Shrews? Essay, Research Paper
Shakespearian submission: Women as wives, mothers and SHREWS?
Lisa Fails
December 1, 2000
Shakespearian submission: Women as wives, mothers and SHREWS?
Mary Beth Rose has given incredible insights on some of the most important concepts within the works of William Shakespeare. “Where are the Mothers in Shakespeare?” is not only a question, also an issue that will be bravely dealt with by newcomers of mainstream feminism as well as those historians who look to the past to discover the faults and misrepresentations of sexuality and gender construction in the Elizabethan Era and those to follow.[1]
Juliet Dusinberre, another notable author, shows that “The Taming of the Shrew (TOTS)” was merely another production put on by William Shakespeare so that he could show images of power in the male world throughout the roles of Pertuchio, Baptista and Lucentio. Through the female character representation by males upon the stage, Dusinberre argues that “Women in the theatre audience may return to the subservient lives of women in Elizabethan social structures, but they too have [finally] been allowed within the theatre, the fantasy of different kinds of power, which link’s them in sympathy with the boy himself as he represents women on stage.”[2]
In Dusinberre’s “The Taming of the Shrew: Women, Acting and Power” she begins to address how Shakespeare’s female roles were played as men. By showing that TOTS, is the most significant of all plays, she reveals to the readers that although Shakespeare will not be presumed a “She-hater,” he did indeed play by the rules of the patriarchal society in which he lived. If women were to play the parts named for them, would this [freedom] given to them cause the modern jealousies of females being the breadwinners, or in this particular business, the female/wife/mother being the popular actress in the household as oppose to the man?
In the opening of this play, the first female role is that of the Hostess. She is one of the few females that will appear in Shakespeare’s works who holds power. She is an innkeeper, with a trade and because of her apprentice status, she as access to authority over Christopher Sly. Her character is still a female. She has thrown Sly out of the bar because of his drunken ways, but she still must call onto the Lord to “help” her out.
Reviewing Shakespeare’s complete works, notice that throughout all of his six remarkable romances, including TOTS, there are no mothers around. Most of Shakespeare’s mothers and wives are portrayed imperfectly. In the eyes of a young child, preferably a female, a mother is next to perfection. She is supposed to be subservient to the husband, while raising the perfect daughter (IF she has already given birth to the next male who will indeed heir after the death of his father, whom she will still be subservient too).
If a mother’s love is what holds families together, why aren’t there any acceptable ones present in Shakespeare’s writings? Looking at those who are present like Lady Macbeth (in Macbeth), the love driven Gertrude (in Hamlet) and the dreaded Tamora in Titus Androcicus, why are they represented in such filthy manners? Why must Gertrude sleep with her brother-in-law and not care as to how she would be looked upon, especially by her own son. Lady Macbeth’s character is far more shrewish then that of Kate in TOTS. Lady Macbeth plots to kill, just to have power. Lady Macbeth is portrayed as a wicked woman, who obviously in Shakespeare’s eyes, represents a woman who is given too much power.
Rose also notes that, on behalf of Shakespeare, women during Renaissance England, might not have been portrayed, due to the realities of having a deceased mother. Because of the risks associated with childbirth, one out of four women would die in the first fifteen years of marriage. Rose believes this data to be inadequate now that new demographic finding are more complete and consistent proving stronger evidence that mothers were important, present and should be represented. [3]
The history of this role given society, has a back bone credited too the many (significantly male) writers of the numerous “Books of Advice on Marriage” or simply known as the “Conduct Books.”[4] These books outline what a marriage should be like. They set out clearly the roles of a husband and wife, and harshly criticized those who did not conform to this prescribed ideal. Around the sixteenth centuries, these “books of advice” were infrequent and their very existence could be sought as insignificant, but because they are fairly numerous, and were published and republished constantly in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, they must be considered reputable.
When looking at these ‘conduct books’, two fundamental questions arise. First, do they actually reflect relationships between husbands and wives during this period, or do they merely represent an ideal, an ideal that was strived for, but never successful in obtaining?
