Boot Camp Debate Essay, Research Paper
In any of today’s society no matter where you look there will be some evidence of crime present. This statement derives from a sociologist theory that says no society can exists without crime. The government is constantly looking for new ways to deal with these reoccurring problems. The focus has been placed upon the government to look into young offenders and the style used to punish them. Weapons possession is quite common among the youth, at least in urban Canada, between one-third and one quarter of students surveyed indicated that they had carried some form of weapon at school over the previous year. Data drawn from Statistics Canada has revealed that the number of reported incidents of violent crimes by males aged 12-17 have risen 64% and more than doubled for females during the decade beginning in 1989 and ending in 1999. A study conducted in Southern Ontario, exploring student perceptions of violence in schools, revealed significant levels of fear relating to possible victimisation. It is these more serious crimes involving young offenders that the government has been forced to deal with. Many suggestions have been made and many bills have been voted on but still no “sure fire” solution to the problem exists. The latest idea brewing in Parliament is the use of boot camps to punish young offenders; however others believe sending young offenders to boot camp is not the answer and there are more efficient ways to correct their negative behaviour.
The newest “brain-storm” that politicians have dwelled upon is sending young offenders that commit serious offences to boot camp. The first question that comes to mind is what is a boot camp? A boot camp is an alternative place to send youths between the ages of 12-17 who commit serious criminal offences. Boot camps have five basic goals: (1) incapacitation, (2) deterrence, (3) rehabilitation, (4) reduction of prison costs and crowding, and (5) punishment (Colledge & Gerber, 1998). These facilities are designed to resocialize the “bad-boys” and “bad-girls” into citizens that will be accepted back into society. The plan is to use a military style to punish the kids and in return teach them discipline and transform them back to law abiding citizens . “Punishment ranges from rigorous exercise – running extra laps around the barracks with a pack on, combinations of sit-ups, chin-ups and pushups – reduced meals or meals outdoors, and work detail, such as digging a whole alone outside for a week” (Simpson, 1996, p. A1). The government feels that with these military style boot camps the percentage of violent crimes by young offenders will begin to decrease.
On the other hand, there is another group of people who do not support the idea of installing a boot camp system into the criminal legislation. First of all the idea of boot camps was instituted in Britain. The results were not even close to what the British Government expected. There was barely even a change in the reduction of the percent of young offenders involved in violent crimes. This raises the thought of what will make the results in Canada any different from those found in Britain. The people against boot camps seem to be believers in the fact that jail and boot camps aren’t the best way to punish a young offender. “Instead, they said, there needs to be a stronger focus on discouraging conditions which lead to criminal behaviour through school and neighbourhood programs. And when a crime is committed by a 12-17 year old, there should be alternative punishments to jail” (Honywill, 1996, p. N1). The critics of boot camps also believe that to stop crime there has to be a lot more attention paid to prevention and nothing else. “Dr. Mark Sandford of McMaster University, said anti-social behaviour takes many years to develop and cannot be solved by quick solutions such as jail or the so-called boot camps, where young people are forced to do strenuous labour during a period of incarceration” (Honywill, 1996, p.2). The decision the critics have come to is boot camps are not the right way to go and there has to be other options open for the punishment of young offenders.
In relation to the alternatives for young offenders, places such as Custody Centers are an enhanced option to consider for the process of rehabilitating younger kids. “The Prince George Youth Custody Center is a secure facility providing a full range of programs to allow youths to make maximal constructive use of their time while in custody” (*members.pgonline/~pgycc/). The P.G.Y.C.C. is located in British Columbia and is responsible for the custody arrangements for all the interior regions. All youths that are admitted into this center are between the ages of 12 and 17. The residents are responsible for their chores, laundry and personal hygiene, and on weekends school is replaced by a variety of programs that emphasise upon special events involving outside community groups. The Center also has many programs that the youths are to take part in. Some examples of these programs are Teen Drug/Alcohol Awareness, Violence Prevention, Psychological Counselling, Arts and Crafts, and Recreation. The programs are designed to help the young offenders in the specific areas that the youths seem to be lacking in mental and physical development. Help of this extent is not available in jail or boot camps; therefor the teenagers will have a lot of one on one counselling and most likely will be properly rehabilitated. Overall the Prince George Youth Custody Center presents a much better atmosphere in order to correct behaviour and resocialize the young offenders back into the community once their time in custody is completed.
