Thw White Whale Essay, Research Paper
Prof. Wineapple
Paper #2, Topic #5
In Melville’s Moby Dick our narrator, Ishmael, has a unique view on the great white whale. “…all these are but subtle deceits, not actually inherent in substances, but only laid on from without; so that all deified Nature absolutely paints like the harlot, whose allurement’s cover nothing but the charnel-house within…” By examining his remarks, we can tell he is a very down-to-earth man; however, Melville uses a common theme of “how do you know for sure”. He is saying, many times throughout the novel, that maybe nothing has any meaning. Despite this, Ishmeal gives numerous examples of what white can mean (i.e. the horror of an albino, or beauty of a white steed etc.) and proceeds to say Moby Dick is all of these things, “Wonder ye then at the fiery hunt?” He is esentially asking us “if you lived in a world where nothing had any meaning, and a great white whale was taunting you to give chase, what would you do?”
My method of attacking the question, how would the three main characters from Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter see the whiteness of the whale?, is going to be a comparison to Melville’s characters. The first comparison is between Hester Prynne and Ishmael. Hester Prynne is a brave lady who faces her sin, as seen in her ability to face severe ridicule on the scaffold. Ishmael is a brave young man who handles any conflict with a strong will, as seen in his agreement to sign onto a whaling ship without knowing the captain. It is also seen in his ability to share a bed with a stranger, and share in his religious activities, and to eventually make a life long committment to the stranger. Hester Prynne is a loving woman who never reveals the identity of her lover to spare him, she puts someone else’e needs before her own. She accepts the consequences of the nature of her sin. It is clear that Ishmael has understanding and compassion, he too can live and accept the natural world. Hawthorne portrays Hester as a victim of many thing, especially as a victim to Chillingworth’s selfishness. Hester, while apologizing for not revealing the identity of Chillingworth, says “I have striven to be true! Truth was the one virtue which I might have held fast and did hold fast through all extremity…a lie is never good even though death threatens on the other side.” Ishmael strives to be true also, he gave us a true meaning of what the color white was, it was merely a cosmetic. This is why I think that Hester would hold the same opinion as Ishmael does. “It is all of these things.”
The second comparison is between Arthur Dimmesdale and Starbuck. Arthur Dimmesdale was an intelligent man who was passionate in his religion. Starbuck was also and intelligent man, although it was a different kind of intelligence, he is wise enough to know Ahab’s obsession with Moby Dick is wrong and dangerous. He too is passionate in his work, he is a realist who thinks that the primary concern of the ship should be to gather the oils of the whales so the crew can gain wealth. However intelligent, both men have tragic flaws. Dimmesdale’s tragic flaw is that he cannot admit to being Hester’s lover, he conceals his sin, which makes it a more severe sin. When Chiilingworth tries to press him, he clearly tries justify his behavior. He allows Chiilingworth to make him feel guilty to the point where he almost goes crazy. After seven years, he overcomes his weakness and reveals he is Pearl’s father. Starbuck’s tragic flaw is his weakness to openly criticize his captain. When Ahab announces his mission to the crew, Starbuck questions him by saying “vengeance, on a dumb brute?” When Ahab pursues his questioning he can do nothing but sigh “God help me, God help all of us!” However, it doesn’t take him seven years to overcome his weakness, as it does Dimmesdale. In chapter one hundred and four, he confronts and challenges Ahabs ignorance regarding the oil vats. Ahab pulls a gun and points it at him, and Starbuck says “…let Ahab beware of Ahab.” This is why I feel Starbuck and Arthur Dimmesdale would ignore the whiteness of the whale and see it as a simple brute.
The final comparison is one between Ahab and Roger Chillingworth. These two are almost perfect matches. Both are delayed emergence characters who are physically deformed and at first portrayed as victims. Ahab and Chillingworth both appear calm and intelligent, completely hiding their anger, at least for a while. Chillingworth commits two severe sins, the first is against the nature of love. He does so in marrying Hester while knowing he wasn’t a suitable husband. His second is subordination of another human’s heart. He is willing to sacrifice another human to satisfy his own selfishness. Ahab also commits numerous sins. The first if these is his cheating of the nature of trust in lying to the ship’s owners about the goal on his mission. The second is his subordination of an entire crew in his hunt for Moby Dick. He is willing to sacrifice his entire crew to satisfy his desire for vengeance. Chiilingworth and Ahab both try to create a scapegoat for destroying themselves, but they both should accept responsibility for themselves. They both try and play a god-like-role and end up as devils. That is why they both would see the whale as purely a representation of all the evil in the world.
“The Albino whale was all of these things, wonder ye then at the fiery hunt?” The whiteness is purely a cosmetic, but as it always is, no one thing means anything definitely. The meaning lies in the value an individual gives to that object.
