Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper
I work at Infowest, Utah s second largest Internet service provider, where I am a server administrator and webmaster. I frequently handle customer service questions, especially when our technicians are indisposed on other phone calls. I have frequently received calls like this one:
Caller: Why can t I access the web site www.cnn? My browser says it is blocked!
LM: Do you subscribe to our XStop service?
Caller: Yes.
LM: Let me check the site. (I check the CNN web site for any reason why our censorship service would be blocking it… I find nothing questionable on the site.) The XStop service must be malfunctioning right now. I ll call them and tell them about the error and get back to you. Can I get your number?
I m amazed how many times I get calls like this, caused by Internet censorship failure, usually when the service censors something it shouldn t. But, of course, I shouldn t be surprised: There are many technical problems with Internet censorship. First of all the manpower and money needed to keep an accurate and up-to-date database of questionable sites, as most censorship firms do, are tremendous. The second problem is the lack of accurate content filtering software, especially on the client side. Also, the internet is multinational, and uses many protocols, languages that computers use to talk to each other and negotiate data exchanges, making it nearly impossible to police the entirety of the network. Lastly, there is the issue of data encryption, which makes censorship of encrypted data impossible.
The way the XStop service works is supposed to solve one of the major problems with Internet censorship software, namely the lack of manpower to keep up the database of questionable sites. The XStop service allows any user who finds a questionable site that isn t in the database to add that site to the database, with little or no review of the submission by anyone at XStop. This scheme saves XStop, the subscribing ISP, and the consumer who is subscribed to the ISP money. This is a fairly good solution to the problem of manpower: The service distributes the responsibility of keeping the database up to date to everyone on the Internet. That way they have the potential of several million people keeping their database up to date and accurate. Right? Wrong. There are many pranksters out there that add sites that don t have questionable content to the database, blocking access to those sites to anyone subscribed to the service. Now, many censorship proponents would say that this isn t much of a problem, the ISPs that use the XStop service, or others like it, can simply report problems to the services and have them fixed. This is fine for them to say: they don t have to deal with irate customers.
The truth is that most ISPs spend more money using and helping maintain services like XStop than they make by offering the service. This problem isn t limited to only services such as XStop; there are other companies out there that provide censorship software that is not publicly maintained, yet the same type of problems occur. Those that are maintaining the database can t cover the entirety of the Internet in their searches for questionable material. The Internet is so large that not even automated search engines, such as Yahoo!, Excite, or Google have all the pages indexed (Google has the largest index, at over a billion pages). The time and money it takes to keep an accurate, up to date database of questionable sites cost too much for any one entity to handle it.
The database upkeep problem isn t the only show stopper when it comes to Internet censorship. There is also the problem of filtering anything other than just the web. There are other services on the Internet that are perfect places to distribute pornographic or otherwise questionable content: FTP, Hotline, Usenet, and GNUtella variants being among the most popular. Filtering these services requires a type of filtering at the receiving end: client side filtering, mostly because they are password protected or use propriety protocols. The content must be downloaded first, then analyzed. The only reliable way to do automated data analysis, especially of graphics files, is some type of artificial intelligence scheme that can make some type of judgment as to whether the content is appropriate or not. There currently is no artificial intelligence technology that can do this without making many errors and, therefore, blocking potentially worthwhile content.
In addition to the problems of manpower and client side filtering is the issue of the sheer size and complexity of the Internet. Many people in America believe the Internet is owned and operated by the U.S. government. While the precursor to the Internet, ARPA net, was developed by the U.S. Department of Defense, the Internet itself has grown way beyond that original seed. The Internet is now a network of millions of computers, clients and servers, in every country on the globe. The rules and regulations of the United States can no longer regulate the entirety of the network. Things that are considered illegal in America can be freely posted on servers elsewhere, for example, England has no laws to keep pornography out of sight of children. People in America can access any server on the the network as they would access a server down the hall. The ambiguous nature of the Internet itself makes it impossible to pass laws banning the posting of pornography in places children can access. Every country in the world would have to pass the same law for it to be truly effective.
The multi protocol nature of the Internet is another contributor to the complexity of the Internet. New protocols for content transfer are being developed every day, rendering software that only censors the protocols of today obsolete in a short time. To add to matters, a great number of these protocols are proprietary, therefore any company wanting to censor the data carried over those protocols would have to license the protocol from the company that created it (potentially very expensive) or try to reverse engineer the protocol and risk a lawsuit.