There are other alternatives for the rehabilitation of young offenders rather than shipping them off to prison or boot camps. The boot camps and prisons do not offer the youths the proper treatment needed to transform a person from a criminal back to a normal citizen of society. Places such as Custody Centers offer a more controlled and logical process of programs developed especially for the special kids sent to these places. It is believed that a program such as the P.G.Y.C.C. will ultimately be more effective in correcting the behaviour of young offenders and in conjunction lower the rate of youth crime around the country.
Colledge, D. and Gerbert, J. (1998, June). Rethinking the assumptions about boot camps.
Federal Probation, vol. 62, issue 1, p.54.
Honywill, B. (1996, Nov. 20). Boot camps not answer: panel: Must discourage
conditions leading to youth crime. The Hamilton Spectator, p. N1.
Simpson, L. (1996, Oct. 5). Academy targets troublesome teens: Military-style school
for boys costs $20,400 a year. The Hamilton Spectator, p. A1.
Prince George Youth Custody Center. [WWW document]. (n.d./ 2000, Mar. 22).
Available: *members.pgonline/~pgycc/
Другие работы по теме:
I Am Daivd Essay Research Paper I
I Am Daivd Essay, Research Paper I Am David is written by Anne Holm and is about a boy called David. David is a twelve year old boy who has spent his life in a concentration camp. One day a man from the camp helps him to escape. He is told that he must go north until he comes to Denmark. He doesn’t know what life is like outside the camp and is constantly scared in case he gets caught.
Anne Frank Essay Research Paper What do
Anne Frank Essay, Research Paper What do you know about Anne Frank? If you don?t know a lot about her I will help you. Anne Frank lived from 1929-1945. She was a young adult who kept an account of everything that went on from 1943-1945 when she was in hiding. Her diary was later published a year after her death, the name of the book was Diary of a Young Girl.
Story Tom Joad Essay Research Paper Tom
Story: Tom Joad Essay, Research Paper Tom Joad, strong and young man in his mid-twenties, was hitchhiking back to his home after being released on a parole. He spent four long years in a prison for killing a person. On his way back he met Casey, a former preacher who baptized Tom when he was kid. They had a little drink together and Tom invited him to walk with him to his house.
Haiti Orphange Essay Research Paper I do
Haiti Orphange Essay, Research Paper I do not like kids. So why I decided that I had a calling to go to an orphanage in Haiti to build a school, I still have not quite figured out. Children have always been a minor annoyance to me, with their constant chatter and energy. Often I have thought that had children in our society been taught better manners, perhaps they would not get me agitated so quickly.
Anwr Essay Research Paper This web article
Anwr Essay, Research Paper This web article written by Ian Christopher, from CNN is a great reason why Bush is out to diminish our natural areas. This article is titled; In Debate Preview, Candidates outline Competing Energy Policies. This is about the energy portion of the debate. Gore is for environmental preservation; therefore, I am on Gore s side of the argument.
Convo Essay Research Paper Can you believe
Convo Essay, Research Paper ?Can you believe that crazy girl Mom??, asked Brenda. ?Well she does love excitement and is willing to try anything like that.?, Explained her mom Bonnie.
Ivan Denisovich Essay Research Paper Imagine being
Ivan Denisovich Essay, Research Paper Imagine being captive in a concentration camp for over eight years. Ivan Denisovich Shukhov has experienced just this. In analyzing only one day of Ivan’s life in a concentration camp, he displays many traits that show that he is a hero. Hero, can be defined in many different ways.
