Of Brewster’s Place By Gloria Naylor And As I Lay Dying By William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper
The differences between the two novels Women of Brewster’s place by Gloria Naylor and As I lay dying by William Faulkner are many and varied. They differ in their tone, style, handling of characters and overall continuity. That, however, is not the topic of this essay. What I will be assessing is how these two authors handle the theme of family. Do they find that family is a support or a trap for the individuals in the story? Maybe both. Do they differ in their way of thinking or are they of one mind on the subject?
I will start by dissecting each story based on these ideas, then I will compare the two ways of thinking.
In Gloria Naylor’s Women of Brewster’s place, there are quite a few individuals, each with her own story and her own trials and tribulations. I will follow the flow of the story and talk about the characters in the same order as she has.
Mattie Michael has had a hard life. She persisted on loving her son, even though he brought her no end of grief. In that sense, she was trapped by her love for him, but that same love, when transferred onto Ettae Mae Johnson, did bring joy in the form of companionship in her later days. Also, she was the impromptu mother-figure for most of Brewster’s place but more specifically that of Luciella Louise Turner, who, when faced with the loss of her only child, had decided to give up on life. With nothing but love, willpower and an unspoken sense of family, was Mattie able to snatch her back from the brink of death.
In the case of Kiswana Browne, we find both support and entrapment. Although she was supported and loved by her family, Kiswana saw them as an impediment to her life as seen by her independent eyes. She could not deny her parents love for her, but at the same time could not abide by their passive role in the African-American community. Later, we see that the love of her parents was unconditional to the point of accepting her life in the shoddy apartment where she lived. Not only did they understand what she was going through, but they also were willing, albeit indirectly, to support her financially. That might be the only case in both stories where love of family outweighs the traps that come along with it.
Cora Lee’s family was plainly a trap for her. A trap due to her own limited outlook on life. The denial of the fact that babies do grow up had limited her choices and subjugated her to a life of almost slavery. Her unlikely salvation came in the form of Kiswana Browne. Cora Lee’s pride could not allow her to let Kiswana find her a bad example of motherhood, and so she took it upon herself, if only for a little while, to fix her children up for the play. That could also be interpreted as support, since Kiswana was the closest thing Cora Lee had ever had to a family since she moved out of her parent’s apartment.
In the case of Theresa and Lorraine however, little could be said except the fact that they depended on each other for a sense of family and belonging since they could not count on anyone else accepting them for what they truly were. Although some support did spring up after the rape, that was mainly sympathy and not really true understanding
On the whole, the people of Brewster’s place tried to take care of one another and they did have an overall sense of family. They all belonged to these streets, not many wanting to be here and most knowing they could never get out.
In Faulkner’s As I lay dying, the sense of family is far easier to find since most the characters in the novel are of the Bundren’s family. I will talk about some of them individually first, then about all of them as a whole.
Anse Bundren, the father figure of the family, has been more of a burden to the family than anything else. His laziness forces the other members of the family to do his chores in his place and thus constitutes a trap for the rest of the family. The closest example we could find of Anse in Gloria Naylor’s novel would be Luciella’s husband. They both are irresponsible and care more for their own well being than the rest of the family.
The linchpin of the family, alive as well as dead, was Addie Bundren. Alive, she took care of the household as well as did field work, thus supporting her family in lieu of her lazy husband. Dead, however, she linked her family in an effort to bring her to Jefferson and thus became more of a burden than anything else. The closest equivalent, while alive, in Gloria Naylor’s novel would be Mattie Michael, while when she is dead it would have to be the death of the baby. The event that brought all of Brewster’s place together.
Jewel, one of Addie’s sons, seems trapped by his love to his dead mother. He can’t think, except in anger, of anything but her. He has a very hard time accepting anyone else’s love for his mother.
Overall, the Bundrens find themselves trapped by the promise of Anse to Addie to bring her to Jefferson. A promise that they intend to keep, if only to pay her back for all the support she had given them while alive. While keeping that promise, though, they find themselves having to rely on each other’s support and subsequently grow somewhat closer as a family. Even in her death, Addie Bundren manages to keep her family together.
Finally, as to comparing Gloria Naylor’s and William’s Faulkner’s view on family, I find that they both perceive it very much alike.
In Women of Brewster’s place, we find many stories with entrapment in them, but ultimately the family, whether direct or indirect, comes through. Mattie is a surrogate mother, Etta Mae a loving sister, Kiswana a loving child, Ciel a needy daughter, Cora Lee a confused child and Theresa and Louise the odd couple.
All in all a normal dysfunctional family. Just like the Bundren’s. Containing many different personalities yet coming out better as a whole.
Другие работы по теме:
Sexual Stereotypes Essay Research Paper Sexual stereotypesThe
Sexual Stereotypes Essay, Research Paper Sexual stereotypes The belief that women are more emotional than men is one of the most common findings in gender stereotype research. Women are thought to experience more frequent and more intense emotions, whereas men are thought to be emotionally inexpressive and to have less intense emotional experiences.
