Of Novel And Movie Essay, Research Paper
Of Mice and Men: A Comprehensive Comparison of Novel and Movie
Who doesn’t know of John Steinbeck’s classic novel “Of Mice and Men”? It
is a novel that almost everyone educated in the United States has either read it
or pretended to read it. But how many have seen the 1992 film “Of Mice and
Men”? The relative obscurity of 1992 screen version of this timeless drama does
not mean that it was poorly done. Just the contrary is true, it is one of the
best film adaptations of a novel that I have seen. The novel and the film are
very similar. The Steinbeck’s novel could be though of as the screenplay’s
first draft. There were some small changes, but they were instituted for the
good of the film. I liked the film better than Steinbeck’s novel.
“Of Mice and Men” is a story of people who express their troubles
clearly, holding on to thin dreams as they go about their thankless business.
The novel, set in the 1930s, is a story of friendship of migrant workers George
Milton and Lennie Smalls. The pair travels from ranch to ranch, dreaming of
someday making enough money so they can buy their own plot of land and a stake
in their future. George is a father figure and protector of the strong simple-
minded Lennie. Lennie’s strength is his gift and his curse. Like the child he
is mentally, he loves animals, but he inadvertently crushes them to death.
Women, to him, are rather like animals, — soft, small, and gentle. And there
lies the tension that powers this narrative to its tragic conclusion.
The film version and the novel are very similar. There is minimal
description in the novel, enough to set the scene, and the rest is dialogue.
The film’s story is very pure and lean as Steinbeck’s original.
Producer/director Gary Sinise and screenwriter Horton Foote don’t try do
anything fancy, they don’t try to make it anything other than exactly what it is,
a timeless simple story. Sinise and Foote make American Literature teachers
everywhere proud; they have left the film’s story uncluttered. Everything is
very clear, and makes sense within its context. They remembered “Of Mice and
Men is a classic for a reason, and if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.
The screenplay and the novel are not synonymous but they are very close
to being that way. Sinise and Foote held very true in their adaptation. All of
the changes made were minor and to nothing to detract from the narrative. There
were many more scenes in the film than the novel. It is believable to think the
novel was originally a play and then was adapted into book form because there
are only four different scenes in the entire novel. Chapter one is set at the
Salinas River, chapter two and three are in the bunkhouse, chapter four in
Crook’s room, chapter five is in the barn, and chapter six is at the river again.
Scenes had to be added to the film to keep the audience from getting bored.
Dialogue was deleted to help move the story along. The only way we get
background information about George and Lennie in the novel is through their
dialogue. There was less dialogue in the film because the audience can learn
the background information from visual cues from the added scenes. For instance,
in the novel, George and Lennie speak of walking ten miles after being forced
off the bus by the driver. But in the film, we see the driver kick the pair off
of the bus. Similarly, George only speaks of the trouble that Lennie had gotten
them into in the town of Weed. But in the movie we are able to see what happens.
Curley’s wife, played by Sherilyn Fenn, plays a larger role in this film
than in the novel. This character steadily develops as layers are peeled back
like an onion. The wife in this version is far more predatory and dangerous
than in Steinbeck’s novel. Initially she acts quite sluttish, but she
eventually shows to be naive, lonely, and trapped in an abusive marriage. She
acts as a feminist voice that Steinbeck probably never intended.
The film version is different because downplays the novel’s political
subtext, a call for humane socialism where people take care of one another.
Instead, the film version focuses on the human condition on the individual level
only. We are given characters, a setting, and events. The drama of this story
comes from two men who have formed a friendship that works – they have a bond in
which each takes according to his needs and gives according to his abilities.
The two main characters truly need each other. When George is not there, Lennie
would get into trouble and when Lennie is not there, George would think of
throwing away his dreams.
