– H.R. 1627 Essay, Research Paper
The Food Quality Protection Act of 1996 (H.R. 1627)
The Food Quality Protection Act of 1996 or H.R.1627 was introduced by Representative
Thomas Bliley (R) on May 12, 1996. It was supported by 243 co-sponsors. The bill was reported
to the House of Representatives after receiving an 18-0 vote in Committee of Agriculture. The
House of Representatives voted unanimously in favor of the Food Quality Protection Act of
1996. The next day the measure was considered by the Senate, and also passed with unanimous
vote. The bill was then signed by President Clinton on July 24, 1996 and become Public Law
104-170 on August 3, 1996 (Detailed Legislative History). It has been said the bill would have
died in the Senate if it had been held over just one day loner due to rapidly mounting panic and
opposition from some major players in the pesticide industry. This would been a major loss
considering Congressman Bliley had been fighting for this reform legislation since the 102nd
Congress (Sray 49 ).
The Food Quality Protection Act of 1996 amends the Food Drug and Cosmetic Act and
the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenicide Act that had been a burden to both growers
and consumers. The bill Requires the Environmental Protection Agency to develop uniform
standards in setting all chemical tolerances allowed in food. The Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency must determine if the tolerance is safe, meaning there is
reasonable certainty that no harm will result from aggregate exposure to the pesticide chemical
residue, and any other type of exposure there is reliable information on (Sray 49). The bill
requires all pesticides to be re-registered under the guidelines that determine if they should be
used or not. The three guidelines for re-registration are the aggregate effects of a pesticide, the
common mode of toxicology, and the effects on infants and children.
The first guideline, aggregate effects of a pesticide, is the total lifetime exposure a person
will have to a chemical. This includes non-food exposure, which is something that was not
included in the past legislation. The next guideline is common mode of toxicity, which makes
the Environmental Protection Agency look at the cumulative exposure of all pesticides not just
specific ones. The last guideline is the effects of pesticides on infants and children. There are
new safety requirements that must be met regarding the amount of exposure that is safe for
infants and children (Sray 49).
Overall the Bill requires the Environmental Protection Agency to look at every chemical
used on food and determine if it is safe to use. The Bill gives incentives to chemical companies
who develop new less harmful chemicals. It also gives allowances to ?minor crops? that are not
as profitable as large commodities. It allows the ?minor crops? to have a longer grace period for
development and implementation of these new laws (Sray 49).
Proponents of this Bill consists of environmental groups, many children?s health
organizations, and as the voting proved all of Congress and the President. Vice President Al
Gore who has supported this bill since its beginning said the law ? brings the latest science to
the supermarket? (Waterfield C2). Gore was involved in hearings on the subject fifteen years
ago and was happy the reform Bill finally passed (WaterfieldC2).
Supporters believe the old legislation was a crisis waiting to happen, and with the new
Food Quality Protection Act children and consumers in general will be much safer. Children?s
groups are especially happy with the new focus on the level of chemical residue in many foods
that children eat. This is important because children differ in their exposure to toxic chemicals.
Children spend much of their time crawling around on the ground and putting their hands in their
mouth, therefore exposing themselves to much toxic chemicals than the average adult. In the
United States one million children are exposed to unsafe levels of pesticides in fruit, vegetables,
or baby food every year, according to a report by the Environmental Working Group (Grossfield
B1). Children also breathe differently. A one year old child breathes 50% more air each minute
relative to their weight than do adults (Reigart D3). Supporters believe this new law would limit
the amount of chemical residue a child is exposed to throughout its lifetime.
Proponents of the Food Quality Protection Act of 1996 believe that the risk to farm
workers and their families will be greatly reduced. One Hundred Thousand farm workers are
treated annually for pesticide related illness according to the American Association of Poison
Control Centers (Grossfeild B1). Proponents believe the research conducted due to the Food
Quality Protection Act of 1996 would reduce the treat of illness to the farm worker.
Environmentalist also support this law, because it makes chemical companies provide
data regarding the toxic life the many chemical and the re-registration of all chemicals. The
re-registration is very important to environmental groups, because new research has been done
that shows many chemicals that could potentially be harmful were not restricted in the old laws.