In TOTS, Katherine’s character gives a first impression as an unruly woman, who obviously is in need of a man in her life to “tame her.” A shrew is, a difficult or gossipy wife, bad-tempered and scolding, who resists or under mind’s the assumed authority of the husband within a marriage. [5] Kate’s character is split. First, as the shrew she is out spoken and not molded into societal roles. Then at the end, Kate is finally free from her evil spirit, and able to conform to the everyday life as a wife by submitting to her husband.
Why would Shakespeare change her? Why couldn’t she be the outspoken wife, who could one day be a good mother/wife, while maintaining her persona as a mellow shrew? According to Shakespeare and others, a disobedient wife was not only a threat to a man’s peace of mind, but to his reputation. However, this situation goes both ways. A man was nothing if his wife was undisciplined and unrespectable, and it reflected badly on the “shrew” if her husband and family were neglected. [6]
In the Induction, Dusinberre points out the portrayal of how a woman should treat her husband. Although this marriage is solely based on lies, once Christopher Sly begins to think that he is indeed a lord, a Lady is “given” to him. She says unto him:
“My husband and my lord, my lord and my husband I am your wife in all obedience.”
Dusinberre’s point continues as the male (Sly) begins to be more comfortable with his role as husband or head of the household. He tells the Lady that he seems to have slept for fifteen years, the Lady replies:
“Ay, and the time seems thirty unto me, being all this time abandoned from your bed.”
Now a full grown misogynistic, Sly says:
“Tis much. Servants, leave me and her alone. Madam, undress you and come now to bed.”[7]
Shakespeare shows in the above passages that as long as a wife acknowledged her inferiority, and behaved always in a way that befitted her status and role as wife and mother, then she could do whatever she liked. The married world the writers were advocating was not an arbitrary one, even if it would seem so by modern standards, as the emphasis was always on companionship, the need for love and affection, and the sharing of domestically duties.
This play raises a few concerns about Shakespeare’s childhood. Did he and his mother have a good relationship? Was he once hurt by a woman, or was it because of his wife’s age difference that he began too see the difference in how a woman should act. Could he have had problems with his wife, and referred to one of the many “Books of advice on Marriage” and then began his writings on the “The Taming of the Shrew?”
Rose and Dusinberre have given much insight to the patriarchal roles in Shakespeare’s society. They’ve shown how mothers and wives have been throughout these years, represented wrongly and without justice. Kate was a shrew, but she changed her ways and began to submit. Not all women will be that way and during Shakespeare’s Era, women probably weren’t.
684
[1] M.B. Rose. “Where are the Mothers in Shakespeare? Options for Gender Representation in the English Renaissance.” Shakespeare Quarterly 42 (1991) 291-314.
[2] J. Dusinberre. “The Taming of the Shrew: Women, Acting and Power. Studies in the Literary Imagination 26 (1993): 67-84.
[3] P. Laslett. The World we have Lost. (1983) London: Methuen, 18, 102.
[4] R. Houlbrooke (ed.), English Family Life (Oxford, 1988).
[5] C. Camden, The Elizabethan Woman (New York, 1975) M. Prior (ed.) and Women in English Society 1500-1800 (London, 1986).
[6] Lady Payton in L. Pollock, Ibid. p.247. (London, 1982).
[7] W. Shakespeare. The Taming of the Shrew. Induction. Scene II lines 107-116.
Другие работы по теме:
Rebuttal Susan Essay Research Paper RebuttalSusan she
Rebuttal Susan Essay, Research Paper Rebuttal Susan: she is trained and it would be a disgrace for her not to work. Rebuttal: It has been observed that most girls at highschool are not really concerned about their studies and they just play around. They are filled with ideas of some man coming up to them as long as they are beautiful.
Northern Virginia Alumnae Club Essay Research Paper
The Northern Virginia Alumnae Club has been selected as the Ideal Club among all of the Pi Beta Phi alumnae clubs for the past two years. Our group is comprised of women of all ages and interests. We have a diverse membership that includes recent graduates, professional women, full time mothers, homemakers, and retirees.
