’s Commentary Of Genesis Essay, Research Paper
Title: Analysis of Susan Niditch’s Commentary of Genesis in the WBCSubject: ReligionType: Type of Paper Analysis of Commentary Academic Level: CollegeContent: An analysis of Susan Niditch’s approach to the study of women in Genesis (from her commentary in THE WOMEN’S BIBLE COMMENTARY- cited in the paper). Description: Describe Niditch’s approach to the study of women in Genesis and what she says overall aout these stories/characters. Also, which story discussed by Niditch, or what comment made by Niditch about a story do you find most interesting? What modern relevance dies this story hold?
In The Women+s Bible Commentary, Susan Niditch presents a commentary on the biblical passages of the book of Genesis which involve women. In this commentary she examines the author+s, |Worldview and concerns, especially those pertaining to women+s issues (12).X In the process of examining the text, she discovers several themes and concepts revolving around women which Niditch recognizes in Genesis and develops in her commentary. These are things such as present and historical misconceptions about the woman+s role in certain passages of the Bible, and the reduction of woman to the status of a womb in ancient Egypt. In turn, this situation precipitates other situations in areas such as domestic life which are equally unfavorable. In her commentary on the book of Genesis, Niditch states that, |In reading the Hebrew Scriptures as a narrative whole, including both Gen. 1:27 and Leviticus one may receive the message that the genders were meant to be equal at the beginningX(13). Later in the commentary, she states that Jewish and Christian traditions have, |Viewed woman+s creation in Genesis 2 as secondary and deriative-evidence of her lower status.(13)X. Niditch then says that Genesis 3 is interpreted by these culures to further indite woman as the one who, |let loose sin and death. (13)X Niditch seems to concentrate on the section of Genesis 2 and 3 as a pivitol place for women in the Bible. She believes that this text is very much misunderstood. Niditch points out that in Genesis 3 Adam is passive. In fact he is quite silent. Eve is the protagonist in the story and it is because of her that humans gain the ability to know the difference between good and evil (13-14). Niditch even says that Eve is a |conscious actor choosing knowledge (14).X This forces the reader of the commentary to question and challenge the tradiotional Jewish and Christian interpretatons of this Bible and ask the question, |What would life be like if Eve had not taken the fruit?X. After eating the fruit, it is at this time that Adam and Eve become human as we know it. They aquire their |Marks of social life and culture: knowledge of good versus evil, clothing that defines and conceals, and gender roles. The woman is to be the bearer of children, the Mother of all life (14).X In fact, Niditch shows that in sections of Genesis such as 16:4, Matriarchs have closed wombs and are humiliated and taunted by co-wives (17). Here, she shows how women in the Bible are very often reduced to being wombs. Niditch illustrates this idea very well in Genesis 16:4. After Hagar conceives Abraham+s child, she finds Sarah, |to be of less worth (17).X Furthermore, the concept of woman is further developed by Niditch in that since motherhood is the center of the woman+s life, there develops a competition between women concerning children. For instance, in Genesis 30:14-16 Leah |hiresX Jacob+s services for the night by buying them with her son+s mandrakes (17).
This leads to the next concept about women in the Bible. Because the area of child bearing and rearing is dominated by women, when it comes to matters concerning these issues, the wife has control and very often the man is, |bumbling, passive, and ineffectualX (16). For istance, in Genesis 16:4 when Sarah has a problem with Hagar and wants to banish her from the camp, Abraham simply tells Sarah to do with her what she wants to do (17). On the other hand, when men are active in these situations, such as Abraham in Genesis 21:10 expressing his disapproval of the banishing of Hagar from the camp the second time, they are often silenced. In this case Abraham is silenced by God who instructs him to follow what Sarah says (18). It is within this setting of domestic power, without any social or political power, that the Matriarch+s of the Bible often tranform into tricksters in order to ensure God+s will. One of the most classic examples of this in Genesis is in chapter 27. Rebekah tricks Isaac into blessing Jacob instead of Esau, his first-born. This story parallel+s Genesis 2 and 3 in that if either Rebekah or Eve had not done what they did, then the kingdom of Israel would have been quite different, if one existed at all (16). Niditch also discussed the woman outside the realm of domestic life. She says that women were, |in effect items of exchange, extremely valuable commodities (16).X This is evident from the common practices of wife-stealing and rape which were associated with war in ancient Israel (24). This concept is very well illustrated in the story of the violation of Dinah in Genesis 34, where she is, |Central to the action,X but she, |Has no voice.(23)X It is this comment which Niditch makes that I find most interesting. Though it is very short, it says a lot. This statement epitomizes the position of women in the Bible generally. The women of ancient Israel, as well as the women of today, carried tremendous responsibility and with that responsibility, they also carried a great burden of being subjugated by man just as if they were slaves or privete property. This is a grave injustice, because the women were just as importand as the men of that time. The men may have controlled !the kingdom of Israel, but as Susan Nititch writes, |By giving birth, the women further the march of the human culture (15).XFrom these stories of the Bible there is much to be learned. Although we, as a culture, have come a long way in the treatment of women in the modern world, there is still much work to be done to aquire total equality among all sexes. This issue goes much deeper than sexism though. It also goes for racism and all other types of prejudice. We, as a sociey, need to realize that all people are created equal, not just all men.