The Lazarus Plot Essay Research Paper Me
The Lazarus Plot Essay, Research Paper Me and my brother Frank are decideing to take a well deserved vacation to the north maine mountians when we got there frank stayed at the camp site setting up camp while i went for a walk through the woods but then to my surprise i saw my girlfriend which was supposed to have died when some terrorist had dropped a bomb on her car i tryed to run ‘owards her but she ran back into the woods so i went back to camp and explained the situation to Frank even though Frank didnt beleive me he went with me into the woods that i had last seen my girlfreind Iola as we went deeper into the woods we were suddenly shot at and were just able to hide behind a tree to escape the bullets after the shooting was over we decided to continue after the people who had fired at us when we caught up with them they were standing around so we jumped into action and made the
Holes Essay Research Paper HolesThe book Holes
Holes Essay, Research Paper Holes The book Holes is about kids that do bad things and they get send to a detention center, Camp Green Lake. Camp Green Lake was once a very large lake, the largest lake in Texas. That was over a hundred years ago. Now it?s just a flat dry land. During the summer the temperature hovers around ninety-five degrees.
Treatment Of The Prisoners In The Concentration
Camps Essay, Research Paper Interdisciplinary Research Research Proposal The Treatment of the Prisoners in the Concentration Camps The topic that I plan to focus on in my research paper is treatment inside different concentration camps during the Holocaust. I plan to focus on three different camps, but I have not narrowed down my choices yet.
Boot Camps Essay Research Paper Boot CampsThe
Boot Camps Essay, Research Paper Boot Camps The history and explanation of how these institutions are operated The increase in violent behavior amongst America’s youth has prompted the implementation of more effective rehabilitation methods. With the percentage of non-violent offenders on the rise, prison incarceration or juvenile detention doesn’t seem to be the right solution for rehabilitation.
Boot Camp Essay Research Paper The rain
Boot Camp Essay, Research Paper The rain was constantly hitting us in our faces, our cold, wet, squinty faces couldn?t take it anymore. Our minds ready to quit and any moment, moans and grunts in the
Boot Camp Incarceration Essay Research Paper With
Boot Camp Incarceration Essay, Research Paper With the ever rising prison population in this country, something has to be done rehabilitate criminals rather than just lock them up. Many feel that the “new” prisons, boot camps are the answer (Champion 1990). I will give a brief overview of boot camp institutions, specifically, about the operation and structure of these, the cost involved with both juvenile and adult facilities, and how effective they really are with regard to recidivism.
Debate Essay Research Paper residential Debates are
Debate Essay, Research Paper residential Debates are a very important part of the electoral process in the United States. These debates help the people of the country understand where each candidate stands on several current issues that the United States faces, as well as to show the people what they plan on doing while in office.
Aushwitz Essay Research Paper AUSCHWITZBY CHRISTOPHER JAMES
Aushwitz Essay, Research Paper AUSCHWITZ CHRISTOPHER JAMES The Nazis establishes Auschwitz in April 1940, under the orders of Heinrich Himmler. Heinrich Himmler was in charge of two Nazi organizations. The camp at Auschwitz originally housed political prisoners from occupied Poland and various concentration camps from within Germany.
Rotc Essay Research Paper Being a cadet
Rotc Essay, Research Paper Being a cadet in Campbell Battalion has been a very rewarding experience but there are a few things that I would change. I think that the first thing I would do is to devise a more calibrated evaluation system like an ARTEP style system. We would still do blue cards but this would help evaluators in the evaluating process as well as give cadets a standard for training.
Roaring Camp Essay Research Paper The Regeneration
Roaring Camp Essay, Research Paper The Regeneration of Roaring Camp And so the work of regeneration began is Roaring Camp (9). The regeneration referred to takes place in a California mining camp in 1850 after
Journey To Topaz Essay Research Paper JOURNEY
Journey To Topaz Essay, Research Paper JOURNEY TO TOPAZ This book, A Journey to Topaz, involves an eleven year old girl named Yuki Chan who lives in California. Up until this point she was a perfectly happy girl and had many friends. But then, one day, Japan bombed America and all of the Japanese were taken to camps, including Yuki.
Network Debate Essay Research Paper It was
Network Debate Essay, Research Paper It was a brutal race. They interrupted our daily scheduled shows with boisterous promises they could never fulfill. They invaded our towns and cities with their advertisements; their faces defaced our buses and benches. And still, no one has emerged as the clean victor.
