Conformity And Obedience Essay, Research Paper
Conformity and Obedience
The desire to be accepted and belong to a group is an undeniable human need. But how does this need affect an individual? Social psychologists have conducted numerous experiments and concluded that, through various forms of social influence, groups can change their members thoughts, feelings, and behavior.
In her essay Group Minds, Doris Lessing discusses our paradoxical ability to call ourselves individuals and our inability to realize that groups define and influence us. We, as humans, hold individualism in the highest regard yet fail to realize that groups diminish our individuality. Lessing writes, when we re in a group, we tend to think as that group does… but we also find our thinking changing because we belong to a group (p. 334). Groups have the tendency to generate norms, or standards for behavior in certain situations. Not following these norms can make you stand out and, therefore, groups have the ability to influence our thoughts and actions in ways that are consistent with the groups . Lessing s essay helps set the context to understand the experiments that social psychologists Solomon Asch, Stanley Milgram and Philip Zimbardo conducted to explain conformity and obedience.
Solomon Asch s experiment in Opinions and Social Pressure studied a subject s ability to yield to social pressure when placed within a group of strangers. His research helped illustrate how groups encourage conformity. During a typical experiment, members of the group were asked by the experimenter to claim two obvious mismatched lines were identical. The single individual who was not privy to this information was the focal point of the experiment. Twelve out of eighteen times the unsuspecting individual went along with the majority, dispelling his beliefs in favor of the opinions of the group.
Why did a subject conform in two-thirds of the tests? Influence causes us to think and act in ways that are consistent with our group, especially when we look to the group as a source of information. We also tend to assume that a large number of people can t all be wrong. Asch writes, the sheer weight of numbers or authority sufficed to change opinions, even when no arguments for the opinions themselves were provided (p. 337).
Stanley Milgram is well known for his work with obedience to authority. His work, The Perils of Obedience, studied whether average individuals would obey an authority figure, telling them to do something that harms another individual.
In his study, the teacher is instructed to read a list of words and ask the learner to recite them back. If the learner answers incorrectly, the teacher is supposed to shock the learner, starting at 15 volts and increasing to 450 volts. With each incorrect answer the teacher is supposed to increase the shock. Although the teacher thought that he/she was administering shocks, the learner was actually never harmed.
Milgram s study undermined the theory that only the most sadistic individuals would submit to such cruelty. His findings showed that, two-thirds of this studies participants fall into the category of obedient subjects, and that they represent ordinary people (p. 352). Milgram concluded that when a person is obeying orders he views himself as the instrument… and no longer regards himself as responsible for his action (p. 354). Milgram s experiment proved that when doing a job as instructed by an authority figure the feelings of duty and personal emotion are separated. Responsibility shifts in the minds of the subordinate from himself/herself to the authority figure. There is a purpose for the actions or goals of the authority, and the subordinate is depended upon to meet those goals.
Another important study in the area of social roles and obedience is Philip Zimbardo s Stanford Prison Experiment. A group of 21 college men were divided into two groups for a study on group dynamics. Eleven men became guards and the other ten prisoners. The prisoners were given numbers instead of being allowed to use their names, systematically stripped, de-loused and given prison clothing to wear. The study was terminated prematurely due to the unexpected and disturbing results. The guards quickly became locked into the role of belittling and dehumanizing the prisoners. Although the subjects were fully aware of the nature of the experiment, given the authority, the guards transgressed the boundaries of norms that are considered acceptable.
Zimbardo s experiment demonstrated the power of social situations to distort personal identity. What social value did this test serve? Zimbardo proved that social roles might affect behavior more than personality in certain situation. Zimbardo writes, abnormal social and personal reactions are best seen as a product of… an environment that supported the behavior (p.374). Like Milgram, Zimbardo determined that almost all humans would do what they are told if they believe the voice of authority is good.
Through their experiments, Asch, Milgram and Zimbardo have proved that social influences can have a profound effect on individuality. One s desire to be accepted can make them unaware of conformity or obedience to authority. The problem lies not only within the group, but also the individual s acceptance of authority without question.
Works Cited
Asch, Solomon. Opinions and Social Pressure. In L. Behrens & L. J. Rosen (Eds). Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. (pp.336-342). New York: Longman Press.
Lessing, Doris. Group Minds. In L. Behrens & L. J. Rosen (Eds). Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. (pp.333-335). New York: Longman Press.
Milgram, Stanley. The Perils of Obedience. In L. Behrens & L. J. Rosen (Eds). Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. (pp.343-355). New York: Longman Press.
Zimbardo, Philip. The Stanford Prison Experiment. In L. Behrens & L. J. Rosen (Eds). Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. (pp.363-375). New York: Longman Press.
338
Другие работы по теме:
Conformity Essay Research Paper Conformity is defined
Conformity Essay, Research Paper Conformity is defined by Zimbardo (1992) as, ?A tendency for people to adopt behaviour, values and attitudes of other members of a reference group.? Mann (1969) identified the two major types of conformity: normative conformity and informational conformity.