I liked the film better than the novel for several reasons. The novel gave
good descriptions of the characters but I learned more about them and the story
form the film because I was watching and listening to them, rather than just
reading about them. John Malkovich’s (Lennie), Gary Sinise’s (George), and Ray
Walton’s (Candy) performances made the film very worthwhile. Malkovich and
Sinise are touching and pleasurable to watch together. Malkovich uses his
baldness with bulky costumes to become convincingly large and stupid. He takes
the time to show us that the wheels are turning very slowly and
uncomprehendingly beneath his broad forehead. Many actors would have easily
overacted playing Lennie. They’d end up looking cartoonish, but Malkovich does
well because he exercises remarkable restraint. Sinise does a lot for this film
by doing less. He lets Malkovich’s character be the attention getter, while he
does well in the quieter caretaking role. Sherilyn Fenn impressed me in
presenting a new take on Curley’s wife. But Ray Walston as Candy may have
turned in the film’s best performance. All Candy had in life was his old smelly
dog, but one of the ranch hands shot him because “he was of no use anymore”.
Walston delivers the best lines of the movie when he says, “I wish someone would
shoot me when I’m of no use anymore. But they won’t, they’ll just send me
away.”
The film is a success because it was well photographed. The film
captured some of California’s picturesque golden wheat fields. The entire film
was very pretty but it maybe too pretty. I had pictured Candy and Slim to be
more dirty and grizzled men. I thought Ray Walston looked a little too feeble
to play Candy but his acting made up for any shortcomings he had in his
appearance. Slim looked a little too young and handsome to be the character I
had envisioned. Overall, the casting and photography was excellent.
Another reason why I liked the film better was because of its dramatic
conclusion. At the end of the novel we know what that George has Carlson’s gun
and then we know what is going to happen. At the end of the film, we don’t know
George has the gun and we can’t see that he is holding the gun to the back of
Lennie’s head. This makes for a very dramatic ending. Because I read the novel,
I knew what was going to happen, but I still was very drawn into the action.
The film was a very good adaptation of a great book. It is a wonderful
story of friendship,loneliness, and pain. This was an excellent film because it
was dramatic but it never went too far and became sappy and overdone. This film
is great because the creators realized how important the original text was in
making this film. They did not fool around with it; the story says all they
want to say.
Другие работы по теме:
Mad Milk Disease Essay Research Paper Mad
Mad Milk Disease Essay, Research Paper Mad Milk Disease? The term ‘Mad Cow’ disease is almost a household name, but only a few people actually know what it means. Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy, more commonly known as Mad Cow disease, infects cows and turns their brains into what resembles a sponge.
Of Mice And Men
– Hopes And Dreams Essay, Research Paper ofmiceandmenthesis Hopes and dreams are both the fuel and fire in Of Mice and Men. Stienbeck uses these to thicken the plot and make the reader take large interest into the character?s outcomes.
Of Mice And Men Comparing The Movie
And The Book Essay, Research Paper The movie of Of Mice and Men had many differences while still giving the same message that the book was portrayed to have. One of the major differences was that Candy never came into the room when Lennie and Crooks were talking to each other. This was major because Crooks never found out that the plan was true about the little house.
Biography Of Of Mice And Men
– Lennie Small Essay, Research Paper My name is Lennie Small. My name is one of the few things I know. The name I should be given is “stupid” or “ignorant” because that is what I am. I admit it, I am not very bright. That is why I have my friend George. He guides me and allows me to utilize my strength. If I were by myself I would cause much trouble for I do not understand many things.
Of Mice And Men 3 Essay Research
Paper Of Mice and Men “A guy goes nuts if he aint got nobody. Don t matter no difference who the guy is, long s he s with you. I tell ya a guy gets too lonely an he gets sick.” A major theme in Steinbeck s novella Of Mice and Men is loneliness. The characters Crooks, Candy and Curley s wife each suffer from this although the severity of their seclusion varied.
A Comparison Between The Great Depression And
Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper The Great Depression is comparable to Lennie and George’s life. I would like to give a comparison of George Milton and Lennie Small to the Great
Lennie From Of Mice
& Phinney Of A Seper Essay, Research Paper Lennie & Finny Finny, from A Separate Peace, and Lennie, from Of Mice and Men, was basically the center of their novels. Everything that went on revolved around them. From the very beginning,
The Terrible Trins Essay Research Paper What
The Terrible Trins Essay, Research Paper What the book is about: The book is about a mother mouse named Dolly and three baby mice named Thomas, Richard and Henry. Together they try to defeat the cats in the farmhouse where they live. The mice are taught by their mother on what not to get into like mouse traps and poison.
