Utilitarianism Essay, Research Paper
John Stuart Mill suggests that a person?s ethical decision-making process
should be based solely upon the amount of happiness that the person can receive.
Although Mill fully justifies himself, his approach lacks certain criteria for
which happiness can be considered. Happiness should be judged, not only by
pleasure, but by pain as well. This paper will examine Mill?s position on
happiness, and the reasoning behind it. Showing where there are agreements and
where there are disagreements will critique the theory of Utilitarianism. By
showing the problems that the theory have will reveal what should make up
ethical decision-making. John Stuart Mill supports and explains his reasoning in
his book, Utilitarianism. Mill illustrates the guidelines of his theory. Mill
defines utilitarianism as the quest for happiness. His main point is that one
should guide his or her judgements by what will give pleasure. Mill believes
that a person should always seek to gain pleasure and reject pain.
Utilitarianism also states that the actions of a person should be based upon the
?greatest happiness principle?. This principle states that ethical actions
command the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people. Mill
further explores the need for pleasure by noting ?a being of higher faculties
requires more to make him happy.? . He acknowledges that some pleasures are
more alluring than others are. He adds to this by making known that when placing
value in things to calculate pleasure, not only quantity important but quality
as well. Mill?s criteria for happiness is easily understood, some statements
that he gives are questionable. John Stuart Mill plainly laid out what he
believes that the basis for ethical decision-making. First, the pursuit of
pleasure is directly related to happiness. This idea can be easily accepted. It
is natural for a person to focus his goals on things that will bring him
pleasure. It would be absurd if someone?s goal in life was to be poor and
starving. This being said, it does not mean that people are only happy due
wealth but that no one?s goals are focused on poverty. Although there are many
issues that can be agreeable with Mill, there are problems that exist with his
theory of utilitarianism. First, Mill says that all ethical decisions should be
based on pleasure. This statement becomes questionable when Mill states that
pleasure is the sole requirement for happiness. Pain indirectly effects
happiness. Pain is an indirect factor because is not the object of one?s
happiness, but is an obstacle which one must overcome to gain it. If one is to
avoid all pain in his or her life, then how will that person truly know what
true pleasure feels like? True pleasure comes only after experiencing pain. If a
person always wins a race, does he or she feel true pleasure each time they win
or does it turn into a feeling that they come to expect? If there is a person
who loses races constantly, will his happiness be greater when he finally wins?
The rewards and pleasures of the second person would greatly outweigh the
feelings of happiness the first had because he or she knows how it feels to be
defeated. The second person knows the pain that is received because of failure
so when he when he will recognize the joy and pleasure that comes with winning.
Using this same setting, would it be better for the second person to run in
races filled with people who are not matched in skill just so he may always win
or should he or she race individuals who are equally matched? Although the first
would produce pleasure, the second example would yield the greater amount of
pleasure due to the understanding that the competition was evenly matched. Both
of these examples show that pain can ultimately cause pleasure, and in some
cases the presence of pain will increase the feeling of happiness. Another point
were there is disagreement is when Mill justifies the pursuit of pleasure by
saying ?actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness;
wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness.? This statement is not
universally true. People have different perspectives, what is pleasure for one
could be pain for another. Who is right and is wrong? A problem evolves because
there is no set definition pertaining to what is pleasurable therefore right and
painful therefore wrong. The final disagreement with Utilitarian states that if
someone saves a person who is drowning, the rescuer did what is morally right
even if his intentions were wrong. This is difficult to understand. If the
rescuer saved the person, only to make the person die of a greater pain ; Mill
still believes the rescuer to be morally right. Intentions should be very
important when it concerns morality. The difficulty in deciding if the
person?s intentions are moral is that there is no way to know for sure. The
fact that there is no way to positively tell, the person committing the act
does. For believers of God and Jesus Christ, it is a sin to have impure
thoughts. According to Mill, the impure thoughts don?t become a sin until
someone else knows about them. Whether the act is told to someone or it is kept
a secret, it is still a sin. No matter how many other people think you are
morally right, if you know in your heart that you are wrong, then there is no
way that you can be moral. Although Mill has made good points, he did not
accurately describe the criteria for happiness. Ethical thinking should not be
based solely on pleasure. It is true that pleasure is important to happiness,
but one must deal with pain and misery to be truly happy. Good and bad
constantly affect each other but, the relationship between the two are polar
opposites. This statement holds true no matter what one believes. To find
happiness, the opposing sides must find a suitable balance. This does not mean
that pain is always a daily part of life, but that it can not and should not be
avoided. If one were to try to avoid pain, it is quite possible that they would
inadvertently pass up pleasure. This would happen because a person would be too
worried to take a chance on failing. Pain is a part of life just as pleasure is.
To reap the benefits of one, there must be consequences given to the other.