Niditch, Susan. |GenesisX. The Women+s Bible Commentary. Ed. Carol A. Newsom and Sharon H. Ringe. Louisville: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1992. 10-24.
Другие работы по теме:
Glatiator Essay Research Paper Review by Susan
Glatiator Essay, Research Paper Review by Susan Granger 3? Stars out of 4 Copyright ? 2000 Susan Granger “Are you not entertained?” charismatic Russell Crowe roars scornfully to the cheering crowd in the Roman Colosseum. Certainly there hasn’t been this kind of awesome sword-and-sandals spectacle since “Spartacus,” “Ben-Hur” and “Cleopatra.” Set in 180 A.D., Crowe plays Maximus, a Roman general who promises his aging mentor, Caesar Marcus Aurelius (Richard Harris) that, as his appointed successor, he will return power to the Senate, thus restoring the Republic.
Rebuttal Susan Essay Research Paper RebuttalSusan she
Rebuttal Susan Essay, Research Paper Rebuttal Susan: she is trained and it would be a disgrace for her not to work. Rebuttal: It has been observed that most girls at highschool are not really concerned about their studies and they just play around. They are filled with ideas of some man coming up to them as long as they are beautiful.
Cheers A Semiotic Analysis By Berger Essay
, Research Paper Cheers : A Semiotic Analysis by Berger In Arthur Asa Berger s essay, he conducts a semiotic analysis of the comedy television show Cheers. In his analysis of the show he points out many characteristics that refer to semiotics. Even though one could not agree with all of his findings, many of them are reasonable.
Kive Essay Research Paper
# a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y Grapes of Wrath, The – Book Summary and Analysis Grapes of Wrath, The – Book Analysis Grapes of Wrath, The – Joads’ Journey Great Expectations – Powerful Themes in the Novel
Mayor Of Casterbridge Essay Research Paper Mayor
Mayor Of Casterbridge Essay, Research Paper Mayor of Casterbridge In the beginning of the novel, Michael Henchard sells his wife Susan and their baby daughter Elizabeth-Jane to a sailor for five guineas after drinking a great deal of rum-laced furmity–a sort of gruel made of wheat, milk, sugar, and spices.
Ethical Decision Making Essay Research Paper Chapter
Ethical Decision Making Essay, Research Paper Chapter One Case Study Debbie Richardson is in her fourth year at Lamb Consulting and has recently been approached by Susan Gatewick, a project manager for Bob Hachet. Susan confided to
You Belong To Me By Mary Higgins
Clark Essay, Research Paper You Belong to Me is Mary Higgins Clark’s fifteenth novel. It is about a young clinical psychologist named Dr. Susan Chandler who hosts a radio talk show. One day the topic of the show is lonely women who disappear and who are later discovered dead. She brings up one specific case of a lady named Regina Clausen.
Friendship Essay Research Paper Honesty companionship and
Friendship Essay, Research Paper Honesty, companionship, and loyalty are the components that configure a true friend. First, honesty includes both persons remaining truthful, sincere, and frank to one another. If there is not a trust between two persons than it is impossible to maintain a friendship.
Susan Faludi Essay Research Paper Susan Faludi
Susan Faludi Essay, Research Paper Susan Faludi and Backlash I AM NOT A BARBIE DOLL. Before you even start reading, these capital letters catch your eye. To add more, she tells us it was held up by a little girl, which plays with our emotions.
Gender Essay Research Paper On July 19
Gender Essay, Research Paper On July 19, 1848, one of the most important conventions for womens’ rights was held in Seneca Falls, New York. This was the first convention of the kind ever held. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony were the main hosts. Their purpose was to convince the American citizens, men and women, of the inequality of women s current position in the American society.
Response To Vinegar Tom Essay Research Paper
The play Vinegar Tom was a very unusual play. Everything in the play was very different and weird. Some of the parts in the play were very vulgar and obscene. The plot of this play confronted many issues dealing with men and women. Although this play was set many years ago, many of those issues still are around even today.
Killing Mr Griffin Essay Research Paper Killing
Killing Mr. Griffin Essay, Research Paper Killing Mr. Griffin In the book Killing Mr. Griffin two of the students are involved are Susan and Betsy. I believe that Susan was a much stronger character of the two. I believe this because Susan seems to has a higher moral sense and doesn t need people to think she is cute and wonderful like Betsy does.
The Mayor Of Casterbridge Essay Research Paper
Both of the novels, The Mayor of Casterbridge and Jude, the Obscure, written by Thomas Hardy are full of hardships and broken hearts. Many of the characters are hurtful and in return hurt badly. Each of Hardy’s novels seem to portray an underlining feeling of aversion towards marriage. In each of his novels most of the marriages are unfulfilling and don’t work out.