The new law will require every chemical to be looked at and determined if it is harmful or not.
Farm chemical organizations and many farmers oppose this bill mainly for two reasons.
The first being the vagueness in the way that the bill is written. Chemical companies believe
how the Environmental Protection Agency implements the Food Quality Protection Act will
critically impact the future of key pesticides vital to maintaining a safe and abundant food
supply. Opponents believe there is no way to accurately measure the long term effects of these
chemicals and the Food Quality Protection Act requires them to do this, which is next to
impossible (Sray 49). Alan Schreiber of the Agrichemical Environmental News says, ? the most
unsettling aspect of the this legislation is what we do not know about it.? He calls the Food
Quality Protection Act of 1996 the Trojan iceberg. Like the Trojan horse, I has several desirable
characteristics, however just as 90% of the iceberg cannot be seen so will the impact of the Food
Protection Act of 1996 (Schreiber 21).
The second reason for farmers and chemical producers opposition to this law is the effect
it will have on small crops. They believe this law will limit or in some cases eliminate some
pesticides used in small crops. Small crops don?t make enough money to fund research and
development on new, safe chemicals. Therefore limiting the choices growers have, which
greatly affect that industry.
I feel that I stand somewhere in the middle on this issue. It has many strong points both
in favor and against. I believe that the re-registration of chemicals is very important, and I also
believe it would be helpful to fully understand these pesticides effect on humans over a long
period of time. I wonder if it is possible to obtain accurate information due to so many different
variables. Improper application, over exposure, and misuse are things that should be taken into
consideration when determining if a chemical is safe to use. Many times we often only look at
the surface on issues such as this. I do think it is a good idea to regulate pesticides in a way that
is the most beneficial to consumers, but I also believe that if this regulation is not carried out
properly, farmers consumers, and everyone will be greatly affected. This law can help people,
but is also can hurt many farmers by placing unrealistic expectations of having perfectly safe
pesticides. California alone produces 20% of the worlds food and without these chemicals this
would not be possible. Pesticides, although harmful in some cases are overall beneficial to
California agriculture and the world.
Myself growing up on a farm I understand how important these chemicals are to making
a living,and producing the best product possible. I also realize the need for new safety measure
for the chemicals. I believe that the Food Protection Act of 1996 meets both of these issues
rather well. If impemeted properly the Food Protection Act of 1996 can benefit farmers,
chemical companies, children, families, and the world.
Grossfield, Stan. (Putting Poisons in the Fields; Safeguarding What We Eat.) The Boston
Globe 20 September 1998:B1
Reigart, Routt. (Don?t Wait For a Crisis) The Oregonian 10 October 1998:D3
Schreiber, Alan. ?The Food Quality Protection Act: A Trojan iceberg.? Agrichemical and
Environmental News Aug. 1996:21.
Sray, Al. ?Turning Politics into Policy.? Farm Chemicals Dec. 1996:49.
United States. Library of Congress.?Detailed Legislative Status of H.R.1627.? 104th
Congress. Thomas. 20 September 1999..
Waterfield, Larry. (Bill called a boon to consumers.) The Packer 12 August 1996:C2
Другие работы по теме:
Fast food and everything about him
Graphics Fast food and everything about him Graphics Fastfood (born fast food, fast food) - the class of fast food, usually offered by specialized institutions. The term "fast food" denote food that Fast can be cooked quickly and provide the client. The term "fast food" was first introduced in the Merriam-Webster dictionary in 1951.
Serfs Essay Research Paper They are the
Serfs Essay, Research Paper They are the ones who supply the lord with food. They are the ones who do the lords work. they are the ones bound to the land, never to leave it. They are the ones who do all these things without reward. They are the serfs. In return for all of their work the lord protects them. It was said by nobles and lords, that without protection they would surely be looted and killed.
Food College Style Essay Research Paper Coming
Food, College Style Essay, Research Paper Coming to this school, one of my biggest fears was what the food would be like. I knew there would be no way I could last a whole year here if the food was terrible, and my budget didn’t allow eating out very
Ants Essay Research Paper Ants are social
Ants Essay, Research Paper Ants are social insects that live in colonies being some of the most successful of insects. Ant colonies include one or more queens, workers, eggs, larvae and
River Project Essay Research Paper Since the
River Project Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the Americas the rivers have been a very important source of transportation. If not for the river the shipment of goods would have taken a very long time and would have been almost impossible through the dense forests of the New World. The Mississippi in time has been used for transportation.