Things Fall Apart Essay Essay Research Paper
Things Fall Apart Essay Throughout many years women have always been inferior to men in all cultures and places. Maybe it’s because men are physically stronger than women and have always had the ability to control them that way. There are also sayings that men a more intelligent than women but that is an arguable statement.
The Shakesperian Blonde Essay Research Paper What
The Shakesperian Blonde Essay, Research Paper What does William Shakespeare have to say about women? Quite a bit, actually. But his writing of the character Gertrude in his play Hamlet can be clearly seen to tie in with one viewpoint of women: the weaker-sex. To be fair, it must be said that he presents both sides of the issue, but let Gertrude be the focus of this study.
Things Fall Apart Role Of Women In
The Ibo Culture Essay, Research Paper The Role of Women in the Ibo Culture The culture in which ‘’Things Fall Apart’’ is centered around is one where patriarchal testosterone is supreme and
Feminine Mystique Essay Research Paper The Feminine
Feminine Mystique Essay, Research Paper The Feminine Mystique The first couple of chapters of The Feminine Mystique basically points out that there was a major problem that was plaguing America’s female population during the 1950’s. The main idea behind this problem was that women were raised to basically become housewives.
Women In History Essay Research Paper Equality
Women In History Essay, Research Paper Equality has been a controversial issue ever since time began. Whether it be race, sex, or religion, it has always been an unsettled topic of concern. Equality between men and
Abuse Essay Research Paper Spousal assault is
Abuse Essay, Research Paper Spousal assault is either the male or the female of the relationship who is being beaten up very brutally by their partner, such as a marriage. In most violent marriages the women in most
The Relevancy Of The Title Of The
Crucible Essay, Research Paper This play is named The Crucible, which means a severe test or trial, because the accused, the families, and the girls are being put through a great ordeal.
The Equality Of Women In ChaucerS Wife
Of Bath Essay, Research Paper The Equality of Women in Chaucer?s Wife of Bath There have been many different interpretations of what Geoffrey Chaucer stood for, but
A Doll HouseMidterm Essay Research Paper A
A Doll House(Midterm) Essay, Research Paper A Doll House I believe that when the Doll House was written, the power within relationships was not equal. The women had no say in what they did. They had to take orders from the male figure. They were house wives. In the Doll House, Nora Helmer was ahead of her time. She did stuff that she shouldn t have done.
The Changing World Of Women Essay Research
Paper The Changing World of Women As a daughter living in a strict environment and living in a traditional ways, things get a little rough. My father is center of the household, so basically
Islam Essay Research Paper Human Images of
Islam Essay, Research Paper Human Images of World Religion Islam Islam means submission, that is, submission to the will of god, the characteristic attitude of members of our faith.
Islam Essay Research Paper Islam
Islam Essay, Research Paper Islam Islam, which in Arabic means submission to God or Allah is the youngest religion of the world. It is a monotheistic religion and one of the Abrahamic
Womens Rights Essay Research Paper Women rightsThroughout
Womens Rights Essay, Research Paper Women rights Throughout history of Western civilization, deep-seated cultural beliefs allowed women only limited roles in society. Many people believed that women’s natural roles were as mothers and wives. These people considered women to be better suited for childbearing and homemaking rather than for involvement in the public life of business or politics.
The Joy Luck Club 2
The Joy Luck Club – Culture Differences Essay, Research Paper The Joy Luck Club, a novel by Amy Tan, is a compilation from eight different women and their lives. The stories are based on their Chinese culture and their mother/daughter relationships. In the novel and in the film production, the women go through many obstacles in life and must overcome them in order to survive.
Things Fall Apart 5 Essay Research Paper
Polygamy in Things Fall Apart It is obvious that in reading Things Fall Apart that polygamy was alive and well in the village of Umuofia. Not only was it accepted it was expected.
My Husbands Nine Wives By Elizabeth Joseph
Essay, Research Paper ?My Husband?s Nine Wives,? an essay written by Elizabeth Joseph, effectively describes a woman?s life made easier due to the principle of polygamy. Polygamy, otherwise known as plural marriage, remains illegal in the United States today; however, it is possible that polygamy go undetected by law because of a marrying couple?s intentional negligence to obtain proper certificates or licenses.
