Health Care Reform Essay, Research Paper
9:15
Due to the upcoming presidential election, the two major political parties, and their candidates, have been focusing on the primary problems that the nation will face. Chief among those problems is the future of Medicare, the national health-insurance plan. Medicare was enacted in 1965, under the administration of Lyndon B. Johnson, in order to provide health insurance for retired citizens and the disabled (Ryan). The Medicare program covers most people aged 65 or older, as well as handicapped people who enroll in the program, and consists of two health plans: a hospital insurance plan (part A) and a medical insurance plan (part B) (Marmor 22). Before Medicare, many Americans didn’t have health insurance coverage, but since its inception the program has enrolled almost 40 million beneficiaries, who jointly fund the insurance program along with the national government (Carnegie).
According to Dr. Don McCanne, a member of the Board of Directors of Physicians for a National Health Program, “Before the passage of Medicare in 1965, only 52% of persons age 65 and over had hospital insurance and less than 15% had adequate health insurance” (McCanne). The Medicare program has improved access to healthcare and improved the quality of life for millions of elderly members, and has provided insurance for millions of persons with disabilities. By reducing the burden of large medical bills, Medicare also has improved the economic status of the elderly. As Dorothy Price points out “Over its 33 year history, Medicare has channeled billions of dollars into the health care system, helping to foster enormous improvements in health care technology and medical education” (Carnegie). Unfortunately though, the program is now facing two major problems: beneficiaries are still having trouble in finding affordable care, and the Medicare program itself is not properly funded. As a result of these problems, the program could cease to exist unless a solution is found.
One of the problems of Medicare itself is that it doesn’t cover the costs of prescription drugs for its members; this has led to one of the major reasons that the program is in danger. A great deal of personal healthcare relies on the use of drugs, and since the program doesn’t cover these costs, the individual must bear them. According to the AARP, in 1999 out-of-pocket costs for prescription drugs were estimated to be $450 per person each year (AARP). Obviously, members have joined the program to defray their medical costs, but these figures indicate that they still have large costs to pay. The other problem faced by the Medicare program is that it is also suffering from a lack of funds. According to Governor George W. Bush, the financial health of Medicare is in serious jeopardy and might face deficit as soon as 2010 (Bush). As a result of these major problems, one might wonder why the plan isn’t scrapped for another program; well according to polls done by the Public Agenda, an Internet public policy site, American citizens are strongly in favor of Medicare, and would rather see the problems ironed out (Public Agenda). Therefore it is necessary to come up with a solution, so that the Medicare program remains intact.
The most favorable solution for these problems is for the national government to alleviate the out-of-pocket costs (such as the costs for drugs) of the beneficiaries by funding the Medicare program through the use of the national budget surplus. As of now, funding for Medicare has been provided through payroll taxes and social security taxes paid by enrolled members and their employers, and also through general revenues provided by the government. In fact, statistics provided by the United States Senate and Senator William Frist (R-Tenn.) indicate that Medicare members fund 25% (about $45/month), and the government covers the other 75% of Medicare costs (Frist). However, using revenue from the budget surplus would take the pressure off the beneficiaries and the government as well, by steadily lowering payroll and social security taxes.
Another important reason that makes this proposal worthy is the fact that the national budget surplus will continue to increase beyond 2010. In fact, according to George W. Bush, the budget surplus is expected to grow well past $5 trillion over the next 10 years (Bush). Considering the fact that Medicare expenditures project to cost around $452.2 billion over that same period (Bush), there will be plenty of money still available for military, education, and other government expenditures. Obviously, if the budget surplus were to decrease or remain stagnant over this time, it would be very costly to maintain Medicare under this proposal, but due to the budget’s optimistic (to say the least) outlook, the proposal is very sensible and effective.