Abortion Essay Research Paper wwwpottersschoolcomabortionIs it right
Abortion Essay, Research Paper www.pottersschool/abortion/ Is it right or is it wrong? Is it murder or is it a woman’s choice. There are so many conflicting views, but who is right? The debate over abortion will probably never be settled in my life time. As with many computer literate people, the author of this site gives us an objective view on abortion.
Auschwitz Essay Research Paper AuschwitzAuschwitz was not
Auschwitz Essay, Research Paper Auschwitz Auschwitz was not one but three different concentration and execution camps. Each camp had it own purpose. The first camp was called Auschwitz I. It was mainly used as a central camp for Nazi officers, producing economic and military-industrial enterprise, and holding enemies of the Nazis.
Night Essay Research Paper Faster you swine
Night Essay, Research Paper Faster, you swine, you filthy sons of bitches (81). This is an example of the physiological abuse and verbal abuse that the S.S. officers had towards the Jews. In the book Night, by Elie Wiesel, the theme of prejudice and inhumanity was strongly revealed. I learned from this book how the physical conditions of the camp Buna was: and how the S.S. officers were verbally and psychologically abusive towards the Jews.
Speaker
#3 Essay, Research Paper He was born on Essen of Germany. He was an ordinary citizen of Germany. The keyword to this essay is that word “was.” After the NAZI came into power, he was treated as an “inferior race.” He did not beat anyone up or abuse anyone. So, why was he being treated badly? He was a Jewish person in a new era.
Napster Debate Essay Research Paper Napster DebateFor
Napster Debate Essay, Research Paper Napster Debate For a project in college eighteen-year old Shawn Fanning wrote a program for a way to download music off the internet. He later put the program on the internet and Napster was born. Napster is a program that allows you to download music on the internet. Since this program is free, many people have downloaded Napster.
Black Feminists Debate Essay Research Paper Black
Black Feminists Debate Essay, Research Paper Black Feminists Debate Whiteness Stephanie Philipovich & Angela Torchia Passage #1: “Here is the house. It is green and white. It has a red door. It is very pretty. Here is the family. Mother, Father, Dick, and Jane live in the green-and-white house. They are very happy.
Debates 2000 Essay Research Paper The Third
Debates 2000 Essay, Research Paper The Third Debate The third Presidential Debate was between Vice President Al Gore and Gov. George W. Bush. The debate was in the format of a Town Hall debate. Both Vice President Al Gore and Gov. Bush performed well. An audience member asked the candidates a question and given two minutes to answer the question set forth.
The Devolution Of Paul Baumer Essay Research
Paper The Devolution of Paul Baumer Paul Baumer changed dramatically throughout the course of the book, All Quiet on the Western Front. Paul went from an able-bodied, spirited young man in the prime of his life, to an atavistic, instinctive man, doomed to be haunted by his experience of war. Paul quickly learned the irrelevance of his 10-year education from school in comparison to his short 10-week education from boot camp.
A Scary Story Essay Research Paper The
A Scary Story Essay, Research Paper The Lakeside Ghost Story My stomach was churning as the big bold letters came into view. They read, Camp Lakeside. The bus came to a sudden stop and a counselor at the front of the bus
The Report Essay Research Paper Each night
The Report Essay, Research Paper Each night a female half wolf half dog would seduce a dog away and allow the pack to kill him. This killing of the dogs lasted until there were 3 dogs remaining. One man tried to save a 4th dog that was being killed by the wolves and ended up getting killed also. From then on the wolves closed in on the camp of the remaining man and 2 dogs.
Rhabilitating Juvenile Offenders Essay Research Paper Rehabilitating
Rhabilitating Juvenile Offenders Essay, Research Paper Rehabilitating Juvenile Offenders America has a problem with juvenile offenders. Yes, it would be easy to lock them up but that costs too much and does little to rehabilitate the juvenile. If detention homes were a deterrent, then crime levels committed by juveniles wouldn?t be so high.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My view on
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My view on the abortion is pro-choice so I will debate the issue from the pro-life point of view. Abortion is in a word: murder. There is no way around it , people that have abortions are committing a crime. If one was killing a person who could defend themselves they would go to jail but the people who have abortions just get continue on with their sinful lives.