There is a quote that goes, ?You must drink from the chalice of pain, before
you can sip from the elixir of self-respect? Another criteria for happiness
and morality should be based upon attentions. If one performs a moral action,
but has immoral intentions, that person should not be considered ethically
correct. To be truly right and happy, one must not only act but think right.
Mill suggests that pleasure should guide our decision-making. While the
statement is true, it is not fully correct. If a person will deal with pain that
come from hard work, dedication, and perseverance, then the benefits will be
that much sweeter.
Другие работы по теме:
MILLS UTILITARIANISM Essay Research Paper In discussing
MILL?S UTILITARIANISM Essay, Research Paper In discussing matters of right and wrong, it is essential to first lay down the foundation of these concepts. These terms are indeed concepts because they hold no certain truth to the general society. True, righteousness may be a measurement of happiness, lack of pain, or a circumstantial mode of contentment, however, if you consider one persons? happiness to be another persons? pain, then what is the true measurement of right? We see that there are actually two distinct aspects to this question, a practical concern and a moral dilemma.
Paternalisic Laws Essay Research Paper The Seatbelt
Paternalisic Laws Essay, Research Paper The Seatbelt Law A paternalistic law is an interference with a person s liberty for that person s own good. An example of a paternalistic law is the law that says: all people must were seatbelts when riding in the front seat of a car. According to John Stuart Mill in his essay On Liberty a problem occurs when the government enforces paternalism.
Utiliatariasm And Its Authors Essay Research Paper
Utilitarianism is the principle idea for the greatest happiness for the greatest numbers. In other words, maximize the pleasure while minimizing the pain. One such philosopher and believer of Utilitarianism is Jeremy Bentham, who lived from 1748 until 1832. He believed that there should be a moral system, and that it should do two things.
Blackmail Essay Research Paper Critical Philosophy PaperFMS
Blackmail Essay, Research Paper Critical Philosophy Paper FMS 106 Tom Ellis I will be discussing John Stuart Mill’s views on paternalism. I will argue how I feel about the subject. Then I will try my best to put myself into Mill’s shoes, argue back and try to see if I can understand where he is coming from with his arguments on paternalism.
My Delima Essay Research Paper People go
My Delima Essay, Research Paper People go through many dilemmas during a lifetime. Many of them require a rational decision to steer them down the right path. During childhood kids do many things that they think are right, but have no idea how wrong they are. You have to learn from your mistakes so later on in life you won?t make those mistakes.
Why Has JS Mill
ґs Version Of Utilitarianism Proved To Be More Acceptable Than Benthamґ Essay, Research Paper Utilitarianism began life as an ethical principle under Jeremy Bentham who theorised that an action if right if it produces the greatest good for the greatest number of people. In its original form the argument had many flaws so John Stuart Mill decided to defend the principle of Utility against itґs critics by refining itґs ideas making them more practical in society.
Js Mill Essay Research Paper The principle
Js Mill Essay, Research Paper The principle of utility is that pleasure and happiness are valuable, pain and suffering are disvaluable, and anything else only causes the happiness or adds to the suffering. A utilitarian is someone who believes the principle of utility to be correct, and is therefore concerned with maximizing the utility of the universe.
Hedonism Essay Research Paper HedonismWebster
Hedonism Essay, Research Paper Hedonism Webster’s dictionary defines hedonism as “the ethical doctrine that pleasure, variously conceived of in terms of happiness of the individual or of society,
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Defining Theor Y Behind J S Mill
’s “On Liberty” Essay, Research Paper After suffering a severe bout of depression during his twenties, John Stuart Mill found himself modifying the views he had learned from his father. Conceiving mentally his own opinions to supply valuable insights from authors with whom he sometimes had the most complex disagreements.
Mill Essay Research Paper John Stuart Mill
Mill Essay, Research Paper John Stuart Mill on Proportional Representation Two very different ideas are usually confounded under the name democracy. The pure idea of democracy, according to its definition, is the government of the whole people by the whole people, equally represented. Democracy as commonly conceived and hitherto practiced, is the government of the whole people by a mere majority of the people, exclusively represented.
Ethics Risk Taking Essay Research Paper The
Ethics Risk Taking Essay, Research Paper The paper is about risk taking and self-command. It was written for a philosophy class in ethics. The title of the paper is “Risk Taking”. It recieved 95 points out of a
Victorian Literature Essay Research Paper Victorian literatureThe
Victorian Literature Essay, Research Paper Victorian literature The first decades (1830s to 1860s) of Queen Victoria’s reign produced a vigorous and varied body of literature that attempted to come to terms with the current transformations of English society, but writers in the latter decades (1870s to 1900) withdrew into AESTHETICISM, a preoccupation with sensation as an end in itself.