Depression And Women Essay Research Paper Around
Depression And Women Essay, Research Paper Around the world, depression occurs more frequently among women than among men. The female-male ratio ranges from 2:1 to 3:1 in most industrialized countries (Nolen-Hoeksema, 1999). “Women are 2-3 times more likely than men to suffer from depression”(Encarta Encyclopedia, 2001). “Why do women feel blue more often than men?”
Little Women By Louisa May Alcott 18321888
) Essay, Research Paper Louisa May Alcott’s most famous novel, Little Women is based on her own family life in Concord, Massachusetts. Like Jo, the book’s heroine, Louisa hungered to gain independence and to
The Comparison Of The Good Earth And
Nectar In A Sieve Essay, Research Paper The Good Earth and Nectar in a Sieve Comparisons The Good Earth and Nectar in a Sieve were two very different novels. One was about a family in India under
Connecticut Yankee Vs Le Morte D
’arthur Essay, Research Paper King Arthur’s Britain, a vastly different Britain than we know today, is revealed through many timeless classics in literature. Two of these pieces of literature are Thomas Malory’s seriously toned Le Morte D’Arthur and Mark Twain’s satirical A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court.
You Just Don
’t Understand Essay, Research Paper Deborah Tannen?s (1990) book, “You Just Don?t Understand,” contains facts about men and women?s communication styles. Tannen says once these gender differences are sorted out, men and women can recognize and understand how to confront real conflicts, rather than fighting styles.
Gender Differences Essay Research Paper Men and
Gender Differences Essay, Research Paper Men and women have different views on shopping. Women find it as an exciting, entertaining and fulfilling task, while men find shopping as an unpleasant chore. Women seem to be more fascinated by the idea of fashion and find an identity with their clothing. Men on the other hand, just view it as a way to clothe themselves, and don?t find any real meaning in it.
The Giver Vs Brave New World Essay
, Research Paper The Giver by Lois Lowry and Brave New World by Aldous Huxley have many similarities. They both take place in futuristic utopias where happiness is the overall goal. Jonas and Bernard, the major characters in the novels, are both restless individuals who want change. Despite the close similarities, there are many contrasts in the two novels.
Differences Bet Men And Women Essay Research
Paper Differences between men and women In spite of the fact that men and women are part of the human race and share several similarities, they are completely different in many aspects that will be analysed in this essay. Though they are considered equal beings, there are deep contrasts that make them completely different in many ways.
Red Star Vs. Room With A View
Essay, Research Paper The differences in views of women’s roles in society differ from E.M. Forester’s A Room with a View and Bogdanov’s Red Star, is what I believe to be a response to economic class in each society. I say this because in the society on Mars all persons were working towards a common goal and pull their resources together, which is a more conceivable of an idea that a group peasants would do than the middle class.
Lennie From Of Mice
& Phinney Of A Seper Essay, Research Paper Lennie & Finny Finny, from A Separate Peace, and Lennie, from Of Mice and Men, was basically the center of their novels. Everything that went on revolved around them. From the very beginning,
Stories Of Amy Tan And Fannie Flag
Essay, Research Paper Two of My Favorite Books Two novels that I could read over and over again, “The Joy Luck Club” by Amy Tan and “Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Caf?” by Fannie Flag. The two novels share similar qualities while conveying their different story lines.
Perspectives Of Love Essay Research Paper I
Perspectives Of Love Essay, Research Paper I believe men and women have trouble understanding love because of their different perspectives. I believe this because soon I ll be finding a partner (as will many others my age) to settle down with. I d like an understanding of the males perspective as well as my own.
Differences Between Men And Wo Essay Research
Paper Differences between men and Women There are many traditional differences that we read about. Some major differences were stated about how the communication styles of men and women very. These differences can cause many problems in daily interaction between men and women. When people are communicating they expect that the other person will communicate in the same way.
A Compare And Contrast Essay Between Anthen
& A Handmaids Tal Essay, Research Paper The two novels, The Handmaid’s Tale and Anthem, are both haunting, first person tales of personal hardship in a closed and controlled society. In this essay I will point out many important similarities and differences between the two books, mainly the setting and the similarities between the two societies in which the stories take place, as well as more important differences between the main characters.
Roles Of Women In The Developed And
The Developing World Essay, Research Paper The differences between the Roles of Women in the Developed and the Developing World Women consist of half the world?s population and do two-third of the world?s working hours. However, they can only receive one tenth of money and own one hundred of property (?Women? 10).
Communication Differences Between Men And Women Essay
, Research Paper INTRODUCTION The differences in gender is the most significant biological difference within the human species. Yet, most of us know very little about how these differences affect work, intimacy and conflict. Starting at a very young age, these differences begin to shape our play, concepts of relationships, productivity, and in general the way we communicate with one another.
