Holmes As A Man And As A Detective ? Essay, Research Paper
What are the main features of Sherlock Holmes as a man and as a detective?
In this essay I shall seek to describe the character of Sherlock Holmes and compare it to his abilities and behaviour as a detective. It should serve as a testimony to the precision and mental ability of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle in using his imagination in building detective cases and building a complex character like Sherlock Holmes.
The Sherlock Holmes stories describe firstly a detective of almost infinite ability in solving the most complex of cases from the smallest of clues. His ability to see the slightest shred of evidence sometimes borders on the absurd for those that are ignorant to these details. One such example of this observation is when Holmes was able to tell how Miss Stoner arrived at his lodgings in The Speckled Band .
The specific traits and abilities that Holmes exhibits are many, including probably the most important observation. His keen sense of observation is essential to his success and is exhibited in every case. Coupled with his observation skills is an interest in science and scientific research, and he shows a scientific base to almost all of his observations. This is perceived by Watson in A Scandal in Bohemia , when he says he was the most perfect reasoning and observing machine that the world has seen . This goes to show that as far as his work is concerned, Holmes uses logical and scientifically based methods. Holmes shows this in The Speckled Band when he says how dangerous it always is to reason from insufficient data . It is said by Watson at the beginning of The Speckled Band that he [Holmes] refused to associate himself with any investigation, which did not tend towards the unusual and even the fantastic . This proves that it is only Holmes who has the observation skills and the logic to solve these cases, as even the police force find it impossible to come to some conclusion, and the cases are dismissed as unsolvable. Watson also comments the Holmes conclusions are, always founded on a logical basis .
Often Holmes proves his hypothesis by meticulous scientific experiment and replication of key events. An example of this would be when Holmes re-enacted the events of the night that Miss Stoner heard the same low whistling sound that her sister did just before she died in The Speckled Band . This proves that Holmes conclusions have a solid base and are difficult, therefore to argue against.
He shows, whilst conducting his investigations, almost no emotional involvement with the characters which enables him to conduct his work in an objective way without emotional interference. An example of this would be The Speckled Band where Holmes is not remorseful bout the death of Roylott. This is shown by Watson s comment in A Scandal in Bohemia , when he tells how emotions would only hinder Holmes as a detective, a crack in one of his own high-power lenses, would not be more disturbing than a strong emotion in a nature such as his . Watson s comment is pointing out that if Holmes were emotionally attached to a case it would effect his judgement completely.
These attributes when put together in one character by Conan Doyle go to form a detective with virtually no weaknesses. This, I believe makes Holmes almost infallible, except I also think that this makes Holmes unable to see the danger of some characters and be overly confident in his own intellect to be out wited by someone. His rare example of fallibility is shown at the end of A Scandal in Bohemia when Watson concludes that Sherlock Holmes was beaten by a women s wit .
As a man, Holmes is portrayed in a way that gives the impression that Holmes skills as a detective, and the fact that he is aware of his amazing abilities and brilliant mind, affects his ability to interact with society in any normal way. His life operates outside of normal contemporary society; Holmes develops no relationships with anyone else, except Watson. Watson comments on this flaw in Holmes in A Scandal in Bohemia when he says as a lover, he would have been placed himself in a false position .
His relationship with Watson is the key in assessing Holmes as a person. He has what can be described as teacher/pupil relationship with Watson, and Watson s respect and admiration of Holmes allows this relationship. There are many occasions in the cases where Watson has learnt from Holmes teachings.
He is also quite a passionate person, he passes some judgement on cases and people, and he has a committed sense of right and wrong. His interpretation is that justice must be done, and people must receive the punishment they deserve, as seen in The Speckled Band where he shows no remorse for the death of Dr Grimsby Roylott, even though Holmes admits he was indirectly responsible . This shows Holmes had passed judgement on Roylott, believing him to be deserving of such a punishment, as his last words were I cannot say that it is likely to weigh very heavily upon my conscience .
He does show extreme bravery and determination, which is helped by the blind faith of Watson, his sidekick. An example of his bravery, and Watson s willingness is in The Speckled Band when they stay in the Miss Stoners room to find out who murdered her sister.
For all these qualities in Holmes, one is left with the impression that he is a cold man who has no real attachment to the world around him and only feelings people have for him is respect for his mind and methods. Yet the impression is also that he does care in a kind of cool, dispassionate way, and has a strong sense of being a defender of right, almost as a calling. It is this consuming passion of his work, which makes Holmes unable to relate to society. In The Speckled Band , Holmes is described as working as he did rather for the love of his art than the acquirement of wealth and in A Scandal in Bohemia , Watson says that Holmes is deeply attracted by the study of crime .