Perhaps the only other alternative to Medicare itself would be for the government to adopt a centralized form of healthcare, similar to the one employed in Canada. In that program, every citizen would be entitled to the same benefits regardless of age, disability, or unemployment. Although this program seems like it would be for the best, it would take many years to implement the system. Legislation for a major issue such as healthcare normally spans several years (Frist), and is one reason that the government and neither party has ever brought the idea to the forefront. Furthermore, the financing for a public healthcare plan would shift more to the people since the government would be realizing all of the costs. Although still in use in Canada, the public healthcare system caused quite a scandal in the late 1980’s in the province of Alberta. In order to make up for the enormous costs accrued by the program, restrictions were placed on the amount of drugs that were to be prescribed by physicians (Marmor 97). This raised many concerns over the program and its lack of medical ethics. In fact, many organizations in Canada have formed coalitions to prevent incidents like this from occurring. One such coalition, the Friends of Medicare, was instrumental in helping pass the Canada Health Act in 1994 (Marmor). The Act is designed to ensure that Canadians receive comprehensive medical care at no cost.
As mentioned earlier, most Americans would rather see the Medicare program revamped instead of replaced. One of the measures that the government took was the establishment of the Medicare HMO (health maintenance organization). This program was designed to allow HMO subscribers the ability to use any hospital or physician. Previously, patients who contracted with HMOs were only allowed to use hospitals and physicians under contract with that HMO provider (Marmor 192). As a result, many people feared that HMO’s were more worried about money, then the health of its subscriber. With the advent of Medicare HMO, many more people subscribed to different providers. According to the Medicare HMO Internet site, the total membership of HMO’s has risen to over 7 million people as a result of its partnership with the Medicare program (MCOL). The problem with the HMO is that it is an even more private form of healthcare insurance then Medicare, and therefore costs more to the individual. Whereas much of the spending for Medicare is provided by payroll taxes, many employers do not even contract with health maintenance organizations due to cost (Ryan). Therefore, subscribers must pay more in premiums each month, then the estimated $45 monthly Medicare charge.
By using revenue from the budget surplus to cover Medicare costs, the national government would be benefiting itself, as well as Medicare subscribers. As previously mentioned, payroll taxes and social security taxes, current sources for Medicare funding, would be considerably lower and more elderly and disabled persons would be able to enroll in the program. The money from the budget surplus would be used primarily for out-of-pocket expenditures, such as prescription drug costs, as wells as to finance hospitals and medical technology. The government would benefit because of a stable national health-insurance plan, and due to a rapidly increasing budget surplus which figures to increase well over $5 trillion over the next ten years. This allows the government to take care of other major problems areas such as education, crime, and the armed forces. Although there are other alternatives such as switching to a more centralized form of medical care or relying on a more private form of medical care, each has several important problems. The time spent on legislation dealing with a public healthcare system, combined with moral aspects of the system make it less appealing. Likewise, added costs and insurance premiums for individuals, and the heavier financial burden on the government make the private system less desirable as well. Based on these facts, the best solution would be to reform the Medicare program through budget surplus financing.
Annotated
fc7
“AARP On Medicare Reform.” AARP 3 March 2000. 21 October 2000
*aarp/election2000/medicare.html*. In this article, the AARP
(Association for the Advancement of Retired Persons) documents the history of
Medicare, and its success providing healthcare insurance to the elderly. However,
the article also points out some of the problems that the program causes; for instance, many of the program’s beneficiaries must pay large out-of-pocket
expenditures in addition to the monthly premiums they are charged.
Bush, George W. “A Defining American Promise.” georgewbush 15 May 2000.
20 October 2000 *georgewbush/News.asp?FormMode=SP
&ID=3. Presidential candidate George W. Bush outlines his agenda on the issues
of economic security and medical care for the elderly. If elected, Governor Bush
will not hesitate to use revenue from the national budget surplus to support social
security and Medicare reform.
