The story of Ishmael by Daniel Quinn is certainly one of the most compelling and interesting books I have ever read. It is not surprising however that it is also a very controversial story nonetheless. I did enjoy the ideas that Quinn offered as explanation for how we, ?the Takers? came into being even though they do formally challenge everything that we?ve learned as far as religion, culture, etc. It taught me that anything can be made a ?truth.? I don?t think that Quinn?s views of the human race are quite accurate enough to satisfy my own qualms about society as we know it.
Quinn?s story of the ?Takers? begins with the Agricultural revolution in the Fertile Crescent. I don?t agree with this statement. He just condemned every civilized culture that has ever existed regardless of any exceptions. What separates us from the primitive people however is ambition. Ishmael said that we take more than what we need, but he calls it a tragic flaw. I see it instead as foresight; we take more than we need because we are careful and we may need something later. This is the very reason civilized societies survive natural disasters so much better than primitive tribes.
The teaching we received tells us that humans aren?t just another animal; why shouldn?t we believe that? After all, we are by far the most intelligent of all species of animal. Our religion tells us that all of the creatures on this planet were made specifically for us, and once again, why shouldn?t we believe that? There aren?t any telepathic gorillas in the wild to tell us otherwise. We have a right and a duty to be the ones to control the ecological balance because we are the only creatures that can go back and correct what we screw up. That is easily what separates us from animals.
Our education makes us understand that the agricultural revolution was inevitable and our lives are better because it happened. This goes back to the question ?Is a revolution villainous if it succeeds?? We see our American Revolution as a glorious release of all evil oppressors. We don?t see Washington as a radical in the same way that we don?t see the first of the ?Takers? as locusts in the fashion that Ishmael did. We see it that way because it succeeded.
Ishmael addressed very good points about many topics, but he conveniently forgot to mention the good things about living in a civilized society. Because we have such an advanced culture, our communications alone can surpass any advancements that a primitive society can conjure. Our medical advancements can outlast a mixture of herbs and a few prayers to a tiki god. Honestly, I would rather be safe than sorry. I am not blind, I can see that the world is in great danger environmentally, but we can fix our mistakes; that is what, once again, separates us from uncivilized people.
Другие работы по теме:
Hatchet wgcs Style Essay Research Paper Hatchet
Hatchet (wgcs Style) Essay, Research Paper Hatchet is written by Gary Paulsen. It is a book about a thirteen year old kid named Brian who crash lands in the Canadian wilderness and has to survive
To Be Or Not Be Essay Research
Paper Snow Falling on Cedar Friday, July 16th 3:00-3:45 Pg. 113-133 They talk about Japanese immigrants who worked on Strawberry plantation fields. They also talk about Japanese culture and weddings. In this chapter they also mention Hastue (Japanese girl) and her relationship with Ishmael Chambers.
Book Report Essay Research Paper The Chosen
Book Report Essay, Research Paper The Chosen, Chaim Potok The Chosen is about two Jewish boys, one a Orthodox Jew and one a Hasidic Jew, and how different and yet the same their lives are. The orthodox Jew, Reuven, is the main character of the story. He lives with his father and his mother is dead. Reuven is a very nice boy who is fourteen years old and aspires to be a Rabbi when he grows up.
Robinson Crusoe Essay Research Paper Daniel Defoes
Robinson Crusoe Essay, Research Paper Daniel Defoe?s most famous novel was published in 1719 with the full title, The Life and strange and surprising Adventures of Robinson Crusoe. It is based, in fact, upon the experiences of Alexander Selkirk who had run away to sea in 1704 and requested to be left on an uninhabited island to be rescued five years later.
Leaver Cultrures Essay Research Paper Any culture
Leaver Cultrures Essay, Research Paper Any culture that takes just what it needs form the surroundings and leaves the rest is called a leaver culture. These people are very nomadic, such as the pygmies in the Forest People. Leavers move to an area that they fell they can live off the surroundings for awhile without using everything up.
Flowers For Algeron Essay Research Paper The
Flowers For Algeron Essay, Research Paper The story “Flowers for Algernon”, by Daniel Keyes, that we read in English was about a mentally retarded person, named Charlie who had an operation to increase his intelligence, but the operation was a failure and Charlie is slow again. He wants to move now so society won t ridicule him for being slow again.