In Conclusion, I think that it is Holmes observational skills and superior intellect which allows him to see cases in an all together different way from other people, that makes him a great detective.
Другие работы по теме:
Топик: Central Processor Unit
The CPU of a computer is a microprocessor, based on a chip or microchip, a small piece of silicon with very large number of electronic 'circuits on it. The CPU interface -this is the way the CPU is connected with the main board. There are two main formats for PC's and those a re the "Socket", and the "Slot" formats.
Am I An Idealist Essay Research Paper
Idealism is a very radical way of solving the mind-body problem, and what I mean by that is that it totally takes out matter and uses the mind as the sole reality. Idealists believe that the mind is reality. Idealism is a meta. Personally myself, I believe that I am and Idealist. The reason I think this is because of one main incentive monism.
The Hound Of The Baskervilles Essay Research
Paper “Perhaps when a man has special knowledge and special powers like my own, it rather encourages him to seek a complex explanation when a simpler one is at hand.” This quote by Sherlock Holmes, the most famous fictional character of A.C. Doyle, describes not only Sherlock Holmes but also his creator. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was an interesting man and his writing were influenced by many things.
Maigret And Then Toy Village Essay Research
Paper I read the book Maigret And Then Toy Village. I really liked this book. The Hound of the Baskervilles and Maigret And The Toy Village were very different. I liked Maigret And
Quality Vs Old Fasion Essay Research Paper
Quality vs. Old Fashion With the introduction of DVD technology, VHS videotapes are eventually going to be put out of production. Just like compact disks have taken over cassette tapes. Although cassette tapes are still being produced, they are not as popular as they were during the late 70’s and early 80’s.
The Hound Of Baskerville Essay Research Paper
The Hound of the Baskervilles 1.Conan Doyle, Arthur. 1976. The Hound of The Baskervilles. Andor Publishing Inc. Park Ridge, New Jersey. 255 pages. 2.The story takes place during the late eighteen hundreds early ninteen hundreds. The beginning of the story is based in London, England, while the rest is based in Devonshire, and Coombe Tracy England.
House Of Baskervilles Essay Research Paper THE
House Of Baskervilles Essay, Research Paper THE HOUND OF THE BASKERVILLES is by far the most popular of all of the adventures of Sherlock Holmes. Filmed over twenty times, serialized, illustrated, and endlessly reread, this short novel is an account of the spookiest case ever solved by the world’s best-known detective.
The Hound Of Baskervilles Essay Research Paper
The Hound of Baskervilles By Sir Arthur Conan Doyle The Hound of Baskervilles is a fictional mystery written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The Hound of Baskervilles was first published into book form in nineteen hundred twenty-seven by Liberty Weekly. Being one of the Sherlock Holmes mysteries The Hound of Baskervilles, is a very well known book.
Sherlock Holmes The Speckled Band Essay Research
Paper The Speckled Band This story is about a women that asks for Shelock Holmes help because she belives that she is going to die like her sister that died two years before. She belives that her sister was either frightened to death or killed by gipsies. Because when this woman Helen found her sister the last words the she sad were: ??Helen! Oh my God, Helen! It was the band! The speckled band!?.
Adventures Of Sherlock Holmes And Scandal In
Bohemia Essay, Research Paper The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes was written by Sir Arthur ConanDoyle. The novel was first published in 1892. A Scandal in Bohemia was a short story about a woman who has pictures of herself and a high Englishnobleman. She used them to blackmail him. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was a novelist, a detective-story writer, and aphysician.
Adventures Of Sherlock Holmes Essay Research Paper
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is an exciting and suspenseful book. In the book there are two crimes committed. Clues are given but the average reader won’t look at them close enough. The first story includes a lady named Helen Stoner whose sister mysteriously died. A few nights before Helen’s sister, Julie, was supposed to get married, they heard a whistling noise.
Rating system in Russia
One of the main aims of making up the is revealing of the most popular topics and genres. The second aim is to find out what actors are the most popular with spectators. It is necessary for successful development of cinema industry in our country.