The biggest stumbling block that is appearing now is encryption. Encrypted data can not be censored, period. The most common encryption in the world now, 2048 bit key escrow encryption, is impossible to break. Many cryptographers claim it would take all the world s supercomputers, working together, several trillion years to break a 2048 bit key. No censorship software could break that kind of encryption to censor the data inside
Censoring the Internet is a controversial subject. Many want it censored, and many do not, but from a technical standpoint it is impossible. The encryption issue is a stake through the heart of internet censorship: how can you know if something needs to be censored if you can t read it? Even without censoring, the multiple protocols on the internet, multiple law systems governing the internet, and the problems with manpower and client side censoring make it impossible to censor the internet in a way that is acceptable, a way that has a chance of censoring any content that may be worthwhile. The bickering may as well be stopped, censorship cannot truly happen on the Internet.
Другие работы по теме:
Censorship Essay Research Paper CENSORSHIPCensorship and the
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Censorship Freedom Or Suppression Essay Research Paper
Censorship Freedom or Suppression ? Government censorship can be looked at as a blessing or an unneeded burden. I personally feel that all censorship is completely unnecessary and should be found unconstitutional. It is the countless moral views that bring no right answer for what should and should not be censored.
Whers The Freedom Going Essay Research Paper
The Internet has developed into a vast basin of knowledge with many users contributing to its growth. With the growth of the Internet, many people have seen is as a source to express one’s ideas to the public. Some would even view the Internet as a virtual community, and say it is a democracy. People argue that with such free will, the Internet should be censored to protect children from pornography.
Censorship Essay Research Paper CensorshipCensorship is the
Censorship Essay, Research Paper CensorshipCensorship is the control of communication between people. This includes restrictions on what can be seen and heard. Mostly, censorship is practiced by Governments. But religious and political leaders and special interest groups also try to control the flow of information.
Censorship Essay Research Paper The negative messages
Censorship Essay, Research Paper The negative messages kids receive via the media have a damaging affect on their psyche and can create serious societal problems. In truth “[t]he violence to which American children are exposed in the name of
Censorship 2 Essay Research Paper The Internet
Censorship 2 Essay, Research Paper The Internet is one of the technologies that are widely used in the world. It is also one of the most controversial technologies. The government wants to put some regulations on the Internet. These regulations mainly consist of the censorship of it. These regulations are lead by the Communications Decency Act.
Press Censorship Essay Research Paper There are
Press Censorship Essay, Research Paper There are many kinds of censorship within our school system. Such as press Censorship, we aren’t aloud to express freely among our school?s newspaper nor
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship by definition
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship by definition is the suppression of published or broadcast material to the public. People have fought and died for the right to hear, read, and see anything and everything that is available. But our right goes beyond that, we have the full right to publish and broadcast material, even though it is controversial.
Censorship 6 Essay Research Paper CensorshipWhat is
Censorship 6 Essay, Research Paper Censorship What is Obscenity? Clearly something hard to talk about. “Obscenity” is difficult to discuss. After all, what makes a thing obscene? It’s an elusive term we use, but can’t explain. Different people often see things differently. Some see obscenity in nude pictures, statues, etc.
Censoring The Net Essay Research Paper Every
Censoring The Net Essay, Research Paper Every time our technology advances and some new form of entertainment, such as television, magazines or music begins to develop or change, there are some people that would like to control what goes on by some form of censorship. The recent growth of the Internet has created the same demand.
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship of
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship of inappropriate material has been an issue with every form of mass media. Now the new and upcoming Internet is becoming the focus. Software makers and service providers are choosing what the public should see. Does this seem right? How can a stranger choose what another person or their family sees on the Internet? Parents and adults should choose what they and their children are exposed to on the Internet.
Censorship 10 Essay Research Paper CensorshipTom Cruise
Censorship 10 Essay, Research Paper Censorship Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidmen star in the film, Eyes Wide Shut, which is a artistic movie about two people having sex. What has society come to? Shouldn t this have been censored? Or is it showing their art to the world? The never ending debate over censorship boast s so many arguments.