The Joy Luck Club 4 Essay Research
Paper The Joy Luck Club The Joy luck club was a book written by Amy Tan. The story is set here in America and in China and is set in the 1940 s and also takes place now. The book is about four Asian women who fled china and their Americanized daughters.
How Women Are Portrayed In Homer
’s Odyssey Essay, Research Paper Women Portrayed in Homer s The Odyssey Women were very important to the Greeks, and they showed this value in many ways. In The Odyssey Homer shows us the different ways women were looked upon through female characters, such as Penelope, Naussica, and Anticlia.
Single Mothers Living Below The Poverty Line
Essay, Research Paper The perspective I have chosen is the social-conflict theory. The social-conflict paradigm is a framework for building theory that envisions society as an arena of inequality generating conflict and social change. This type of analysis focuses on the inequalities within our society and the conflict that they cause between the advantaged and the disadvantaged.
Wife Of Bath From The Canterbury Tales
Essay, Research Paper The most obtentatious of the travlers, the Wife of Bath has been married five times and is currently searching for another man to marry. The Wife of BAth is opinionated and boisterous, and her tale which centers around the question “what do women want?,” promotes her view that women wish to have autority over men.
Domestic Violence And Marriage Essay Research Paper
Marriage and Domestic Violence Family violence has existed since the conception of the family unit. Women for hundreds of years were viewed as less than human, property, in place to serve at the pleasure of their husband. Woman who grew up in homes where their mothers were beaten or hit accepted it as their role as wife and most often married men who also abused them.
We Are Our Mothers Daughters
’ Essay, Research Paper Book Review We Are Our Mothers? Daughters News correspondent Cokie Roberts, author of a meaningful book titled We are Our Mothers? Daughters, published in 1998, call number 001-170, discusses significant
Review Of Good Wives Essay Research Paper
Review of Good Wives Today, women are an intricate part of our working society. There are more women holding full-time jobs than ever before. A women’s role is just not in the house; it extends far beyond into the working world where women are even holding positions such as chief executive officers of Fortune 500 Companies.
Gender Stereotype Essay Research Paper According to
Gender Stereotype Essay, Research Paper According to the writers in chapter, “Gender Stereotyping And the Media”, gender stereotypes are harmful to men and women. Gender stereotypes set impossible standards for men and women that lead to unhappiness, loneliness and possibly violence towards themselves.
Julius Caesars Women Essay Research Paper Portia
Julius Caesar`s Women Essay, Research Paper Portia and Calpurnia are the two main women in the story of Julius Caesar. They had two totally different parts in the story. One was kind of a servant wife and
Women In Ancient Greek Society Essay Research
Paper Women in Ancient Greek Society Homer and Greek society were strongly machista. The Odyssey presents stories in which men were heroes, won wars and governed countries while females were in second plan and didn t play any expressive role in society. Women were always servants of the men throughout the poem; their existence was based on serving the men in the book.
Koran And Women Essay Research Paper The
Koran And Women Essay, Research Paper The Koran’s Attitude Towards Women The Koran is a book following the religion of the Muslim people. In it, many aspects of their ways of life and their attitudes towards different people are addressed. It mentions the strong feelings of the true believers towards Jews and Christians, however it gives a view of women that is taken two ways.
Women In Buddhism Essay Research Paper
“The men may have started this war, but the women are running it.” In the beginning of the war, around 1941, most American women lived as their mothers previously had. Women were supposed to have jobs just until they were married and those who did work after they were married or were mothers were regarded with a sense of pity and scorn from society.
Women S Liberation Essay Research Paper Women
Women S Liberation Essay, Research Paper Women continually drive for more freedom and consequently have acquired more freedom. In the last thirty years women have made incredible progress. In many instances, women still feel inferior to men as a result of how some men choose to treat the weaker sex. How should men treat women? What causes inferiority for women? Are men and women equal?