The Mouse Of All Men By John
Steinbeck Essay, Research Paper The book I read was Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. Of Mice and Men is a great book. It shows how loving somebody so much could also mean doing anything for them, even murder them.
Prejudice In Of Mice And Men Essay
, Research Paper Prejudice in Of Mice and Men Novel by John Steinbeck In the past and present there have been many divisions of people for many reasons. Examples of this prejudice include discrimination
Comparison Between Call Of The Wild And
Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper The supplemental assignment I did was the one with the two books by different authors of the same genre. The books I read were Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck and Call of the wild by Jack London. These two books are classified under the genre of drama.
Mice And MenCrooks Essay Research Paper I
Mice And Men-Crooks Essay, Research Paper I believe that every character in this book is lonely in their own way and has certain needs that they will inevitably never fulfil. I also feel that Crooks is the loneliest character in the book, this is because of the extremely racist and volatile environment on the ranch.
Of Mice And MenOutcasts Essay Research Paper
Of Mice and Men In the novel, Of Mice and Men, Crooks and Curley s wife could both be considered outcasts. Crooks could be considered an outcast because of his race. Curley s wife could be considered an outcast because most of the characters believe trouble always follows her. Both Crooks and Curley s wife are thought of as social outcasts for various reasons, such as race and reputation.
The Three Main Themes Of John Steinbeck
’s Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper Of Mice and Men, a novel written by John Steinbeck, clearly develops three themes: man s desire to create and seek dreams, man s desire for companionship, and man s
Curly
’s Wife–Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper Curley s wife in Of Mice and Men is given a fairly one-dimensional portrayal throughout the novella, as her character stays, for the most part, enigmatic. The most obvious example would be her lack of a name. She is continually referred to as a possession of her husband and without a name she becomes almost insignificant.
Herbal Supplements And Mice Essay Research Paper
A nutritional scientist was trying to get a new herbal supplement approved by the Food and Drug Administration. Her belief is that the herbal supplement can improve endurance in humans. The scientist took 30 mice and split them into 15 groups of two mice. The two mice in each group are of the same species, have same diet patterns, and same size.
John Steinbeck And Of Mice And Man
Essay, Research Paper John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men is nothing short of magnificent. The book is about two men that travel together looking for work. The plot centers on George
Death 2
Death – The Final Motif In Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper My mother is dead, my father is dead, my sister is dead, and now I am going to kill myself. When reading that list is becomes obvious after the first couple of deaths that there are more to follow. In John Steinbeck?s masterpiece Of Mice and Men, the use of deaths as a motif, or a reoccurring theme, is just the opposite.
I Heard The Owl Call My Name
Essay, Research Paper Of Mice and Men ?I ain?t got no people,? George said. ?I seen the guys that go around on the ranches alone. That ain?t no good. They don?t have no fun. After a long time they get mean. They
Emotions Seen In 2
Emotions Seen In – Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper Emotions seen in “Of Mice and Men”This essay will deal with the way emotions were used in the story of “Of Mice and Men”. Not only friendship and loyalty between George and Lennie. Faith, hope, charity, love, hate, jealousy and indifference are among the other emotions that develops during the story between them and the other characters, and that shows us Steinbeck s way of character definition.
Mice Essay Research Paper A mouse is
Mice Essay, Research Paper A mouse is a small rodent. The word mice or mouse is sometimes used to refer to any small rodent. The word mouse has no exact meaning in classification systems. There are numerous amounts of mice in the world, but for convenience they are often grouped as the Eurasian mice and the American mice.