Is Censorship Wrong And Cynical Essay Research
Paper Music, movies, and books should not be censored. Authors deliberately create to express themselves through these things. In consequence of censorship, the public would not be able to receive the main idea of the product for which it was intended. However there are opinions and facts that support both sides to this controversy.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship making the
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship, making the world a better place. Censorship affects our society in many different ways, it affects the music we listen to, the movies we watch, the books we read, and many other aspects of our everyday lives. Even though many might argue that censorship doesn t really have a place in a society that emphases freedom of speech and the freedom to express oneself, but censorship is an essential and needed part of our growing society, it s needed in the television industry, the Internet, and the music industry.
Censorship Essay Research Paper CensorshipSince the beginning
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship Since the beginning of art and entertainment society has tried to censor the public from the so called ?influences? of art, television, movies, and music. Censorship is suppose to protect the children from seeing form of sex, violence, profanity and drugs. If its suppose to protect the children from seeing these thing why do I see so many children doing those things.
Censorship 2 Essay Research Paper CensorshipThere are
Censorship 2 Essay, Research Paper CensorshipThere are many aspects to censorship. But before I explain the many different aspects of censorship, I would like to discuss what censorship includes. Censorship is the supervision and control of the information and ideas that are circulated among the people within a society.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Probably the most
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Probably the most obvious example of intolerance in our society today is the existence of censorship. I have yet to encounter a valid argument for any form of censorship. Such arguments as are presented invariably take the form of concern for the well being of others , children frequently being the alleged victims quoted .
Should The Internet Be Censored Essay Research
Paper I believe that the Internet is a good source of information on a wide variety of subjects. I have personally used the Internet for a year now and have found it very useful for helping me with my school work as well as being very entertaining. However I have been deterred by some of the information that is easily accessible and that anyone could look at such as, detailed instructions on how to make harmful or fatal explosives and illegal pornographic material.
Refutation Essay Research Paper Refutation PaperMost Internet
Refutation Essay, Research Paper Refutation Paper Most Internet users are enjoying their freedom of speech on the Net, which is supposed to be protected by the First Amendment of the United States. However there are many organizations who are trying to strip americans of their rights. Their main argument is that of pornographic access to childrin via the web.
Censorship On Freedom Of Speech Essay Research
Paper In my research, I found out that censorship goes against our freedom of speech. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, censorship would shut out parents from deciding what television programming is acceptable for their children, and giving that right to bureaucrats and to executives.
Letter On Censorship Essay Research Paper Dear
Letter On Censorship Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr Smith,I am writing to you on the subject of censorship. It is my belief that the laws governing film censorship should be more versatile.Children of today are becoming mature and adult-like at an
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship an official
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship: an official authorised to examine printed matter, films, news, etc., before public release, and to suppress any parts on the grounds of obscenity, a threat to security, etc. (Dictionary, MS Encarta)
Internet Regulation Essay Research Paper The internet
Internet Regulation Essay, Research Paper The internet was created for the cold war, in the event that the U.S. were attacked, there would be no communication among the nations leaders, because traditional communication would be disrupted by a nuclear blast. Since that time, the internet survived only though commercialization, the original form of the internet was scrapped when the cold war ended.
Censorship Of Pornography Essay Research Paper Censorship
Censorship Of Pornography Essay, Research Paper Censorship of Pornography Introduction: I would like to apologize ahead of time, for what I’m about to say may offend some of you in the audience. Wild sex, naked bodies, these are just a few things that deal with pornography and our government sensors it every day.
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Speech II
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Speech II Outline Intro: Censorship is when a third party makes decisions about what can be communicated between two people; even if the two agree that the censorship is okay, it is still censorship. Although the Internet was created in the 1960s as a communications tool of the U.S. military that would withstand even the most severe nuclear war and still be operable, it was not until after the government opened it up to public use in the late 1980s that the Internet became a unique communications phenomenon.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Why There Should
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Why There Should be Censorship Censorship is the examination of material for objectionable matter. It is used to keep material from influencing people the wrong
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Internet CensorshipThe
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Internet Censorship The Internet is a wonderful place of entertainment and education, but like all places used by millions of people, it has some murky corners people would prefer children not to explore. In the physical world, society as a whole wants to protect children, but there are no social or physical constraints to Internet surfing.
The Internet And World Wide Web Defined
Essay, Research Paper Christopher L. Isaacs 1010 ? Technical Writing Extended Definition 00 March 6th The ?Internet? and ?World Wide Web? Defined In recent years the Internet and World Wide Web (WWW) have become more and more popular as an information resource. Many people believe that the WWW is the same as the Internet.