Conformity Essay Research Paper A Japanese proverb
Conformity Essay, Research Paper A Japanese proverb says, “The nail that sticks out will be hammered down.” Society tries to place many rules on us as individuals as to what is acceptable and what is not. We must decide for ourselves whether to conform to such a social decorum. We are taught as soon as we are old enough to grasp the idea that it is bad to be unique and to avoid being different.
Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper Henry David Thoreau
Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau, one of the biggest Transcendentalists of his time, was very outspoken on the idea of conformity. He believed and advocated the idea that people should not be involved with government, transportation, or activities that might give the possibility for people to conform.
Human Nature S Inclination Towards Conformity Essay
, Research Paper Human nature feels a sense of acceptance when conformed to those in its environment. People need to follow patterns, standards, and a structure of behavior to feel secure. A pattern to conform to is a kind of shelter. (Unknown) Whether a strong faith in religion, failure to decipher the truth, to follow the majority, or a realization of one s conformity, Arthur Miller s The Crucible supports human nature s natural inclination towards conformity through the plot and characters.
Does Neo Of The Matrix Fullfill Joseph
Cambell’s Heroic Archetype Essay, Research Paper An engine consists of many parts which work together to transform energy into mechanical force. With the absence of any of those parts, the collection is no longer an engine, but an assembly of parts with no purpose. Similar to this is the archetype of the hero.
Fear Of Humiliation Leads To Conformity Essay
, Research Paper Fear of Humiliation leads to conformity. Fear of humiliation leads to conformity. People agree with others because they fear ridicule or being isolated from the crowd. They fear the idea of not being a part of the whole. They fear isolation or worse, being ostracized by the group. Most people usually have an innate desire to fit in with a group.
Assimilation Essay Research Paper Chinese
Assimilation Essay, Research Paper Chinese Anglo-Conformists Assimilation into a society is difficult for anyone, yet is especially difficult for those who have social externalities. Social externalities are those that are visible, physical qualities. There are three forms of assimilation: Anglo-conformity, melting pot, and cultural pluralism.
Justice Essay Research Paper The concept of
Justice Essay, Research Paper The concept of justness is a subjective reality. Justice is not present in any one person, justice appears to be present only in consensus. There is no just,
Rebellion And Conformity Essay Research Paper A
Rebellion And Conformity Essay, Research Paper A Japanese proverb says, The nail that sticks out will be hammered down. Society tries to place many regulations on us as individuals as to what is admissible and what is not. We must decide for ourselves whether to conform to such a social decorum. We are taught as soon as we are old enough to grasp the idea that it is undesirable to be unique and to avoid being different.
Conformity Essay Research Paper ConformityFeelings of disgust
Conformity Essay, Research Paper ConformityFeelings of disgust fill me when I observe the identity of an individual being crushed by the widespread need to fit in with society and be like everyone else. Differences in character, appearance, and emotion are created by unique pasts, and form the foundation for personal beliefs.
Conformity Essay Research Paper Feelings of disgust
Conformity Essay, Research Paper Feelings of disgust fill me when I observe the identity ofan individual’s soul being crushed by the widespread need to fit in with society and be like everyone else. Our unique pasts create differences in character, appearance and emotion, which form the foundations for our personal beliefs.
New England Transcedentalsim Essay Research Paper Ralph
New England Transcedentalsim Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson was a nineteenth-century transcendentalism author. Self-reliance and independence were ideas that were highly valued by him as well as other transcendentalist authors of his time. The transcendentalist believed in non-conformity and a belief that nature was an influential aspect of peoples life.
Psych In 12 Angry Men Essay Research
Paper The film Twelve Angry Men follows the jury deliberation of a first degree murder case. The jury, totaling twelve men, dispute their decision of innocence or guilt throughout the movie. Many concepts of social psychology including conformity, anger displacement, and stereotypes are used in the struggle between these men to reach a verdict.
Conformity Essay Research Paper Andrew Worthington
Conformity Essay, Research Paper Andrew Worthington Conformity Conformity: the state of having changed yourself to match the appearances and/or personalities of those around you. In many cases, people feel the need to conform because they wish to feel a part of something bigger than them. This is unfortunate however, because it robs people of their individuality and their free will.
Conformity Essay Research Paper The more people
Conformity Essay, Research Paper The more people already agree upon or share a particular idea, the more easily a newcomer will in turn be be converted to that idea, and the more difficult it will be for one already converted to reject that idea
Fahrenheit 451 Essay Research Paper John F
Fahrenheit 451 Essay, Research Paper John F. Kennedy once said, ” Conformity is jailer of freedom and the enemy of growth.” This quote relates directly to the novel Fahrenheit 451, by Ray Bradbury. According to this statement, when a person is told how to live their own lives they often forget to make their own decisions, and they are no longer their own person.
