is to his conscience. Another similarity they share would be minority and the majority and the unjust ways the minority faces. A difference between the two authors would be the way they view anarchy. Thoreau believes society, when ready, should prevail upon themselves without a government while King believes there should be some sort of governmental guidance. Throughout the two pieces the similarities they share on ideas and beliefs can easily be noted as well as the differences.
Both believed that individuals should do what they believe is right in accordance to their conscience. In Thoreau s words he believes …the only obligation which I [Thoreau] have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think is right. Thoreau uses the word obligation to assert his right to the integrity of his own mind. He believes that an individual should refuse to obey any government rule he believes is unjust. Thoreau himself practiced this doctrine of passive resistance when, in 1846, he refused to pay toll taxes. This is similar to King s ideas, I submit that an individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and willingly accepts the penalty by staying in jail to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the very highest respect for law. King believes that if you go against your consciences then you are being unjust to yourself. He feels that if you go against your beliefs, then there is something pulling you to go against laws that are unjust and follow your conscience which it is then good as long as you truly believe the law is unjust. People shouldn t follow society and what laws they inflict upon them, but yet should do what they believe is right. They both agree that if someone breaks a governed law for the sake of their own beliefs and accept the consequences then they are respectable. This similarity both King and Thoreau share had an impact on the purpose of their writing to express the importance of following one s conscience to do what is right.
Another comparison of the two would be minority vs. majority. Both Thoreau and King feel that the minority makes up the majority of the population, however, they have no say in any governmental decisions. The government has all the power and tries to keep the minority out of any powerful issues. Thoreau believes that …when the power is once in the hands of the people, a majority are permitted, and for a long period continue, to rule is not because they are most likely to be in the right, nor because this seems fairest to the minority but because they are physically strongest. The largest group, which consists of weak thoughts, are the strongest because they have the most power to blockade any strong ideas of the minority. King states that An unjust law is a code inflicted upon a minority which that minority had no part in enacting or
creating because they did not have the unhampered right… Minority, although they make up the majority, have no input and therefore have no voice. Unjust laws forbid the minorities from growing. Therefore, both authors use minority vs/ majority as an example in expressing their feelings to show how unjust laws are forbidding growth of power among minorities.
Thoreau and King, although, did oppose one another s ideas on the subject of anarchy. Thoreau believes that the best government would be no government at all. …government is best which governs not at all. He believes that if mankind was ready for it, society shouldn t be governed. People should be able to grow and expand as an individual before taking part in any government, …we should be men first, and subjects afterward. King, in contrast, believes that there should be some type of government and restrictions as long as they are just. In no sense do I advocate evading or defying the law… King respects the law to a morally right stance. As long as there in justice to a restriction, King respects and condemns laws.
Thoreau summed up his idea of the role of government in Civil Disobedience. He wrote, there will never really be a free and enlightened State until the State comes to recognize the individual as a higher and independent power, from which its own power and authority are derived, and treats him accordingly. The essay greatly influenced such reformers as Leo Tolstoy of Russia, Mahatma Gandhi of India, and the leaders of the present-day American civil rights movements. Both Thoreau and King had an influence over society in the past and continue to do so. They both believed that an individual is better than a society and the only way one can expand is if they break the machine of government. The risk these leaders brought upon themselves is one they risked for mankind. It is important that these individuals did what they believed should be done, otherwise society would be a mass of weak thoughts that would hold down the growth of man as an individual.
Другие работы по теме:
The Little Business Man Essay Research Paper
The Little Business Man By Morley Callaghan In this story, The Little Business Man, by Morley Callaghan, we met several different characters. The most important characters, Luke and Uncle Henry, had several different values. Luke s values were care, protection and optimism, while his uncle s values were organization, insensibility, and efficiency.
King Henry IV And Joseph Strorm
: Archtypical Fathers Essay, Research Paper King Henry IV and Joseph Strorm: Archtypical Fathers An ideal father is one who is both caring and understanding. To fit this
Summary Of The Red Convertible Essay Research
Paper Often times, an inanimate object can be as important and sometimes more important than the characters of the story. In Louise Erdrich’s “The Red Convertible,” the car played an equally important role with that of the characters, but for different reasons.