Carnegie, Wilson. “Altman Discusses Medicare Problems.” BrownDailyHerald
6 December 1999. 22 October 2000 *browndailyherald/stories.
Cfm?S=O&ID=868*. This newspaper article featured an article with Stuart
Altman, a professor of national healthy policy at Brandeis University. In it,
Altman discusses the nation’s need for proper Medicare funding. Currently, the
Program is jointly funded by tax dollars and government revenue, but is in
jeopardy of running a deficit in the future.
Frist, William R. “Who is Eligible.” Senate.gov 26 January 1998. 21 October 2000
*senate.gov/~frist/show_med/sld018.htm*. Senator William
Frist of Tennessee presents a slide show explaining how the Medicare program
Works. Frist describes the two parts of the Medicare plan, and also explains
who is eligible to enroll in Medicare. Furthermore, Frist discusses how Medicare
is funded, and the roles of various commissions in health care reform.
Marmor, Theodore. Understanding Health Care Reform. New Haven: Yale Univ. Pr,
1994. Theodore Marmor discusses the debate over President Clinton’s health care
reform bill, and its alternatives. He explains what we can and can’t expect from the bill, and also analyzes some proposed solutions regarding healthcare costs.
Marmor is a professor at Yale University, and has been called on by Congress several times for policy proposals and debate. He is considered an expert on health care reform.
McCanne, Dr. Don. “Rebuilding Medicare for the 21st Century.” Medicare4All
11 February 2000. 21 October 2000 *medicare4all/report/med
4.html*. Dr. Don McCanne, a member of the Board of Directors of the
Physicians for a National Health Program, credits Medicare for giving millions
of elderly and disabled persons medical insurance coverage. However, he also
points out that the program is seriously under funded, and faces deficit problems
in the future. In McCanne’s opinion, government funding is the best way to
alleviate the rising costs of Medicare.
Другие работы по теме:
Nursing Essay Research Paper What is a
Nursing Essay, Research Paper What is a Nurse Practitioner? A nurse practitioner is a registered nurse (RN) who has advanced education and clinical training in a health care
Pros Of Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper
Pros of Welfare Reform In the summer of 1996, Congress finally passed and the President signed the “Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996″, transforming the nation’s welfare system. The passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act sets the stage for ongoing reconstruction of welfare systems on a state-by-state basis.
Prescription Drugs Essay Research Paper In a
Prescription Drugs Essay, Research Paper In a recent article, an MNBC correspondent brought up the issue of high prices on prescription drugs. Many of these drugs are special vitamins, as well as
Health Care Essay Research Paper In the
Health Care Essay, Research Paper In the early 1800, public officials were making collective efforts to control communicable diseases such as smallpox, yellow fever, cholera, typhoid, and measles. In order to reduce the presence of communicable diseases, quarantine measures often became law. People who were contaminated were placed in isolation in order to avoid spreading the disease.
Health Care Economics Essay Research Paper People
Health Care Economics Essay, Research Paper People place various levels of price on their lives and the lives of their loved ones. People take drastic measures in an attempt to increase and improve one’s life. Unfortunately, money and economics have a great influence on the value of life. As presented in the text, the Jones-Lee Approach, the relationship between wages and risk, and the study with the smoke detectors, all show that even with health, as with material consumer products, people will purchase more when the price is cheaper.
Canadians And Americans Essay Research Paper Canadians
Canadians And Americans Essay, Research Paper Canadians and Americans There is much that has distinguished the Canadian experience as different from thatwhich has, and continues to, define the American experience. At first glance, superficiallyCanada and the United States share many aspects in common, for as one comedian oncestated “Canadians are just unarmed Americans with health care”, and for the most part,this is the common belief, as viewed by other nations in this world.
Health Care Reform Essay Research Paper From
Health Care Reform Essay, Research Paper From FDR s New Deal to Lyndon Johnson s Great Society, the United States government has attempted to centralize extensive social policies. In the early eighties, when recession and inflation were at a high, Ronald Reagan took office and pronounced that the federal government needed to take a lesser role in the lives of the American people.