Cooking Steps Made Simple Essay Research Paper
Cooking steps made simpleWhen I first learned to cook about six years ago, there were no magazine articles or books in bookstores explaining how to cook; there were only cookbooks with recipes for one to decipher. Today, the articles and books that explain how to cook are minimal. Not everyone can compete with Julia Child in cooking gourmet food with the menu devised in our minds without referring to cookbooks, but many of us can learn to cook effectively.
Genetic Engeneering Essay Research Paper Human Awareness
Genetic Engeneering Essay, Research Paper Human Awareness Essay Should genetically engineered food be grown and sold in South Australia? Recently more and more foods that we buy from the supermarket are involved in the manipulation of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) also known as genetic engineering or gene technology. but should genetic engineered food be sold to us the consumers even if we don t know that it has been altered? Like every issue genetic engineering has its good points and it s bad points.
Analysis Of Austin S Air Quali Essay
, Research Paper Christopher Lee Analysis of Austin s Air Quality When taking an analysis of a certain area s air quality, many different factors are taken into account. The more factors, the more accurate the analysis will be. Air quality can be measured in more than one way. The Ozone Forecast and the measure of Airborne Particulates are two factors that are considered when toxicologists analyze the air quality.
Baby Foods Essay Research Paper Baby foods
Baby Foods Essay, Research Paper Baby foods are basically sold through supermarket, grocery stores, mass merchandisers, and some of direct marketing.? Opportunities:The demand in baby food industry is constant. Except United States, there are good opportunities in international markets like European, Asia and South America.
Hep A Essay Research Paper Infectious hepatitis
Hep A Essay, Research Paper Infectious hepatitis is a contagious liver disease, which is sometimes fatal. Infectious hepatitis is more commonly known as hepatitis A because of the virus that causes it. This disease infects around 143,000 people in the United States per year.
Mcdonaldization Of Society Essay Research Paper The
Mcdonaldization Of Society Essay, Research Paper The way that Burger King and other fast food restaurant chains do business and markets their products to consumers is due to the change in our society to where the consumer wants the biggest, fastest, and best product they can get for their money. This change in society can be attributed to a process known as McDonaldization.
The Mcdonaldization Of Society Essay Research Paper
In chapter four of “The McDonaldization of Society,” George Ritzer discusses calculability, the second dimension of McDonaldization. Calculability involves calculating, counting, and quantifying, which makes it very efficient in the process of McDonaldization. When taking the fast-food industry as an example, there are three key issues dealing with calculability.
The Truth About Fast Food Essay Research
Paper The truth about fast food restaurants. Fast food restaurants are a very quick and easy way to get food if you are in a hurry, but there is a dark side to this convenience. Most fast food restaurants are generally bad for both people and the environment. The production of food is in a way harmful to the environment.
Bad Cafeteria Essay Research Paper Griffin ElliottOctober
Bad Cafeteria Essay, Research Paper Griffin Elliott October 18, 2001 Talk about losing an appetite. Barbecue sauce and puddles of pop cover the tables. As students go to sit down, their attention is drawn to the sticky substance on their hands. One usually prefers to have a clean table while they eat but it is seldom that one will be available while dining at the Loyola Cafeteria.
Marketing Paper On Burger King Essay Research
Paper TWO COMPETITIVE TOOLS THAT I FEEL WOULD HELP BURGER KING ARE QUALITY AND VARIETY. WE ARE ALL FAMILIAR WITH THEIR PRODUCTS THEREFORE, WE ALL SHOULD AGREE THAT SOMETIMES THE FOOD SEEMS LIKE IT HAS BEEN SITTING ON THE SHELF A WHILE. ALSO, THEY SHOULD INCORPORATE MORE VARIETY INTO THEIR MENU. BURGER KING, (ALONG WITH ALL THE OTHER FAST FOOD RESTAURANTS) HAS SUCH A LIMITED VARIETY OF ITEMS TO CHOSE FROM.