Le Huitieme Jour Essay Research Paper Date
Le Huitieme Jour Essay, Research Paper Date: 1997 Genre de film: Drame Metteur en Sc?ne: Jaco Van Dormael Realisateur: Philippe Godeau Avec: Daniel Auteuil comme Harry
Quinn On Heart Of Darkness Essay Research
Paper Quinn on Heart of Darkness We cannot read Quinn?s Ishmael without re-evaluating ourselves. Quinn confronts us with powerful revelations about mankind. According to Quinn, if we continue to live in our taker lifestyles, we will eventually destroy ourselves. Conrad?s Heart of Darkness illustrates a real life manifestation of Quinn?s insights.
Moby Dick The Winding Road Essay Research
Paper Moby-Dick: The Winding Road Homosexuality portrayed in the novel, Moby-Dick, was used many times over the 135 chapters. Ishmael s encounters with Queequeg, and their subsequent marriage challenges the controversial lines of male identity in the mid-nineteenth-century. Controversial lines were in fact crossed many times in this book, and Moby-Dick critics express deep concern in the way Melville uses Queequeg as a vessel to explore homosexuality and push it along with underlying tones throughout the novel.
Sonw Falling On Cedars Essay Research Paper
Snow Falling on Cedars, by David Guterson, is an emotional story about the life of a man who could not move on and a woman who could. The man, Ishmael, is hopelessly in love with the woman, Hatsue. Ishmael holds on to Hatsue even after he gains the knowledge that it is extremely improbable that he can ever be with her.
Daniel Boone Essay Research Paper More than
Daniel Boone Essay, Research Paper More than any other man, Daniel Boone was responsible for the exploration and settlement of Kentucky. His grandfather came from England to America in 1717. His father was a weaver and blacksmith, and he raised livestock in the country near Reading, Pennsylvania. Daniel was born there on November 2, 1734.
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper Ignorance Ignorance
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Ignorance Ignorance is seen every day of our lives. Even people in the 1850?s were aware of ignorance. Ignorance is defined as being uneducated or resulting from or showing lack of knowledge. Ignorance can be taken to extremes though. There is complete ignorance where the person thinks that even though they do not understand it all they still know everything.
Robinsin Crusoe Essay Research Paper A book
Robinsin Crusoe Essay, Research Paper A book review of Daniel Defoe’s: Robinson Crusoe Robinson Crusoe is an imaginary story about a merchant-adventure marooned on a desert island off the northern coast of South America. Daniel Defoe wrote this novel in 1719.He based the story partly on the experiences of a Scottish sailor, Alexander Selkirk, but defoe’s realistic account of Crusoe’s like is much more interesting, and has become one of the most popular books in English.
Setting Essay Essay Research Paper Setting EssayThere
Setting Essay Essay, Research Paper Setting Essay There is a place high in the limestone bluffs of Southern Illinois, where Daniel loves to spend his time. He perches on fallen tree trunks and watches flowers bloom in the springtime. He inhales their fragrant smell and daydreams until evening. This green haven of luscious moss and feathery ferns is peaceful year round.
The Great White Whale And Its Many
Meanings Essay, Research Paper The Great White Whale and its Many Meanings Herman Melville, in his epic novel Moby-Dick, utilizes the symbolism of the color of the Great White Whale to demonstrate his theme of duality. However, Captain Ahab tragically had a single mind set towards Moby Dick, as he believed that the whale was the symbol of the world?s evil and had to be destroyed.
Ishmael Essay Research Paper a review of
Ishmael Essay, Research Paper a review of… Ishmael In the past few centuries there have been a handful of books written that offer up ideas about humanity that are so completely new to a reader but are so completely convincing that they can force a reader to take a step back and assess all that they know to be true about their life and their purpose.
The Breakdown Of Community Ray Oldenburg Ishmael
Reed Essay, Research Paper WR 121 Paper #2 The Breakdown of Community In Ray Oldenburg’s “The Problem of Place in America” and Ishmael Reed’s “My Neighborhood” the authors express thier dissatisfaction with the community. Oldenburg
Snow Falling On Cedars Hatsue And Ishmael
’s Incompatibility Essay, Research Paper Snow Falling On Cedars: Hatsue and Ishmael’s Incompatibility Dear Ishmael, ?I don’t love you, Ishmael. I can think of no more honest way to say it.