Queen Elizabeth And Henry VIII Essay Research
Paper She took over the position of England’s leader when her father Henry VIII died. She didn’t care one way or the other what every ones religion was. So she made Anglican the national
Becket Essay Essay Research Paper
“Friendship often does collapse over such unjust ideas.” This quote alone illustrates the dissolution of friendship that occurs between Thomas Becket and Henry II in early English history. What would one think if a trusted friend turns on them and stabs them in the back? Certain situations in the lives of Thomas Becket and Henry II build up then dissolve their friendship.
Arch Bishop
– Becket Essay, Research Paper Before being named Arch Bishop, Becket found his pride in serving Henry and performing his duties as his Lord Chamberlain, all the while searching for his true honor and pride. He found them to be defending the honor of God and the Church after he became Arch Bishop.
Becket Essay Research Paper Summary of Becket
Becket Essay, Research Paper Summary of Becket by Jean Anouilh Becket is a movie that portrays the conflict of power between the throne and the church. It is the story of Henry II and his companion Thomas Becket. The movie begins by giving a brief summary of the history up to the point where the movie begins. This information is crucial to the understanding of the situation.
Henry Iv Essay Research Paper Henry IV
Henry Iv Essay, Research Paper Henry IV, A Look at a Machiavellian Ruler When looking at Henry IV while studying Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince, one can see that henry was extremely Machiavellian in his ways. The Prince, written by Machiavelli, was written to guide a ruler in the key concepts of being able to have a kingdom that endures and to obtain and control and power in order to succeed during his reign.
The Red Convertible Essay Research Paper In
The Red Convertible Essay, Research Paper In the Red Convertible by Louise Erdrich, the main character Henry loses his hold on reality. The story takes place in North Dakota on an Indian Reservation where Henry lives with his brother Lyman. Henry and Lyman buy a Red Convertible that later in the story illustrates Henry?s lack of ability to stay sane.
Henry IV Essay Research Paper The father
Henry IV Essay, Research Paper The father and son relationship is one of the most important aspects through the youth of a young man. In Shakespeare?s play Henry IV, he
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay, Research Paper Henry Cabot Lodge Henry Cabot Lodge was an American diplomat. He was born on July 5th 1902. He was born in Nahant Massachusetts. He did alot for our country so in the next few paragraphs I will tell you about Henry Cabot Lodge and some of his accomplishments.
A Battle Into Adulthood Red Badge
Essay, Research Paper A Battle for Adulthood Throughout the novel The Red Badge of Courage, written by Stephen Crane, a theme is portrayed within a battle that takes place during the Civil War. It is that each person must find the courage to win his or her won battle for maturity or adulthood. A soldier, who is also the main character, Henry Fleming, exemplifies this theme.
Henry VIII By William Shakespeare 15641616 Essay
, Research Paper From the start, this play seemed scourged. It closed after its debut because a fire burned down the theater where it was being performed. Critics have lambasted Henry VIII for its lack
The Terrible Trins Essay Research Paper What
The Terrible Trins Essay, Research Paper What the book is about: The book is about a mother mouse named Dolly and three baby mice named Thomas, Richard and Henry. Together they try to defeat the cats in the farmhouse where they live. The mice are taught by their mother on what not to get into like mouse traps and poison.
Evolution Of A Soldier Essay Research Paper
Henry Becomes A Man In the book The Red Badge of Courage, Henry changes in many ways as a soldier. In the beginning of the story he is scared of battle and runs, yet by the end of the book he is a true soldier. Many important events shape Henry s evolution into a veteran soldier. Many of Henry s own glorified notions of war are what make him so wary and unsure of himself.
Red Badg Of Courage Essay Essay Research
Paper Henry Fleming was just a child when he entered the army. Even though his journey into manhood took a while, he finally got where he was headed . This journey included many people and things, that help Henry along the way.
Fighting On Two Fronts- Henry Fleming In
Red Badge Of Courage Essay, Research Paper “Fighting on Two Fronts”: Henry Fleming in Red Badge of Courage The Civil War forced many young boys out of childhood and into adulthood. Most of these young boys were not prepared for war, and Henry Fleming was one of these boys.
Henry David Thorea Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry David Thorea Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau conducted an experiment, living simple, and peaceful in a small cabin that he built himself. The observations about nature, the importance of the individual, value of a simple life, and more relevant today, as environment abuses multiply, the pressure to consume increases, and the pace o life continues to speed up.