An Analysis Of The MAyor Of Casterbridge
Essay, Research Paper The plot of The Mayor of Casterbridge, by Thomas Hardy, can often be confusing and difficult to follow. The pages of this novel are filled with sex, scandal, and alcohol, but
Annie Oakley Essay Research Paper On August13
Annie Oakley Essay, Research Paper On August,13 1860, Pheobe Ann Moses was born to Jacob and Susan Moses in their one room cabin in Patterson, Ohio. When Annie was around 6, her father contracted pnemonia while traveling the 18 miles home from town in a blizzard, and died in the spring of 1866. Afterward, Susan had trouble supporting the six childen.
Bioethics
— Prenatal Screening Essay, Research Paper Debates on Bioethics have been a central and key in society?s thoughts on new and involved medical science, as it conflicts with our own predetermined morals and value judgements. The more advanced our medicine becomes the more we must question, how much should we know about each other, as well as how much should we know about ourselves? The presented case, that of Susan M., provides an interesting look at the right of a parents knowledge of their child?s prenatal condition, as well as the doctor?s obligation to inform, also including the prenatal child?s rights, and the possibility of abortion.
Antony Analysis Essay Research Paper Antony Analysis
Antony Analysis Essay, Research Paper Antony Analysis Short Essay The beauty of William Shakespeare s writing does not lie in his actual writing, but the themes in which his plays suggest. Almost all of his plays can be connected to a higher theme, one that most people can relate. In the play, Antony and Cleopatra, the theme of manipulation runs ramped.
Portrait Of A Murderer My Last Duchess
Essay, Research Paper Susan FerrellJuly 29, 1998 Portrait of a MurdererAn Analysis of the Duke inRobert Browning s, My Last Duchess Robert Browning s poem, My Last Duchess is probably his most famous dramatic monologue and is an excellent example of this form of poetry (Landow). Dramatic monologue is a one-sided literary composition in which the speaker gradually reveals his character (Browning).
John Minnie And Petie A Love Triangle
Essay, Research Paper Karen Rayne Mrs. Wolf English 102.004 2 March 2001 John, Minnie, and Petie, A Love Triangle: Comedy and Tragedy in Susan Glaspell’s Trifles
The Old Man And The Sea An
Analysis Essay, Research Paper The Old Man and The Sea: An Analysis I read this book for the first time in high school and I remembered it just as well as if I had read it yesterday. As I read it again I remembered some of the
Susan Smith Essay Research Paper Susan SmithWhen
Susan Smith Essay, Research Paper Susan Smith When turning on the television, radio, or simply opening the local newspaper, one is mess with news of arrests, murders, homicides, serial killers, and other such tragedies. 1994 must be a great year to be alive if you are a criminal! Nobody takes liability for his or her own actions anymore.
Susan B Anthony Essay Research Paper Friends
Susan B. Anthony Essay, Research Paper Friends and fellow citizens: I stand before you tonight under the indictment for the alleged crime of having voted at the last presidential election without having a lawful right to vote. It shall be my work this evening to prove to you that in thus voting, I not only committed no crime, but, instead simply exercised my citizen s rights, guaranteed to me and all United States citizens by the National Constitution, beyond the power of any state to deny.
Elizabeth Cady Stanton And Susan B. Anthony
Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony Susan B. Anthony is the most well known name in women’s rights from the 1800s. Most people who are not familiar with the history of this time are aware of Susan’s reputation and nearly everyone of my generation has seen and held a Susan B. Anthony silver dollar.
Susan B Anthony Essay Research Paper Susan 2
Susan B. Anthony Essay, Research Paper Susan Brownell Anthony was a magnificent women who devoted most of her life to gain the right for women to vote. She traveled the United States by stage coach, wagon, and train giving many speeches, up to 75 to 100 a year, for 45 years. She went as far as writing a newspaper, the Revolution, and casting a ballot, despite it being illegal.
The Lion The Witch And The Wardrobe 2
The Lion, The Witch, And The Wardrobe: An Analysis Essay, Research Paper The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe: An Analysis The main characters in this story are Peter, Susan, Edmund, and
In Cold Blood By Truman Capote Essay
, Research Paper On In the book In Cold Blood, Truman Capote engages in an analysis of both the murderers and the people who surrounded the Clutter family. Capote goes through
The Mayor Of Casterbridge By Thomas Hardy
Essay, Research Paper As depicted in Thomas Hardy?s The Mayor of Casterbridge, man?s future lies in the hands of his past actions. The intelligent or ignorant decisions that man makes, places an immediate or long-term effect on the rest of man?s life. Occurring in the rustic town of Casterbridge, Michael Henchard, whose interactions with the people of Casterbridge lead to his demise, is only one of the people who decide their own destiny through there actions.
Killing Mr Essay Research Paper Killing Mr
Killing Mr Essay, Research Paper Killing Mr. Griffin I read the book Killing Mr. Griffin, by Lois Duncan. There was an English teacher, Mr. Griffin, which nobody liked. Especially one particular group of
Pornography Essay Research Paper Susan JacobyA First
Pornography Essay, Research Paper Susan Jacoby ?A First Amendment Junkie? Censoring pornography is wrong. Pornography should not be censored just be cause some people find it offensive. I cannot recall the last time someone made me look at a pornographic picture, or made me buy a pornographic magazine or movie.