Другие работы по теме:
Moby Dick Essay Essay Research Paper Moby
Moby Dick Essay Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick Essay Throughout time, people have associated their problems with with something bad that happened to them. That thing became the center of their problems by causing a lot of suffering to that person. In Moby Dick, Melville has many interpretations of what the white whale symbolizes.
Mobydick Essay Research Paper The meaning of
Mobydick Essay, Research Paper The meaning of the name itself is quite simple: The whale was often sighted in the vicinity of the Island of Mocha, and “Dick” was merely a generic name like “Jack” or “Tom”. The transformation of “Mocha” to “Moby” presented a greater mystery. Melville himself never explained the origin of the latter word.
Dolphins Orcas Essay Research Paper Orcas Orcas
Dolphins: Orcas Essay, Research Paper Orcas ? Orcas are actually the largest members of the dolphin family. ? The name “orca” means “demon from hell” in Greek. The scientific name is Orcinus Orca
A Visual Analysis Of Jonah Cast Up
? Essay, Research Paper A collection of marble sculptures called the ?Jonah Group? is now on display at the Cleveland Art Museum. ?Jonah Swallowed, Jonah Cast Up, Jonah Praying, Jonah Under the Gourd Vine, and The Good Shepherd,? are the separate titles for each of the different statues depicting events in the Bible story.
Whaling In US Compared To Japan Essay
, Research Paper Did you know that in the last 50 years over two million whales have been killed? The United States views whaling very differently than Japan does. It is a complicated and controversial topic. Many people have opinions about whale hunting. However, everyone should know both sides of the whale hunting issues before they act on the issue.
Humpback Whale Essay Research Paper Humpback WhaleIntroductionAs
Humpback Whale Essay, Research Paper Humpback Whale Introduction As the boat sways up and down, hours take years to complete, and the anticipation grows to see that one element of the whole trip. That element being the site of the enormous tail fin of a humpback whale. These trips are often taken via television for most people, but there are a select few who see the real thing.
Hawaii Essay Research Paper Nicole Maguire
Hawaii Essay, Research Paper Nicole Maguire Prof. Mills Native Hawaiians Hawaii is an archipelago of enchanting and exotic islands that remained unknown to the rest of the world for thousands of years. When the islands were finally discovered they weren t desolate, they were inhabited by a whole group of people that were very capable.
Whales Essay Research Paper The United States
Whales Essay, Research Paper The United States views whaling very differently than Japan does. The first whale hunters were in the prehistoric times. At first they would just kill and eat beached whales. That became such a habit that they started hunting them. Most whale hunters use harpoons, guns, lances, or bombs that blow up inside the whale.
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper What the
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper What the item is about? The novel Moby Dick is the story of how Ishmael the narrator came to set sail on a fateful whaling voyage. He travels to Nantucket, where he visits the docks to find a ship; he discovers the Pequod. As Ishmael and his friend Queequeg make their way to board the ship, they meet a haggard looking, wild-eyed man who calls himself Elijah.
Moby DickInnocent Or EvilInnocent Side Essay Research
Paper Moby Dick Innocent or Evil? By Kevin Cook Can the lust for revenge, wealth, or power be so strong in a person that they become so enthralled by this lust that they become a madman? This question could not be more fully answered, nor better demonstrated by the behavior of the captain of the whaling ship, ?The Peqoud?, in Herman Melville?s book, Moby Dick.
Charlies Treatment Essay Research Paper Charlie the
Charlie?s Treatment Essay, Research Paper Charlie, the main character in Charlie, by Daniel Keyes is treated differently by everyone he knows. Imagine you had mental retardation. You only know the basics of anything. You can?t spell and
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper I Author
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper I. Author Information Herman Melville, was born in 1819, in a very “good” neighborhood in New York. A. Many influences on Melville’s works were European literature, experiences in his travels, and tragedy in his life. B. Melville was born into the time when inspiring works of American literature began to emerge.
Moby Dick 4 Essay Research Paper Moby
Moby Dick 4 Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick What the White Whale Symbolizes I looked at chapter 42, The Whiteness of the Whale , and how Melville uses symbolism of color. In many parts of the world the color white has a religious meaning, it gives a god like appearance. To Captain Ahab he has a totally different outlook of the White Whale.
Whale Essay Research Paper gThe blue whale
Whale Essay, Research Paper ?gThe blue whale heart is the size of a small car, the major arteries leading from the heart a small child can stand it! ?g This is an example about
The Klan Essay Research Paper The
The Klan Essay, Research Paper * The Klan name and symbol break through the paper curtain of the anti-White media and brings us to the attention of those who want to
Moby Dicks Symbolism Essay Research Paper Throughout
Moby Dicks Symbolism Essay, Research Paper Throughout the whole story the white whale is not only depicted as a an unexplainable force of nature but is also given an almost divine quality , he is constantly compared to God, and as the people fear and revere God they also fear Moby Dick and whales in general.The Whalers of the town see the whales not as thier prey but they see them as thier advisaries.An advisary that equals and often times surpasses them in prowess.From the begining of the film we are confronted with the image of the whale as the personificaion of power and strength ,as Stubb says in the inn “If God where to be any fish he would be a whale.” From this qoute alone it is evident that the whale holds a great deal of power.It is also obvious that to confront a whale is
The Great White Whale And Its Many
Meanings Essay, Research Paper The Great White Whale and its Many Meanings Herman Melville, in his epic novel Moby-Dick, utilizes the symbolism of the color of the Great White Whale to demonstrate his theme of duality. However, Captain Ahab tragically had a single mind set towards Moby Dick, as he believed that the whale was the symbol of the world?s evil and had to be destroyed.