Ulysses By Tennyson Essay Research Paper The
Ulysses By Tennyson Essay, Research Paper The poem I chose to write about is ?Ulysses?, by Alfred Lord Tennyson. It is a poem based on Homer?s Odyssey, which is the story of Odysseus (Ulysses) and
Conformity Essay Research Paper Not ConformingIn my
Conformity Essay, Research Paper Not Conforming In my personal experience I consider myself a Farley normal human being that would generally follow most of the considered ?social norms? in our society. I take a shower every day, I don?t talk to strangers on the elevator, and I like to eat my cereal with milk.
The Obligation To Obey Essay Research Paper
It has been said that as long as the human species is in a living state conformity shall be part of how human society functions and part of man?s natural tendencies. The more people already agree upon or share a particular idea, the more easily a newcomer will in turn be converted to that idea, and the more difficult it will be for one already converted to reject that idea.
Coporate Empires Essay Research Paper Corporate EmpiresCorporate
Coporate Empires Essay, Research Paper Corporate Empires. Corporate empires are the downfall of civilization. If society continues to allow the corporate giants to monopolize our economy we will lose our rights as individuals. Corporate empires use people as puppet subjects for their schemes and plans.
Bartleby Essay Essay Research Paper Bartleby EssayDiscuss
Bartleby Essay Essay, Research Paper Bartleby Essay Discuss the conflict of the individuals’ need to communicate his individual thoughts and feelings versus the desire of society’s institutions, for conformity in Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” and Updike’s “A & P.”
Perils Of Obedience Essay Research Paper The
Perils Of Obedience Essay, Research Paper The Perils of Obedience This experiment is a test to see if people are naturally aggressive. Milgram does not believe that people are naturally aggressive. Although some people think people are naturally aggressive. Ordinary people can be part of a bad course of actions without having any anger toward then victim.
The Doll
’s House Essay Essay, Research Paper The Doll’s House Essay A contributing factor to the story “The Doll s House” by Katherine Mansfield is the characterization of Kezia as she travels in her innocence through the symbolic world of experience. Kezia is essential to the plot because she represents a taboo, offering opposition to common ways of thinking.
Literary Analysis For Fahrenheit 451 Essay Research
Paper In Ray Bradury’s novel, Fahrenheit 451, there is a very commonly known as a book of science fiction book. More specifically one that refers to the future, and the consequences that can be inflicted as a result of the world having very little individuality. However, this book also has had a long lasting effect on the world as we know it to be presently.
Conformity Vs Individuality Essay Research Paper Conformity
Conformity Vs. Individuality Essay, Research Paper Conformity vs. Individuality “People don’t talk about anything…and nobody says anything different from anyone else” This quote, from Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, demonstrates how this fictional society had no individuality, yet they expressed no disprovement of the conformity.
Illustrations Of Conformity Essay Research Paper Conformity
Illustrations Of Conformity Essay, Research Paper Conformity, perhaps the most cumbersome of all social pressures, appears many times throughout Literature. For instance, in Nathaniel Hawthorne s Young Goodman Brown, the element of conformity appears, as an excuse for the main character to engage in conduct that he realizes is wrong.
150 Nazi Essay Research Paper 1 Hitler
150% Nazi Essay, Research Paper 1. Hitler demanded that the nation produce a “violently active, dominating, intrepid, brutal youth.” What part did the schools play in carrying out that
Who Are The Americans
? – Black Boy Essay, Research Paper Who Are the Americans? (And How are they Supposed to Behave?) Richard Wright, author and main character of Black Boy wrote about his ongoing struggle to figure out the unanswerable question of why. His questions of why stemmed mainly around why people had to conform and act a certain way for certain people (more specifically why black people or Negroes had to operate in a certain manner in the presence of whites).
Conformity And Obedience In An Enemy Of
The People Essay, Research Paper Conformity and Obedience in An Enemy of the People An Enemy of the People, by Henrik Ibsen, is the story of a man named Dr. Thomas Stockman, who becomes a deviant to society. After discovering that the waters in the town’s baths are polluted, Dr. Stockman tries to spread the news and have the baths shut down.
Morality Essay Research Paper Morality is the
Morality Essay, Research Paper Morality is the cooperation of the part to the whole in order to instill conformity in everyone. How does society place morality on people? One of the major methods is through religion. Using the Devil as a catharsis, the single-shared belief in some type of God brings people together in conformity, ethically.
Blind Conformity In The Crucible Essay Research
Paper Crucible Essay – Blind Conformity Blind conformity to mass thought is an issue that greatly affected the events of the Salem Witch Trials in The Crucible. The tendency of the townspeople to conform blindly may have come from their religion. Puritanism did not encourage individuality, and anyone who was “different” was looked down upon.
One Flew Over The Cooko
’s Nest Essay, Research Paper One Flew Over The Cuckoo?s Nest In our study of this novel of rebellion, and protest. The ward in One Flew Over the Cuckoo?s Nest is microcosism of a much larger world, where
A Separate Peace
– A Journey To Maturity Essay, Research Paper The novel A Separate Peace includes many important themes. The author, John Knowles, was able to make the book more realistic because of his personal experiences. Knowles, like the characters in the book attended a boarding school. Many of his dilemmas were similar to those of Gene and Finny.