The Difference Between Men
& Women Essay, Research Paper Having been a member of the female gender for almost twenty years, I?ve come to realize the differences between men and women are like night and day.
The Destruction Of The Human Spirit In
Frankenstein And The Picture Of Dorian Grey Essay, Research Paper The human spirit is one of the most beautiful forces in the world, but it is also one of the most vulnerable.In the novels Frankenstein by Mary Shelley and The Picture of Dorian Grey by Oscar Wilde, this idea of the human spirit is portrayed clearly.Both novels have similar aspects about the human spirit, but they also have their differences.Both novels have main characters who are influenced greatly by someone that they admire, and they are destroyed by that influence.The difference that these novels have is that in Frankenstein, the main character is influenced and destroyed by something he creates himself, while in The Picture of Dorian Grey, the main character is influenced and destroyed by his friend and mentor.Again, both novels portray the human spirit’s motivation and vulnerability.
Men 2
Men & Women: A Cross Cultural Relationship Essay, Research Paper Men & Women: A Cross Cultural Relationship In the Story ?How to Talk to a Hunter?, Pam Houston makes many assumptions about the differences between what men and women expect from a relationship. The relationships men and women hold can almost be viewed as cross cultural in nature.
The House Of The Spirits And Chronicle
Of A Death Foretold – Comparison Essay, Research Paper When analyzing Isabel Allende’s and Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s lives, parallels between them become increasingly obvious, thus the rationalization for some of the similarities that are observed between their historically fictional novels The House of the Spirits and Chronicle of a Death Foretold, respectively.
The Womans Proper Role In Society Essay
, Research Paper Tony Jacques Social Problems in American Society Russ D. What is the woman’s proper role in American society? Men and women are by no means equal. There are always going to be certain attributes of each gender that the other can’t duplicate. This does not mean that any one is better than the other, but that, aside from the obvious fundamental differences, we should treat both sexes equally, making allowances for these differences.
American Culture And Gender Vs. Racial Differences
Essay, Research Paper American Culture and Gender vs. Racial Differences With all of the social and economic gains made by women and ethnic groups through the past 30 years, it is amazing how America still focuses on both gender and racial differences. It doesn’t matter if you are African American, Caucasion, Asian or whatever.
The Joy Luck Club 2
The Joy Luck Club – Culture Differences Essay, Research Paper The Joy Luck Club, a novel by Amy Tan, is a compilation from eight different women and their lives. The stories are based on their Chinese culture and their mother/daughter relationships. In the novel and in the film production, the women go through many obstacles in life and must overcome them in order to survive.
Alienation Paper Hemmingway Essay Research Paper Alienation
Alienation Paper Hemmingway Essay, Research Paper Alienation Paper The novels The Old Man and the Sea and The Sun Also Rises are both written by Ernest Hemingway. Some of the aspects of the stories are similar, and some are different. Each book presents a character that has been alienated, but the method used to present the character varies.
Joy Luck Essay Research Paper The Joy
Joy Luck Essay, Research Paper The Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan, is a powerful portrayalThe Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan, is a powerful portrayal of four Chinese women and the lives of their children in America. The book discusses the conflicting cultures between the United States and China, and how men treat women throughout their lives.
Comparison Of Sonnets 18 And 130 Essay
, Research Paper Sonnets 18 and 130 In Shakespeare’s sonnets 18 and 130 he referred to two women that he loved. These two sonnets shared similarities and yet contained many exciting
Othello And Much Ado About Nothing Essay
, Research Paper The two villains in ?Much Ado About Nothing? and ?Othello? share much in common, despite their numerous differences. It is evident that Shakespeare
Comparison Of 1984 And Brave New World
Essay, Research Paper A Brave New World is a story about Bernard Marx, who rejects his society because he finds that he is not satisfied with living a controlled life. 1984 is a story about Winston who
Femininity Essay Research Paper The New FemininityFemininity
Femininity Essay, Research Paper The New Femininity Femininity is not a word that we are encouraged to use these days. A lot of people would argue that femininity is the thing that keeps women obedient to men. However, there is a hidden assumption behind this term. The assumption is that masculinity is superior to femininity; that femininity is not a beautiful and powerful thing in its own right.
Jane Eyre And Little Women Jane And
Jo Comparison Essay, Research Paper The novels Jane Eyre and Little Women are strikingly similar in many ways, and the characters Jane Eyre and Jo March are almost mirrors of each other. There are many similarities between Jane and Jo, and also some differences, as well. From childhood, although they find themselves in completely different situations, both girls experience many of the same trials in their younger years.
Cats And Dogs Essay Research Paper Cats
Cats And Dogs Essay, Research Paper Cats and Dogs We all know the motto, it has probably been around since the beginning of time, You can t live with them and you can t live without them. This can only refer to men and women/husband and wife. Of course, there are many differences and many more similarities between sexes.
Women In Men
’s Sports Essay, Research Paper Should women be allowed to play on male sports teams? Method of Development: What physical and mental differences do males and females have which might