Blue Whale Essay Research Paper The Blue
Blue Whale Essay, Research Paper The Blue Whale The blue whale or balaenoperta musclus is the largest animal to ever have lived on Earth. Whalers have reported this whale to being over 100 feet long and weighing over 150 tons!
Environment Friendly Essay Research Paper Environment FriendlyThe
Environment Friendly Essay, Research Paper Environment Friendly The Pacific Whale Foundation (PWF) is a unique environmental organization. It just doesn?t talk about whales and dolphins, it actually studies and protects them first-hand. Their research efforts helped create marine sanctuaries in Australia, New Zealand, and the United States; save dolphins from deadly fishing practices in South America; and establish whalewatching as a replacement for whale killing.
The Whale Shark Essay Research Paper The
The Whale Shark Essay, Research Paper The Whale Shark At a whopping forty-six feet and a massive fifteen tons, you can see why the whale shark is called they whale shark. The whale shark is the biggest shark and the biggest fish in the ocean (The Whale Shark Bibliography – Tethys Marine). As you can see it is not a whale.
Symbolism In Moby Dick Essay Research Paper
Moby-Dick Symbolism is using a person, place, or thing to represent something else which is larger and often untouchable. It is used in literature to allow authors to be objective while still expressing his/her views. Symbols in a story can be interpreted differently by different people Some symbols stand for things that are obvious while others need a more involved explanation.
Captain Ahab Essay Research Paper Captain AhabIf
Captain Ahab Essay, Research Paper Captain Ahab If you ever saw Captain Ahab in a dark alley, you’d probably turn and run the other way. His scarred body and wooden leg are just a couple of characteristics that show who he is. Ahab is the captain of the whaling ship Pequod, and their mission is to go on a trip and bring back as many whales as possible.
Comparing Two Poems Essay Research Paper Topic
Comparing Two Poems Essay, Research Paper Topic: compare and contrast the two poems. The two poems Package for the Distant Future and The Song of the Whale differs mainly in their subject matter and the way they evoke different feelings and images and also the style and presentation of the poem. Coincidently both poems contain the themes of death and caring for the environment, which the writers feel strongly about.
Moby Dick By Herman Melville (1819 -
– 1891) Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick, or, The White Whale is a book of amazing depth. It can be read on several levels: for over a century it has captivated young readers, naturalists, historians and literary scholars
A Comparison Of Melville
’S Moby Dick And Bartleby Essay, Research Paper Herman Melville’s stories of Moby Dick and Bartleby share a stark number of similarities and differences. Certain aspects of each piece seem to compliment each other, giving the reader insight to the underlying themes and images. There are three concepts that pervade the two stories making them build upon each other.
Justice Moby Dick Essay Research Paper In
Justice: Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper In the novel Moby Dick, Ishmael is saved while the rest of the Pequod?s crew die at sea. There is a specific point in the theme of the novel where each crew member sealed their
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper Moby Dick
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick Story by Herman Melville This is a story about a sailor named Ishmael, who is the narrator. Captain Ahab, the one-legged commander of the ship Pequod, is the main character. Ahab has sworn to kill this huge whale, Moby Dick, who took away his leg. Starbuck is the first mate of the Pequod, and Queequeg, Tashtego, and Daggoo are the three harpooners.
Captain Ahab Essay Research Paper Captain AhabCaptain
Captain Ahab Essay, Research Paper Captain Ahab Captain Ahab in the novel Moby Dick is quite a character. He is the Captain of the whaling ship the Pequod and is out on a voyage to kill the great white whale named Moby Dick. Throughout his journey on sea, Ahab maintains focus on one thing, and only one thing, killing Moby Dick.
Color Of Water Essay Research Paper One
Color Of Water Essay, Research Paper One aspect of identity where feedback can be given almost instantaneously is race, as it involves a person’s skin color. Young children often ignore each others’ races unless they
Gps Essay Research Paper Describe how GPS
Gps Essay, Research Paper Describe how GPS works and how normal citizens have been able to use it to make their lives easier. GPS is a global positioning satellite that is used to show the exact position on earth that you are. This system is used in many ways. Many people in a new city use rental cars. These people will probably get lost.