As Gass To Cars Essay Research Paper
As gas to cars, food is human?s source of energy. If there is no food there is no energy, If there is no energy the body cannot work, in other words, dies. But the concept of food has changed throughout history. In fact, the concept of food in one period differs from one place to the other and from one class to another.
Pesticides Essay Research Paper Pesticides are chemicals
Pesticides Essay, Research Paper Pesticides are chemicals that are used to destroy pests. In the agricultural industry, pesticides are classified into two categories, carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic. A carcinogenic pesticide is a substance or agent producing or inciting cancer. Conversely, a non-carcinogenic pesticide is substance that does not produce or incite cancer.
Pesticides Essay Research Paper Pesticides What are
Pesticides Essay, Research Paper Pesticides: What are they? Pesticides are chemicals that are used to destroy pests. In the agricultural industry, pesticides are classified into two categories, carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic. A carcinogenic pesticide is a substance or agent producing or inciting cancer.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper The protection from
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper The protection from force, that is, the protection of individual rights, would be achieved through the use of a police force to protect the rights of citizens at home; a military, to protect the rights of citizens from foreign aggression; and a court system to enforce contracts and settle disputes between citizens.
Food Stamps Essay Research Paper while others
Food Stamps Essay, Research Paper while others think that giving away food stamps is a helpful thing, i think that the gov. should stop distrubuting food stamps. the aqusition and use of food stamps is frequently abused. people can easily obtain food stamps by creating their eligibility even if it involves cheating. one thing i believe that the government should stop handing out food stamps is that most of the people who receive food stamps are capable of working.
Honey Bee Dances Essay Research Paper The
Honey Bee Dances Essay, Research Paper The honey bee does a waggle dance is the food source is MORE THAN 50 meters away. A waggle dance is when the bee does a little ditty like a figure-eight. If the food source is LESS THAN 50 meters
Fast Food Essay Research Paper The fast
Fast Food Essay, Research Paper The fast food industry is one of the largest industries in the world. Fast food has been known to be a large area of investment involving food. Restaurants such as McDonald s and Burger King have been known for their popularity mostly from advertisements and are highly rated to be the trademarks for the fast food industry.
Upton Sinclairs Book The Jungle Essay Research
Paper Upton Sinclair, he wrote a book called “The Jungle”. The book was about the meat packing industry’s in Chicago. What would the city of Chicago’s meat industry be like without Upton Sinclair? The book described what the meat industry’s were putting in the meat that the people of Chicago ate back in the early 1900’s.
Tyler Pet Foods Inc Essay Research Paper
Tyler Pet Foods, Inc. I. SUMMARY Tyler Pet Food Inc. is a major distributor of dog food for show-dog kennels in the United States. After some researches and discussions, Tyler Pet Foods(TPF) decided to enter into the household dog food market in the Boston, Massachusetts, metropolitan area. TPF hired a consulting firm to help it promote and distribute its product.
Progressive Reform Essay Research Paper The Progressive
Progressive Reform Essay, Research Paper The Progressive Era produced widespread consumer, labor, and political changes in our country in the late 1800 s. For a while a basic principle inherited from Great Britain was used by American businesses, which led to consumer protection. Many labor laws were passed to protect workers who were injured on the job.
Reflection As Revision Essay Research Paper Reflection
Reflection As Revision Essay, Research Paper Reflection as RevisionAll through life I have always been told by people that it’s quality not quantity that matters. I cannot even remember the first time I heard it. If I only had a dollar for every time I was told that. If ever asked for the ultimate clichi, I would have to say quality not quantity.
Why Coral Reefs Need To Be Protected
And Conserved For Future Generations Essay, Research Paper Coral Reefs need to be preserved for many reasons. In this paper I will discuss a few of them. First of all, they houses a collection of diverse organisms, and contribute
How Did The Special Agencies Of The
United Nations Help To Provide A Better Quality Of Life Essay, Research Paper At the outbreak of the Second World War, in 1939 the League of Nations collapsed.? However
Take A Bite Of Wisconsin Essay Research
Paper Take a Bite of Wisconsin Since the early 19th century, Wisconsin has been known for cheesemaking excellence. Wisconsin’s high quality milk is the secret ingredient used to put the quality of cheeses above all