Innocence
& Experience Essay, Research Paper Innocence to Experience Innocence and experience helps to raise questions in the readers mind to expand the focus on the concepts by the author. Most people develop beliefs through many sources such as media, personal observations, experiences, friends, or teachers.
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper Option 1
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper Option 1 The naming of the school is an important decision. Think about an important person for whom a new school should be named write to
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper Transportation has
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper Transportation has become a major necessity in today’s society. Without the industrial revolution introducing the automobile, most people would find it very hard and frustrating to get around. Henry Ford had become a big part of starting this faster and safer “transportation era”.
Henry Foyal Essay Research Paper Henry Fayol
Henry Foyal Essay, Research Paper Henry Fayol’s Principal of management Fayol was a key figure in the turn-of-the-century Classical School of management theory. He saw a manager’s job as:
Expository Essay On A Farewell To Arms
Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemmingway’s A Farewell to Arms, the protagonist, Frederic Henry is both dysfunctional and tragic. Throughout the story Henry lives up to this
Code Hero In A Farewell 2 Arms
Essay, Research Paper In Ernest Hemingway s A Farewell to Arms, Hemingway shows Frederick Henry s progression into a code hero. Frederick Henry achieved many code hero characteristics by
The Courtship Of Miles Standish By Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow (1807-1882) Essay, Research Paper Henry Wadsworth Longfellow was brought up as a New England aristocrat steeped in European culture. His works,
The Life Of Sir Thomas More Essay
, Research Paper The Life of Sir Thomas More Thomas More was born on February 7, 1478. His life is chronicled in historic writing. He was well schooled and very self-disciplined. His accomplishments throughout his life were, and still are, amazing. More was liked and respected by many.
Book Review A Farewell To Arms Essay
, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms is about Frederick Henry, an American second lieutenant in the Italian army who falls in love with an English volunteer nurse named Catherine Barkley during the first World War. After Henry is wounded, he is sent the hospital where Catherine is stationed. This where their love affair begins.
Luke Essay Research Paper Baldwins s Vow
Luke Essay, Research Paper Baldwins s Vow Luke Baldwin’s Vow is a story written by Morley Callaghan. It is a story about the vow Luke makes. In this essay I will tell you about the good and bad things that Luke goes through.
Civil Disobeiance Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Disobeiance Essay, Research Paper Civil Disobedience Civil disobedience is the refusal to obey civil laws. This refusal is in the form of nonviolence. People who use civil disobedience are usually protesting a
Characterization Of Uncle Henry Essay Research Paper
Characterization of Uncle Henry This characterization of Uncle Henry focuses on the two main ways that he is portrayed in “Luke Baldwin’s Vow.” These two ways are: what Morley Callaghan, the author, reveals through the narrator and what other characters say about Henry. In this short story, Henry is usual referred to as Uncle Henry because he is Luke’s uncle.
Patrick Henry Fight Against The Constitution Essay
, Research Paper Although Henry refused to serve on the Constitutional Convention, Madison needed Henry’s persuasive ways. Henry had a way to make people agree with his ideas. Even though Henry didn’t serve on the Constitutional Convention, he was still present to put in his word. As soon as the meetings opened, Henry began to argue against the Constitution.
Henry James Essay Research Paper Asesyan 1Son
Henry James Essay, Research Paper Asesyan 1 Son of the religious philosopher henry James, Sr., and brother of the psychologist and philosopher William, Henry James was born in New York City, April 15, 1843. His early life was spent in America; on and off he was taken to Europe, especially during the impressionable years from twelve to seventeen.
Cry For Freedom Essay Research Paper Cry
Cry For Freedom Essay, Research Paper Cry for FreedomAlthough Patrick Henry and Martin Luther King, Jr. are both skilled orators and use similar rhetorical devices to appeal to their audiences, they call for freedom for two totally different kinds of people. Both Patrick Henry and Martin Luther King, Jr. show their strengths as speakers through their use of these rhetorical devices.
Henry Viii Essay Research Paper Henry VIII
Henry Viii Essay, Research Paper Henry VIII was king of England (1509-1547), and the founder of the church of England. He was the son of King Henry VII he influenced the character of the English monarchy.