Lamb To The Slaughter And The Speckled
Band” Essay, Research Paper Murder mysteries all have a similar plot consisting of a body, a motive, a weapon, a suspect, an alibi and detectives. Viewers and readers expect this in the text, Lamb to the Slaughter
Romeo And Juliet Essay Research Paper The 2
Romeo And Juliet Essay, Research Paper ?The Differences? The play Romeo and Juliet, by William Shakespeare is a tragic love story. When reading the play it can be very difficult to understand. This is mainly because you are unable to see the setting and the characters. Two producers, Zefirelli and Luhrmann, have created films based on this play.
Sherlock Holmes Essay Research Paper First Holmes
Sherlock Holmes Essay, Research Paper First, Holmes is the first scientific detective. Second, all of his cases ended up solved so therefore there are no flaws in his method. Well after researching in and out of books and web sites, I finally found the “true” way Holmes solved crimes. The site I found such spectacular information is Sherlockian.Net.
Escapism In
“Young Sherlock Holmes” Essay, Research Paper A simple adventure film is made into much more in ?Young Sherlock Holmes.? The special effects employed accentuate the escapist qualities that exist within the movie. The mystery begins when a few certain men are injected with a hallucinogen and they imagine inanimate objects coming alive and trying to kill them.
Sherlock Holmes Essay Research Paper When Sir
Sherlock Holmes Essay, Research Paper When Sir Arthur Conan Doyle created Sherlock Holmes, he had no idea that his creation would become on of the most read and talked about fiction characters ever. Doyle himself did not even think that the Sherlock Holmes stories were good literature, but as he found out, people were not interested in the quality of his writing but rather being entertained by the world’s most famous detective.
Comparative Essays On Sherlock Holmes Essay Research
Paper Conan Doyleґs hero Sherlock Holmes was popular in Victorian and Edwardian society for many reasons. What in your opinion ,makes the stories “The Red Headed League ”and “The Speckled Band”exciting and successful ? Sherlock Holmes stories are some of the best detective stories ever written . They were written by Sir.
Sherlock Holmes And The Speckled Band Essay
, Research Paper Sherlock Holmes The Speckled Band This story is about a women that askes for Shelocks Holmes help because she belives that she is going to die like her sister that died two years before. She belives that her sister was either frightened to death or killed by gipsies. Because when this women Helen found her sister the last words the she sad were: Helen! Oh my God, Helen! It was the band! The speckled band! .
The Adventures Of Sherlock Holmes Essay Research
Paper The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes The two main characters of The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes are Dr. John Watson and Sherlock Holmes. They are both complex characters in their own ways, though Holmes is more mysterious. This may be because Watson narrates the stories, so we can see what he thinks and feels.
Geographic Features Of A Region Has Important
Effects On Development Essay, Research Paper Geographic Features of A Region Has Important Effects on Development The geographic features of a nation or region have an important effect
Tooth And Nail Book Report Essay Research
Paper Tooth And Nail Book Report Written By Charles Elster and Joseph Elliot 10 Facts About the book 1. The main character is a young women named, Caitlin Ciccone, who is a typical American, girl next door type of
Sherlock Holmes Essay Research Paper The Man
Sherlock Holmes Essay, Research Paper The Man with the Twisted Lip By Sir Arthur Conan Doyle In this short story, by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Mr. Neville St. Clair has been kidnapped. His wife is in town one day and she sees him hanging outside of a window. As she looks up at him, he lets out a scream and is yanked back into the room from where he stands.
Pbx Hybrid Networks Essay Research Paper PBX
Pbx Hybrid Networks Essay, Research Paper PBX and Key/Hybrid Systems PBX and Key systems are the wave of communication for business everywhere. The key difference between PBX and Key/Hybrid systems are the amount of stations each can handle. Key systems are designed for clients with very small line size requirements and very basic needs.
Burton Snowboards Webpage Analysis Essay Research Paper
FEATURES The web site has many graphics and pictures. You can browse the site in two languages, either English or Japanese. The site has many option for all people. For people that want information on the sport of snowboarding who are interested in getting started, to news and chat rooms.
Literature And Warfare Of Great Britain Essay
, Research Paper Literature and Warfare of Great Britain Great Britain was the home of many famous people during the early part of the twentieth century. Many of these famous people were associated with literature. Great Britain was also the setting of a few tragedies during that time period. One of these tragic occurrences was World War I.
Power Mac G4 Essay Research Paper Withits
Power Mac G4 Essay, Research Paper With its Pentium-crushing speed and new design, the Power Mac G4 picks up where the old Macintosh (G3) left off. Its enclosure is now highly polished silver and