Attention Deficit Disorder Essay Research Paper The
Attention Deficit Disorder Essay, Research Paper The First Lady Hilary Rodham Clinton and the Clinton Administration has proposed to increase focus and funding for research on the use of psychotropic medications in very young children. The recent reporting of stories in the news media documenting the increased use of psychotropic medications in children under five years old, for conditions such as ADD and depression, has appropriately raised concerns among parents, health care professionals, and legislators.
Nixon Essay Research Paper NixonI Civil
Nixon Essay, Research Paper Nixon I. Civil Rights A. Some people, mostly blacks, did not get equal rights. B. Nixon believed fundamentaly in responsible civil rights policy on
Reform Party Essay Research Paper A Reform
Reform Party Essay, Research Paper A Reform is a way of changing society. During the 1880?s and 90?s many people had different opinions on reform and how society was to be changed. This was the ending of the war and people needed a brake through both everyday life and politics. Since there were so many people there were different arguments about how the reforms should be.
Nurse Essay Research Paper The occupation of
Nurse Essay, Research Paper The occupation of a Registered Nurse seems to take an enormous amount of responsibility. The duties of a Registered Nurse are many. The R.N. “helps individuals and groups take steps to improve or maintain their health.” Other duties of a Nurse is to administer medications, assist in convalescence and rehabilitation, and “instruct patients and their families in proper care.” Nurses also “assist physicians during treatments and examinations.” Most important of all the nurse “helps people stay well and care for sick and injured people”(O.O.H. 159).
Given Elderly Care Essay Research Paper Older
Given Elderly Care Essay, Research Paper ?Older People and Care Giving Care Giving Networks Variations by Marital Status? To define what a care giving network is, would be to say that it is the care for elderly persons based on how an elderly is taken care of, and by whom they are given the care from. So many factors affect this situation though.
African Americans
– Multidimensional Health Care Crisis Essay, Research Paper African Americans face a multidimensional health care crisis that affects the young or old, rich or poor. Too many African Americans are uninsured or underinsured. The elderly cannot afford long-term health care leaving the family to care for them.
Presidency 2 Essay Research Paper There are
Presidency 2 Essay, Research Paper There are currently eight candidates running for the United States Presidency. Even though there are eight running, there are only two that are most likely to win. These two are Vice President Al Gore and Texas Governor George W. Bush. The election all depends on what the candidates debate about and where they stand on the issues.
Weed Essay Research Paper The Marijuana Reform
Weed Essay, Research Paper The Marijuana Reform Party believes: That adults who choose to use marijuana in the privacy of their own homes should not be subject to civil or criminal sanctions.
Health Essay Research Paper Should the United
Health Essay, Research Paper Should the United States adopt a Universal Health coverage system? Germany, the Netherlands, Japan, and in the United States Hawaii, all use a system of health care that is universal, comprehensive, and private. In, 1993, President Clinton proposed a plan for universal health insurance.
Social Essay Research Paper The three most
Social Essay, Research Paper The three most important ways the government should intervene with the economy is through social programs, health and safety controls and environment protection. Government funded social programs are essential for an economy and a country as a whole to prosper. Some of the social-insurance programs in place are welfare, pension and disability.
Health Care Ethics Essay Research Paper Improving
Health Care Ethics Essay, Research Paper Improving Access to Health Care for the Uninsured For decades, the American system of health care has relied primarily on employer-sponsored insurance programs as a gateway through which individual s access health care services. Gaps have been filled in through public insurance programs such as Medicare, Medicaid, the State Children s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) and other more locally-based programs to cover elderly, disabled and certain low income populations who cannot access the employer-based market.
Computers Essay Research Paper Why We StartedInternet
Computers! Essay, Research Paper Why We Started Internet Mental Health is a free encyclopedia of mental health information. It was designed by a Canadian psychiatrist, Dr. Phillip Long, and programmed by his colleague, Brian Chow.