Of Mice And Men Loneliness Essay Research
Paper Of Mice and Men: Loneliness Loneliness is one of the main emotions Of Mice and Men. Lenny must have been lonely and George too. When we meet them in Of Mice and Men they already
Mice Of Men Essay Research Paper Justin
Mice Of Men Essay, Research Paper Justin Clay Period 1&2 Am. Lit. Of Mice and Men The novel Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, is about two ranch hands, George and Lennie. George is a small, smart-witted man, while Lennie is a large, mentally- handicapped man. They are trying to raise enough money to buy their own ranch, by working as ranch hands.
Of Mice And Men What Are Friends
For? Essay, Research Paper Set in Soledad, California on a typical Western Ranch, we find George and Lennie. George and Lennie come right out of John Steinbeck’s novel, Of mice and men. Of mice and men is a novel which shows the trials and tribulations of true friendship. This novel, with all of its twists and turns is a great piece of American Literature.
True Friendship Essay Research Paper True FriendshipBut
True Friendship Essay, Research Paper True Friendship But not us! An why? Because I got you to look after me, and you got me to look after you, and that s why. (Page 14) This quote came from Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck. Lennie and George can trust and depend on each other because they are true friends. George is the smart, sophisticated and reliable one of the two.
Of Mice And Men A Comparison Of
The 2 Movies And The Book Essay, Research Paper In Class we watched two movies based on a book we read called Of Mice and Men. Both of the movies were very similar to the book. In I was able to hear exact lines from the book in the two movies.
Of Mice And Men And Grapes Of
Wrath Comparison Essay, Research Paper Of Mice and Men and The Grapes Of Wrath John Ernst Steinbeck’s novels The Grapes of Wrath and Of Mice and Men share many common themes such as dependancy, survival and unity. Although subtle, the most intriguing link between these two novels is Steinbecks infatuation with the human soul.
Effects Of Lonliness In Of Mice And
Men Essay, Research Paper The Effects of Loneliness Have you ever been alone walking or lying on your bed thinking about how lonely you are? Do you ever wonder why you are sometimes ostracized from the group? You can experience loneliness, mentally or physically. It can also drive you out of your mind. In John Steinbeck?s, Of Mice and Men, Crooks, Candy, and Curly?s wife have little to no friends and are forlorn.
Mice And Men Candys Dog Essay Research
Paper Mice and Men There is an abundance of characters in the story Of Mice and Men, and some characters may seem insignificant. One character that is very important, even though one may not think so, is Candy?s Dog. His role, although short and simple, is powerful, and this is apparent throughout the entire book.
Mice
&Men(A) Essay, Research Paper The book that I have read that has really stayed with me is Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. I really enjoyed reading it which is unusual because I usualy don’t enjoy reading to much. Therewas something about George and Lennie’s friendship that really made me think. Seeing how theywere and how they shared life was really intresting.
Mice And Men Essay Research Paper Title
Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper Title of Paper : Essay on “Of Mice and Men” Grade Received on Report : 96% In the novel Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck uses stereotypes and discrimination to convey a message
Character Summary The Mice Essay Research Paper
?Of Mice And Men?, being a story about two men and their struggles, however never really going into detail of the mice in which were unjustly murdered. The mice slaughtered by Lennie were never really at fault for their actions. When being harshly petted by Lennie, the mice would only try to protect themselves, thus Lennie resorted to killing the mice in his own defense.
Of Mice And Men Isolation Essay Research
Paper Of Mice and Men “Isolation” John Steinbeck’s novel Of Mice and Men contains the haunting theme of isolation that captures the “abused” little man of 1920’s America. Throughout the novel, it is shown that loneliness and isolation has a greater affect on us than may seem. Steinbeck’s characters experience different forms of isolation based on the specific prejudice contained within themselves.
Lonliness In Of Mice And Men Essay
, Research Paper Lonliness in Of Mice and Men The novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinback deals with many themes that are reflective of the time period in which the novel was written. Loneliness is one of the many themes in this novel that are reflective of the time period in which the novel was written. It is shown in many of the characters in the novel.
Of Mice And Men Film Review Essay
, Research Paper Of Mice and Men: Review In this, the third and latest movie version of John Steinbeck?s Of Mice and Men, screenplay written by Horton Foote and directed by Gary Sinese, the audience is