Utility An Impartial And Equitable Standpoint Essay
, Research Paper Utility: An Impartial and Equitable Standpoint Mackey- Philosophy 318 Section Wednesday 12:00- 1:00 Tu Phan Phliosophy 318- Mackey The foundation of Utility is based on John Stuart Mill’s notion that one must strive to act in such a way to produce the greatest good of the greatest number.
John Stuart Mill Essay Research Paper John
John Stuart Mill Essay, Research Paper John Stuart Mill 1806-1873 John had a teleological view of ethics. He is also known as the 1st advocate for women. Lived during the time of the Industrial Revolution. Born to a rich man, he was the youngest, Mr. Mill retired after having John and deticated his life to making John a genius.
Feminist Movement Essay Research Paper It was
Feminist Movement Essay, Research Paper It was in the mid-1800s when the first signs of the feminist movement came about. In 1861, a man named John Stuart Mill wrote The Subjection of Women, which
Kant And Mill Essay Research Paper Kant
Kant And Mill Essay, Research Paper Kant: Universal Law Formation of the Categorical Imperative Mill: Utilitarianism Immanuel Kant?s philosophy frames the Universal Law Formation of the Categorical Imperative as a procedure for determining morality of actions. This method contains two vital components.
Mill Vs Kant Essay Research Paper SummaryImmanuel
Mill Vs. Kant Essay, Research Paper Summary Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill are philosophers who addressed the issues of morality in terms of how moral traditions are formed. Immanuel Kant has presented one viewpoint in The Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals that is founded on his belief that the worth of man is inherent in his ability to reason.
Mill
’s Utilitarianism Essay, Research Paper “Utilitarianism” is the ethical doctrine, which essentially states that which is good is that which brings about the most happiness to the most people. John Stuart Mill believed that the decisions we make should always benefit the most people as much as possible regardless of the consequences to the minority or even yourself.
John Stuart Mill Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper
JOHN STUART MILL S UTILITARIANISM Along with other noted philosophers, John Stuart Mill developed the nineteenth century philosophy known as Utilitarianism – the contention that man should judge everything in life based upon its ability to promote the greatest individual happiness. While Bentham, in particular, is acknowledged as the philosophy s founder, it was Mill who justified the axiom through reason.
Utilitarianism Mill Essay Research Paper In Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism Mill Essay, Research Paper In Utilitarianism, J.S. Mill was trying to show that “actions and institutions should increase the overall amount of happiness in the world” , and stressed the importance of utilitarianism as the first principle in ethics, to which any ambiguities with second principles such as ‘do not kill’ may appeal.
Untitled Essay Research Paper As John Stuart
Untitled Essay, Research Paper As John Stuart Mills, I believe that my philosophy on government will satisfy the needs of the society. Throughout the 1880?s people have revolted under the circumstances that the government is focused on the society and the individual. My system focuses on liberty, meaning the rights and principles of the individual of a society.
Basics On Keats Essay Research Paper John
Basics On Keats Essay, Research Paper -John Keats was born in 1795 and died in 1821 -John Keats was born in Moorfield, England -John Keats had two brothers, George and Tom, and a sister Fanny
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper The California
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper The California Gold Rush had many effects on the American people, westward expansion, the environment, economy and Indian relations ultimately affecting the world as a whole. When John Marshall first found gold in January 1848 at Sutter’s Mill in California many people on the east coast did not believe the news.
Role Of Women In The 19Th Century
Essay, Research Paper Role of Females In the nineteenth century women were perceived in many different ways. Two noted nineteenth century writer were john Stuart Mill and Henrik Ibsen. Even though most of their stories were greatly different they did share the common thought that women are their own people and should be free.
Classical Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper
“Classical Utilitarianism,” by John Rawls This short piece by Rawls makes the point that “utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons.” This is an intriguing statement and warrants discussion. Rawls view of utilitarianism is that the goal for society is the fulfillment of the maximum satisfaction of all its members.
John Stuart Mills Essay Research Paper Is
John Stuart Mills Essay, Research Paper Is ignorance bliss? Would human beings, without higher thought processes, lead a happier existence? Or, is it better to be a human dissatisfied, than a pig satisfied ?(Mill, 335). These are questions that plagued the mind of John Stuart Mill. These are questions that help us look into ourselves and form our own opinions of pleasure, happiness, and utility.
Keynesian Theory And The New Deal Essay
, Research Paper The crash of the stock market brought many hard times. Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal was a way to fix these times. John Stuart Mill and John Maynard Keynes were two economists whose economic
Mills Theory Of Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper
MILLS THEORY OF UTILITARIANISM AND HOW IT EFFECTS LIVING A DECENT OR JUST LIFE When faced with a moral dilemma, utilitarianism identifies the appropriate considerations, but offers no realistic way to gather the necessary information to make the required calculations. This lack of information is a problem both in evaluating the welfare issues and in evaluating the consequentialist issues which utilitarianism requires