American Medical Association Essay Research Paper American
American Medical Association Essay, Research Paper American Medical Association One of the main topics on everybody’s mind as the new millennium is coming up is their personal health. To make sure that there are sources for people to use to accomplish good health, the American Medical Association was created to promote the art and science of medicine and the betterment of public health.
Clinical Psychology Essay Research Paper Career In
Clinical Psychology Essay, Research Paper Career In Clinical Psychology A clinical psychologist is a psychologist with a more extensive background in psychology and puts more emphasis on experimental psychological research. A clinical psychologist is more likely to work in health care setting with patients with more severe disorders.
Debate Gore Bush Essay Research Paper Debate
Debate Gore Bush Essay, Research Paper Debate of Gore/Bush: Tuesday October 17, 2000 Topics Discussed: Education: Gore: Gore believes that teachers should be able to have one on one sessions with their students and in order to do so he believes that classrooms should be smaller and more teachers should be hired.
Health Care Essay Research Paper Health care
Health Care Essay, Research Paper Health care is an issue that everyone has to face no matter where they live. In great Britian thecosts for medical treatment is payed for by the government. In the United States there has beenmuch debate over a national health-care system. As it is today, health-care is paid for by thegovernment, but the money comes from the people s taxes.
Hydrotherapy Essay Research Paper There are many
Hydrotherapy Essay, Research Paper There are many alternative methods of health care available today. People that are disappointed with medical or surgical health care are turning to alternative methods to help themselves. Some alternative methods are positive through, acupuncture, therapeutic touch and hydrotherapy.
Al Gore Essay Research Paper Candidate for
Al Gore Essay, Research Paper Candidate for President Al Gore (democrat) After serving the U.S. Army in the Vietamn War, Al Gore became a reporter for a Nashville newspaper. He then attended Vanderbilt law school and was elected to the House of Representatives for eight years and was soon elected to the U.S.
Colon Cancer Essay Research Paper MN Talking
Colon Cancer Essay, Research Paper MN Talking Points On Colon Cancer Treatment and Prevention As representatives of the citizens of New York State, we have a responsibility to ensure that everyone has access to the highest quality health care possible.
UK Welfare State Essay Research Paper Good
UK Welfare State Essay, Research Paper Good health is an important factor to an individual?s welfare. It is an essential prerequisite for the enjoyment of life. For this reason the importance
About Health Care Essay Research Paper ABOUT
About Health Care Essay, Research Paper ABOUT HEALTH CARE I think there are many causes which have permitted in the last years increase people+s life expectancy. I consider people are living longer thanks to government policies on public+s health and due in most part to the great medical and technological advances that have been made in the last decades.
Campaign Finance Reform Essay Research Paper Campaign
Campaign Finance Reform Essay, Research Paper Campaign Finance Reform: Soft Money One of the key issues facing this year?s Presidential Campaign is campaign finance reform. More specifically, whether or not to ban soft
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper Title Welfare
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper Title: Welfare ReformCategory: otherDescription:Body of paper: Welfare is a subject that many people can not agree on. It is one of the most debated topics in almost every political campaign because of it s great importance to the American public. Bill Clinton offered his view on the subject in his 1992 speech “Ending Welfare as We Know It”.
Canadian Health Care VS US Health Care
Essay, Research Paper One of the major differences between the U.S. and Canadian health care system is the payment system. In the United States, physicians are paid more for doing more, and the return on their time is higher if they perform a procedure than if they use their cognitive skills. Because of the fact that procedures often require hospital care, this approach translates into higher expenditures for hospital care.
Medicare Essay Research Paper MEDICAREMany articles
Medicare Essay, Research Paper -MEDICARE- Many articles have been written about the medicare program in Canada. It’s a real intense topic in Canada today. This brief essay is based on the costs of medicare , an introduction to the medicare program, and if our country Canada can afford the medicare program.