Snow Essay Research Paper The novel Snow
Snow Essay, Research Paper The novel, Snow Falling on Cedars, by David Guterson, gives some examples on how past events can effect a community. In 1954 on an island near Seattle, this
Mrs Doubtfire Essay Research Paper MRS DOUBTFIREMrs
Mrs. Doubtfire Essay, Research Paper MRS. DOUBTFIRE Mrs. Doubtfire is the creation of a man, unwilling to accept the role of being a weekend father. Daniel, the father, is determined to spend more time with his children and goes to extreme measures to do so. When Daniels wife, Miranda, starts divorce proceedings, he impersonates a middle-age female English nanny.
Snow Falling On Cedars Ishamel
– Friend Or Foe? Essay, Research Paper Ishamel: friend or foe? There are evil people in the world. It?s amazing what they can do and have done, that?s why so many people watch documentaries of Jeffry Dahmer and Ed Geen. Evil comes in many forms and several different levels of severity. From cheating to kleptomania and kicking cats to lampshades.
Oedipus Essay Research Paper The Presence of
Oedipus Essay, Research Paper The Presence of the Oedipus Complex in Paul Auster’s City of Glass Throughout history literature has had several themes or ideas that have persisted though all of its different movements. One of these ideas is that of the Oedipus complex. The Story of Oedipus was originally written by Sophocles in the fifth century BC.
Daniel Webster Essay Research Paper Daniel Webster
Daniel Webster Essay, Research Paper Daniel Webster was the ninth born son of Ebenezer Webster, who was a farmer and tavern-keeper. He was born in Salisbury, New Hampshire on January 18th in 1782. He was nicknamed ?Black Dan.? When he was a child he was mostly bedridden, many thought he wouldn?t make it. He was forced to read.
Daniel Boone Essay Research Paper Daniel Boone
Daniel Boone Essay, Research Paper Daniel Boone was responsible for the exploration and settlement of Kentucky. Daniel?s father was a weaver and blacksmith, and raised livestock in the country near
Biblical And Mytholigical Allusions Of Herman Melville
’s Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Biblical and Mythological Allusions In Hermon Melville s Moby Dick An allusion is a reference to a well-known person, place, event, literary work, or work of art. (Thompson 1155). Writers often use biblical and mythological allusions to which their readers are familiar.
Ishmael Reed Essay Research Paper Ishmael Reed
Ishmael Reed Essay, Research Paper Ishmael Reed, together with Toni Morrison, is one of today’s pre-eminent African American literary figures–perhaps the most widely reviewed since Ralph Ellison, and, along with Samuel Delany and Amiri Baraka, probably the most controversial.
Hell Day Essay Research Paper Hell day
Hell Day Essay, Research Paper Hell day is a fun day where everything is like a burn day. If you would listen you could learn about this day and be apart of this day. If you are wise then you will relize that hell day is satans Birthday!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Moby Dick
– Brotherhood Is Introduced Essay, Research Paper In the intricate novel of Herman Melville?s Moby Dick, the notion of a ?universal brotherhood of Man? is introduced in the first fifteen chapters. Melville uses the relationship of Ishmael and Queequeg and the everyday standards of the shipmen to illustrate these ideas.
Justice Moby Dick Essay Research Paper In
Justice: Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper In the novel Moby Dick, Ishmael is saved while the rest of the Pequod?s crew die at sea. There is a specific point in the theme of the novel where each crew member sealed their
Moby Dick By Herman Melville Essay Research 2
?Moby Dick? By Herman Melville Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick In the novel ?Moby Dick? by Herman Melville, the apparent themes: good vs. evil, civilized vs. uncivilized, and conventional vs. unconventional
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper Moby Dick
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick Story by Herman Melville This is a story about a sailor named Ishmael, who is the narrator. Captain Ahab, the one-legged commander of the ship Pequod, is the main character. Ahab has sworn to kill this huge whale, Moby Dick, who took away his leg. Starbuck is the first mate of the Pequod, and Queequeg, Tashtego, and Daggoo are the three harpooners.
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper SS 9
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper S.S 9 L.G 10 Benedict Arnold Benedict Arnold was one of the important figures in the American Revolution. He began as a patriot, and soon later married a loyalist. Benedict